Small Claims

Mbugua v Mulewa [2026] SCC 144 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Mombasa
Case number
SCCCOMM/E238/2026 ROSALINE WANJIKU MBUGUA VS PETER MULEWA
Judgment date
30 June 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The claimant’s loan claim was dismissed. The respondent’s counterclaim succeeded against the claimant, with judgment for Kshs. 391,608 plus costs and interest from the filing date. The counterclaim against Beatrice Mbugua was dismissed without costs because she was not a proper party.

Supporting judgment passages

Ultimately, the Respondent’s counterclaim succeeds and judgment is entered in favor of the Respondent as against the Claimant, for Kshs. 391,608/- plus costs and interest from date of filing. The Claim dated stands dismissed.

Passage 21 →

account for Kshs. 808,400/- as being paid out to the Claimant and her daughter Beatrice Mbugua. The court finds the argument by the Claimant that Beatrice Mbugua was not party to the agreement between the Claimant and Respondent disingenuous as, the Claimant herself has relied on the MPESA statement of Beatrice Mbugua as part of her pleadings. In any case, the Respondent is not asserting that the said Beatrice was party to the loan agreement simply that loan repayments were made through her a fact which has been corroborated by the Claimants own evidence as stated earlier. It was therefore not necessary for the Respondent in the Counterclaim to include the said Beatrice as a party. The Counterclaim against the 2nd Respondent is thus dismissed without costs on account of being prejudicial to the said party as they are not a proper party to the Claim.

Passage 18 →
Issue 1Whether the Respondent is in default of the loan

Held. No. The court found that the respondent had paid Kshs. 808,400 to the claimant and her daughter, repaying the loan in full and in excess. He was therefore not in default.

Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. This was a factual determination from the M-PESA payment records; no separate legal rule was necessary to resolve it.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Respondent is in default of the loan

Court’s reasoning →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The Claimant has relied on two MPESA statement as evidence in support of her case. The first statement being for the Claimant and the other for her daughter Beatrice Mbugua. Per the MPESA statements, the Respondent has between 28th March 2023 to 25th January 2025 sent a total of Kshs. 808,400/- to the Claimant and her daughter Beatrice. By her own documents the Claimant is bound to this position which confirms that the Respondent has repaid the loaned amount in full and in excess. This court thus finds that the Respondent is not in default.

Passage 14 →
Issue 2Whether the Claimant is entitled to any reliefs

Held. No. The claimant’s claim was dismissed because she did not prove that the respondent remained indebted to her. The dismissal was without an order as to costs.

Ratio. Parties are bound by their pleadings, and a party alleging a fact must prove it. On the claimant’s own evidence, the respondent was not indebted to her, so she failed to prove the claim on a balance of probabilities.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Claimant is entitled to any reliefs

Passage 15 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Ultimately, the Respondent’s counterclaim succeeds and judgment is entered in favor of the Respondent as against the Claimant, for Kshs. 391,608/- plus costs and interest from date of filing. The Claim dated stands dismissed.

Passage 21 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

It is trite law that parties are bound by their own pleadings and that he who alleges must prove. In the instant case, the evidence filed by the Claimant has proven that the Respondent is not indebted to the Claimant. As such, the Claimant is not entitled to any reliefs having failed to prove its case on a balance of probabilities. The claim is thus dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Passage 16 →
Issue 3Whether the Counterclaim is merited and what is the consequence thereof.

Held. The counterclaim succeeded against the claimant, and judgment was entered for the respondent for Kshs. 391,608 plus costs and interest from the date of filing. However, the counterclaim against Beatrice Mbugua was dismissed without costs because she was not a proper party, notwithstanding that repayments had been made through her.

Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. The court’s determination turned on the payment records and the parties through whom repayment was made; it stated no distinct legal rule necessary to the monetary counterclaim determination.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Whether the Counterclaim is merited and what is the consequence thereof. Turning to the counterclaim, the Respondent equally filed MPESA transaction records for the period 1st January 2023 to 31st July 2025. Therein, the court has been able to

Passage 17 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

account for Kshs. 808,400/- as being paid out to the Claimant and her daughter Beatrice Mbugua. The court finds the argument by the Claimant that Beatrice Mbugua was not party to the agreement between the Claimant and Respondent disingenuous as, the Claimant herself has relied on the MPESA statement of Beatrice Mbugua as part of her pleadings. In any case, the Respondent is not asserting that the said Beatrice was party to the loan agreement simply that loan repayments were made through her a fact which has been corroborated by the Claimants own evidence as stated earlier. It was therefore not necessary for the Respondent in the Counterclaim to include the said Beatrice as a party. The Counterclaim against the 2nd Respondent is thus dismissed without costs on account of being prejudicial to the said party as they are not a proper party to the Claim.

Passage 18 →

Ultimately, the Respondent’s counterclaim succeeds and judgment is entered in favor of the Respondent as against the Claimant, for Kshs. 391,608/- plus costs and interest from date of filing. The Claim dated stands dismissed.

Passage 21 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether Peter Mulewa was in default under the loan advanced by Rosaline Wanjiku Mbugua; whether the claimant was entitled to the reliefs sought; and whether the respondent’s counterclaim for Kshs. 391,608 was merited. It also addressed…

Material facts

The parties agreed that on or about 1 January 2023, the claimant advanced the respondent Kshs. 239,400 at an agreed interest rate of 30% per annum. By 21 June 2025, the pleaded accrued interest was Kshs. 177,392, making the claimed total Kshs. 416,792. The…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT MOMBASA COUNTY COURT NAME: MOMBASA SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E238/2026 ROSALINE WANJIKU MBUGUA VS PETER MULEWA

JUDGMENT

It is an agreed fact by the parties as per their pleadings that on or about the 1st day of January 2023, the Claimant advanced various sums of money to the Respondent at his request. The total sum advanced amounted to Kshs. 239,400/- and it was agreed between that the said amount would attract interest at the rate of 30% per annum.

Further, it is not in dispute that by 21st June 2025, the loan interest accrued to Ksh 177,392/- thereby making the total loaned amount plus interest Ksh. 416,792/-.

The Claimant states that despite repeated promises to repay and despite numerous demands made by the Claimant, the Respondent has failed, neglected and/or refused to settle the outstanding debt. Further, that the Respondent cannot be permitted to retain the Claimant's money indefinitely while at the same time refusing to honour his repayment obligations. The Claimant relied on MPESA transaction records to support her claim.

On his part, the Respondent admits the debt but counterclaims against the Claimant Kshs. 391,608/- being the excess of the money repaid to the Claimant. It is the Respondent’s position that he has settled the debt in full and has made several payments all amounting to Kshs. 808,400/- to the Claimant and her daughter. The Respondent has filed MPESA transaction records to 7evidence their stance.

The matter proceeded for hearing on 9th June 2026 with both parties giving their evidence. Upon consideration of the pleadings, documents in support of the respective cases as well as the oral testimony by the parties, three issues stand out for determination;

a) Whether the Respondent is in default of the loan

b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to any reliefs

c) Whether the Counterclaim is merited and what is the consequence thereof.

Whether the Respondent is in default of the loan

The Claimant has relied on two MPESA statement as evidence in support of her case. The first statement being for the Claimant and the other for her daughter Beatrice Mbugua. Per the MPESA statements, the Respondent has between 28th March 2023 to 25th January 2025 sent a total of Kshs. 808,400/- to the Claimant and her daughter Beatrice. By her own documents the Claimant is bound to this position which confirms that the Respondent has repaid the loaned amount in full and in excess. This court thus finds that the Respondent is not in default.

Whether the Claimant is entitled to any reliefs

It is trite law that parties are bound by their own pleadings and that he who alleges must prove. In the instant case, the evidence filed by the Claimant has proven that the Respondent is not indebted to the Claimant. As such, the Claimant is not entitled to any reliefs having failed to prove its case on a balance of probabilities. The claim is thus dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Whether the Counterclaim is merited and what is the consequence thereof. Turning to the counterclaim, the Respondent equally filed MPESA transaction records for the period 1st January 2023 to 31st July 2025. Therein, the court has been able to

account for Kshs. 808,400/- as being paid out to the Claimant and her daughter Beatrice Mbugua. The court finds the argument by the Claimant that Beatrice Mbugua was not party to the agreement between the Claimant and Respondent disingenuous as, the Claimant herself has relied on the MPESA statement of Beatrice Mbugua as part of her pleadings. In any case, the Respondent is not asserting that the said Beatrice was party to the loan agreement simply that loan repayments were made through her a fact which has been corroborated by the Claimants own evidence as stated earlier. It was therefore not necessary for the Respondent in the Counterclaim to include the said Beatrice as a party. The Counterclaim against the 2nd Respondent is thus dismissed without costs on account of being prejudicial to the said party as they are not a proper party to the Claim.

The Judiciary of


2/3

Ultimately, the Respondent’s counterclaim succeeds and judgment is entered in favor of the Respondent as against the Claimant, for Kshs. 391,608/- plus costs and interest from date of filing. The Claim dated stands dismissed.

DATED SIGNED AND READ VIRTUALLY AT MOMBASA THE……30TH…. DAY OF……JUNE……2026

In the presence of;


HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

……Mr. Musa h/b for Gioche….…for Claimant;

……Mr. Frank Calvin….. for Respondent C/A Esther

SIGNED BY/FOR:

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-30 10:54:45

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-06-30 10:54:45

The Judiciary of


3/3

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder