Small Claims

Hassan v Dore [2026] SCC 63 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
3 July 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Claim allowed. Judgment entered for the claimant for Kshs. 737,504 plus interest at court rate from judgment until full payment, with costs of Kshs. 40,000. The respondent was granted a 30-day stay of execution.

Supporting judgment passages

12. In the end, I do find that the claimant has proven the claim to the required standard thus the claim is merited. To that end, I hereby order as follows: -

Paragraph 12 →

1. Judgment is hereby entered in favour of the claimant as against the respondent for the sum of Kshs. 737,504.00/= plus interest at court rate from the date of judgment till payment in full.

Paragraph 1 →

2. The claimant is also awarded costs of Kshs. 40,000/=.

Passage 21 →
Issue 1whether the claimed amount was satisfactorily proven.

Held. Decided for the claimant. The executed vehicle-sale agreement recorded payment of Kshs. 737,504, documentary proof supported those payments, and the vehicle was not delivered by the agreed date. The respondent's alleged DDE-based illegality was unsupported by the agreement or other evidence. The paid sums were therefore recoverable, and the claim was proved on the required standard.

Ratio. Civil claims are determined on a balance of probabilities, with the burden resting on the party asserting a fact. The claimant's executed agreement and payment evidence established the payment and non-delivery. Although the respondent alleged that the agreement was illegal, it bore the burden of proving that allegation; unsupported assertions of illegality could not defeat the claim.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

5. I have seen and considered the pleadings, testimonies, evidence and submissions before court. The main issue for determination is whether the claimed amount was satisfactorily proven.

Paragraph 5 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

11. Consequently, in absence of delivery, I do find that the sums paid to the respondent in connection to the transaction were recoverable.

Paragraph 11 →

12. In the end, I do find that the claimant has proven the claim to the required standard thus the claim is merited. To that end, I hereby order as follows: -

Paragraph 12 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

8. I have considered the court record. The claimant’s case was founded on an alleged car sale agreement between the parties. The claimant produced the car sale agreement dated 8/3/2025 in support of the claim. Notably, the same was executed by both parties. Further, the respondent did not denounce the agreement. The sam provided that the respondent would sell to the claimant a vehicle (Mercedes Benze C0.20 Black) for Kshs. 1,300,957/=. It also reflected that the claimant had paid Kshs. 737,504/= and there was a balance of Kshs. 563,453/=. The respondent was to deliver the vehicle by 30/5/2025 or refund the cash on the same day, however, the claimant pleaded that delivery was not done thus the filing of the claim. There was also documentary proof of the payments made to the respondent.

Paragraph 8 →

9. Though the respondent claimed that the same was an illegal contract as the vehicle was to be imported under the DDE contract, there was nothing to support such allegation. The agreement did not make any such provision, and the respondent did not produce any evidence such as correspondence between the parties or documents supporting import under such program for the specified vehicle. Having failed to proof the allegation of illegality, the defense could not succeed.

Paragraph 9 →

10. In Palace Investment Ltd v Geoffrey Kariuki Mwenda & Another [2015] eKLR, the Court of Appeal stated that a party bearing the burden of proof must adduce evidence of such quality that the court can conclude that the claim is more likely than not to be true. As such, the burden of proof in civil matters remains with the party asserting the claim, and where the evidence is evenly balanced or insufficient, the party bearing that burden fails. It was upon the respondent to proof that the contract was illegal as alleged. From the record, the burden of proof was not discharged and the same remained a mere allegation.

Paragraph 10 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The claimant instituted this suit via the undated statement of claim judgment seeking judgment against the respondent for Kshs. 737,504.00/= on the basis that the parties entered an agreement dated 5/12/2020 for the purchase of a motor vehicle for the sum of Kshs. 737,504.00/= but the respondent failed to deliver the vehicle despite payments.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have seen and considered the pleadings, testimonies, evidence and submissions before court. The main issue for determination is whether the claimed amount was satisfactorily proven.

Paragraph 5 →

Decision / orders

In the end, I do find that the claimant has proven the claim to the required standard thus the claim is merited. To that end, I hereby order as follows: -

Paragraph 12 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the claimant proved, on a balance of probabilities, entitlement to recover Kshs. 737,504 paid to the respondent under the parties’ motor-vehicle sale agreement; and whether the respondent proved that the agreement was illegal because it allegedly…

Material facts

The claimant alleged that the parties agreed for the respondent to sell a Mercedes Benze C0.20 Black vehicle. Although the claim referred to an agreement of 5 December 2020, the claimant produced a car-sale agreement dated 8 March 2025, executed by both…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT NAIROBI

SCCCOMM NO. E99417 OF 2025

MOHAMUDHAKAN HASSAN..……...……..…….…….…………CLAIMANT

VERSUS

ABDUL KAHIA DORE………......……………….....................RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. The claimant instituted this suit via the undated statement of claim judgment seeking judgment against the respondent for Kshs. 737,504.00/= on the basis that the parties entered an agreement dated 5/12/2020 for the purchase of a motor vehicle for the sum of Kshs. 737,504.00/= but the respondent failed to deliver the vehicle despite payments.

2. The respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 4/9/2025 which were deemed to be the respondent’s response to the claim. They were on grounds that the claim was a non-starter as the parties had entered into an illegal oral agreement for the respondent to import the vehicle under the Disability Duty Exemption (DDE) program for the claimant. It was thus pleaded that the claimant could not pursue any legal remedy and had no right of action based on an illegal contract.

3. denying any such transaction or balance. It was pleaded that there was no satisfactory evidence and the claimant was put to strict proof.

4. The matter proceeded under Section 30 of the Small Claims Act and the claimant filed submissions dated 16/2/2026. The respondent’s were however not on record.

5. I have seen and considered the pleadings, testimonies, evidence and submissions before court. The main issue for determination is whether the claimed amount was satisfactorily proven.

6. The standard of proof in civil claims is on a balance of probabilities. See the Court of Appeal in Mumbi M'Nabea v David M.Wachira [2016] eKLR.

7. Sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, Chapter 80 of the Laws of Kenya places the burden of proof of a fact on the person who wishes the court to believe in the existence of such fact.

8. I have considered the court record. The claimant’s case was founded on an alleged car sale agreement between the parties. The claimant produced the car sale agreement dated 8/3/2025 in support of the claim. Notably, the same was executed by both parties. Further, the respondent did not denounce the agreement. The sam provided that the respondent would sell to the claimant a vehicle (Mercedes Benze C0.20 Black) for Kshs. 1,300,957/=. It also reflected that the claimant had paid Kshs. 737,504/= and there was a balance of Kshs. 563,453/=. The respondent was to deliver the vehicle by 30/5/2025 or refund the cash on the same day, however, the claimant pleaded that delivery was not done thus the filing of the claim. There was also documentary proof of the payments made to the respondent.

9. Though the respondent claimed that the same was an illegal contract as the vehicle was to be imported under the DDE contract, there was nothing to support such allegation. The agreement did not make any such provision, and the respondent did not produce any evidence such as correspondence between the parties or documents supporting import under such program for the specified vehicle. Having failed to proof the allegation of illegality, the defense could not succeed.

10. In Palace Investment Ltd v Geoffrey Kariuki Mwenda & Another [2015] eKLR, the Court of Appeal stated that a party bearing the burden of proof must adduce evidence of such quality that the court can conclude that the claim is more likely than not to be true. As such, the burden of proof in civil matters remains with the party asserting the claim, and where the evidence is evenly balanced or insufficient, the party bearing that burden fails. It was upon the respondent to proof that the contract was illegal as alleged. From the record, the burden of proof was not discharged and the same remained a mere allegation.

11. Consequently, in absence of delivery, I do find that the sums paid to the respondent in connection to the transaction were recoverable.

12. In the end, I do find that the claimant has proven the claim to the required standard thus the claim is merited. To that end, I hereby order as follows: -

1. Judgment is hereby entered in favour of the claimant as against the respondent for the sum of Kshs. 737,504.00/= plus interest at court rate from the date of judgment till payment in full.

2. The claimant is also awarded costs of Kshs. 40,000/=.

13. The respondent is awarded 30 days stay of execution.

It is so decreed.

DATED and DELIVERED at NAIROBI via CTS this 3rd Day of July 2026

HON. GLADYS .W. KIAMAH

RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder