Small Claims

Reganne Logistics Ltd v Macharia [2026] SCC 132 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Mombasa
Case number
SCCCOMM/E346/2026 REGANNE LOGISTICS LTD VS JEFF GACHOKA MACHARIA
Judgment date
24 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Claim partly allowed. The court entered judgment for the Claimant for USD 3,454 (stated as equivalent to KShs. 445,566), with interest from the date of judgment. Each party was to bear its own costs.

Supporting judgment passages

In the end, this court finds that the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities and enters judgment in favor of the Claimant for USD 3454 equivalent to KShs. 445,566/-interest from date of judgment. Parties to bear their own costs.

Passage 20 →
Issue 1Whether the transport agreement dated 28 January 2026 was a valid and binding contract between the parties.

Held. Decided. The transport agreement satisfied the elements of a valid contract and was valid and binding on the parties.

Ratio. A valid contract requires offer, acceptance and consideration; the court found those elements satisfied on the agreement before it.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

and particularly the transport agreement dated 28th January 2026, this court finds that the said agreement has satisfied the elements of a valid contract and constitutes a valid and binding agreement between the parties.

Passage 12 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

and particularly the transport agreement dated 28th January 2026, this court finds that the said agreement has satisfied the elements of a valid contract and constitutes a valid and binding agreement between the parties.

Passage 12 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

To begin with, it is well established that the essential elements for a valid contract are an offer, acceptance and consideration. This position was affirmed by the Learned

Passage 9 →

and particularly the transport agreement dated 28th January 2026, this court finds that the said agreement has satisfied the elements of a valid contract and constitutes a valid and binding agreement between the parties.

Passage 12 →
Issue 2Whether the Respondent breached the contractual obligation to return the empty container within 28 days and was liable for resulting demurrage.

Held. Decided. The Respondent breached the agreement by delivering the container after the 28-day period. The court rejected his asserted account that delay resulted from the lack of a validated storing order, finding his documents did not support it and that the WhatsApp evidence showed offloading on 2 March rather than 2 February. No valid justification for the two-week delay was shown, and the messages demonstrated an admission of fault.

Ratio. A party breaches a contract by failing or refusing, without lawful excuse, to perform what is due under it. The Respondent's late delivery without a valid justification breached the express 28-day return term, which made him personally liable for resulting demurrage.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Be that as it may, in Jackline Njeri Kariuki v. Moses Njung’e Njau [2021] eKLR the court held that; a breach of contract is committed when a party, without lawful excuse, fails or refuses to perform what is due from him under the contract, or performs defectively, or incapacitates himself from performing. Presently, the Respondent was clearly in breach having delivered the container way after the 28-day timeline. No valid reason as to why the Respondent delayed for two weeks has been provided in order to justify the delay. In fact, the whatsapp messages filed demonstrate an admission of fault as the Respondent suggested a settlement plan to the Claimant.

Passage 16 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The Respondent on his part states that he delivered the container at the warehouse but on arrival, was denied access for the reason that the Claimant had not obtained a validated storing order. This resulted in the Respondent having to wait till 2nd February 2026 for the container to be received and offloaded. The Respondent filed the gate pass dated 2nd February 2026 to corroborate this fact. The court has scrutinized the documents filed by the Respondent and found that they do not support this version of events. Per the whatsapp screenshots, the Respondent offloaded the container at the private yard on 2nd March 2026 and not 2nd February 2026 as pleaded. Why the Respondent would deliberately plead untrue facts worrying.

Passage 15 →

Be that as it may, in Jackline Njeri Kariuki v. Moses Njung’e Njau [2021] eKLR the court held that; a breach of contract is committed when a party, without lawful excuse, fails or refuses to perform what is due from him under the contract, or performs defectively, or incapacitates himself from performing. Presently, the Respondent was clearly in breach having delivered the container way after the 28-day timeline. No valid reason as to why the Respondent delayed for two weeks has been provided in order to justify the delay. In fact, the whatsapp messages filed demonstrate an admission of fault as the Respondent suggested a settlement plan to the Claimant.

Passage 16 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

It was a term of the agreement that the Respondent had 28 days from the date of loading on 17th January 2026 to return the empty container to Mombasa and in the event of any delay resulting in accrual of container demurrage, the Respondent would be held personally liable for such charges.

