Employment law

Eagle HR Consultants Ltd v Wanjiru & 58 others [2026] KEELRC 2807 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
8 October 2026
Judge(s)
C. N. Baari

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 17th June, 2026, brought pursuant to Rule 6 of the Employment and labour Relations Court Rules, Sections 18 (1) (b) and 3A of the Civil Procedure Rules and Order 50, Rule 1 & 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and Article 159 of the Constitution. The Applicant seeks orders THAT: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the Motion, the Supporting Affidavit, the Replying Affidavit, and the oral arguments made before the Court, the issues for determination are:

Paragraph 17 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

MISC. APPLICATION NO. E287 OF 2026

EAGLE HR CONSULTANTS LIMITED…………………..……… APPLICANT

VERSUS

JAMES MWAURA WANJIRU & 58 OTHERS…..…..….…RESPONDENTS

RULING

1. This ruling relates to the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 17th June, 2026, brought pursuant to Rule 6 of the Employment and labour Relations Court Rules, Sections 18 (1) (b) and 3A of the Civil Procedure Rules and Order 50, Rule 1 & 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and Article 159 of the Constitution. The Applicant seeks orders THAT: -

i. Spent

ii. THAT pending the hearing and determination of this application, this Honourable Court do stay proceedings of the listed matters in prayer 3 of this Application.

iii. THAT this Honourable Court do grant an Order to transfer the following suits currently pending before the Nairobi Chief Magistrate's Court, Employment and Labour Relations Division to Limuru Magistrates Court for hearing and determination:-

1. MCELRC E2397/2025: Martin Ndungu v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

2. MCELRC E2398/2025: Sammy Anderson Kalu v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

3. MCELRC E2399/2025: Geofrey Karanja Njeri v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

4. MCELRC E2400/2025: Anthony Wanjala v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

5. MCELRC E2401/2025: Peter Kamau Nganga v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

6. MCELRC E2455/2025: Eric Ongeri Momanyi v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

7. MCELRC E2456/2025: Samuel Wamwaki Mungau v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

8. MCELRC E2457/2025: Michael Ngege Migwi v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

9. MCELRC E2458/2025: Stephen Mbuvi Musyoka v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

10. MCELRC E2459/2025: Jared Bosire Omanga v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

11. MCELRC E2460/2025: Paul Ngugi Murage v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

12. MCELRCE2462/2025: Joshua Nyaga v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

13. MCELRC E2463/2025: Samuel Mwangi Njau v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

14. MCELRC E2464/2025: Paul Kimani Ndungu v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

15. MCELRC E2465/2025: James Malobe Mwende v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

16. MCELRC E2466/2025: James Nzyoka Musau v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

17. MCELRC E2467/2025: Mutunga Mutisya v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

18. MCELRC E2468/2025: Felix Mulwa Kitula v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

19. MCELRC E2469/2025: Catherine Atieno Okoth v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

20. MCELRC E2470/2025: Macvivienfoe Akoth v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

21. MCELRC E2471/2025: Philip Omweri Ratemo v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

22. MCELRC E2472/2025: Jared Egesa Okumu v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd 23.

23. MCELRC E2473/2025: Anthony Mbugua Ngugi v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

24. MCELRC E2474/2025 Gideon Gakure Mugure v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

25. MCELRC E2475/2025: Joshua Mukaa Nziu v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

26. MCELRC E2476/2025: Evans Ogechi v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

27. MCELRC E2477/2025: Samuel Mutua Musili v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

28. MCELRC E2478/2025: Rodgers Wanzala Oburo v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

29. MCELRC E2480/2025: Kitheka Kitili v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

30. MCELRC E2481/2025: Eric Mmayi Mwati v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

31. MCELRC E2482/2025: Caleb Onyango v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

32. MCELRC E2483/2025: Paul Njoroge v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

33. MCELRC E2484/2025: James Gatungo Wanjala v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

34. MCELRC E2485/2025: Stephen Michuki v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

35. MCELRC E2486/2025: Mwanzia Nguluma v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

36. MCELRC E2519/2025: Simon Comba Nganga v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

37. MCELRC E2575/2025: Musa Juma Japheth v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

38. MCELRC E2576/2025: Jesse Wanyoike Muthee v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

39. MCELRC E2577/2025: Samuel Mutua Musili v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

40. MCELRC E2716/2025: Bernard Wambua Kitoko v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

41. MCELRC E2717/2025: Simon Mbugua Kariuki v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

42. MCELRC E204/2026: Amwayi Kenneth Kitayi v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

43. MCELRC E524/2026: Geoffrey Mutinda Githome v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

44. MCELRC E663/2026: Christopher Kariri Nyamira v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

45. MCELRC E664/2026: Joseph Ndolo Mukeka v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

46. MCELRC E667/2026: Kelvin Mutua Kithome v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

47. MCELRC E788/2026: Joshua Mutungi Maluki v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

48. MCELRC E790/2026 Raphael Makata Mwende v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

49. MCELRC E791/2026: Joram Gitau Kamau v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd

50. MCELRC E792/2026: James Mwaura Wanjiru v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

51. MCELERC E793/2026: Stephen Mbithi John v Eagle HR Consultants Ltd.

iv. Costs of this application be awarded to the Applicant.

2. The application is supported by the grounds set out on the face and the supporting affidavit of MOSES KIRUI.

3. The Applicant states that the causes of action arose in Limuru, making Limuru Law Courts the appropriate forum for hearing the suits. It avers further that the parties, witnesses and subject matter are principally located in Limuru and its environs.

4. It is the Applicant’s position that the suits raise similar questions of fact and law, and their transfer to Limuru would facilitate their efficient and coordinated determination. It states that hearing the matters at Limuru would be more convenient and in the interests of justice, as it would promote the expeditious disposal of the suits while reducing costs and inconvenience to the parties.

5. The Applicant maintains that the transfer would minimize the risk of inconsistent or conflicting decisions by different courts, and that this Court has jurisdiction under Section 18 of the Civil Procedure Act to transfer suits between competent subordinate courts.

6. The Applicant finally contends that the Respondents would suffer no prejudice from the transfer, and that to the contrary, the transfer would be fair, just and equitable.

7. The Respondents opposed the application vide a replying affidavit sworn by Bentlynn Omolo on 23rd June, 2026. The Respondents state that the Applicant had previously challenged the suitability and jurisdiction of the Nairobi Court through a Preliminary Objection dated 30th October 2025, contending that the disputes ought to be heard elsewhere.

8. They argue that the Preliminary Objection was fully argued, with the parties filing and exchanging written submissions, and that on 5th March 2026, the trial court considered the parties’ respective arguments and dismissed the Preliminary Objection for lack of merit.

9. The Respondents state that the issue of whether the suits were properly instituted before the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Nairobi, and whether another forum was more appropriate, was directly raised, argued and determined in the ruling delivered on 5th March, 2026, and that the present application substantially seeks the same relief and raises substantially the same issues, albeit framed as an application for transfer.

10. The Respondents therefore contend that the issues are res judicata and/or subject to issue estoppel, having already been determined by the court.

11. The Respondents further aver that the Applicant has not disclosed the full effect of the 5th March 2026 ruling, despite its relevance to the present application, and that the ruling has neither been reviewed, varied nor set aside and remains in force.

12. The Respondents state that several of the suits sought to be transferred have already undergone mentions, pre-trial processes and case management directions before the Nairobi Court.

13. The Respondents maintain that the application has been brought in bad faith and is intended to delay the hearing and determination of claims that have been pending since 2025. They contend that a transfer at this stage would cause further delay and additional costs, given the substantial progress already made before the Nairobi Court.

14. The Respondents also point to material inconsistencies in the application, including discrepancies in the number of Respondents, duplication of names and inconsistencies in the list of suits sought to be transferred. They argue that the Applicant’s reliance on the fact that the causes of action arose in Limuru and that witnesses are located there does not constitute a new circumstance, since those matters were within the Applicant’s knowledge from the inception of the suits and were available when the Preliminary Objection was argued.

15. It is consequently contended that the Applicant has not demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant transfer of the suits, and the Respondents therefore urge the Court to dismiss the Motion dated 17th June 2026 with costs.

16. The parties urged the application orally before the Court on 21st September 2026, reiterating their respective pleadings.

Analysis and determination

17. Having considered the Motion, the Supporting Affidavit, the Replying Affidavit, and the oral arguments made before the Court, the issues for determination are:

i. Whether the application is barred by the doctrine of res judicata and/or issue estoppel

ii. Whether the Applicant has demonstrated sufficient grounds for transfer of the suits herein from Nairobi to Limuru.

Whether the application is barred by the doctrine of res judicata and/or issue estoppel

18. The Respondents’ principal objection is that the Applicant previously raised a Preliminary Objection dated 30th October 2025 challenging the propriety of the Nairobi Court as the forum for determination of the suits referred to herein. It is not disputed that the trial court heard and dismissed the objection on 5th March 2026.

19. The doctrine of res judicata is anchored in Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act. In IEBC v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] eKLR, the Supreme Court stated that the doctrine applies where the matter directly and substantially in issue was previously determined between the same parties, parties litigating under the same title, that the determination was by a competent court, and that the suit was heard and finally determined.

