Background
This suit has a checkered history. On 5/6/2024, the court was told that the initial plaintiff passed on in September 2022. There had been no substitution. The court marked the suit abated.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This suit has a checkered history. On 5/6/2024, the court was told that the initial plaintiff passed on in September 2022. There had been no substitution. The court marked the suit abated.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI
ELC E193 OF 2020
MANSUKHLAL VITHALDAS HINDOCHA ……PLAINTIFF
VS
STEPHEN JUMA NDEDA …………………..DEFENDANT
RULING
1. This suit has a checkered history. On 5/6/2024, the court was told that the initial plaintiff passed on in September 2022. There had been no substitution. The court marked the suit abated.
2. By an application dated 11/6/2024, the court was asked to revive the abated suit. The application was allowed on 10/7/2024. When the matter came up on 29/1/2025, the court was told that the defense had been struck out on 10/11/2021. PW1 proceeded with his evidence.
3. There is no evidence that the defendants attended court to cross-examine the witness. The plaintiff closed the case, and judgment was reserved for 17/12/2025. This is when the defendants filed an application dated 3/12/2025 seeking leave to come on record, arrest of the judgment, setting aside of the proceedings for the suit to start de novo, leave to comply with Order 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and to adduce evidence in support of the defendants.
4. The reasons are contained on the face of the application and in a supporting affidavit of Stephen Juma Adenda sworn on 3/12/2025. It is deposed that though a defense was filed dated 22/2/2021, it was struck out for non-compliance with Order 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules on 10/11/2021 as he was yet to receive some documents from the Land Registrar, and that there was a pending application dated 30/4/2021 and a preliminary objection on res judicata. The defendant terms the striking out of his defense drastic, yet it had raised triable issues.
5. The defendant says that he was blocked from presenting his documents in support of ownership of the suit property contrary to Articles 40 and 50 of the Constitution. The defendants admit that on 10/7/2024, the respondent was granted leave to comply with Order 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules by filing a trial bundle after leave was granted to file an amended plaint.
6. The defendant says that on 14/11/2024, the plaintiff abandoned filing the amended plaint, which would have allowed him to regularize his defense. The defendant says that if judgment is delivered, there will be a miscarriage of justice before he is allowed to file pre-trial documents and a defense.
7. The court's record shows that the defendant on 17/6/2021 told the court that he was awaiting a Land Registrar letter to comply with Order II of the Civil Procedure Rules. The court ordered the defendant to comply within 30 days; in default, his defense to stand struck out with costs.
8. At a mention on 10/11/2021, the defendant had not complied. He asked for more time, which was opposed by the plaintiff. The court declined to extend time. It held that the orders of 17/6/2021 had taken effect. The defendant did not appeal or seek review of those orders.
9. Further, the defendant did not appear in court on 4/4/2022, 27/6/2022, and 23/11/2022. He only made appearances on 13/2/2023, 17/4/2023, 6/7/2023, 27/9/2023, 11/12/2023, 12/3/2024, 13/3/2024, and 5/6/2024.On 10/7/2024, when directions to comply with Order 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules were issued, the defendant was represented.
10. The counsel attended court on 14/11/2024. A date for pre-trial was given for 11/12/2024. Learned counsel for the defendant did not seek to revive its struck-out defense.
11. The defendant was present when a date for 29/1/2025 was given. He did not show up on that day and later on 25/2/2025. On 31/7/2025, the defendant was represented by a new advocate who had filed a notice of change of advocates. He sought an adjournment to peruse the proceedings. The defendant was granted an opportunity to regularize their defense. The hearing was rescheduled for 30/9/2025. The defendant did not show up. The matter proceeded with PW1, and the plaintiff's case was closed. Two weeks before judgment could be rendered, the defendant filed the instant application.
12. In Musila v Thengi & 2 others (Civil Appeal 607 of 2019) [2025] KECA 750 (KLR) (9 May 2025) (Judgment), the court cited with approval Union Insurance Company of Kenya Ltd v Ramzan Abdul Dhanji, Civil Application No. Nai. 179 of 1998 (Court of Appeal at Nairobi), that whereas the right to be heard is a basic natural justice concept and ought not to be taken away lightly, the court looks at the record to see if the applicant has been accorded that opportunity.
13. The court said that the law is not that a party must be heard in every litigation, but that a party must be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and once that opportunity is given and is not utilized, the party not utilizing the opportunity can only blame themselves.
14. In this application, the applicant has set out 13 grounds in support of the certificate of urgency, 40 grounds in support of the notice of motion, and 41 paragraphs in the supporting affidavit. None of the close to 80 paragraphs addresses the question of why, given the opportunity to be heard, the applicant failed to comply with Order 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules and has, to date, not attached the draft witness statements and documents he will rely upon at the hearing, if at all he is given a chance.
15. There is no single letter attached to show that the defendant, then and up to now, wrote to the Land Registrar to retrieve the documents to rely upon, filed and served the same upon the plaintiff.
16. The defendant became aware of the striking out of his defense on 10/11/2021. As of the recall of PW1, the defendant for four years had not asked for the reinstatement of his defense. As of the hearing date, the defendant had not sought leave to defend the suit.
17. The defendant has not given a plausible reason for the inordinate delay. Above all, the defendant was given a chance to attend the hearing and did not show up to cross-examine the plaintiff.
18. The court record shows that the defendant has been indolent and not vigilant in defending the suit. That lethargy is exhibited in the manner in which the defendant has casually approached the court.
19. The defendant filed a notice of change of advocates, yet he is still seeking leave to come on record. Is it that the defendant is so ignorant of the procedures, that he does not know that he does not need leave to change advocates? Is it that the defendant did not peruse the file or was all along attending mentions without knowing that there was no defence, list of witnesses, and exhibits to be relied upon at the hearing, until the plaintiff closed his case?
20. What led the advocate on record to wake up from his slumber on the eve of the judgment, yet the date for the hearing had been taken by consent?
21. The court is not convinced that the defendant is entitled to the reliefs sought in the notice of motion. It is dismissed with costs.
22. Judgment on 27.1.2027.
Signed, dated and delivered on this 4th day of November, 2026 at Milimani.
….……………….
Honorable Justice C.K. Nzili
Judge.
In the presence of:
Mr. Kagunyi for plaintiff/respondent
Miss Wanjau for defendant/applicant
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Beverly