Passage 13 →

Be that as it may, in Jackline Njeri Kariuki v. Moses Njung’e Njau [2021] eKLR the court held that; a breach of contract is committed when a party, without lawful excuse, fails or refuses to perform what is due from him under the contract, or performs defectively, or incapacitates himself from performing. Presently, the Respondent was clearly in breach having delivered the container way after the 28-day timeline. No valid reason as to why the Respondent delayed for two weeks has been provided in order to justify the delay. In fact, the whatsapp messages filed demonstrate an admission of fault as the Respondent suggested a settlement plan to the Claimant.

Passage 16 →
Issue 3What demurrage relief was proved and payable by the Respondent.

Held. Decided. Although the Claimant was entitled to relief, it did not prove the full amount claimed. On scrutiny of the invoices, the court allowed USD 700 for 16–28 February 2026 and USD 2,754 for 1 March–20 April 2026, totaling USD 3,454, stated as KShs. 445,566 at KShs. 129 per dollar, with interest from judgment.

Ratio. No distinct ratio identified in the judgment. The court's reduction of the claim was based on its factual scrutiny and calculation from the filed invoices; no distinct legal rule governing the calculation was identified.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(Judgment), the court held that under common law there cannot be a wrong without a remedy, put differently, Equity will not suffer a wrong to be without a remedy. The court finds in the circumstances of the case before it that the claimant is entitled to relief, but not in the whole amount claimed. After scrutinizing the invoices filed by the Claimant this court finds that the demurrage for the period of 16th to 28th February 2026 was USD 700, translating to USD 54 per day. From 1st March to 20th April 2026 demurrage would therefore stand at USD 2754 equivalent to Kshs. 355,266/- as per the current exchange rate of Kshs. 129 to the dollar. In total the Respondent is liable to pay USD 3454.

Passage 19 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

(Judgment), the court held that under common law there cannot be a wrong without a remedy, put differently, Equity will not suffer a wrong to be without a remedy. The court finds in the circumstances of the case before it that the claimant is entitled to relief, but not in the whole amount claimed. After scrutinizing the invoices filed by the Claimant this court finds that the demurrage for the period of 16th to 28th February 2026 was USD 700, translating to USD 54 per day. From 1st March to 20th April 2026 demurrage would therefore stand at USD 2754 equivalent to Kshs. 355,266/- as per the current exchange rate of Kshs. 129 to the dollar. In total the Respondent is liable to pay USD 3454.

Passage 19 →

In the end, this court finds that the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities and enters judgment in favor of the Claimant for USD 3454 equivalent to KShs. 445,566/-interest from date of judgment. Parties to bear their own costs.

Passage 20 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the transport agreement dated 28 January 2026 was a valid and binding contract; whether Jeff Gachoka Macharia breached its term requiring return of the empty container within 28 days of loading; and the recoverable amount of demurrage arising from any…

Material facts

Reganne Logistics Ltd claimed KShs. 754,000, said to equal USD 5,800 in demurrage. It said the Respondent agreed to transport container FCIU9146655 from Mombasa to Kigali for Oceanline Logistics and return it empty to Mombasa within 28 days from loading on 17…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT MOMBASA COUNTY COURT NAME: MOMBASA SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E346/2026 REGANNE LOGISTICS LTD VS JEFF GACHOKA MACHARIA

JUDGMENT

The claim herein seeks judgment against the Respondent in the sum of KShs. 754,000.00 (equivalent to USD 5,800 arising out of demurrage charges accrued as a direct consequence of the Respondent's breach as per the Claimant. It is the Claimant’s case that the parties herein entered into a transport agreement dated 28th January 2026 wherein the Respondent undertook to transport goods on behalf of the Claimant’s client, Oceanline Logistics in a container bearing number FCIU9146655 from the port of Mombasa to Kigali, Rwanda, and to return the empty container to Mombasa within twenty-eight from the date of loading, which was on 17th January 2026.

Further, the claimant submits that the evidence shows that demurrage began accruing on 16th February 2026 (after expiry of the 28 free days from 17th January 2026, at USD 700 for the first cycle, and has continued to accrue at USD 100 per day thereafter. By 20th April 2026, the total accrued demurrage stood at USD 5,800 equivalent to KShs. 754,000/-.

On the other hand, the Respondent denied entering into the said agreement or being liable to pay demurage charges as he attributed the failure to deliver the empty container on time to the lack of a validated storing order from the Claimant to the Warehouse. This resulted in the warehouse rejecting the container leading the Respondent to park the container at Barwaqo Auto Garage, a private warehouse.

The court in rendering its judgment has considered the documents filed by the respective parties as well as the oral evidence presented.

To begin with, it is well established that the essential elements for a valid contract are an offer, acceptance and consideration. This position was affirmed by the Learned

Judges of the Court of Appeal in Charles Mwirigi Miriti v Thananga Tea Growers

Sacco Ltd & another [2014] KECA 538 (KLR). Applying this to the present case

and particularly the transport agreement dated 28th January 2026, this court finds that the said agreement has satisfied the elements of a valid contract and constitutes a valid and binding agreement between the parties.

It was a term of the agreement that the Respondent had 28 days from the date of loading on 17th January 2026 to return the empty container to Mombasa and in the event of any delay resulting in accrual of container demurrage, the Respondent would be held personally liable for such charges.

According to the Claimant, the evidence shows that demurrage began accruing on 16th February 2026 (after expiry of the 28 free days from 17th January 2026, at USD 700 for the first cycle, and has continued to accrue at USD 100 per day thereafter. By 20th April 2026, the total accrued demurrage stood at USD 5,800 equivalent to KShs. 754,000/-. This is corroborated by the filed invoices by the Claimant.

The Respondent on his part states that he delivered the container at the warehouse but on arrival, was denied access for the reason that the Claimant had not obtained a validated storing order. This resulted in the Respondent having to wait till 2nd February 2026 for the container to be received and offloaded. The Respondent filed the gate pass dated 2nd February 2026 to corroborate this fact. The court has scrutinized the documents filed by the Respondent and found that they do not support this version of events. Per the whatsapp screenshots, the Respondent offloaded the container at the private yard on 2nd March 2026 and not 2nd February 2026 as pleaded. Why the Respondent would deliberately plead untrue facts worrying.

Be that as it may, in Jackline Njeri Kariuki v. Moses Njung’e Njau [2021] eKLR the court held that; a breach of contract is committed when a party, without lawful excuse, fails or refuses to perform what is due from him under the contract, or performs defectively, or incapacitates himself from performing. Presently, the Respondent was clearly in breach having delivered the container way after the 28-day timeline. No valid reason as to why the Respondent delayed for two weeks has been provided in order to justify the delay. In fact, the whatsapp messages filed demonstrate an admission of fault as the Respondent suggested a settlement plan to the Claimant.

Having found that the Respondent was in breach, in Kenya Wildlife Service v Awuor

(Civil Appeal E013 of 2022) [2023] KEHC 3721 (KLR) (26 April 2023)

(Judgment), the court held that under common law there cannot be a wrong without a remedy, put differently, Equity will not suffer a wrong to be without a remedy. The court finds in the circumstances of the case before it that the claimant is entitled to relief, but not in the whole amount claimed. After scrutinizing the invoices filed by the Claimant this court finds that the demurrage for the period of 16th to 28th February 2026 was USD 700, translating to USD 54 per day. From 1st March to 20th April 2026 demurrage would therefore stand at USD 2754 equivalent to Kshs. 355,266/- as per the current exchange rate of Kshs. 129 to the dollar. In total the Respondent is liable to pay USD 3454.

In the end, this court finds that the Claimant has proved its case against the Respondent on a balance of probabilities and enters judgment in favor of the Claimant for USD 3454 equivalent to KShs. 445,566/-interest from date of judgment. Parties to bear their own costs.

DATED SIGNED AND READ VIRTUALLY AT MOMBASA THE……24TH…. DAY OF……JUNE……2026

In the presence of;

……N/A…..Claimant;


HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

……Ms. Cherono….. for Respondent C/A Esther

SIGNED BY/FOR:

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-24 11:45:37

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-24 11:45:37

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder