REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI
ELC NO. 464 OF 2012
DEFINED PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LIMITED….1ST PLAINTIFF
DIANA KARAN ACHIENG T/A AKOSOMBO DESIGNS .………………………….………………….2ND PLAINTIFF
SAMMY NGAO T/A MASAI SHOP…………………… 3RD PLAINTIFF
EVERDELICIOUS SPRINGS LIMITED………….…. 4TH PLAINTIFF
PAUL THUMBI KUBAI & ISAIAH MWANIKI
T/A MOTOR SCOPE ……………………………..…….5TH PLAINTIFF
DOMINIC KIMANI KARANJA …………………..…...6TH PLAINTIFF
TUSSY OKWARO T/A XALA AFRICA ……….…..…. 7TH PLAINTIFF
ASMARA FOODS LTD ……………………………...….8TH PLAINTIFF
ESTHER TEBULIWA NYINDO
T/a LESENTECH INTERIOR DESIGNS ……………. 9TH PLAINTIFF
JOSEPH KENANDA MAKARIOUS ……………..…. 10TH PLAINTIFF
ELEGANT OCCASSIONS LIMITED ……….……….11TH PLAINTIFF
ATEINO ONYONYI ……………………………..…….12TH PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
HASSAN SAID OMAR ………………….…………….1ST DEFENDANT
OLYMPIC TRADING COMPANY LTD …….……….2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
1. The general rule is that costs follow the event. This is captured in Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act. This suit was listed for notice to show cause why it should not be dismissed on 21/7/2026. Instead of showing cause, the plaintiff sought to have the suit withdrawn with no order as to costs.
2. The defendants, while not opposing the withdrawal, submitted that the suit has taken the plaintiff over 10 years and dragged them to court, where they have incurred costs and expenses to defend themselves to the extent of exhausting their intellectual capacity, time, and resources, including compliance with Order II of the Civil Procedure Rules.
3. The court record shows that this suit was filed on 31/7/2012 regarding a lease dated 23rd March 2010 for 5 years, which the defendants were alleged to have breached and forced the plaintiff to vacate on 18/5/2012, thereby causing them loss, damage, and injury.
4. After the first defendant passed, on the defendants were given time to substitute. When the matter came up on 23/10/2024, the 2nd and 10th defendants' advocates said that they had no instructions to proceed with the matter. Another advocate came on record on 27/1/2025. Other reasons for non-prosecution of the suit were the death of the 13th plaintiff.
5. Legal costs are at the discretion of the court. No party has a right to costs unless ordered by the court. The general rule may be departed from by the court in exceptional circumstances. Such exceptions include tender offers and if the plaintiff does not succeed in all aspects of their claim.
6. The basis for the court to depart from the general rule was discussed in Joseph Oduor Anode v. Kenya Red Cross Society [2012] eKLR.The court said reasons must be given for departing from the general rule.
7. If the defendant infringed on the rights of the plaintiff, the plaintiff is entitled to enforce his right and, in the absence of any real reason such as misconduct, is entitled to the costs of the suit as a matter of course.
8. The discretion to grant or deny costs must be exercised judiciously, as held in Party of Independent Candidate of Kenya & another v Mutula Kilonzo & 2 others [2013] eKLR, High Court E.P. No. 6 of 2013, and in Orix Oil (Kenya) Limited v Paul Kabeu, Francis Kiriu & Teresa Waithira Kiriu (all trading as Royal Filling Station) [2014] eKLR.
9. In this matter, the plaintiffs brought the suit out of an alleged eviction or interference with the leased premises by the landlord. Looking at the records of the case, both parties have contributed to the delay of the matter. The court finds that each party in the circumstances should bear their own costs.
10. File marked closed.
Signed, dated and delivered on this 4th day of November, 2026 at Milimani.
….……………..
Hon. Justice C.K. Nzili,
Judge.
In the presence of:
Mr. Bruno for 1st defendant
Mr. Magadi for Mr.Osundwa for 2nd defendant
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn N.