Employment law

Gichuhi v Tropikal Brands (Africa) Limited & another [2026] KEELRC 4655 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause E226 of 2021
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the Claimant’s motion application dated 9th July, 2025, brought pursuant to Section 3 of the Employment & Labour Relations Act and Article 159 of the Constitution of Kenya, wherein the Claimant seeks the following reliefs: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The sole issue for determination is whether the 2nd Respondent’s witness statement and list and bundle of documents, filed seven days outside the period directed by the Court, should be expunged from the record.

Paragraph 20 →

Reasoning passage

In the upshot, I find and hold that the interests of justice will be better served by admitting the documents as opposed to expunging them as sought herein.

Paragraph 34 →

Full judgment

THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. E226 OF 2021

PAULINE WAMBUI GICHUHI.……………………….………….CLAIMANT

VERSUS

TROPIKAL BRANDS (AFRICA) LIMITED…………...……1ST RESPONDENT

DANONE NUTRICIA AFRICA……………………….….2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling relates to the Claimant’s motion application dated 9th July, 2025, brought pursuant to Section 3 of the Employment & Labour Relations Act and Article 159 of the Constitution of Kenya, wherein the Claimant seeks the following reliefs: -

i. THAT the 2nd Respondent's Witness Statement dated 20th May, 2025 as well as the 2nd Respondent's List of Documents dated 20th May, 2025, be expunged from the Court record.

ii. THAT the costs of this Application and be awarded to the Claimant.

2. The application is supported by grounds on the face of the Motion and the affidavit of Pauline Wambui Gichuki, sworn on 9th July, 2026.

3. The Claimant contends that the 2nd Respondent’s application dated 22nd June 2024 sought to strike out her claim, which had already been filed three years earlier. It avers that by a ruling delivered on 30th April 2024, although the Court found no merit in the 2nd Respondent’s application, it nevertheless granted the Respondent 14 days to file its List of Witnesses, Witness Statement and Supplemental Bundle of Documents in the interests of justice, which period lapsed on 14th May 2025.

4. The Claimant states that the 2nd Respondent subsequently filed its Witness Statement and List of Documents dated 20th May 2025, without seeking an extension of time. The Claimant therefore argues that the documents were filed out of time and in breach of the Court’s express directions.

5. The Claimant avers that the late filing is an abuse of the Court process, contending that it undermines the Court’s orders and unnecessarily delays the determination of a matter that had already substantially progressed.

6. She consequently urges the Court to expunge the impugned documents from the record.

7. The 2nd Respondent opposed the application vide a Replying affidavit sworn by Hermann YOUAN on 23rd March, 2026. It states that by a ruling delivered on 30th April 2025, the Court allowed the Claimant’s application dated 1st March 2024 and directed that it file and serve its list of witnesses, witness statements and supplementary bundle of documents within 14 days.

8. It avers further that the Claimant’s application had sought leave to file a further list of documents, and that in the circumstances, it required the Claimant’s further documents to fully appreciate the case and prepare a comprehensive response.

9. It is its case that it nevertheless filed and served its list of witnesses, witness statement, and list and bundle of documents on 21st May 2025, albeit seven days outside the prescribed 14-day period.

10. The 2nd Respondent explains that the seven-day delay was neither deliberate nor contumelious and was not intended to obstruct justice. It attributes the delay to logistical and administrative challenges, including that it is a foreign company whose key decision makers and approving authorities are based in France, necessitating additional time to obtain instructions, approvals, and the execution of the requisite documents.

11. It further states that it was obtaining and reviewing relevant material, including the Claimant’s intended transcript of the disciplinary proceedings, to enable it to prepare a comprehensive response. The Respondent contends that the delay was therefore minimal, reasonably explained, and not occasioned by negligence or an intention to prejudice the Claimant. The 2nd Respondent further avers that the documents were filed and served immediately upon finalization.

12. The Respondent maintains that the Claimant has suffered no prejudice, particularly because her case had been reopened and she had not yet concluded her testimony, giving her an opportunity to respond to the documents during the hearing.

13. The 2nd Respondent further denies any wilful disobedience of the Court order and characterizes the allegation of contempt as unfounded and exaggerated. It asserts that expunging documents is a discretionary power which should be exercised sparingly, particularly where no prejudice or abuse of process is demonstrated. The Respondent relies on the principle that substantive justice should be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities, and argues that a minor and excusable delay should not deprive it of the opportunity to fully present its case.

14. The 2nd Respondent contends that the documents filed on 21st May 2025 are material and necessary for the just determination of the dispute, particularly on the nature of the relationship between the Respondents, and whether an employment relationship existed between the Claimant and the 2nd Respondent.

15. It argues that expunging the documents would cause it substantial prejudice and impair its right to a fair hearing, without conferring any corresponding benefit on the Claimant. It therefore seeks enlargement of time and an order deeming the documents filed on 21st May, 2025, as duly and properly filed and on record.

