Small Claims

Mbaka v Stanley [2026] SCC 109 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Mombasa
Case number
SCCCOMM/E309/2026
Judgment date
3 July 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment for the Claimant against the Respondent for Kshs. 414,992, representing the unpaid loan balance after crediting proved repayments. The claim for bank charges was not established. The award carries interest and costs of the suit from the date of judgment.

Supporting judgment passages

Based on the evidence on record therefore, the Claimant has proved its case on a balance of probabilities aganist the Respondent and judgment is entered for the Claimant against the Respondent for Kshs. 414,992/- together with interest and costs of the suit from the date herein.

Passage 12 →

Upon consideration of the evidence on record, the court has been able to establish that indeed the Respondent has been making payments to the Claimant as per the filed MPESA transaction messages. The court has been able to account for Kshs. 199,523 as the total amount paid. The balance therefore stands at Kshs. 414,992/-.

Court’s reasoning →

statements is repeated card purchases at TOSHA PETROLEUM BOMBOLULU and other merchants and Bank to Card transfers for unidentified purposes. The bank statements alone are not sufficient evidence of the Respondent's liability to settle bank charges. Additionally, the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 filed by the Claimant does not support the claim for bank charges as there is no evidence of the same being repayable by the Respondent from the said letter.

Passage 10 →
Issue 1Whether the Respondent remained liable for the loan debt, including whether the commitment letter was binding despite the allegation of duress and after crediting repayments.

Held. The Respondent remained liable for Kshs. 414,992. The court accepted MPESA evidence showing payments totalling Kshs. 199,523 and deducted that amount from the Kshs. 614,515 loan principal. It upheld the 18 April 2025 commitment letter as a valid, binding acknowledgment of debt because the Respondent did not prove duress.

Ratio. An allegation that a debt-acknowledgment agreement was made under duress must be supported by satisfactory evidence. In the absence of such proof, the commitment letter remains a binding acknowledgment of debt. Proven repayments must be credited against the admitted loan principal.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Upon consideration of the evidence on record, the court has been able to establish that indeed the Respondent has been making payments to the Claimant as per the filed MPESA transaction messages. The court has been able to account for Kshs. 199,523 as the total amount paid. The balance therefore stands at Kshs. 414,992/-.

Court’s reasoning →

The Respondent pleaded to have written the commitment letter under duress but failed to lead any evidence of duress to the satisfaction of the court such as steps taken after the fact to avoid the said agreement. I rely on the court’s finding in Ruto v Cherono (Civil Appeal E200 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 10947 (KLR) (20 September 2024) (Judgment) on what constitutes proof of duress. The court will thus uphold the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 as a valid acknowledgment of debt binding upon the Respondent.

Passage 11 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Upon consideration of the evidence on record, the court has been able to establish that indeed the Respondent has been making payments to the Claimant as per the filed MPESA transaction messages. The court has been able to account for Kshs. 199,523 as the total amount paid. The balance therefore stands at Kshs. 414,992/-.

Court’s reasoning →

The Respondent pleaded to have written the commitment letter under duress but failed to lead any evidence of duress to the satisfaction of the court such as steps taken after the fact to avoid the said agreement. I rely on the court’s finding in Ruto v Cherono (Civil Appeal E200 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 10947 (KLR) (20 September 2024) (Judgment) on what constitutes proof of duress. The court will thus uphold the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 as a valid acknowledgment of debt binding upon the Respondent.

Passage 11 →

Based on the evidence on record therefore, the Claimant has proved its case on a balance of probabilities aganist the Respondent and judgment is entered for the Claimant against the Respondent for Kshs. 414,992/- together with interest and costs of the suit from the date herein.

Passage 12 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The Respondent pleaded to have written the commitment letter under duress but failed to lead any evidence of duress to the satisfaction of the court such as steps taken after the fact to avoid the said agreement. I rely on the court’s finding in Ruto v Cherono (Civil Appeal E200 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 10947 (KLR) (20 September 2024) (Judgment) on what constitutes proof of duress. The court will thus uphold the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 as a valid acknowledgment of debt binding upon the Respondent.

Passage 11 →
Issue 2Whether the Claimant proved that the Respondent was liable for Kshs. 545,000 in alleged bank charges.

Held. No. The bank statements showed card purchases, transfers, and transactions whose purposes did not establish the Respondent's liability. The commitment letter also did not show that bank charges were repayable by the Respondent.

Ratio. Bank statements alone do not prove that another party is liable for bank charges where they do not demonstrate the purpose of the transactions or an obligation by that party to repay them; a commitment letter likewise cannot establish that liability unless it provides for repayment of those charges.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

As regards the bank charges, the Claimant has filed bank statements which in this courts view do not substantiate the claim as all that can be gotten from the said

Passage 9 →

statements is repeated card purchases at TOSHA PETROLEUM BOMBOLULU and other merchants and Bank to Card transfers for unidentified purposes. The bank statements alone are not sufficient evidence of the Respondent's liability to settle bank charges. Additionally, the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 filed by the Claimant does not support the claim for bank charges as there is no evidence of the same being repayable by the Respondent from the said letter.

Passage 10 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

statements is repeated card purchases at TOSHA PETROLEUM BOMBOLULU and other merchants and Bank to Card transfers for unidentified purposes. The bank statements alone are not sufficient evidence of the Respondent's liability to settle bank charges. Additionally, the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 filed by the Claimant does not support the claim for bank charges as there is no evidence of the same being repayable by the Respondent from the said letter.

Passage 10 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

statements is repeated card purchases at TOSHA PETROLEUM BOMBOLULU and other merchants and Bank to Card transfers for unidentified purposes. The bank statements alone are not sufficient evidence of the Respondent's liability to settle bank charges. Additionally, the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 filed by the Claimant does not support the claim for bank charges as there is no evidence of the same being repayable by the Respondent from the said letter.

Passage 10 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Respondent remained indebted to the Claimant under the admitted loan after the payments asserted by the Respondent; whether the Claimant proved that the Respondent was liable for Kshs. 545,000 in alleged bank charges; and whether the commitment…

Material facts

The parties agreed in their pleadings that the Respondent received Kshs. 614,515 from the Claimant as a loan. The Claimant alleged that the Respondent agreed to repay that principal plus bank charges, claiming Kshs. 1,159,515 comprising Kshs. 614,515…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT MOMBASA COUNTY COURT NAME: MOMBASA SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E309/2026

BENSON MURITHI MBAKA VS JOSHUA MUTETHIA STANLEY

JUDGMENT

It is an agreed fact by the parties as per their pleadings that the Respondent received Kshs. 614,515/- from the Claimant as a loan. Per the Statement of Claim dated 8th April 2026 the Claimant seeks judgment for a total of Kshs. 1,159,515/- being the principal sum of Kshs. 614,515/- and bank charges of Kshs. 545,000/-. By instituting this claim however, the Claimant has waived all sums in excess of one million Kenya Shillings, in line with the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court.

As per the Claimant, the Respondent agreed to refund the principal sum plus bank charges. The Respondent on his part denies the claim stating that he has already repaid Kshs. 204,323/- and that he never agreed to nor was he aware of the alleged bank charges. In support of his case, the Respondent filed screenshot messages of MPESA transactions to the Claimant for diverse dates between 4th September 2025 to 25th February 2026.

Upon consideration of the evidence on record, the court has been able to establish that indeed the Respondent has been making payments to the Claimant as per the filed MPESA transaction messages. The court has been able to account for Kshs. 199,523 as the total amount paid. The balance therefore stands at Kshs. 414,992/-.

As regards the bank charges, the Claimant has filed bank statements which in this courts view do not substantiate the claim as all that can be gotten from the said

statements is repeated card purchases at TOSHA PETROLEUM BOMBOLULU and other merchants and Bank to Card transfers for unidentified purposes. The bank statements alone are not sufficient evidence of the Respondent's liability to settle bank charges. Additionally, the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 filed by the Claimant does not support the claim for bank charges as there is no evidence of the same being repayable by the Respondent from the said letter.

The Respondent pleaded to have written the commitment letter under duress but failed to lead any evidence of duress to the satisfaction of the court such as steps taken after the fact to avoid the said agreement. I rely on the court’s finding in Ruto v Cherono (Civil Appeal E200 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 10947 (KLR) (20 September 2024) (Judgment) on what constitutes proof of duress. The court will thus uphold the commitment letter dated 18th April 2025 as a valid acknowledgment of debt binding upon the Respondent.

Based on the evidence on record therefore, the Claimant has proved its case on a balance of probabilities aganist the Respondent and judgment is entered for the Claimant against the Respondent for Kshs. 414,992/- together with interest and costs of the suit from the date herein.

DATED SIGNED AND READ VIRTUALLY AT MOMBASA THE…3RD…. DAY OF……JULY……2026

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

In the presence of;

…Mr. Atiang.…for Claimant;

…Mr. Kebaso.. for Respondent C/A Esther

SIGNED BY/FOR:

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-07-03 09:33:06

□ TH E JUDICIAR Y O F KENY A ★

HON. THERESA N. MWANGEKA

Mombasa Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Date: 2026-07-03 09:33:06

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder