Land law

Karanja v Njihia & 3 others [2026] KEELC 7487 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Suit 584 of 2015
Judgment date
4 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Applicant/ has filed the Notice of Motion application dated 15th January 2026 seeking for the following orders

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Consequently, I find no merit in the application dated 15th January 2026 and the same is hereby dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

Paragraph 32 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC SUIT NO. 584 OF 2015

MAINA KARANJA ................................................................................... PLAINTIFF

-VERSUS-

ABRAHAM MWANGI NJIHIA ...........................................................1ST DEFENDANT NAIROBI CITY COUNTY ................................................................2ND DEFENDANT

TERCY INVESTMENT LIMITED ........................................................3RD DEFENDANT

THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR.........................................................4TH DEFENDANT

RULING

Introduction

1. The Applicant/ has filed the Notice of Motion application dated 15th January 2026 seeking for the following orders

i. Spent

ii. THAT this honourable court be pleased to grant orders of stay of execution of the judgment/decree and all consequential orders issued on 9th February 2023 pending the hearing and determination of this application.

iii. THAT this honourable court be pleased to grant orders of stay of execution of the judgment/decree and all consequential orders issued on 9th February 2023 pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

iv. THAT Judgment and all consequential orders issued on 9th February 2023 be set aside.

v. THAT the 3rd Defendant be granted leave to file a Statement of Defence and Counter Claim to be heard on merit.

vi. THAT the honourable court do grant such other orders to meet the end of justice.

vii. THAT costs of this application be provided for.

2. The Applicant was premised on grounds as in the supporting affidavit of Mercy Kanyara interalia where she deponed that the Applicant herein is the registered owner of the suit property. That the Applicant was not aware of the summons that had been effected by way of substituted service in the local daily nation of 21st March 2017 and hence no aware of the suit and only became aware when an eviction notice was served on 8th January 2026.

3. She deponed that the suit proceeded in its absence and hence need to allow the Applicant be heard on their case as they raise a triable defence and hence this application seeking to set aside the judgement.

4. That the suit property has been leased to third parties who are tenants of the 3rd Defendant and unless the orders of stay of execution of judgement are issued, he will face irreparable harm as the tenants will be evicted

5. The Applicant further deponed that they are willing and ready to pay throw away costs.

Reply

6. The Plaintiff opposed the application vide a replying affidavit sworn on the 2nd February 2026.He deponed that he was the registered owner of the suit property having obtained it through an allotment by the 2nd Defendant and further issuance of lease dated 31st January 2001.

7. That the 1st Defendant caused for title to be issued to him fraudulently in conjunction with the 2nd Respondent notwithstanding that the Plaintiff had acquired title over it. That the purported sale of the suit to the 3rd Defendant by the 1st Defendant was therefore an irregularity as it was not available for sale

8. He deposed that he raised a caution on the same and the 3rd Defendant was aware of his claim over the suit property .That based on this order of events, he filed the present suit where the 3rd Defendant was served by way of substituted service but did not enter appearance an the matter proceeded with participation of the 2nd and 4th Defendant which matter was delivered in his favour and he was issued with a certificate of title the court having ordered the title in the 3rd Defendant’s name to be revoked.

9. He depones that the Applicant cannot claim lack of knowledge of the suit rather it is a case where the 3rd Defendant has been indolent in defending their case.

10. The Applicant filed a further affidavit annexing its draft defence

11. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions with the Applicant filing submissions dated 18th February 2026 whereas the Respondent filed submissions dated 27th February 2026.

Applicant/3rd Defendant submissions.

12. Counsel submitted on the following issues;

Whether the sufficient cause had been shown to warrant setting aside of the judgement.

13. The Applicant reiterated on the contents of its supporting affidavit that the Applicant was not aware of the suit and on becoming aware of it filed this instant application annexing its defence that was argued to have triable issues and that in the interest of justice the court should allow the application relying in the case of Wachira Karani Vs Bildad Wachira [2016] eKLR and the court of Appeal case of Geeta Bharat Shah & 4 others Vs Omar Said Mwatayari & another [2009] KECA 126 (KLR).

14. Counsel submitted on whether stay of execution should issue as per order 22 rule 22 of the civil procedure rules. He submitted that the application had been made without undue delay having been filed on the 15th January 2026 after became aware of the orders issued when served with a notice of eviction on the 8th January 2026.

15. He submitted that he hd demonstrated substantial loss being that the suit property had tenants in occupation who might end up facing eviction and in the cause of it have their properties destroyed and loss of livelihoods. That should the matter proceed and be in favour of the Applicant and the orders of stayed not issued, the prejudice will be irreversible as status quo will have been altered.