16. The Respondent maintains that the interests of justice favour consideration of all relevant material to facilitate a complete and effective adjudication of the dispute.

17. It contends that the Claimant’s application is meritless, overly technical, and intended to prevent the 2nd Respondent from fully participating in the proceedings.

18. The 2nd Respondent consequently prays that the Claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 9th July 2025 be dismissed with costs.

19. Parties canvassed the motion by way of written submissions. The Court received submissions from the participating parties and have been duly considered.

Analysis and Determination

20. The sole issue for determination is whether the 2nd Respondent’s witness statement and list and bundle of documents, filed seven days outside the period directed by the Court, should be expunged from the record.

21. The overriding objective under Section 3 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act requires the Court to facilitate the just, expeditious, efficient and proportionate resolution of disputes. A party, however, ought not to simply disregard a prescribed timeline and assume that Article 159(2)(d) will automatically cure the default.

22. The Supreme Court in Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] KESC 12 (KLR) held that extension of time is an equitable remedy, not a right, and that the applicant bears the burden of explaining the delay.

23. Having said this, Article 159(2)(d) does not permit procedural rules to be elevated above substantive justice. In Raila Odinga & 5 Others v IEBC & 3 Others [2013] eKLR, the Supreme Court explained that the provision is intended to prevent procedural requirements from trumping the primary objective of doing substantive justice.

24. The Court of Appeal has similarly cautioned in Gachuhi & Another v Wanjohi & 5 Others [2022] KECA 473 (KLR), that Article 159(2)(d) does not oust a litigant’s obligation to comply with procedural imperatives.

25. The more specific question of admitting material filed outside the prescribed timelines was considered by this Court in Ondieki v Works Development Agency & 5 Others [2022] KEELRC 1637 (KLR), where it observed that pre-trial directions are essentially case management tools and should not necessarily operate to exclude relevant evidence where the Court is satisfied with the explanation offered and the opposing party can be given an opportunity to respond. The Court considered the stage of the proceedings, the nature of the evidence, the reason it was not filed earlier and the prejudice likely to be occasioned.

26. More recently, in DHL Worldwide Express Kenya Ltd v Mutuma [2024] KECA 938 (KLR), the Court of Appeal interfered with the refusal by the ELRC to admit supplementary documents, holding that the discretion had not been exercised judiciously. The Court emphasized procedural fairness and the need to maintain a level playing field, particularly where the opposing party could adequately respond to the additional material.

27. The Court must, however, guard against indolence and trial by ambush. In Waithera v Haltons Pharmacy Limited [2023] KEELRC 832 (KLR), the Court considered a challenge to documents filed out of time and without leave, noting the importance of compliance with case management directions and the circumstances in which a default may warrant intervention.

28. It is not disputed that the 2nd Respondent did not comply with the express direction requiring it to file and serve its documents within fourteen days. The question, however, is whether that default, in the circumstances of this case, warrants the drastic remedy of expunging the documents from the court record.

29. The delay of seven days is in my view relatively short. More importantly, the 2nd Respondent has explained that it is a foreign company whose relevant decision makers and approving authorities are based in France, and that it required additional time to obtain instructions, approvals, and execution of the necessary documents.

30. The explanation cannot be regarded as an automatic justification for non-compliance. A litigant, especially a corporate litigant, is expected to organize its affairs so as to comply with court timelines. The fact that decision makers are located outside Kenya does not, in itself, suspend or extend a court imposed deadline. Nevertheless, the explanation must be considered alongside the short duration of the delay, the stage reached in the proceedings and the prejudice, if any, to the Claimant.

31. The 2nd Respondent filed and served the documents shortly after the expiry of the period, but there is no evidence of repeated or wilful disobedience. The Court is further persuaded by the fact that the Claimant's case was reopened and has not concluded her testimony.

32. In my view, the Claimant retains a meaningful opportunity to consider, respond to and challenge the impugned evidence. There is, therefore, no demonstrated prejudice that cannot be cured by an appropriate order of the Court.

33. Conversely, expunging the documents would potentially deprive the 2nd Respondent of evidence which it says is central to its defence.

34. In the upshot, I find and hold that the interests of justice will be better served by admitting the documents as opposed to expunging them as sought herein.

35. Accordingly, I find the Claimant’s Notice of Motion dated 9th July 2025, lacking in merit, and is hereby dismissed.

36. The 2nd Respondent’s Witness Statement and the List and Bundle of Documents filed and served on 21st May 2025 are hereby deemed duly filed and properly on record.

37. Costs shall be in the cause.

38. Orders accordingly.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE

Appearance:

Mr. Thuita present for the Claimant

Ms. Ithondeka present for the 1st Respondent

Mr. Andiwo & Ms. Akech present for the 2nd Respondent

Ms. Esther S -C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder