Background
The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 15th November, 2025 and sought the following reliefs:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 15th November, 2025 and sought the following reliefs:-
Paragraph 1 →In view of all the foregoing, and having considered written submissions filed on behalf of both parties herein, I find no merit in the Chamber Summons application dated 8th January, 2026, and the same is hereby dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 21 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E1123 OF 2025
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Agnes Kitiku Nzei)
ODEGIH KEN OWIDHI OPIYO CLAIMANT
VERSUS
D. LIGHT LIMITED ..RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The Claimant sued the Respondent vide a Memorandum of Claim dated 15th November, 2025 and sought the following reliefs:-
(a) Refund of USD 1,000 and USD 1,500 unlawfully deducted from the Claimant’s September and October 2022 salary respectively.
(b) Payment of baggage allowance unlawfully deducted from the Claimant’s final terminal dues.
(c) Refund of Kshs.804,266.56 (being 494,774.00 + 309,472) unlawfully deducted from the Claimant’s final terminal dues.
(d) Reimbursements of USD 4,765.51 to the Claimant.
(e) Costs of the suit.
(f) Interest on (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) above until payment in full.
(g) Any other relief that the Court may deem fit to grant.
2. The Claimant pleaded that he had been employed by the Respondent on a permanent and pensionable basis vide a letter of appointment/offer dated 11th March, 2020 for the position of General Manager Ethiopia and Horn of Africa at an initial monthly salary of Kshs.800,000/=; which terms were subsequently improved vide an Addendum Agreement dated 22nd January, 2021. That the Claimant’s employment contract was terminated on 17th November, 2022 on account of redundancy.
3. The Claimant further pleaded that upon notice of termination, the Respondent calculated his final dues at Kshs.2,886,557.08/=, less money owed to the Respondent, less tax and statutory deductions. That the Respondent approved baggage in favour of the Claimant, but never paid. It was further pleaded by the Claimant that upon receipt of the final dues calculations, he immediately made communication to the Respondent, making it aware for consideration the sums/deductions claimed.
4. The Claimant further pleaded that the said deductions were unlawful and oppressive, and more so considering the circumstances under which the Claimant was terminated within a short notice. That vide letters written by separate firms of Advocates separately retained by the Respondent, the Respondent admitted the deductions in issue but gave contradicting reasons for the same.
5. The Respondent subsequently filed a Chamber Summons application dated 8th January, 2025. The Court was on 8th July, 2026 informed by Counsel for both parties that the date of the application ought to have been 8th January, 2026, that it had been dated 8th January, 2025 in error.
6. For purposes of this Ruling, I will refer to the said application’s date as 8th January, 2026. This Ruling determines the said application.
7. The Respondent/Applicant seeks the following Orders:-
(a) That the Court be pleased to send the dispute herein to arbitration.
(b) That the Court be pleased to stay the proceedings herein pending referral, hearing and determination of the dispute through the structured dispute resolution mechanism envisaged under the Employment Contract/Letter of Appointment.
(c) That costs of the Application be provided for.
8. The application sets out on its face the grounds on which it is brought, and is based on the affidavit of Grace Kala sworn on 8th January, 2026 in support of the application. It is deponed in the said supporting affidavit, inter-alia:-
(a) that Clause 19 of the letter of appointment requires parties to the contract to refer the matter to arbitration where a dispute arises between them.
(b) that Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution mandates the Courts to promote alternative dispute resolution mechanisms to enable the just and expeditious disposal of suits.
(c) that Section 6(1) [of the Arbitration Act] requires Courts to stay proceedings which are subject of an Arbitration Agreement where the party enters appearance or files any pleadings or takes any other step in the proceedings.
9. The application is opposed by the Claimant vide his replying affidavit sworn on 4th March, 2026. It is deponed in the said replying affidavit, inter-alia:-
(a) that the application is brought in bad faith, and smacks of an intent to gain unfair advantage and/or undermine the Claimant’s interests.
(b) that the word MAY as used in the arbitration clause indicates that the type of dispute resolution in the clause (arbitration) is non-mandatory. That it is permissive or optional, rather than compulsory.
(c) that the Claimant engaged the Respondent for two (2) years preceding the suit herein, and that upon his Advocates serving an intention to sue, the Respondent/Applicant’s response was to the effect that they were ready to defend any claim lodged against them.
(d) that preferring to arbitration after this long is bad faith and taste as the Claimant has already chosen the option of litigating in Court.
(e) that Clause 19(a) & (e) provide that the Arbitration Tribunal shall constitute of three (3) arbitrators, and that the entire cost of the arbitration shall be shared equally between the two parties.
(f) that as an individual who is no longer in employment after being terminated and dues withheld, the requirement of arbitration will be overwhelmingly costly to the Claimant; considering that the three (3) arbitrators will be required to arbitrate over a claim of less than Kenya Shillings Two Million.
(g) that it would be unjust for the Claimant to be required to pay costs irrespective of his possible success.
(h) that the arbitration clause is unfair, and goes against the imperatives of the Employment Act, the Constitution and tenets of natural justice, and [should] be struck off.
10. Parties filed written submissions for and against the application. The sole issue falling for determination, in my view, is whether the orders sought can justly issue.
11. Clause 19 of the Claimant’s letter of appointment dated 11th March, 2020, a copy whereof is annexed to the aforesaid supporting affidavit, states:-
“19. Dispute Settlement
The parties shall use their best efforts to settle amicably all disputes arising out of or in connection to this contract or its interpretation.
(a) Any dispute between the parties on matters arising pursuant to this contract that cannot be settled amicably within thirty (30) days after the receipt by one party of the other party’s request for such amicable settlement may be referred by either party to arbitration in accordance with the laws of Kenya.
(b) The arbitration tribunal shall constitute of three (3) arbitrators. Each party shall appoint one (1) arbitrator and the third (3) arbitrator shall be appointed by the two (2) arbitrators.
(c) If the parties fail to agree on the appointment of arbitrators, the arbitrators shall be appointed by the Chairperson of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators – Kenya Branch on the request of the applying party.
(d) The arbitration proceedings shall be held in Nairobi.
(e) The entire cost of the arbitration shall be shared equally between the two parties”.
12. It is to be noted from the opening sentence in the foregoing arbitration clause that parties to the contract “shall first use their best efforts to settle amicably all disputes arising out of or in connection to the contract or its interpretation”. The Claimant has deponed that it took him two years trying to engage the Respondent over the deductions/non-payments in issue, and that when he finally issued a notice to sue, the Respondent’s response was that it was ready to defend the suit. This deposition is not denied by the Respondent.
13. The Respondent has not demonstrated “any effort”, best or otherwise, to settle the dispute herein amicably before institution of the suit herein. The word used regarding efforts by the contracting parties to settle disputes amicably is “shall”. The Respondent’s failure and/or refusal to engage in such effort amounted to breach of a contractual duty. A party cannot purport to enforce a contract of which it is in breach.
14. Sub-Clause (a) of the aforesaid arbitration clause is permissive, as the word used there is may; meaning that referral to arbitration is optional; but once one opts to go the arbitration way, sub-clauses (b), (c), (d) and (e) make mandatory provisions regarding the arbitration process. The Claimant opted to file a suit in this Court, and in my view, the suit is properly before this Court, and this Court is seized of Jurisdiction to entertain, to hear and to determine the same.
15. It must be noted that employment contracts are not commercial contracts. Employment contracts belong to a special category of contracts whereby the contracting parties are not of equal bargaining power. One party (the employer) owns the means of production while the other party is selling his or her labour to earn a living. The party owing the means of production (the employer) naturally wields high/higher bargaining power. More often than not, if not always, the employer determines and sets the terms and conditions of employment in his enterprise/organization, with the employee’s role in the employment contract making being limited to signing and dating the already prepared contract. In rare occurrences, the employee may be given an opportunity to negotiate the salary and benefits payable to him by the employer. Otherwise, it is usually a case of take or leave on the part of the employee.
16. Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 established this Specialized Superior Court to deal with all matters employment and labour relations; and by dint of Article 162(3) mandated Parliament to determine the Jurisdiction and functions of the Court, which mandate Parliament executed by enacting the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. The said Act gives this Court a wide jurisdiction and judicial powers to ensure fair administration of Justice in employment and labour relations matters.
17. The Court of Appeal stated as follows in the case of Paramount Bank Limited – vs – Vaqvi Syed Qamara & Another [2017] eKLR:-
“. . . The preamble to the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act states that the Court is established to hear and determine disputes relating to “employment and labour relations” and “for connected purposes”. Among its powers under Section 12, the Court hears and determines all disputes relating to and arising out of employment and labour relations. In the exercise of that jurisdiction, the Court has the power to award compensation or damages in any circumstances contemplated under the Act or any other written law and to grant any other appropriate relief that it may deem fit.”
18. It is worthy noting that provisions of the Arbitration Act are not saved in the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. If the legislature intended that employers and employees would take away this Court’s jurisdiction over some employment matters by simply including an arbitration clause in contracts of employment, then provisions of the Arbitration Act would have been saved in the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.
19. Instead, Section 15(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act provides as follows:-
“(1) Nothing in this Act may be construed as precluding the Court from adopting and implementing, or on its own motion or at the request of the parties, any other appropriate means of dispute resolution, including internal methods, conciliation, mediation and traditional dispute resolution mechanisms in accordance with Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution”.
20. In my view, the import of the foregoing provision is that the Court may, on its own motion or at the request of the parties litigating before it, refer a matter for alternative dispute resolution pursuant to Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution. The said statutory provision does not contemplate or envision a situation where parties to a contract of employment contract themselves out of this Court’s jurisdiction. Any Clause in a contact of employment that purports to remove the parties thereto from this Court’s jurisdiction is, in my view, null and void.
21. In view of all the foregoing, and having considered written submissions filed on behalf of both parties herein, I find no merit in the Chamber Summons application dated 8th January, 2026, and the same is hereby dismissed with costs.
22. The suit herein shall be fast-tracked, and shall be set down for hearing.
23. Orders accordingly.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS
9TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
AGNES KITIKU NZEI
JUDGE
ORDER
This Ruling has been delivered via Microsoft Teams Online Platform. A signed copy will be availed to each party upon payment of the applicable Court fees.
AGNES KITIKU NZEI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mr. Omondi for the Claimant
Mr. Mwangi for the Respondent