20. The material before the Court establishes that, indeed, the Applicant had previously challenged the Nairobi Court’s jurisdiction to hear the matters and that the objection was dismissed on 5th March 2026. However, the mere fact that territorial jurisdiction or the appropriateness of Nairobi was previously raised does not necessarily mean that the application for transfer is res judicata. The Court must examine the actual issue that was determined in the earlier ruling as well as the relief that was sought therein.

21. This distinction is particularly important because Rule 6(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024 provides the permissible places where employment proceedings may be instituted, while Rule 6(2) expressly empowers the Court, on its own motion or upon application and for recorded reasons, to transfer any proceeding to the most convenient court station for hearing and determination.

22. The present application, in my view, does not amount to an attempt to reopen the question of whether the Nairobi Court possesses jurisdiction, but an invocation of the Court’s discretionary power under Rule 6(2). All the Applicant therefore needed to do is demonstrate that Limuru is the more convenient station and that the transfer sought would serve the interests of justice.

23. The plea of res judicata based on the fact that a previous Preliminary Objection concerning the forum had been dismissed is therefore without merit.

24. Similarly, the plea of issue estoppel cannot be applied mechanically. The Court must identify the precise issue that was necessarily and finally determined in the earlier proceedings.

25. It therefore follows that a determination that Nairobi had jurisdiction is not, without more, necessarily a determination that Nairobi is the most convenient station for purposes of Rule 6(2).

26. The plea of estoppel thus equally cannot hold, and is declined.

Whether the Applicant has demonstrated sufficient grounds for transfer of the suits herein from Nairobi to Limuru.

27. The governing provision in respect of transfer is Rule 6(2) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024. The Rule contemplates transfer of an employment proceeding to “the most convenient court station” for hearing and determination.

28. In Kigotho v Acme Wanji Investment Limited [2024] KEELRC 13618 (KLR), the Court exercised its power under Rule 6(2) and transferred an employment claim from the Milimani Commercial Court to the Mavoko Magistrates’ Court after finding that the latter was the court with territorial jurisdiction.

29. Similarly, in Muchemi v Shujaazinc Limited [2025] KEELRC 1064 (KLR), the Court considered Rule 6(1) and (2) and recognized that the power to transfer proceedings is directed towards placing the matter before the most convenient court station.

30. The Applicant has placed before Court several considerations in support of transfer. It contends that the causes of action arose in Limuru, that the parties and witnesses are principally located there, that the suits involve substantially similar factual and legal questions, and that hearing them at Limuru would reduce expense and inconvenience.

31. These are no doubt relevant considerations. The fact that the cause of action arose in a particular locality is, however, not, by itself, determinative, but it is a material factor when assessing convenience. Further, the location of witnesses and the subject matter of the proceedings are relevant to the efficient and affordable determination of disputes.

32. The overriding objective of the civil process requires the Court to consider the just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of disputes and the efficient use of judicial resources. Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act identifies, among other objectives, the efficient disposal of proceedings and the timely disposal of cases at an affordable cost.

33. The Respondents have raised a significant consideration, which is that several of the suits have already undergone mentions, pre-trial processes and case management directions before the Nairobi Court. They contend that transfer at this stage would result in delay and additional costs.

34. The Respondents’ argument is, in my view, material. The Court need not merely identify the geographical location where the cause of action arose. It must balance that consideration against the stage reached in the proceedings, the inconvenience likely to be occasioned by transfer, the costs involved, and the overriding requirement for expeditious disposal.

35. The Applicant has, in my view, not demonstrated, with sufficient specificity, how the alleged inconvenience of continuing the matters at Nairobi outweighs the disruption that would be occasioned by transferring a substantial number of suits which have already progressed through case management. The fact that the causes of action arose in Limuru and the witnesses may be found there was, according to the Respondents, information known to the Applicant from the commencement of the proceedings.

36. There is also no significantly new circumstance arising after the ruling of 5th March 2026 that has been demonstrated to justify disturbing the position already adopted by the trial court.

37. Further, the proposed transfer of such a large number of cases at this stage is, in my view, more likely to cause disruption and delay than to advance their expeditious disposal.

38. In the present circumstances, I am not persuaded that the Applicant has established sufficient grounds for this Court to exercise its discretion in its favour.

39. I therefore find and hold that the Applicant has failed to demonstrate sufficient grounds for the exercise of the power of transfer.

40. Consequently, the Notice of Motion dated 17th June 2026 is dismissed.

41. The prayer for stay of proceedings, being interlocutory and dependent upon the success of the substantive prayer for transfer, likewise fails.

42. The costs of the application shall be borne by the Applicant.

43. It is so ordered.

SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 8TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

C. N. BAARI

JUDGE.

Appearance:

Ms. Somba h/b for Dr. Okubasu for the Applicant

Ms. Cheruiyot h/b for Mr. Ntabo for the Respondents

Ms. Esther S- C/A

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder