Small Claims

Kuria v Manundu & another [2026] SCC 42 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Nairobi
Case number
Civil Case E066 of 2025
Judgment date
26 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The claimant’s renewed preliminary objection on jurisdiction was rejected: the Small Claims Court held it has jurisdiction over personal-injury claims arising from alleged assault. Nevertheless, the suit was struck out because its expeditious determination could not be achieved and the claimant’s conduct showed reluctance to prosecute it; costs of Kshs. 10,000 were awarded to the respondents.

Supporting judgment passages

3. The position of this court on its jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims for assault has neither changed nor was it overturned on appeal. This court therefore reiterates its above finding that it has jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims arising out of an assault.

Paragraph 3 →

8. In the present case, the scale leans heavily in favour of striking out the suit. This is not because the court lacks jurisdiction but because the overriding objective of the Small Claims Court, which is facilitating the expeditious disposal of disputes cannot be achieved. Moreover, it would be futile to continue hearing a matter where the claimant’s conduct demonstrates a reluctance to have the matter determined expeditiously.

Passage 36 →

9. Consequently, this suit is struck out with costs to the respondents which are assessed at a minimal fee of Kshs. 10,000/=.

Passage 37 →
Issue 1Whether the Small Claims Court has jurisdiction to determine the claimant’s personal-injury claim arising from an alleged assault.

Held. Decided. The Court held that it has jurisdiction over personal-injury claims arising from assault and rejected the claimant’s renewed jurisdictional objection. The road-traffic-accident decision relied on by the claimant was distinguishable because its insurance-verification concerns had no bearing on an assault claim.

Ratio. Section 12(1)(d) of the Small Claims Court Act confers jurisdiction over compensation for personal injuries. A personal-injury claim based on alleged assault falls within that jurisdiction. The Gathaiya decision did not displace that result because it concerned road-traffic claims and statutory insurer rights of re-examination and verification that do not apply to this claim.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

3. The position of this court on its jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims for assault has neither changed nor was it overturned on appeal. This court therefore reiterates its above finding that it has jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims arising out of an assault.

Paragraph 3 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

3. The position of this court on its jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims for assault has neither changed nor was it overturned on appeal. This court therefore reiterates its above finding that it has jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims arising out of an assault.

Paragraph 3 →

4. The claimant’s learned counsel in his submissions on the issue, referred this court to the land mark decision in Gathaiya vs AG and 2 others; and 176 interested parties (Petition E008 of 2024) (consolidated) (2026) KEHC 290 (KLR) (22nd January 2026) (Judgement) and asserted that the court’s finding in that matter, that the Small Claim Court was unsuited to handle personal injury claims arising from road traffic accidents applied in a similar manner to personal injuries claims arising out of an assault.

Paragraph 4 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

4. The claimant’s learned counsel in his submissions on the issue, referred this court to the land mark decision in Gathaiya vs AG and 2 others; and 176 interested parties (Petition E008 of 2024) (consolidated) (2026) KEHC 290 (KLR) (22nd January 2026) (Judgement) and asserted that the court’s finding in that matter, that the Small Claim Court was unsuited to handle personal injury claims arising from road traffic accidents applied in a similar manner to personal injuries claims arising out of an assault.

Paragraph 4 →
Issue 2Whether the suit should continue despite the claimant’s failure to supply the required supporting documents and her conduct in prosecuting the claim.

Held. Decided. The Court struck out the suit, not for want of jurisdiction, but because the overriding objective of expeditious disposal could not be achieved. The claimant had not attached a medical report or receipts, failed to use leave granted to file additional documents, and acted inconsistently by later challenging jurisdiction she had previously defended. Costs of Kshs. 10,000 were awarded to the respondents.

Ratio. Where continued proceedings cannot achieve the Small Claims Court’s overriding objective of expeditious dispute resolution, and the claimant’s conduct demonstrates reluctance to have the matter determined promptly, striking out is justified. The Court treated the delay and non-prosecution conduct—not absence of jurisdiction—as determinative.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

8. In the present case, the scale leans heavily in favour of striking out the suit. This is not because the court lacks jurisdiction but because the overriding objective of the Small Claims Court, which is facilitating the expeditious disposal of disputes cannot be achieved. Moreover, it would be futile to continue hearing a matter where the claimant’s conduct demonstrates a reluctance to have the matter determined expeditiously.

Passage 36 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

8. In the present case, the scale leans heavily in favour of striking out the suit. This is not because the court lacks jurisdiction but because the overriding objective of the Small Claims Court, which is facilitating the expeditious disposal of disputes cannot be achieved. Moreover, it would be futile to continue hearing a matter where the claimant’s conduct demonstrates a reluctance to have the matter determined expeditiously.

Passage 36 →

9. Consequently, this suit is struck out with costs to the respondents which are assessed at a minimal fee of Kshs. 10,000/=.

Passage 37 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

8. In the present case, the scale leans heavily in favour of striking out the suit. This is not because the court lacks jurisdiction but because the overriding objective of the Small Claims Court, which is facilitating the expeditious disposal of disputes cannot be achieved. Moreover, it would be futile to continue hearing a matter where the claimant’s conduct demonstrates a reluctance to have the matter determined expeditiously.

Passage 36 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling determines the claimant’s preliminary objection raised on 11th February 2026 challenging the jurisdiction of this court to handle the instant suit. In a nutshell, the claimant’s case against the respondents was for inter alia general damages and special damages. She averred that on 30th October 2024 at about 9:45 a.m., the respondents attacked her at their residential compound in Old Donholm estate, causing her to loss and…

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

Consequently, this suit is struck out with costs to the respondents which are assessed at a minimal fee of Kshs. 10,000/=.

Paragraph 9 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Small Claims Court had jurisdiction to determine a claim for compensation for personal injuries allegedly caused by assault; whether the decision in Gathaiya v AG and 2 others; and 176 interested parties applied to the claim; and whether the suit…

Material facts

Lucy Nduku Kuria alleged that, on 30 October 2024 at about 9:45 a.m., Felix Manundu and Jane Mueni attacked her at their residential compound in Old Donholm estate. She sought general and special damages for injuries and loss allegedly sustained. The judgment…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MILIMANI

CIVIL CASE NO. E066 OF 2025

LUCY NDUKU KURIA …............................................................ CLAIMANT

VERSUS

FELIX MANUNDU ........................................................... 1ST RESPONDENT

JANE MUENI ................................................................. 2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling determines the claimant’s preliminary objection raised on 11th February 2026 challenging the jurisdiction of this court to handle the instant suit. In a nutshell, the claimant’s case against the respondents was for inter alia general damages and special damages. She averred that on 30th October 2024 at about 9:45 a.m., the respondents attacked her at their residential compound in Old Donholm estate, causing her to loss and sustain injuries for which she sought compensation.

2. It is important to note that the respondent had raised a similar preliminary objection against the jurisdiction of this court to handle the matter on 17th January 2025 and this court dismissed the objection. In its decision delivered on 5th June 2025, this court held as follows;

“7. The scope of the Small Claims Court’s jurisdiction is provided under section 12 of the Small Claims Court Act which provides;

Subject to this Act, the Rules and any other law, the Court has jurisdiction to determine any civil claim relating to—

a contract for sale and supply of goods or services;

a contract relating to money held and received;

liability in tort in respect of loss or damage caused to any property or for the delivery or recovery of movable property;

compensation for personal injuries; and

set-off and counterclaim under any contract. [Emphasis added]

8. In the present case, the claimant has sued the respondents for damages after she was allegedly attacked and injured by the respondents.

9. Her cause of action is based on what is legally defined as a tort of trespass to person. In the case of HWK v Rachel N. Kang’ethe & Karen Hospital Nairobi [2019] KEHC 1753 (KLR) the court held;

“The tort of trespass to a person is a wrong committed against the personal security or personal liberty of one man by another. There are three varieties of trespass to person namely assault, battery and wrong imprisonment.”

10. In its determination of the Small Claims Court’s jurisdiction, the court in Ogwari v Hersi (Civil Appeal 223 of 2022) [2023] KEHC 2011 (KLR) (3 July 2023) (Judgment) held that claims for personal injury due to assault and allied causes can still be filed in the Small Claims Court.

11. The court in Jane v Runga (Civil Appeal E034 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 11036 (KLR) (18 September 2024) (Judgment) similarly found that the Small Claims Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine personal injury claims.

12. While it would have been ideal for the criminal matter to be heard and determined first, the institution of criminal proceedings does not bar a civil court from simultaneously hearing a matter arising out of similar facts. (Maina & 4 others v Director of Public

Prosecutions & 4 others (Constitutional Petition E106 & 160 of 2021 (Consolidated)) [2022] KEHC 15 (KLR) (Constitutional and Human Rights) (27 January 2022) (Judgment)

13. Accordingly, the preliminary objection based on the court’s jurisdiction is dismissed.”

3. The position of this court on its jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims for assault has neither changed nor was it overturned on appeal. This court therefore reiterates its above finding that it has jurisdiction to handle personal injury claims arising out of an assault.

4. The claimant’s learned counsel in his submissions on the issue, referred this court to the land mark decision in Gathaiya vs AG and 2 others; and 176 interested parties (Petition E008 of 2024) (consolidated) (2026) KEHC 290 (KLR) (22nd January 2026) (Judgement) and asserted that the court’s finding in that matter, that the Small Claim Court was unsuited to handle personal injury claims arising from road traffic accidents applied in a similar manner to personal injuries claims arising out of an assault.

5. The present suit is however distinguishable from the case of Gathaiya vs AG (supra) as the cause of action in the present case did not arise from a road traffic accident but from an alleged assault. An insurer’s right to have a claimant re-examined and to verify the information provided by the claimant as provided under Section 3A and 3B of the Insurance (Motor Vehicle Third Party Risks) Act, 2013, was central to the decision of the court in the case of Gathaiya vs AG (supra). The provisions of the Insurance (Motor Vehicle Third Party Risks) Act, 2013 have no bearing in the determination of the present suit. It would however be prudent for a claimant to adhere to Rule 12 (5) (3) of the Small Claims Court Rules which provides thus;

“A person claiming compensation for personal injuries pursuant to section 12(1)(d) of the Act shall attach to the Statement of Claim—

(a) a medical report from a licenced medical practitioner; and

(b) any receipts in respect of medical expenses incurred on treatment.”

6. The claimant in the present suit did not attach a medical report or receipts to her claim. She only became aware of this omission during the hearing of the matter. Although the court granted the claimant leave to file additional documents, she failed to take advantage of that opportunity. Her conduct thereafter suggest that she has since lost interest in pursuing the claim. This is illustrated by the fact that whereas she had vigorously opposed the respondent’s preliminary objection raised on 17th January 2025 challenging this court’s jurisdiction to determine the personal injury claim arising from the alleged assault, she subsequently sought, quite inconsistently, to challenge this court’s jurisdiction on the very grounds she had earlier resisted.

7. This court takes note that the instant suit was filed on 13th November 2024. The suit has not been heard to conclusion or determined close to two years later. In other circumstances, this court would have been inclined to sustain the suit in the interest of justice, considering the time and resources already expended by the court and the parties. The decision of the court in the Biosystems Consultants v Nyali Links Arcade (Civil Appeal E185 of 2023) [2023] KEHC 21068 (KLR) (31 July 2023) (Ruling) would be instructive in this regard. In that elaborate decision, Majanja J. held as follows on the timelines of the Small Claim Court;

“56. The purpose of the Small Claims Court Act is to facilitate expeditious disposal of the disputes while at the same time respecting the right to be heard. The net result is that balancing the two may result at times to overshooting the 60 days. The 60 days do not have penal consequences for good reason. They are aspirational. This is part of having access to justice over amounts that need not be in the normal system. Allowing the application will open floodgates that will eventually defeat the purpose of the Act.

57. It is my take that the non- compliance goes to the court’s performance and is answerable internally. It cannot affect parties who are in court and ready to be heard. I have seen defendants use various gimmicks to have matters adjourned and thereafter turn around to say, 60 days are over. The parties have wasted a full month arguing in this court and with preliminary objections that are much ado about nothing.”

8. In the present case, the scale leans heavily in favour of striking out the suit. This is not because the court lacks jurisdiction but because the overriding objective of the Small Claims Court, which is facilitating the expeditious disposal of disputes cannot be achieved. Moreover, it would be futile to continue hearing a matter where the claimant’s conduct demonstrates a reluctance to have the matter determined expeditiously.

9. Consequently, this suit is struck out with costs to the respondents which are assessed at a minimal fee of Kshs. 10,000/=.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT MURANG’A THIS 26TH DAY OF JUNE 2026.

HON. GRACE WAITHĨRA

SENIOR RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

RULING SENT VIA CTS PLATFORM IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 23 (4) (B) OF THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT RULES.

ANY AGGRIEVED PARTY HAS LEAVE TO EXERCISE THEIR RIGHT OF APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE DATE HEREOF.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder