Small Claims

Wanjala v Progressive Credit Ltd [2026] SCC 80 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Mombasa
Case number
SCCCOMM/E358/2026 MICHAEL WANJALA VS PROGRESSIVE CREDIT LTD
Judgment date
29 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The claim succeeded substantially. The court declared the 14 April 2026 repossession of tuk-tuk KTWB 800D unlawful; ordered its immediate release, subject to the respondent’s right to repossess after proper and lawful notification of default and proclamation if the claimant remains in default; and awarded loss-of-use damages at Kshs. 1,500 per day up to judgment, with interest from judgment. The respondent’s Kshs. 62,462 counterclaim was dismissed. Each party was to bear its own costs.

Supporting judgment passages

The Respondent has filed a counterclaim for Kshs. 62,462/- against the Respondent. Kshs. 22,000/- being auctioneer fees and Kshs. 40,462/- being the loan default amount as at the time of filling. As already stated herein, the repossession of the Claimant’s tutktuk was illegal, the Respondent can therefore not be entitled to any money from the Claimant for an illegal act. Additionally, this court has already found that the Claimant is in default of Kshs. 12,678/-. Consequently, the counterclaim fails and is dismissed.

Passage 31 →

The prayer for mandatory injunction compelling immediate release of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D to the claimant is allowed with the rider that the Respondent reserves its right to upon proper and lawful notification of default and proclamation, to repossess the security herein if the Claimant remains to be in default.

Passage 34 →

The claim for damages for loss of user of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D calculated from the day of repossession being on the 14/4/2026 until the day of the judgement at the amount of kshs.3,000/-per day is allowed at the rate of Kshs.1,500/- per day up to date of judgment. The amount shall earn interest from date of judgment and each party to bear its own costs.

Passage 35 →
Issue 1Whether the Claimant was in default.

Held. Decided. The claimant was in default by Kshs. 12,678. The offer required repayment in four monthly instalments of Kshs. 12,702, totalling Kshs. 50,808. His payment of Kshs. 38,130 over three months did not fulfil those agreed terms.

Ratio. The signed offer letter was the binding contract because the claimant did not establish illegality, coercion, or fraud. The court would enforce rather than rewrite its repayment terms. The agreed 7% interest did not offend the in duplum rule.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Claimant was in default.

Court’s reasoning →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

It has not been disputed that the Claimant repaid Kshs. 38,130/- of the loan and that he had repaid the same in three months. This however was not the agreement as per the letter of offer. Once the Claimant elected to satisfy his loan within three months and not four as agreed, he was to restructure the monthly installments due in order to reflect this position. The Claimant was to pay Kshs. 50,808/- in total if there was no default. He has however paid Kshs. 38,130/- translating to a default of Kshs. 12,678/-equivalent to one month’s default. This court therefore finds that the Claimant is in default of Kshs. 12,678/-.

Passage 23 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

It is not in dispute that the Claimant took out a loan with the Respondent for Kshs. 39,673/- this is evidenced by the Claimant himself as well as the letter of offer filed by the Respondent. The letter of offer is the binding contract between the parties. The Claimant in his testimony in court admitted to signing the offer letter. He did not dispute the terms of the offer letter to be illegal, arrived at through coercion or fraud. As such this court will uphold the terms of the offer letter as binding and not attempt to rewrite the same.

Passage 21 →

It was a term of the offer letter that the sum of Kshs. 39,693/- was to be repaid in four monthly installments of Kshs. 12,702/-. Further, the loan would attract an interest of 7%. The same was agreeable to the Claimant at the time of taking the loan and does not offend the induplum rule in this court’s view which applies to all money lenders as was held in Francis Maria Wambugu vs Jitegemee Credit Ltd (2020) KEHC 2586 (KLR) and Mugure & 2 Others vs Higher Education Loans Boards (2022) KEHC 11951 (KLR).

Passage 22 →
Issue 2Whether the Respondent issued the Claimant with notice of default.

Held. Decided. No proper notice of default was given. The demand letter relied on did not prove receipt by the claimant and contained an erroneous postal address, despite the respondent having the claimant’s contact information and multiple contractual service methods.

Ratio. Upon default, the respondent was obliged to notify the claimant. Although clause 7 permitted service through specified physical, electronic, or publication means, the respondent did not establish effective service under those terms.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Respondent issued the Claimant with notice of default.

Passage 24 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

From the evidence on record, the Respondent relied on a demand letter dated 15th July 2025 as proof of notice of default to the Claimant. However, the said letter does not evidence receipt by the Claimant. The postal address written is equally erroneous. The Respondent possesses all the contact information relating to the Claimant, they were even able to trace him through their auctioneers and repossess the security herein. How then were they not able to effect proper service of the notice of default despite there being numerous avenues to effect the same is the question that tis court remains with. As such, the court finds that no proper notice was ever given to the Claimant of his default for him to be aware of the same and act on it.

Passage 26 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The Claimant being in default meant that the Respondent was obligated to notify him of the same. As per Clause 7 of the offer letter any notice by the lender shall be deemed to have been properly served on the borrower if delivered by hand or sent by post or by personalized electronic media including phone, SMS, social media, email, internet or other convenient means as notified to the lender by the borrower or through print media by a notice published in a local daily of nationwide circulation in Kenya.

Passage 25 →

From the evidence on record, the Respondent relied on a demand letter dated 15th July 2025 as proof of notice of default to the Claimant. However, the said letter does not evidence receipt by the Claimant. The postal address written is equally erroneous. The Respondent possesses all the contact information relating to the Claimant, they were even able to trace him through their auctioneers and repossess the security herein. How then were they not able to effect proper service of the notice of default despite there being numerous avenues to effect the same is the question that tis court remains with. As such, the court finds that no proper notice was ever given to the Claimant of his default for him to be aware of the same and act on it.

Passage 26 →
Issue 3Whether the process of repossession was proper.

Held. Decided. The attachment and repossession were illegal and void. The claimant had not been made aware of his default, and the respondent did not displace his evidence that the auctioneers repossessed the tuk-tuk before service of the relevant notice.

Ratio. Repossession was improper where the claimant had not received notice of default. The respondent’s bare affidavit narrative, without calling the auctioneers, did not rebut the claimant’s account that no notice was served before repossession.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the process of repossession was proper.

Passage 27 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The Claimant stated that the auctioneers came and took his tutktuk on 14th April 2026 and that they never identified themselves. The Respondent never called the auctioneers as a witness to rebut the evidence of the Claimant but relied on the affidavit file of Rose Waithira Kahiga in respect of the circumstances leading up to the repossession and that the Claimant refused to sign the Proclamation Notice and the Notice of Sale of Movable Properties. This court finds the same to contain a bare narration of the events and not enough to dislodge the Claim by the Claimant that by the time the Claimant came back to where the tutktuk was on the material day the auctioneers had already repossessed the tuktuk and was not served with the notice. As such, the attachment and repossession was illegal and resultantly void. I rely on the case of Mogo Auto Limited v Ochola (Civil Appeal E071 of 2023) [2023] KEHC 17527 (KLR) 4th May 2023).

Passage 29 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

It therefore follows that the repossession of the security herein was improper as the Claimant was not made aware of his default. According to the Claimant, he had repaid his loan in full, he still maintains this. The Respondent as per its documents deals with borrowers through a relationship manager. It is the duty of this relationship manager to actively engage the borrower once a loan is in default especially where the borrower has previously been making regular payments as the case herein before taking the aggressive action of repossessing the security.

Passage 28 →

The Claimant stated that the auctioneers came and took his tutktuk on 14th April 2026 and that they never identified themselves. The Respondent never called the auctioneers as a witness to rebut the evidence of the Claimant but relied on the affidavit file of Rose Waithira Kahiga in respect of the circumstances leading up to the repossession and that the Claimant refused to sign the Proclamation Notice and the Notice of Sale of Movable Properties. This court finds the same to contain a bare narration of the events and not enough to dislodge the Claim by the Claimant that by the time the Claimant came back to where the tutktuk was on the material day the auctioneers had already repossessed the tuktuk and was not served with the notice. As such, the attachment and repossession was illegal and resultantly void. I rely on the case of Mogo Auto Limited v Ochola (Civil Appeal E071 of 2023) [2023] KEHC 17527 (KLR) 4th May 2023).

Passage 29 →
Issue 4Whether the Claimant is liable to pay Kshs. 62,462/- as per the Counterclaim

Held. Decided. The claimant was not liable for the Kshs. 62,462 counterclaim, and it was dismissed. Although the court found a Kshs. 12,678 default, the respondent could not recover the counterclaimed sums, including auctioneer fees, arising from its illegal repossession.

Ratio. A respondent cannot recover money from a claimant for an illegal repossession; therefore the claimed auctioneer fees and loan-default amount were not recoverable through this counterclaim.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Claimant is liable to pay Kshs. 62,462/- as per the Counterclaim

Passage 30 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The Respondent has filed a counterclaim for Kshs. 62,462/- against the Respondent. Kshs. 22,000/- being auctioneer fees and Kshs. 40,462/- being the loan default amount as at the time of filling. As already stated herein, the repossession of the Claimant’s tutktuk was illegal, the Respondent can therefore not be entitled to any money from the Claimant for an illegal act. Additionally, this court has already found that the Claimant is in default of Kshs. 12,678/-. Consequently, the counterclaim fails and is dismissed.

Passage 31 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The Respondent has filed a counterclaim for Kshs. 62,462/- against the Respondent. Kshs. 22,000/- being auctioneer fees and Kshs. 40,462/- being the loan default amount as at the time of filling. As already stated herein, the repossession of the Claimant’s tutktuk was illegal, the Respondent can therefore not be entitled to any money from the Claimant for an illegal act. Additionally, this court has already found that the Claimant is in default of Kshs. 12,678/-. Consequently, the counterclaim fails and is dismissed.

Passage 31 →
Issue 5Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs claimed.

Held. Decided. The court issued a declaration that the repossession was unlawful; allowed immediate release of KTWB 800D, while preserving the respondent’s right to lawfully repossess after proper notification and proclamation if default persists; and awarded loss-of-use damages at Kshs. 1,500 per day up to judgment, with interest from judgment. Each party was to bear its own costs.

Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. The reliefs followed from the finding that repossession was illegal; the court articulated no separate governing principle for the loss-of-use rate or consequential orders.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs claimed.

Passage 32 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

As herein explained, the repossession of the Claimant’s tuktuk was illegal. Consequently, a declaration hereby issues that the actions of repossession by the Respondent on motor-vehicle registration(tuk-tuk) number KTWB 800D on the 14/4/2026 were unlawful without a proper notice and failing to provide proper documentation of default & repossession.

Passage 33 →

The prayer for mandatory injunction compelling immediate release of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D to the claimant is allowed with the rider that the Respondent reserves its right to upon proper and lawful notification of default and proclamation, to repossess the security herein if the Claimant remains to be in default.

Passage 34 →

The claim for damages for loss of user of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D calculated from the day of repossession being on the 14/4/2026 until the day of the judgement at the amount of kshs.3,000/-per day is allowed at the rate of Kshs.1,500/- per day up to date of judgment. The amount shall earn interest from date of judgment and each party to bear its own costs.

Passage 35 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

A declaration that the actions of repossession by the Respondent on motor-vehicle registration(tuk-tuk) number KTWB 800D on the 14/4/2026 were unlawful without a proper notice and failing to provide proper documentation of default & repossession.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether Michael Wanjala was in default under the loan agreement; whether Progressive Credit Ltd gave him notice of default; whether the repossession of tuk-tuk KTWB 800D was proper; whether Wanjala owed Kshs. 62,462 under the…

Material facts

Wanjala borrowed Kshs. 39,673 from Progressive Credit Ltd under an offer letter he admitted signing. The letter provided for repayment in four monthly instalments of Kshs. 12,702 and interest at 7%. He paid Kshs. 38,130 in three months, while the court found…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT MOMBASA COUNTY COURT NAME: MOMBASA SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E358/2026 MICHAEL WANJALA VS PROGRESSIVE CREDIT LTD

JUDGMENT

The Statement of Claim herein filed on 22nd April 2026 seeks the following orders;

1. A declaration that the actions of repossession by the Respondent on motor-vehicle registration(tuk-tuk) number KTWB 800D on the 14/4/2026 were unlawful without a proper notice and failing to provide proper documentation of default & repossession.

2. Mandatory injunction compelling immediate release of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800Dto the claimant or any other order this court deems fit within the circumstances.

3. Damages for loss of user of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D calculated from the day of repossession being on the 14/4/2026 until the day of the judgement at the amount of kshs.3,000/-per day;

4. A declaration that the interest charged offend the in duplum rule contrary to section 44A of the Banking Act.

5. Interest of the amount awarded on (III) above herein at the court rates.

6. Costs of the suit.

In rendering its judgment, the court has considered the respective pleadings and

documents filed in support of each case as well as the oral testimony of the respective witnesses.

From the evidence on record, the court distills the following as the issues for determination;

1. Whether the Claimant was in default.

2. Whether the Respondent issued the Claimant with notice of default.

3. Whether the process of repossession was proper.

4. Whether the Claimant is liable to pay Kshs. 62,462/- as per the Counterclaim

5. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs claimed.

Whether the Claimant was in default.

It is not in dispute that the Claimant took out a loan with the Respondent for Kshs. 39,673/- this is evidenced by the Claimant himself as well as the letter of offer filed by the Respondent. The letter of offer is the binding contract between the parties. The Claimant in his testimony in court admitted to signing the offer letter. He did not dispute the terms of the offer letter to be illegal, arrived at through coercion or fraud. As such this court will uphold the terms of the offer letter as binding and not attempt to rewrite the same.

It was a term of the offer letter that the sum of Kshs. 39,693/- was to be repaid in four monthly installments of Kshs. 12,702/-. Further, the loan would attract an interest of 7%. The same was agreeable to the Claimant at the time of taking the loan and does not offend the induplum rule in this court’s view which applies to all money lenders as was held in Francis Maria Wambugu vs Jitegemee Credit Ltd (2020) KEHC 2586 (KLR) and Mugure & 2 Others vs Higher Education Loans Boards (2022) KEHC 11951 (KLR).

It has not been disputed that the Claimant repaid Kshs. 38,130/- of the loan and that he had repaid the same in three months. This however was not the agreement as per the letter of offer. Once the Claimant elected to satisfy his loan within three months and not four as agreed, he was to restructure the monthly installments due in order to reflect this position. The Claimant was to pay Kshs. 50,808/- in total if there was no default. He has however paid Kshs. 38,130/- translating to a default of Kshs. 12,678/-equivalent to one month’s default. This court therefore finds that the Claimant is in default of Kshs. 12,678/-.

Whether the Respondent issued the Claimant with notice of default.

The Claimant being in default meant that the Respondent was obligated to notify him of the same. As per Clause 7 of the offer letter any notice by the lender shall be deemed to have been properly served on the borrower if delivered by hand or sent by post or by personalized electronic media including phone, SMS, social media, email, internet or other convenient means as notified to the lender by the borrower or through print media by a notice published in a local daily of nationwide circulation in Kenya.

From the evidence on record, the Respondent relied on a demand letter dated 15th July 2025 as proof of notice of default to the Claimant. However, the said letter does not evidence receipt by the Claimant. The postal address written is equally erroneous. The Respondent possesses all the contact information relating to the Claimant, they were even able to trace him through their auctioneers and repossess the security herein. How then were they not able to effect proper service of the notice of default despite there being numerous avenues to effect the same is the question that tis court remains with. As such, the court finds that no proper notice was ever given to the Claimant of his default for him to be aware of the same and act on it.

Whether the process of repossession was proper.

It therefore follows that the repossession of the security herein was improper as the Claimant was not made aware of his default. According to the Claimant, he had repaid his loan in full, he still maintains this. The Respondent as per its documents deals with borrowers through a relationship manager. It is the duty of this relationship manager to actively engage the borrower once a loan is in default especially where the borrower has previously been making regular payments as the case herein before taking the aggressive action of repossessing the security.

The Claimant stated that the auctioneers came and took his tutktuk on 14th April 2026 and that they never identified themselves. The Respondent never called the auctioneers as a witness to rebut the evidence of the Claimant but relied on the affidavit file of Rose Waithira Kahiga in respect of the circumstances leading up to the repossession and that the Claimant refused to sign the Proclamation Notice and the Notice of Sale of Movable Properties. This court finds the same to contain a bare narration of the events and not enough to dislodge the Claim by the Claimant that by the time the Claimant came back to where the tutktuk was on the material day the auctioneers had already repossessed the tuktuk and was not served with the notice. As such, the attachment and repossession was illegal and resultantly void. I rely on the case of Mogo Auto Limited v Ochola (Civil Appeal E071 of 2023) [2023] KEHC 17527 (KLR) 4th May 2023).

Whether the Claimant is liable to pay Kshs. 62,462/- as per the Counterclaim

The Respondent has filed a counterclaim for Kshs. 62,462/- against the Respondent. Kshs. 22,000/- being auctioneer fees and Kshs. 40,462/- being the loan default amount as at the time of filling. As already stated herein, the repossession of the Claimant’s tutktuk was illegal, the Respondent can therefore not be entitled to any money from the Claimant for an illegal act. Additionally, this court has already found that the Claimant is in default of Kshs. 12,678/-. Consequently, the counterclaim fails and is dismissed.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs claimed.

As herein explained, the repossession of the Claimant’s tuktuk was illegal. Consequently, a declaration hereby issues that the actions of repossession by the Respondent on motor-vehicle registration(tuk-tuk) number KTWB 800D on the 14/4/2026 were unlawful without a proper notice and failing to provide proper documentation of default & repossession.

The prayer for mandatory injunction compelling immediate release of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D to the claimant is allowed with the rider that the Respondent reserves its right to upon proper and lawful notification of default and proclamation, to repossess the security herein if the Claimant remains to be in default.

The claim for damages for loss of user of motor-vehicle registration number KTWB 800D calculated from the day of repossession being on the 14/4/2026 until the day of the judgement at the amount of kshs.3,000/-per day is allowed at the rate of Kshs.1,500/- per day up to date of judgment. The amount shall earn interest from date of judgment and each party to bear its own costs.

DATED SIGNED AND READ VIRTUALLY AT MOMBASA THE…..29TH…. DAY

OF………JUNE……2026

In the presence of;


HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

…Mr. Tindi….. for Claimant;

…Mr. Musamali….… for Respondent C/A Esther

SIGNED BY/FOR:

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-29 12:03:59

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-29 12:03:59

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder