Background
A Declaration the Respondents actions violate the Petitioners rights under Articles 41, 43, 47 and 40 of the Constitution and sections 10, 17, 35 and 51 of the Employment Act and the Pensions Act.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Petition nominally succeeded only in limited documentary relief: the 1st respondent must issue a certificate of discharge within 30 days and include the petitioner’s 35% disability in his Authority for Discharge from Service. All other prayers were declined, and each party was ordered to bear its own costs.
In the upshot the petitioner’s case is nominally successful to the extent that;
Passage 185 →
(a) The 1st respondent shall issue a certificate of discharge to the petitioner within 30 days.
Passage 186 →
(d) For the avoidance of doubt all other prayers are declined.
Passage 189 →
Held. Decided against the petitioner. He failed to prove that his discharge was actuated by medical disability. The evidence established completion of 21 years’ colour service, without approval for an extension, and no medical officer had pronounced him mentally or physically unfit for further service. The 35% disability assessment and pension award did not establish a medical discharge.
Ratio. A medical discharge under section 255(1)(d) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act requires a medical officer’s pronouncement that the service member is mentally or physically unfit for further service. A disability-pension assessment is a distinct assessment and does not, without that pronouncement and proof, reclassify a discharge from completion of colour service. The petitioner bore the burden of proving the alleged medical basis for discharge.
Issue
(i) Whether the Petitioner was discharged on the basis of medical unfitness or otherwise.
Passage 67 →
Held
For the foregoing reasons, the court finds that the petitioner has failed to demonstrate that his discharge by the 1st respondent was actuated by a medical disability. Since the Petitioners disability was assessed at 35%, it is unclear as to whether it was classified as permanent, or temporary and puzzlingly, the petitioner did not appeal for a renew of the finding as mandated by the Regulations. An application for review would have fortified the petitioner’s case significantly.
Passage 148 →
Ratio
In a similar vein, the 1st respondent admitted that prior to the discharge a medical Board was appointed and awarded the petitioner 35% disability pension but was never pronounced the Petitioner as mentally or physically unfit for further service under section 255 (1) (d) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act. This is the correct position since neither Dr Wambui Sylvia of GECK Royal Victory Hospital nor any other medical officer made the pronouncement and none is on record.
Passage 123 →
The Petitioner bore the burden of proof that the discharge was on account of his medical condition diagnosed in January/February 2023 or thereafter and the Pensions Assessment Committee assessed the degree of disablement and the appropriate award, which he was notified.
Passage 130 →
From the foregoing provisions, it is discernible that after twenty-one (21) years of colour service, a service member continues serving only if the service commander or the officer authorised by the service commander approves the continuation of service.
Passage 146 →
Held. Decided in favour of the 3rd respondent. The bank lawfully set off Kshs.3,175,637.50 credited to the petitioner’s ordinary transactional account against his two defaulted loan facilities. The petitioner did not establish that the set-off was unlawful or that the credited sum remained protected under section 13 of the Pensions Act.
Ratio. The petitioner was bound by the banking agreement, which entitled the bank to apply funds in his transactional account to defaulted loan accounts. Section 13 of the Pensions Act protects pension, gratuity or allowance while held by the employer, provident fund or pension fund; it does not protect deposits once credited to the account holder’s ordinary bank account. As mutual debtor and creditor, the bank could exercise set-off, subject to paying any balance to the petitioner.
Issue
(ii) Whether the 3rd respondent was entitled to appropriate the petitioner’s pension dues
Passage 68 →
Held
For the foregoing reasons it is the finding of the court that the petitioner has failed to prove that the 3rd respondents’ action of setting off the sum of Kshs.3,175,637.50 was unlawful or that the sum was protected by section 13 of the Pensions Act.
Passage 179 →
Ratio
In the instant case since the Petitioner’s salary was the security the salary had to be paid into his account during the subsistence of the loan and being the only transactional account with the bank, the 3rd respondent, in the court’s view had the contractual right to apply the funds in the account to the loan accounts in default.
Passage 167 →
In the instant case the 3rd respondent was both a debtor and a creditor to the petitioner and since the petitioner (creditor/debtor), owed in the bank more than it owed him, it was entitled to set-off and any balance would be payable to the petitioner.
Passage 176 →
In the courts view, section 13 of the Pensions Act does not protect deposits in a bank account held by the Account holder but safeguards the amount held by the employer, provident fund or other pension fund from being attached, levied or sequestratered.
Passage 178 →
Held. Partially decided in the petitioner’s favour. The court rejected the constitutional-rights declarations, a corrected medical-discharge letter, and all remaining substantive prayers. However, under section 257(4) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act, the petitioner was entitled to a certificate of discharge. The 1st respondent was ordered to issue it within 30 days and to include the petitioner’s 35% disability in the Authority for Discharge from Service. Parties were to bear their own costs.
Ratio. A certificate of discharge is required by section 257(4) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act. But mandamus to correct the discharge classification could not issue because the petitioner had not proved that the classification as completion of colour service was incorrect. The discharge documentation nevertheless ought to record the assessed 35% disability.
Issue
(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs prayed for.
Passage 69 →
Held
(a) The 1st respondent shall issue a certificate of discharge to the petitioner within 30 days.
Passage 186 →
(b) The 1st respondent shall include the petitioner’s disability of 35% in his Authority for discharge from service.
Passage 187 →
(d) For the avoidance of doubt all other prayers are declined.
Passage 189 →
Ratio
The petitioner is however entitled to a Certificate of Discharge by dint of Section 257 (4) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act.
Passage 181 →
Concerning mandamus to compel the 1st respondent to issue a corrected discharge letter, the court is not persuaded such order should issue on account that the petitioner has not evidentiary demonstrated that the 1st respondent’s classification of the discharge was incorrect. The three letters dated February 2025 could not by themselves establish the petitioner’s permanent inability.
Passage 182 →
Be that as it may the letter of discharge or discharge certificate ought to have stated that the petitioner had a disability of 35%.
Passage 183 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
A Declaration the Respondents actions violate the Petitioners rights under Articles 41, 43, 47 and 40 of the Constitution and sections 10, 17, 35 and 51 of the Employment Act and the Pensions Act.
Paragraph 1 →The court identified whether the petitioner was discharged because of medical unfitness or otherwise; whether the 3rd respondent could appropriate funds credited to his account as pension dues; and whether he was entitled to the remedies sought.
Josiah Wafula Barasa joined the Kenya Defence Forces (KDF) in August 2002 and was discharged on 22 November 2023 after 21 years’ service. His Authority for Discharge from Service, dated 25 July 2025, gave the reason as completion of colour service. A medical…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
PETITION E148 OF 2025
JOSIAH WAFULA BARASA………….……….……………PETITIONER
VERSUS
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY MINISTRY OF DEFENCE ……………………………………………………………..…1ST RESPONDENT
THE HON ATTORNEY GENERAL ………………..…2ND RESPONDENT
ABSA BANK OF KENYA LTD………………………...3RD RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
The instant Petition was filed on 1st August 2025 while the other documents were filed on 25th July 2025.
The Petitioner’s case is that he was compulsorily discharged from the Kenya Defence forces on 22nd November 2023 but the 1st Respondent misclassified the discharge as “completion of colour of service” otherwise due in 2032.
That the misclassification denied the Petitioner entitlement to treatment as a medical discharge mandatory for the 3rd Respondents loan protection insurance held to the Petitioners loan facilities.
That the 3rd Respondent had refused to issue a proper corrected official discharge letter to the Petitioner despite multiple formal requests and violated the Petitioner’s Constitutional rights.
That the 3rd Respondent’s insurer had declined the Petitioners claim for loan protection coverage exposing him to threat of forced loan recovery from his pension benefits and the sum of Ksh.3,175,637.50 had been credited to his bank account and under threat to offset the loan balance. The Petitioner avers that he was yet to receive a Certificate of Service.
The Petitioner cited Articles 41, 43(1) (a), 46, 47, 48 and 50 of the Constitution of Kenya Section 10 (1), 5, 12, 17, 35(5) and 51 of the Employment and the Pensions Act generally as the basis of the Petition and prays for;
1. A Declaration the Respondents actions violate the Petitioners rights under Articles 41, 43, 47 and 40 of the Constitution and sections 10, 17, 35 and 51 of the Employment Act and the Pensions Act.
2. An order of mandamus compelling the 1st Respondent to issue a corrected official discharge letter categorically stating that the petitioner’s discharge was due to medical disability and his colour service was not due for completion until 2032.
3. An order that the 1st Respondent shall deliver the corrected discharge letter within seven (7) days of the court’s order either directly to the 3rd Respondent’s loan protection insurer or to the Petitioner for immediate onward transmission.
4. An Order compelling the 1st Respondent to issue the Petitioner with a Certificate of Service.
5. An order restraining the 3rd, Respondent from appropriating, attaching or otherwise interfering with the Petitioner’s Pensions income pending settlement of the valid insurance claim.
6. An order directing the 3rd Respondent to forthwith submit the Petitioners valid Insurance claim to the insurer upon receipt of the corrected discharge letter and to suspend any loan recovery action until the claim is fully processed and settled.
7. An order compelling the 3rd Respondent to refund, with interest at court rates any portion of the Petitioner’s pension already appropriated loan facilities in contravention of the applicable insurance cover.
8. Costs of this petition.
1st Respondents Reply
Vide a Replying Affidavit sworn on 13th January 2026 in opposition to the Petition, Major Wycliffe Kiplangat deponed that he was the Staffing Officer II at the KDF Headquarters and the Petitioner was enlisted into the KDF on 3rd August 2002 and discharged on 22nd November 2023 as averred and the applicable law on enlistment and discharge was the Kenya Defences Forces Act and the initial prescribed period of colour service was for a period not exceeding 12 years from the date of attestation and any re-engagement for a further period of colour service must not exceed 21 years from the date of original attestation after which service was year to year.
The affiant deponed that before he was discharged, the Petitioner was offered the opportunity to apply for re-engagement annually but he declined on the premise that he did not wish to continue in service after 21 years of service and was discharged and retired after 21 years of service and was granted 90 days terminal leave until 22nd November 2023.
That a Medical Board was constituted as a matter of procedure for those existing the service to ascertain any additional compensation upon exit and the Board found that the Petitioner had a condition that warranted additional pension consideration under the Kenya Defence Forces (Pension and Gratuities) (Officers and Service Members) Regulations, 2021 and was awarded 35% disability pension on account of hypertension and expressive mood he was discharged on medical grounds and at no time was he pronounced by a medical officer to be mentally or physically unfit for service.
That the Petitioner acknowledged receipt of Certificate of Discharge from service and was properly discharged from service on completion of colour service.
The affiant deponed that the Petition was an afterthought to avoid settling financial obligations with the 3rd Respondent and none of his right had been violated and the Petition was for dismissal.
3rd Respondent’s Reply
By a Replying Affidavit sworn by Mr. Samuel Njuguna on 23rd June 2026, in opposition to the Petition, the affiant deponed that the relationship between the Petitioner and 3rd Respondent was banker/customer relationship as the Petitioner maintained Account number 0708143324 at the 3rd Respondents Bunyala Branch.
That Clause 1.5 of the General terms permitted the 3rd Respondent to set-off any credit balance in any account against amounts due and payable by the Petitioner to the 3rd Respondent.
That on 6th December, 2022, the Petitioner sought credit facilities from the 3rd Respondent and the same was advanced, Kshs.2,300,000 under Loan Account Number 20478945878 and had another facility under Account Number 2049368979 and ceased servicing both loans from September 2023 and had remained indefault.
That sometime in July 2025 the Petitioner had contended that he was discharged from employment on grounds of disability and claimed that the outstanding facilities be recovered from the credit insurance cover and the Personal Customer Agreement required the Petitioner to notify the banks of any event that could give rise to claim under the policy and after seeking information from the 1st Respondent, it confirmed that the Petitioner was discharged upon completion of colour service and the petitioner provided no evidence of discharged on account of disability.
That on 10th July 2025 the Petitioners account was credited with Kshs.3,175,637.50 from the National Treasury and the 3rd Respondent off set Kshs.333,454.95 from the account to clear the amount due under Loan Account Number 2049368979 and Kshs.2,200,000 to offset the amount owed under Loan Account Number 2047894878 as a contractual right as the Petitioner owed the amount in question and the funds were not protected. That the 3rd Respondent had already applied the funds to partially clear the petitioner’s debt and any proceeds received under the insurance policy shall be used to pay off the loan with interest’s costs and expenses and any balance credited to the transactional account. That a debt of Kshs.597,958.20 was still unpaid.
When the matter came up on 24th June 2026, the Petitioner’s counsel sought seven (7) days to file and serve a Further Affidavit and there being no objection, the court granted counsel seven (7) days to do so and issued directions on the filing and exchange of submissions (14 days a piece) and a mention on 21st September 2026 for purposes of a judgment date. The Further Affidavit was filed on 10th August 2026, one (1) month and 16 days later together with submissions.
The petitioner contested the alleged opportunity to extend service and cited the evidence from Royal Victory Hospital as proof of his depression and the fact that a Medical Board was convened. The petitioner further contested the manner in which the 3rd Respondent used his monies to set-off the loans, that there were discrepancies.
Petitioner’s submissions
As to whether the 1st Respondent violated the Petitioner’s rights by failing to issue a corrected discharge letter reliance was placed on Judicial Service Commission v Mbalu Mutava & another (2015) eKLR, on Article 47 of the Constitution of Kenya.
Reliance was further placed on Article 41 on issuance of terminal documents including certificate of service citing the decision in Naumy Jemutai Kirui v Unilever Tea Kenya Ltd (2020) eKLR and Angela Wakobi Muoki v Tribe Hotel Ltd (2016) eKLR to urge that the reasoning applied to a corrected discharge document. Counsel submitted that since the Medical Board found that the Petitioner was disabled up to 35% the discharge was medical.
On appropriation of pension funds, counsel for the Petitioner cited section 13 of the Pensions Act on protection of pension, to argue that since the 3rd Respondent was not the Government, it could not appropriate the monies in the Petitioner’s account.
Counsel urged that the decision in Barclays Bank of Kenya Ltd v Kepha Nyabera & 191 others (2013) eKLR was distinguishable. Counsel submitted that in the instant case no debt had crystalized upon a specific contractual condition precedent. That the debts were written off or 22nd April 2025 and 27th August 2025.
Also cited was the decision in National Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 others v Asam-Con Ltd (2025) KECA 504 (KLR) on consolidation of debt and set off to urge that there was no charge over the petitioner’s pension account and no debt was owing.
Reliance was also placed on Margaret Njeri Muiruri v Bank of Baroda (Kenya) Ltd (2014) eKLR on good faith and proportionality, to urge that the wholesome appropriation of the 79.8% petitioner’s pension lumpsum was neither proportional nor transparent. The decision in Mitu-Bell Welfare Society v Kenya Airports Authority (2021) eKLR was also cited on realization of article 43 of the Constitution of Kenya.
Counsel submitted that having initiated the insurance claim, the respondent could not abandon it, midstream and the amount owed was inconsistent.
That the balance of prejudice weighed heavily in favour of the petitioner. Counsel urged the court to allow the reliefs prayed for.
1st and 2nd Respondent’s Submissions.
The three Respondents did not isolate any specific issues for determination but relied on section 3(2) (a) of the Employment Act on the non-applicability of the Employment Act to the Kenya Defence Forces to urge that Sections 10, 12, 17, 35 and 51 of the Employment Act were inapplicable to this petition.
Counsel urged that the Petitioner failed to utilize the internal grievance resolution mechanism under Section 303 of the Kenya Defence Forces Act and failed to discharge the burden of proof that his rights had been violated citing the decision in County Government of Nyeri & another v Cecilia Wangechi Ndungu (2015) eKLR to reinforce the submission.
That a disability pension award did not reclassify the Petitioners discharge since it is a distinct statutory entitlement and no law had been cited for the position that a disability pension was dependent on discharge on medical grounds and not all forms of disability qualified a service member to an automatic discharge on medical grounds.
Concerning protection of persons with disability reliance as placed on Article 27 and 54 of the Constitution on prohibition of discrimination and rights of persons with disability as were the decisions in Gichuru v Package Insurance Brokers Ltd (2021) KESC 12 (KLR) and Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers Union v Rea Vipingo Plantations Ltd & Dr. Ashraph (2015) eKLR on consideration of possible alterations by the employer in dealing with a person with disability to submit that the Petitioners position that his discharge was on medical grounds was erroneous and the petitioner exited when he chase to do so via completion of colour service and the 1st Respondent acted constitutionally.
Reliance was placed on the decision in Judicial Service Commission v Mbalu Mutava & another (2015) eKLR on grounds in which an administrative decision may be impugned to urge that the 1st Respondent processed the petitioner’s discharge in accord with the Kenya Defence Forces Act and convened a stand and medical Board and was paid disability pension.
Counsel submitted that the relationship between the Petitioner and the 3rd Respondent was contractual and neither the 1st nor the 2nd respondent held or controlled the funds disbursed to the Petitioner and they were strangers to the relationship and could not be held liable. That the Petitioner did not dispute the fact that he owed money to the 3rd Respondent.
Counsel urges the court to dismiss the Petition with costs.
3rd Respondent’s Submission
As to whether the Petitioner was discharged from service due to disability or completion of colour service, counsel relied on section 253 of the Kenya Defence Forces Act to urge that since the Petitioner had completed 21 years of service, the discharge was completion of colour service.
Reliance was also placed on section 2 of the persons with Disability Act for a definition of disability. On whether the Petitioner ought to have benefited from credit insurance cover, counsel submitted that it was the petitioner’s duty to notify the 3rd respondent of any event giving rise to a claim under the insurance cover and the medical reports on record had not been forwarded to the 3rd Respondent and the claim that he was discharged on medical grounds was into substantiated.
On the right to off-set the Petitioners outstanding loans against the amount to his credit account counsel submitted that the Petitioners argument that the insurance cover should have been applied to off-set the debt was unmerited as every credit is treated as available to the customer and to the bank to clear any outstanding facilities citing the sentiments of the court in EMK v SSS (2015) KEHC 7524 (KLR) to urge that the money deposited in the Petitioners account was a regular credit.
Also cited was the decision in Manolete Partners PLG v White (2024) EWCA Civ 1418 Nov. 2024.
As to whether the Petitioner can pursue written off amounts counsel submitted that the sum of Kshs.597,958.20 written off was due even though it had been written off in the bank’s books. Citing the Court of Appeal decision in Nicholus Mahihu Muriithi v Barclays Bank of Kenya Ltd (2018) KECA 606 KLR, Supreme Court of India decision in Salim Akbarali Nanji v Union of India & others Civil Appeal No. 6715 of 2024 to urge that the writing off of the debt did not absolve the Petitioner from liability and nothing prevented the 3rd Respondent from recovering the same.
Counsel urged the court to dismiss the Petition with costs to the 3rd Respondent.
Analysis and determination
It is common ground that the Petitioner joined the KDF in August 2002 and served until 22nd November 2023 when he was discharged. The letter of discharge dated 25th July 2025 stated that the reason for discharge was “completion of colour service” which he contests contending that after being diagnosed with hypertension and depressive disorder he became medically unfit to continue in service and was compulsorily discharged and was thus entitled to a medical discharge under the Kenya Defence Forces Act (herein after KDF Act).
The Petitioner is also contesting the set-off by the 3rd Respondent using his pension lumpsum, paid by the National Treasury.
The issues for determination are:
(i) Whether the Petitioner was discharged on the basis of medical unfitness or otherwise.
(ii) Whether the 3rd respondent was entitled to appropriate the petitioner’s pension dues
(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs prayed for.
On the first issues, while the 1st respondent contended that the petitioner was discharged upon completion of colour service and not on account of disability, the petitioner deposed and counsel submitted that the discharge ought to have been classified as disability as he was diagnosed with hypertension and major depressive disorder.
Under section 255 of the KDF Act;
(1) A service member may be discharged by the Service Commander or an officer authorised in that behalf at any time during the members period of colour service –
(a) if, within two years after the date of attestation the commanding officer considers that the member is unlikely to be an efficient member of the Defence Forces.
(b) for activities or behaviour likely to be prejudicial to the preservation of public security.
(c) if the member is convicted of a civil offence; or
(d) if the member is pronounced by a medical officer to mentally or physically unfit for further service;
(e) on reduction of establishment;
(f) at the members request on compassionate grounds;
(g) if for any reason the members services are no longer required.
(h) if the member is granted a commission; or
(i) if the member is sentenced by a court martial to be dismissed from the defence force.
(2) The Service Commander or an officer authorised in that behalf as the case may be shall accord and specify reasons in writing for any discharge to the affected service member.
Under section 257 of the KDF Act,
(1) …
(2) …
(3) …
(4) Every service member shall be given, on discharge a certificate of discharge containing the prescribed particulars.
A reading of the foregoing provisions, leave no doubt that discharge on completion of colour service is the expected or typical mode of discharge of service members. The Regulations on payment of pension and gratuity to officers and service members are provided for under the Kenya Defence Forces (Pension and Gratuities) (Officers and Service members) Regulations.
Regulation 18 establishes the Pensions Assessment Committee which consists of five (5) members including a civilian medical practitioner appointed by Defence Council with a Quantum of three (3) and the Secretary who is public officer.
Under Regulations of Regulations
(1) Where an officer or service member suffers disablement as a result of a would injury or disease, the committee shall-
(a) determine whether the wound, injury or disease was due to hastened by or aggravated by his or her service; and
(b) in the case of disability, assess the degree thereof and may where it is satisfied that the wound, injury or disease was due to hastened by or aggravated by his or her service, proceed to award pension for permanent disablement and additional hardship allowance in accordance with Regulations 22 and 23.
(c) Award pension on insanity
(d) Award Assisted Living Allowance in accordance with Regulation 40
(e) Receive, revise and determine any claim for review and assessment of pensions or gratuity.
(2) In the exercise of its powers and duties under these Regulations, the committee may appoint a service member officer or board of service medical officers-
(a) to advice on any claim; or
(b) to carry out any medical examination which is required to be carried out by or under these regulations or which, in the opinion of the committee, should be carried out in order to enable the committee to assess the entitlement or the degree of disablement of any officer or service member for any other reason which the committee considers sufficient.
3. …
(4) The Committee shall keep a record of all the awards made and shall-
(a) furnish a copy thereof to the Chief of the Kenya Defence Forces and the Military Pensions Liaison Officer; and
(b) inform every person in respect of whom an award has been made of the terms of the award and the procedure to be followed in order to obtain payment.
Regulation 2 defines “degree of disablement” to mean
Under regulation 21
(1) the degree of disablement to be assessed by the committee shall be the measure of disablement which in considered to have been suffered by an officer or service member or retired officer or discharged service member by a comparison of his or her current condition with the condition of a healthy able-bodied person of the same age without taking into account-
(a) his or her earning capacity in his or her disabled condition, in his or her own or in any other specific trade or occupation, and
The effect of any individual factors or extraneous circumstances.
(2) the degree of disablement shall be expressed as percentage (100 percent representing total disablement) in any one of the following classifications-
(a) 100 percent;
(b) Less than 100 percent but not less than 80 percent;
(c) Less than 80 percent but not less than 60 percent;
(d) Less than 60 percent but not less than 40 percent;
(e) Less than 40 percent but not less than 20 percent;
(f) Less than 20 percent but not less than 11 percent;
(g) 10 percent and under.
(3) In the case of disablement suffered by reason of two or more disabilities attributable to service, the degree of disablement shall be determined with reference to the combined disablement from the disabilities together but it shall not exceed 100 percent.
(4) The degree of disablement for specified injuries and certain other disabilities shall be assessed in accordance with the schedule of these regulations.
Regulation 22 sets out the gratuity or pension payable for permanent disablement. These provisions are clear that an officer or service member of the KDF is deemed health and able-bodied until and unless the contrary is proved.
The petitioner’s case is principally that the discharge was medically instigated and the discharge certificate ought to indicate as much and his was a permanent disability. However, the only document from the KDF availed by the petitioner entitled “Authority for Discharge from service-service member dated 25th July 2025 revealed that the discharge was not medically instigated nor inferenced, but completion of colour service after the prescribed duration with 90 days terminal leave.
This is the document the petitioner is challenging as incorrect and attached copies of three (3) letters by one Dr Wambui Sylvia, Consultant Psychiatrist G.E.C.K Royal Victory Hospital Outering Road opposite Baba Dogo Junction P.O Box 74846 00200, Nairobi Tel +254722997977 email info@royalvictoryhosp.org dated 10th February 2023, 24th February 2013 and 30th February 2023.
The letter states that he was admitted at the facility on 24th January 2023 and discharged on 18th February 2023 and was to attend psychotherapic sessions on a weekly basis as outpatient. No other medical records were provided.
In a similar vein, the 1st respondent admitted that prior to the discharge a medical Board was appointed and awarded the petitioner 35% disability pension but was never pronounced the Petitioner as mentally or physically unfit for further service under section 255 (1) (d) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act. This is the correct position since neither Dr Wambui Sylvia of GECK Royal Victory Hospital nor any other medical officer made the pronouncement and none is on record.
Section 107 of the Evidence Act provides
(1) Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist.
(2) When a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person under
Under section 109 of the Act;
The burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence, unless it is provided by any law that the proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person.
See Miller v Minister of Pensions (1947) ALLER 372, Palace Investments Ltd v Geoffrey Kariuki Mwenda & another (2015) KECA 616 (KLR) Kangi & another v Kibeya & 3 others (1987) KLR 347 CMC Aviation Ltd v Crusair Ltd (NOI) (1987) KLR 103 and Muhiu Mucheru v National Bank of Kenya Ltd (2019) KECA 1058 (KLR).
The Petitioner bore the burden of proof that the discharge was on account of his medical condition diagnosed in January/February 2023 or thereafter and the Pensions Assessment Committee assessed the degree of disablement and the appropriate award, which he was notified.
Relatedly, the petitioner tendered no evidence to demonstrate that the three letters were forwarded to the Commander or authorised officer other prior to the discharge or after and whether they were taken into consideration at any stage including whether the Pensions Assessment Committee required him to undergo another medical examination for its own purposes or relied on the letters he obtained elsewhere.
On the duration of service Section 253 of the KDF Act provides;
(1) The term for which a person who has attained the age of eighteen years may enlist shall be one of the prescribed periods of colour service (not exceeding twelve years) beginning on the date of attestation.
(2) In computing the period of a service member, there shall be excluded therefrom-
(a) All periods during which the member has been absent from duty by reason of-
(h) imprisonment; or
(i) desertion; or
(j) absence without leave exceeding seven days; and
(b) any period ordered by a court- martial to be forfeited.
(3) Within two years before completing the period of colour service of a service member who is of good character, the member, with approval of the competent service authority, may re-engage for such further period of colour service as may be prescribed, subject to subsection (5)
(4) Except as provided by sub-section (6), the further period of colour service, together with the previous period of colour service, shall not exceed a total continuous period of twenty-one years colour service from the date of the original attestation or the date upon which the person attained the age of eighteen years, whichever is the later.
(5) A service member who has completed a period of twenty-one years of colour service may-
(a) with approval of the service commander or an officer authorised by the service commander in that behalf, continue to serve from year to year as if the period of colour service were still unexpired; and
(b) at any time give to the member’s commanding officer three months’ notice to be discharged and on the expiration of that notice, the member may claim to be discharged.
(6) A service member who completes a period of colour service (and any period by which that service is prolonged under subsection (6) of this section or under section 255 or is otherwise discharged (other than under section 254 or 256), shall thereupon be transferred to the reserve and shall serve therein until attaining the age of fifty-five years.
From the foregoing provisions, it is discernible that after twenty-one (21) years of colour service, a service member continues serving only if the service commander or the officer authorised by the service commander approves the continuation of service.
Having served for 21 years, the petitioner had completed the colour service as ordained by the provisions of section 253 (4) of the KDF Act and the authorised officer Major M. O Odindo did not approve extension of service period. Could it have been coincidental that the petitioner’s completion of colour service and the disability crystalised at the same time?
For the foregoing reasons, the court finds that the petitioner has failed to demonstrate that his discharge by the 1st respondent was actuated by a medical disability. Since the Petitioners disability was assessed at 35%, it is unclear as to whether it was classified as permanent, or temporary and puzzlingly, the petitioner did not appeal for a renew of the finding as mandated by the Regulations. An application for review would have fortified the petitioner’s case significantly.
As to whether the 3rd Respondent was entitled the appropriate monies in the petitioner’s account, parties adopted contrasting positions with the petitioner maintaining that pension is protected by law. Section 13 of the Pensions Act provides-
(1) A pension, gratuity or other allowance granted under this Act shall not be assignable or transferable except for purposes of satisfying –
(a) a debt due to the Government; or
(b) an order of any court for the payment of periodical sums of money towards maintenance of the wife, or former wife, or minor child, of the officer to whom the pension, gratuity or other allowance has been granted and shall not be liable to the attached, sequestratered or levied upon for or in respect of any debt or claim whatever except a debt due to the Government.
The petitioner admitted that he took two unsecured facilities from ABSA Bank under Loan Account No. 20478945878 and 2049368979 and the latter had an outstanding balance of Kshs.33,454.96. For unexplained reasons, the petitioner did not disclose how much was due under Loan Account Number 2047945878 whose principal sum was Kshs.2,300,000 advanced on 6th December 2022 less than one (1) year earlier. The Respondent deponed that by July 2023, Loan Account Number 2047945878 had an outstanding balance of Kshs. 2,200,000 and both amounts were offset when the sum of Kshs.3,175,637.50 was credited to the petitioner’s account on 10th July 2025. The crux of the matter is whether 3rd respondent acted within the law. Under the Personal Customer Agreement between the petitioner and the 3rd respondent the facilities advanced to the petitioner had to be insured against the possibility of death or disability during the term of the loan for the value of the loan. In his application for the facility dated 6th December 2022, the Petitioner indicated that insurance premium was being financed as well but the account from which the amount would be financed was not indicated.
According to counsel for the petitioner, since the sum of Kshs.3,175,637.50 was the petitioner’s pension lumpsum, it was protected and could not be used to discharge the petitioner’s obligations to the 3rd respondent Bank.
It is not in dispute that petitioner had an account with the bank being Account Number 0708143324 at Bunyala Branch and had two (2) facilities in default since September 2023 and the 3rd respondent was aware that its customer was no longer in employment.
Under the Personal Customer Agreement, the petitioner had contracted to;
“…maintain a credit balance at all times. If a debit arises, it is immediately due and payable from you to us and you agree to fund your account to repay the debit balance immediately…”
The petitioner executed the relevant contractual document(s) and was thus bound by its terms.
It is trite law that parties are bound by the terms of their contract. In Magut v National Bank of Kenya (2026) KECA 610 (KLR) the Court of Appeal held:
“A court law cannot rewrite a contract between parties. The parties are bound by the terms of their contract unless coercion, fraud, undue influence or material mistake are pleaded and proved. It is ordinarily no part of equity’s function to allow a party to escape from a bad bargain. However, courts have never been shy to interfere with or refuse to enforce contracts which are unconscionable, unfair or oppressive. In this matter, the appellant has pleaded and proved none of these exceptional circumstances. The contracts stand on their terms. The appellant is bound by these contracts and must honour them as written (see National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipes Plastic Samko lit (K) Ltd & another (2002) E.A 503.
We accordingly find that the appellant was bound by the terms of the agreements between the parties he was therefore duty bound to honour his obligations having entered the agreements consciously we apply the ruminations of Lord Clarke in the case of RTS Flexible Systems Ltd v Molkerei Alois Mutter GMBH (2010) 1 WLR 753 at (45) (2010) UKSC 14 that held as follows:
“Having perused the documents and the correspondence between the parties, there is no doubt that the appellant borrowed money and that he defaulted in payment why would he even make proposals on repayment of the outstanding arrears…”
See also Morries & Co. v Kenya Commercial Bank (2003) 2 E.A 605.
The foregoing rendition applies on all fours to the circumstances of the instant suit.
In Barclays Bank of Kenya Ltd v Kepha Nyabera & 191 others (Supra), the Court of Appeal held:
“The general rule is that a secured creditor is not obliged to resort to his security. He can claim repayment by the debtor personally and leave the security alone. He can also sell the charged securities or set off or combine accounts. All these remedies could be exercised at any time or times simultaneously or contemporaneously or successively or not at all. This was held in CHINA AND SOUTH SEA BANK LTD V TAN SOON GIN (Gorge Tan) 1990 1AC 536 -545. We agree with this holding and hold that the appellant bank is not obliged to abandon its set-off rights and realize the security over immovable properties.”
In the instant case since the Petitioner’s salary was the security the salary had to be paid into his account during the subsistence of the loan and being the only transactional account with the bank, the 3rd respondent, in the court’s view had the contractual right to apply the funds in the account to the loan accounts in default.
The petitioner’s account was not designated as his pensions account nor were the monies in the account. The monies in the account were at the petitioner’s disposal in any manner he deemed fit including repaying the amount he owed the 3rd respondent.
Indeed the 3rd respondent had by letter dated 13th January 2025 requested the petitioner’s employer to forward his letter of discharge and comprehensive medical reports for purposes of the facility insurance under which the amount owed was payable by the insurer in the event of death or disability, and the Department of Defence responded.
It was not the 3rd respondent’s obligation to request for the documents. It was the petitioner’s duty to avail them but he failed to do so leaving the 3rd respondent with no option as to how it would recover the amount outstanding.
The 3rd respondent was under no obligation to pursue the insurance claim without proper documentation from the petitioner and forego the right of set-off, bearing in mind that the 3rd respondent appeared more eager to follow the claim than the petitioner who did not apply for a renew of the discharge letter or appeal the decision to discharge him from service.
The petitioner as adverted to elsewhere in this judgment was bound by the agreement he had entered into.
In Farah Abdalla Idha t/a Safif Trading v Gulf African Bank Ltd (2021) KECA 187 KLR, the court held:
“That the banker/customer relationship is in the nature of that between, a debtor and his creditor was enunciated in Edward Thomas Foley v Thomas Hill & others (1848) 2HLC P. 28 where Lord Brougham observed that: “this trade of a banker is to receive money, and use it as if it were his own, he becoming debtor to the person who had lent or deposited with him the money to use as his own and for which money he is accountable to his customer…”
See also in this regard Hebby Ondieki v Barclays Bank of Kenya Ltd (2008) KEHC ….(KLR) and Joachimson v Swiss Bank Corporation (1921) ALLER 92.
In the instant case the 3rd respondent was both a debtor and a creditor to the petitioner and since the petitioner (creditor/debtor), owed in the bank more than it owed him, it was entitled to set-off and any balance would be payable to the petitioner.
As regards the alleged violation of the right property to under Article 40 of the Constitution, it was incumbent upon the petitioner to demonstrate that the 3rd respondent had arbitrarily deprived him his rightful property. Evidence on record shows that the petitioner was indebted to the 3rd respondent under two (2) facilities both of which were in default.
In the courts view, section 13 of the Pensions Act does not protect deposits in a bank account held by the Account holder but safeguards the amount held by the employer, provident fund or other pension fund from being attached, levied or sequestratered.
For the foregoing reasons it is the finding of the court that the petitioner has failed to prove that the 3rd respondents’ action of setting off the sum of Kshs.3,175,637.50 was unlawful or that the sum was protected by section 13 of the Pensions Act.
On the declarations that the respondents violated the petitioner’s constitutional right to fair labour practices, economic and social rights, right to property and fair administration action, including various provision of the Employment, the court is not persuaded the respondents jointly or severally violated any of the petitioner’s constitutional rights.
The petitioner is however entitled to a Certificate of Discharge by dint of Section 257 (4) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act.
Concerning mandamus to compel the 1st respondent to issue a corrected discharge letter, the court is not persuaded such order should issue on account that the petitioner has not evidentiary demonstrated that the 1st respondent’s classification of the discharge was incorrect. The three letters dated February 2025 could not by themselves establish the petitioner’s permanent inability.
Be that as it may the letter of discharge or discharge certificate ought to have stated that the petitioner had a disability of 35%.
On the certificate of service, the court is of the view that the provisions of section 257 (4) of the Kenya Defence Forces Act are sufficient.
In the upshot the petitioner’s case is nominally successful to the extent that;
(a) The 1st respondent shall issue a certificate of discharge to the petitioner within 30 days.
(b) The 1st respondent shall include the petitioner’s disability of 35% in his Authority for discharge from service.
(c) Parties shall bear their own costs.
(d) For the avoidance of doubt all other prayers are declined.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI ON THIS 8TH OCTOBER, 2026.
DR. JACOB GAKERI
JUDGE
ORDER
In view of the declaration of measures restricting court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open court. In permitting this course, this court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this court the duty of the court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.
DR. JACOB GAKERI
JUDGE