Plaintiff/Respondent’s submissions

16. Counsel submitted that the Applicant was served by substituted service which was lawful pursuant to the orders of the court and once substituted service is effected and affidavit of service filed, then there a raises presumption of proper service and cannot be invalidated because the Applicant claims lack of knowledge.

17. The Plaintiff further submitted that the annexed draft defence did not raise triable issues and does not address the core issues in the judgement that the ownership of his title emanated from the 1st Defendant who had no title to transfer.

18. On whether stay should issue he argued that stay was meant to preserve subject matter pending determination of proceedings and in this case, the title of the 3rd Defendant had been revoked and the Applicant given title over the suit property. That the Applicant had not met the threshold for grant of stay of execution.

19. That there was inordinate delay, the application having been filed in January of 2026 whereas the judgement was rendered on 9th February 2023.

20. Lastly counsel submitted that litigation ought to come to an end and that the application is seeking to reopen matters already heard and determined conclusively.

Analysis and determination

21. Upon considering the Application, the replying affidavit and the pleadings herein the following issue comes up for determination:

Whether the judgement should be set aside

22. Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 provides as follows:-“Where judgment has been entered under this order the court may set aside or vary such judgment and any consequential decree or order upon such terms as are just.”A reading of this provisions clearly stipulates that the court has unfettered discretion to set aside judgment on such terms as it deems fit and just.

23. In the case of Patel Vs East Africa Cargo Service Limited (1974) EA 75, the Court underscored this provision in the following terms:“ The main concern of the court is to do justice to the parties and the court will not impose conditions on itself to fetter the wide discretion given to it by the Rules.”

24. Before I can exercise my jurisdiction under Order 10 Rule 11 above, I firstly have to ascertain whether the default judgment is a regular or irregular one

25. . The court in the case of Fidelity Commercial Bank Limited vs Owen Amos Ndungu & Another, HCC.NO. 241/1998 gave a distinction between a regular and irregular judgment as follows: “A distinction is drawn between regular and irregular judgments. Where summons to enter Appearance has been served and there is default in entry of Appearance the ex parte judgment entered in default is regular. But where the Exparte judgment sought to be set aside is obtained either because there was no proper service or any service at all, of the summons to enter appearance, such judgment is irregular and the affected Defendant is entitled to have it set aside as of right”

26. In our instant case it is not in dispute that the summons to enter appearance were served through substituted service and hence the default judgement entered therefore was a regular one which in turn gives this court the discretion to set it aside or not.

27. Where the default judgment is regular, then I have to consider if the draft Defence filed raises triable issues. This was the holding in the case of James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another Vs Marios Philotas Ghikes & Another [2016] eKLR. In the pertinent part, the court held thus: “In a regular default Judgment, the Defendant will have been duly served with summons to enter Appearance, but for one reason or another, he failed to enter appearance or to file a Defence, resulting in default Judgment. Such a Defendant is entitled under Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules to move to court to set aside the default Judgment and to grant him leave to defend the suit. In such a scenario, the court has unfettered discretion in determining whether or not to set aside the default Judgment and will take into account such factors as to the reason as for the failure of the Defendant to file his memorandum of Appearance, or defence, as the case may be, the length of time that has elapsed since the default judgment was entered; whether the intended Defence raises triable issues, the respective prejudice each party is likely to suffer whether on the whole, it is in the interests of justice to set aside the default Judgment.”

28. From the foregoing, it follows therefore that before a regular Judgment can be set aside, the following conditions must obtain:

a) Reason for failure to file a memorandum of Appearance or Defence;

b) The length of time that has elapsed since default Judgment was entered

c) Whether the intended Defence raises triable issues;

d) Prejudice likely to be suffered by each of the parties; and

e) Whether on the whole, it is in the interests of justice to set aside the default Judgment.

29. In this case I have already dealt with service and ascertained it was effectively served, the time taken to file this application is a period of 4 years which the Applicant points back to service and hence will not consider it.

30. I have looked at the annexed draft defence dated 9th February 2026 attached to the further affidavit and I note that the same does not raise triable issues. The Defendant has not backed up his defence to establish how he acquired title from the 1st Defendant who had no legal rights to transfer the suit property.

31. The 3rd Defendant has also not disputed the title that was held by the Plaintiff neither has it been challenged on the basis of fraud or misrepresentation with sufficient evidence find the defense to be a mere denial.

Final disposition:

32. Consequently, I find no merit in the application dated 15th January 2026 and the same is hereby dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED via e-mail at NAIROBI on this 4th day of November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder