Small Claims

Sankare v Mungai & 2 others [2026] SCC 176 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
10 July 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment for the claimant against all respondents jointly and severally. Liability was wholly apportioned to the respondents, and special damages of Kshs. 335,175 were awarded. The award attracts interest at court rates from 30 June 2022 until payment in full; costs were assessed at Kshs. 43,118. Execution was stayed for 30 days.

Supporting judgment passages

15. In sum, judgment is entered in favor of the claimant against the respondents jointly and severally for a sum of Kshs. 335,175/= made up as follows;

Paragraph 15 →

16. The above award shall attract interest at court rates from the date of filing suit, being 30th June 2022, until payment in full.

Paragraph 16 →

17. The claimant shall have the costs of this suit which are assessed at a sum of Kshs. 43,118/=.

Paragraph 17 →
Issue 1Apportionment of liability for the road traffic accident.

Held. Liability was resolved wholly in the claimant's favour. The court found that the 3rd respondent negligently rear-ended the claimant's vehicle and caused the accident; the 2nd respondent was vicariously liable. Interlocutory judgment had already been entered against the 1st respondent, and final judgment was entered against the respondents jointly and severally.

Ratio. In a civil claim, liability may be proved on a balance of probabilities by unchallenged evidence, including an unchallenged police abstract reflecting the investigation findings. A driver following another vehicle bears a heavier duty of care because of the unobstructed view of the vehicle ahead, particularly when driving at night.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

5. The two issues for determination in this case are the apportionment of liability and computation of special damages.

Paragraph 5 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

9. The claimant was only required to prove his case on a balance of probabilities. CW2’s evidence on the party to blame was not challenged by the respondent. Based on his evidence, the accident occurred at night when a driver is required to be doubly cautious and on the lookout for other road users. Further, a driver travelling behind another vehicle bears the heavier standard of care due to their unobstructed view of the the vehicle ahead of them. In this case, it has been proved on a balance of probabilities that the respondent’s driver drove negligently and as a result he caused the accident by ramming into the rear of the claimant’s vehicle. This court therefore finds that the claimant proved that the 3rd respondent was to blame for the accident and the 2nd respondent vicariously liable for his actions. Having entered interlocutory judgment against the 1st respondent, the issue of liability is resolved in the claimant’s favor.

Paragraph 9 →

a. Liability is entered wholly in favour of the claimant against the respondents;

Passage 35 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

8. Additionally, the respondents did not challenge the production of the police abstract. In the case of Swan Carriers Ltd v Damaris Wambui (Suing as the legal representative to the estate of the late Maritim Mwangi Ngirigasha [2019] KEHC 7717 (KLR) the court held that police are expected to conduct investigations before arriving at the decision as to who is to blame for the accident. The police abstract lifts the contents of the occurrence book where the findings of investigations are recorded. In the absence of evidence to the contrary the court will rely on the evidence adduced.

Paragraph 8 →

9. The claimant was only required to prove his case on a balance of probabilities. CW2’s evidence on the party to blame was not challenged by the respondent. Based on his evidence, the accident occurred at night when a driver is required to be doubly cautious and on the lookout for other road users. Further, a driver travelling behind another vehicle bears the heavier standard of care due to their unobstructed view of the the vehicle ahead of them. In this case, it has been proved on a balance of probabilities that the respondent’s driver drove negligently and as a result he caused the accident by ramming into the rear of the claimant’s vehicle. This court therefore finds that the claimant proved that the 3rd respondent was to blame for the accident and the 2nd respondent vicariously liable for his actions. Having entered interlocutory judgment against the 1st respondent, the issue of liability is resolved in the claimant’s favor.

Paragraph 9 →
Issue 2Computation of special damages.

Held. The claimant proved special damages of Kshs. 335,175: repair expenses of Kshs. 230,840, assessment charges of Kshs. 7,220, re-inspection charges of Kshs. 2,620, car-hire charges of Kshs. 60,000, and investigation charges proved only to Kshs. 34,495 rather than the Kshs. 45,000 claimed.

Ratio. Special damages are not a natural consequence of the wrong alleged and must be both specifically pleaded and proved with certainty. The court awarded only the amounts supported by the documentary evidence produced.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

5. The two issues for determination in this case are the apportionment of liability and computation of special damages.

Paragraph 5 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

14. The claimant also sought a sum of Kshs. 45,000/= being investigation charges. An investigation report and payment vouchers totaling to Kshs. 34,495/= were produced in support of the claim. The claimant therefore proved a total of Kshs. 335,175/= in special damages.

Paragraph 14 →

b. Special damages- Kshs. 335,175/=

Passage 36 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

10. Turning to the issue of damages, the relief sought by the claimant against the respondents is in the nature of special damages. Special damages are not a natural consequence of the actions complained of and must therefore not only be specifically pleaded but must also be proved to a degree of certainty. (See Hahn v Singh [1985] KECA 129 (KLR)

Paragraph 10 →

14. The claimant also sought a sum of Kshs. 45,000/= being investigation charges. An investigation report and payment vouchers totaling to Kshs. 34,495/= were produced in support of the claim. The claimant therefore proved a total of Kshs. 335,175/= in special damages.

Paragraph 14 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The claimant herein has sued the respondents for compensation following a road traffic accident vide a statement of claim dated 24th July 2025. He claims that on 30th July 2022, he was driving his motor vehicle registration number KDE 994U along Outering road near Shell petrol station in Nairobi, when the 3rd respondent negligently drove the 1st and 2nd respondents’ motor vehicle registration number KCC 815N, causing it to ram into the…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The two issues for determination in this case are the apportionment of liability and computation of special damages.

Paragraph 5 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered: (1) how liability for the road traffic accident should be apportioned; and (2) the amount of special damages proved by the claimant. The judgment also addressed whether the 2nd respondent was vicariously liable for the 3rd respondent’s…

Material facts

Kevin Saitoti Sankare claimed compensation after a collision said to have occurred on 30 July 2022 on Outering Road near Shell petrol station, Nairobi. He alleged that the 3rd respondent drove into the rear of his vehicle, causing extensive damage. He claimed…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT MILIMANI

SCCC NO. E4655 OF 2025

KEVIN SAITOTI SANKARE ......................................................... CLAIMANT

VERSUS

STEPHEN THIIRU MUNGAI .............................................. 1ST RESPONDENT

PETER NDIRANGU IRUNGU ........................................... 2ND RESPONDENT

DICKSON WAMBUA MBUVI ........................................... 3RD RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. The claimant herein has sued the respondents for compensation following a road traffic accident vide a statement of claim dated 24th July 2025. He claims that on 30th July 2022, he was driving his motor vehicle registration number KDE 994U along Outering road near Shell petrol station in Nairobi, when the 3rd respondent negligently drove the 1st and 2nd respondents’ motor vehicle registration number KCC 815N, causing it to ram into the rear of his vehicle. As a result of the accident, the claimant’s vehicle was extensively damaged.

2. The claim against the respondents was for special damages amounting to Kshs. 345,086/= for the following expenses;

a. Repair charges- Kshs. 230,840/=

b. Assessment charges- Kshs. 7,220/=

c. Re- Inspection charges- Kshs. 2,620/=

d. Car hire charges- Kshs. 60,000/=

e. Investigation charges- Kshs. 45,000/=.

3. Default judgment was entered against the 1st respondent who failed to enter appearance despite service. For their part, the 2nd and 3rd respondents, filed a response dated 28th August 2025 denying the entire claim. In the alternative, they averred that if the accident had occurred as alleged, it had been caused by the claimant’s negligence.

4. When the matter came up for hearing, a legal officer at GA insurance limited, Teresia Gatiku (CW1) and PC Anyula Okumu (CW2) testified in support of the claimant’s case. No witnesses were called to testify in support of the respondents’ case.

ISSUES, ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

5. The two issues for determination in this case are the apportionment of liability and computation of special damages.

a. LIABILITY

6. The claimant blames the respondent’s driver for causing the accident. In his statement of claim, he averred that the accident occurred when the 3rd respondent rammed the respondents’ vehicle into the rear of his vehicle. The claimant did not give evidence on the circumstances that led to the occurrence of the accident. However, a police abstract was produced by CW2 to support the claim that the respondents’ vehicle was blamed for the accident. CW2 testified that the accident occurred at around 7:20 p.m. It had involved motor vehicles, KCJ 534 G Nissan Tiida, KDG 599U Mazda Azela and KCC 815F Isuzu minibus. He referred to the contents in the occurrence book to support the assertion that the respondents’ driver was found liable for the accident.

7. Although the respondents denied the occurrence of the accident, they did not adduce evidence to counter the claimant’s case. The consequences of the failure by the respondents to call a witness was discussed by the court in the case of Linus Nganga Kiongo & 3 Others V Town Council of Kikuyu Civil Case 79 OF 2011 [2012] eKLR thus;

“The plaintiffs have given evidence on oath supported by documentary evidence which go to prove their case. Accordingly, in the absence of any evidence to the contrary and as proof in civil cases is on a balance of probabilities, I find that the plaintiffs are entitled to succeed.”

8. Additionally, the respondents did not challenge the production of the police abstract. In the case of Swan Carriers Ltd v Damaris Wambui (Suing as the legal representative to the estate of the late Maritim Mwangi Ngirigasha [2019] KEHC 7717 (KLR) the court held that police are expected to conduct investigations before arriving at the decision as to who is to blame for the accident. The police abstract lifts the contents of the occurrence book where the findings of investigations are recorded. In the absence of evidence to the contrary the court will rely on the evidence adduced.

9. The claimant was only required to prove his case on a balance of probabilities. CW2’s evidence on the party to blame was not challenged by the respondent. Based on his evidence, the accident occurred at night when a driver is required to be doubly cautious and on the lookout for other road users. Further, a driver travelling behind another vehicle bears the heavier standard of care due to their unobstructed view of the the vehicle ahead of them. In this case, it has been proved on a balance of probabilities that the respondent’s driver drove negligently and as a result he caused the accident by ramming into the rear of the claimant’s vehicle. This court therefore finds that the claimant proved that the 3rd respondent was to blame for the accident and the 2nd respondent vicariously liable for his actions. Having entered interlocutory judgment against the 1st respondent, the issue of liability is resolved in the claimant’s favor.

b. SPECIAL DAMAGES

10. Turning to the issue of damages, the relief sought by the claimant against the respondents is in the nature of special damages. Special damages are not a natural consequence of the actions complained of and must therefore not only be specifically pleaded but must also be proved to a degree of certainty. (See Hahn v Singh [1985] KECA 129 (KLR)

11. It was claimed that a sum of Kshs. 230,840/= was spent on repair expenses. To prove these sums, the claimant produced a copy of a technical report which estimated the costs of repairs at a sum of Kshs. 230,840/=. An invoice for the cost of repairs was issued by St. Austin’s service center ltd and payment vouchers by GA insurance for the sum of Kshs. 230,840/=.

12. The claim for assessment charges was proved through the production of an invoice and receipt issued by Nordics Assessors for a sum of Kshs. 7,220/=. For re-inspection, the claimant sought a sum of Kshs. 2,620/=. These sums were proved through production of an invoice and receipt issued by Nordics Assessors.

13. A sum of Kshs. 60,000/= was sought for car hire services. To prove the expenditure a car hire contract, payment vouchers for a total sum of Kshs. 60,000/= and a receipt for the sum of Kshs. 60,000/= were produced.

14. The claimant also sought a sum of Kshs. 45,000/= being investigation charges. An investigation report and payment vouchers totaling to Kshs. 34,495/= were produced in support of the claim. The claimant therefore proved a total of Kshs. 335,175/= in special damages.

CONCLUSION

15. In sum, judgment is entered in favor of the claimant against the respondents jointly and severally for a sum of Kshs. 335,175/= made up as follows;

a. Liability is entered wholly in favour of the claimant against the respondents;

b. Special damages- Kshs. 335,175/=

16. The above award shall attract interest at court rates from the date of filing suit, being 30th June 2022, until payment in full.

17. The claimant shall have the costs of this suit which are assessed at a sum of Kshs. 43,118/=.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT MURANG’A THIS 10TH DAY OF JULY 2026.

HON. GRACE WAITHĨRA

SENIOR RESIDENT MAGISTRATE/ADJUDICATOR

JUDGMENT SENT VIA CTS PLATFORM IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 23 (4) (B) OF THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT RULES.

THE EXECUTION OF THIS JUDGMENT IS STAYED FOR 30 DAYS.

ANY AGGRIEVED PARTY HAS LEAVE TO EXERCISE THEIR RIGHT OF APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE DATE HEREOF.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder