Employment law

Kenya Building Construction Timber & Furniture Industries Employees Union v Vaghjiyan Enterprises Limited [2026] KEELRC 4654 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E720 of 2022
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application was partly allowed: extension of time to file the Notice of Appeal was declined as unnecessary because the Notice filed on 12 March 2026 was timely; the request for leave for Mucheru Law LLP to come on record was spent; and execution of the 2 March 2026 judgment was stayed pending appeal. The existing security deposit was maintained, and costs were to abide the appeal.

Supporting judgment passages

a) That the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March, 2026 was filed within time, and the prayer for extension of time is therefore unnecessary and is declined.

Passage 63 →

c) A stay of execution of the judgment delivered on 2nd March, 2026, be and is hereby granted pending determination of the appeal.

Passage 65 →

d) The costs of the application shall abide the appeal.

Passage 66 →
Issue 1Whether there is a basis to extend time for filing the Notice of Appeal; and

Held. No. The Notice of Appeal filed on 12 March 2026 was within time, because the judgment had been delivered on 2 March 2026. The enlargement prayer was therefore unnecessary and was declined.

Ratio. Extension of time is discretionary, with the applicant bearing the burden to provide a satisfactory basis, including explanation and length of delay, prejudice, and promptness. However, an extension cannot properly be granted as a precaution where the Notice of Appeal was already filed within time.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(i) Whether there is a basis to extend time for filing the Notice of Appeal; and

Passage 34 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

a) That the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March, 2026 was filed within time, and the prayer for extension of time is therefore unnecessary and is declined.

Passage 63 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

19. The power to enlarge time is a judicial discretion. The Supreme Court in Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] KESC 12 (KLR) set out the guiding principles, stating that extension of time is not a right, and that the applicant bears the burden of laying a satisfactory basis including the length and explanation of the delay, the prejudice to the Respondent and whether the application was brought without undue delay.

Paragraph 19 →

22. It then follows that, on the evidence before the court, the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March 2026 was lodged within time.

Paragraph 22 →

23. Consequently, the prayer for enlargement of time is unnecessary and cannot properly be granted merely as a precautionary order.

Paragraph 23 →
Issue 2Whether the Applicant has established the requirements for stay of execution.

Held. Yes. A stay of execution of the judgment delivered on 2 March 2026 was granted pending determination of the appeal. The application had been filed without unreasonable delay, and the existing deposit of Kshs. 3,401,726 was maintained as security because the decree did not compute the individual unfair-termination compensation. Costs were to abide the appeal.

Ratio. Under Order 42 rule 6(2), stay requires potential substantial loss, an application without unreasonable delay, and court-ordered security. A bare assertion that decree-holders lack means does not ordinarily establish inability to refund. Security is to protect the successful party and should cover the actual decretal obligation, without punishing or fettering an intending appellant's right of appeal.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(ii) Whether the Applicant has established the requirements for stay of execution.

Passage 35 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

38. The decree, however, does not compute the compensation amount, and for this reason, the amount of security already deposited will be maintained.

Paragraph 38 →

c) A stay of execution of the judgment delivered on 2nd March, 2026, be and is hereby granted pending determination of the appeal.

Passage 65 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

i. that substantial loss may result unless stay is granted;

Passage 50 →

31. The Applicant herein contends that the Claimants are persons of limited means and may be unable to refund the decretal amount if the intended appeal succeeds. While inability to refund a decretal sum may, in an appropriate case, constitute substantial loss, the burden lies upon the Applicant to place sufficient material before the Court to demonstrate the alleged inability. A bare assertion that the decree-holders are persons of limited means is ordinarily insufficient.

Paragraph 31 →

35. The Claimant's contention that the compensation awarded under paragraph 64 was omitted from the Applicant's computation is material. Security must cover the actual decretal obligation, and not an amount selectively extracted from the Judgment.

Paragraph 35 →
Issue 3Whether there is a basis to extend time for filing the Notice of Appeal

Held. No. The court found that the Notice of Appeal filed on 12 March 2026 was timely and declined extension as unnecessary.

Ratio. Where the Notice of Appeal has already been filed within the prescribed time, enlargement is unnecessary and should not issue merely as a precautionary order.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether there is a basis to extend time for filing the Notice of Appeal

Court’s reasoning →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

a) That the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March, 2026 was filed within time, and the prayer for extension of time is therefore unnecessary and is declined.

Passage 63 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

22. It then follows that, on the evidence before the court, the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March 2026 was lodged within time.

Paragraph 22 →

23. Consequently, the prayer for enlargement of time is unnecessary and cannot properly be granted merely as a precautionary order.

Paragraph 23 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before Court is the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 1st April, 2026, brought pursuant to Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution, Sections 12 and 27 of the ELRC Act, Sections IA, I, and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Rule 17 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, and Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Respondent/Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the rival positions. The issues for determination are:

Paragraph 16 →

Reasoning passage

Accordingly, the Consent to Change Advocates, having been duly executed by the outgoing and incoming advocates and filed in the Court record, I find no necessity for a separate order granting leave merely to validate that consent.

Paragraph 27 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether time should be enlarged for the respondent to file a notice of appeal; whether Mucheru Law LLP required leave to come on record after judgment; and whether execution should be stayed pending determination of the appeal.

Material facts

Following a judgment delivered on 2 March 2026, the respondent sought enlargement of time to file a notice of appeal, validation of a contemporaneously filed notice, leave for its new advocates to come on record, and stay. It attributed delay to former…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E720 OF 2022

KENYA BUILDING CONSTRUCTION

TIMBER & FURNITURE

INDUSTRIES EMPLOYEES UNION……………………………...CLAIMANT

VERSUS

VAGHJIYAN ENTERPRISES LIMITED ………….……………RESPONDENT

RULING

1. Before Court is the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 1st April, 2026, brought pursuant to Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution, Sections 12 and 27 of the ELRC Act, Sections IA, I, and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Rule 17 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, and Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Respondent/Applicant seeks the following reliefs: -

i. Spent

ii. Spent

iii. Spent

iv. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to extend the time for the Applicant to file and serve the Notice of Appeal against the Judgment of Hon. Justice J. N. Abuodha delivered on 13th February, 2026.

v. THAT the Notice of Appeal filed concurrently with this application be deemed as properly filed and served upon payment of requisite court fees.

vi. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to grant a stay of execution of the Judgment and Decree delivered on 13th February, 2026 pending the hearing and determination of the intended Appeal in the Court of Appeal.

vii. THAT the costs of this application be in the cause.

2. The application is supported by grounds on the face of the Motion and the affidavit of Hiten Vagjiani, sworn on 1st April, 2026.

3. The Applicant states that the delay in filing the Notice of Appeal arose from its former advocates, who did not promptly inform it of the delivery of the Judgment sought to be appealed against. The Applicant avers that it has since appointed Mucheru Law LLP, who acted diligently to regularize the matter.

4. The Applicant further attributes the delay to an apparent discrepancy between the Judgment date of 2nd March 2026 and the CTS date of 13th February 2026.

5. The Applicant contends that the delay is neither inordinate nor unexplained, and that the intended appeal is arguable and should not be defeated by a breakdown in communication with their former counsel.

6. The Applicant further argues that unless execution is stayed, the intended appeal may be rendered nugatory. It further contends that the Claimants/Respondents are persons of limited means and may be unable to refund the decretal sum should they be forced to pay the decretal sum.

7. The Applicant finally avers that it is willing to furnish security as may be directed by the Court and urges that the orders sought be granted in the interests of justice and the overriding objective.

8. The Claimant/Respondent opposed the application vide a replying affidavit sworn by Julius Macharia Maina on 14th May, 2026. The Claimant contends that there is no basis for the prayers seeking leave for Mucheru Law LLP to come on record or for the enlargement of time to file a Notice of Appeal, since the Respondent/Applicant, through the same firm of Mucheru Law LLP, had already lodged a Notice of Appeal on 12th March 2026, which was subsequently served upon the Claimant on 23rd March 2026.

9. The Claimant further disputes the alleged confusion regarding the date of Judgment, asserting that the Judgment in ELRC Cause No. 720 of 2022 was delivered on 2nd March 2026, and not 13th February 2026. The Claimant further states that the CTS and the decree signed on 24th March 2026 confirm this position.

10. The Claimant states that the Respondent’s own Notice of Appeal identifies 2nd March 2026 as the date of delivery of the Judgment. The Claimant further contends that the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March 2026 was lodged within the prescribed 14 day period running from the date of Judgment, 2nd March 2026, and therefore no extension of time was necessary.

11. The Claimant states that the CTS also shows that, together with the Notice of Appeal, the Respondent filed a Consent to Change Advocates, duly signed by the former and the incoming advocates, but which consent was not served upon the Claimant. The Claimant therefore questions the Respondent’s failure to disclose these matters, which were already reflected in the CTS.

12. On the issue of stay, the Claimant refers to the conditional stay orders issued on 16th April 2026, which were served on 29th April 2026. It disputes the Respondent’s computation of the decretal sum at Kshs. 3,401,726, asserting that the correct amount, including the individual compensation awarded under paragraph 64 of the Judgment, is Kshs. 4,753,111.

13. The Claimant avers that the Respondent only served the relevant documents after receiving its demand dated 27th March 2026 for payment of the full decretal sum. The Claimant further states that the Respondent deliberately omitted the compensation component from its Motion in an attempt to mislead the Court regarding the amount to be deposited as security. It therefore maintains that any conditional stay should only take effect upon deposit of the full decretal sum of Kshs. 4,753,111.

14. The Claimant finally submits that since the Respondent had already filed a Notice of Appeal within time, there is no basis for enlargement of time.

15. Parties canvassed the application through written submissions. Each party filed submissions, which were duly considered.

Analysis and Determination

16. I have considered the rival positions. The issues for determination are:

(i) Whether there is a basis to extend time for filing the Notice of Appeal; and

(ii) Whether the Applicant has established the requirements for stay of execution.

Whether there is a basis to extend time for filing the Notice of Appeal

17. The Applicant/Respondent seeks enlargement of time within which to lodge a Notice of Appeal against the Judgment which it contends was delivered on 13th February 2026.

18. The Applicant attributes the delay to its former advocates' failure to promptly communicate the delivery of the Judgment and to an alleged discrepancy between the date appearing in the Judgment and that shown in the CTS.

19. The power to enlarge time is a judicial discretion. The Supreme Court in Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] KESC 12 (KLR) set out the guiding principles, stating that extension of time is not a right, and that the applicant bears the burden of laying a satisfactory basis including the length and explanation of the delay, the prejudice to the Respondent and whether the application was brought without undue delay.

20. In the present case, however, the question of enlargement of time is substantially overtaken by events, going by the evidence before the Court. The Claimant/Respondent has demonstrated, and the Applicant has not seriously controverted, that Mucheru Law LLP lodged a Notice of Appeal on 12th March 2026, and served it on the Claimant on 23rd March, 2026.

21. More importantly, the Claimant's evidence is that the Judgment was delivered on 2nd March, 2026, and that this is the date appearing in the Respondent's own Notice of Appeal. Further, the physical copy of the Judgment in the court record also shows that the Judgment was delivered on 2nd March, 2026 and not 13th February 2026 as alleged by the Respondent/Applicant.

22. It then follows that, on the evidence before the court, the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March 2026 was lodged within time.

23. Consequently, the prayer for enlargement of time is unnecessary and cannot properly be granted merely as a precautionary order.

24. The Claimant has also questioned the prayer concerning the coming on record of Mucheru Law LLP, pointing out that the CTS contains a Consent to Change Advocates signed by the outgoing and incoming advocates.

25. Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that where there is a change of advocate after judgment, the change may be effected either by an order of the Court upon application with notice to all parties, or by a consent filed between the outgoing and incoming advocates.

26. In Municipal Council of Kisumu v Advocates & Another [2024] KECA 1120 (KLR), the Court of Appeal reaffirmed that a litigant changing advocates after judgment must comply with Order 9 Rule 9, while recognizing that the rule permits the change to be effected by consent.

27. Accordingly, the Consent to Change Advocates, having been duly executed by the outgoing and incoming advocates and filed in the Court record, I find no necessity for a separate order granting leave merely to validate that consent.

28. The prayer for leave to come on record is consequently spent.

29. On the prayer for stay of execution, Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules provides the substantive conditions for stay as follows:

i. that substantial loss may result unless stay is granted;

ii. that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and

iii. such security as the Court orders for the due performance of the decree.

30. These principles were succinctly restated in Butt v Rent Restriction Tribunal [1979] KLR 417, where the Court of Appeal held that the discretion to grant stay should be exercised in a manner that does not prevent an appeal. The Court must, however, consider the special circumstances of the case.

31. The Applicant herein contends that the Claimants are persons of limited means and may be unable to refund the decretal amount if the intended appeal succeeds. While inability to refund a decretal sum may, in an appropriate case, constitute substantial loss, the burden lies upon the Applicant to place sufficient material before the Court to demonstrate the alleged inability. A bare assertion that the decree-holders are persons of limited means is ordinarily insufficient.

32. On the question of delay, the application was filed on 1st April 2026, shortly after the Judgment that was delivered on 2nd March 2026. The Court is therefore satisfied that the application for stay was brought without unreasonable delay.

33. The Court further notes that the Applicant has expressed willingness to furnish security, which is an important consideration, and has indeed deposited an amount, but which the Claimants contend is not sufficient to satisfy the decree. In Mbula v Nguku [2023] KEHC 17886 (KLR), the court held that security is intended to ensure that, should the appeal fail, the successful litigant is not left without an effective means of enjoying the fruits of the decree.

34. The Applicant has deposited an amount of Kshs. 3,401,726, whereas the Claimant asserts that, upon including the compensation awarded to the individual grievants under paragraph 64 of the Judgment, the decretal amount is Kshs. 4,753,111.

35. The Claimant's contention that the compensation awarded under paragraph 64 was omitted from the Applicant's computation is material. Security must cover the actual decretal obligation, and not an amount selectively extracted from the Judgment.

36. The purpose of security is not to punish an intending appellant or to fetter the right of appeal, but to protect the successful party against the risk that the decree will ultimately become incapable of enforcement.

37. The decree placed before this court, indeed, carries an award of Kshs. Kshs. 3,401,726 and further grants compensation for each grievant for unfair termination.

38. The decree, however, does not compute the compensation amount, and for this reason, the amount of security already deposited will be maintained.

39. In conclusion, I make the following findings:

a) That the Notice of Appeal filed on 12th March, 2026 was filed within time, and the prayer for extension of time is therefore unnecessary and is declined.

b) The prayer for leave for Mucheru Law LLP to come on record is similarly spent, as a valid Consent to Change Advocates between the outgoing and incoming advocates was duly filed.

c) A stay of execution of the judgment delivered on 2nd March, 2026, be and is hereby granted pending determination of the appeal.

d) The costs of the application shall abide the appeal.

40. Orders accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Ms. Chege present for the Claimant

Ms. Kaggia h/b for Mr. Gathu for the Respondent

Ms. Esther S -C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder