Background
The termination of the contract of employment between the Claimant and the Respondent was unlawful, illegal and unfair to the Claimant;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The termination of the contract of employment between the Claimant and the Respondent was unlawful, illegal and unfair to the Claimant;
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. 260 OF 2019
CHARLES KURIA MAINA CLAIMANT
VERSUS
HARLEY’S LIMITED RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
The claimant is a male adult. The respondent is a limited liability company.
The Claimant was employed by the Respondent on 28 January 2008 as a Medical Representative, with a salary of Kshs. 33,500. On 1 September 2013, he was appointed Team Leader, responsible for promoting the Vitabiotics range of products, earning a gross salary of Kshs. 115,000. This included various allowances. At the time of termination, his gross monthly salary had risen to Kshs. 330,000.
The claim is that, during his employment, the Respondent offered to sell the claimant a motor vehicle, registration number KCD 929K, for Kshs. 1,790,000 payable through salary deductions, and also provided him with a Samsung S8 phone and a laptop.
On 15 October 2018, the Respondent received an anonymous complaint from a former employee, following which several allegations were raised against the Claimant, including intimidation and harassment of staff, lack of accountability, sexual harassment and misuse of entertainment allowance. The allegations were unfounded and intended to procure his resignation, which the Respondent allegedly sought in exchange for a favourable recommendation.
The Claimant’s case is that the Respondent frustrated his work by locking him out of his official email account, redirecting his staff to his assistant, removing him from official WhatsApp groups and restricting his interaction with clients. He received two show-cause letters and responded.
He was invited to a disciplinary hearing on 5 December 2018.
The claimant challenged the fairness of the disciplinary process, contending that staff were intimidated from supporting him, he was denied representation on grounds of confidentiality, and new witnesses introduced allegations against him without supplying their statements before the disciplinary hearing.
The claim is that on 14 December 2018, the Respondent published a notice in the Daily Nation stating that the claimant had ceased to be its employee with effect from 8 December 2018 and was no longer authorised to represent it. He contends that the publication was defamatory, as he had not been formally notified of his termination and was at the time only under suspension. He claims that the publication damaged his reputation and prospects of securing employment within the pharmaceutical industry. He was thereafter ejected from the Respondent’s premises without payment of his terminal dues.
The Claimant responded to the Response and Counterclaim and denied the allegations. He argued that his promotions resulted from general employee progression and were based on his performance. He contends that the decision to terminate his employment was triggered by his position concerning the Respondent’s legal obligations to the Kenya Revenue Authority, which differed from that of the Operations Director. He further alleges that the Managing Director pressured him to resign and, upon his refusal, the Respondent began looking for grounds upon which to terminate his employment.
The Claimant also maintains that decisions concerning conferences, product samples, promotions, budgets and payments were collective departmental decisions and not made by him alone. He denies the allegation of mileage fraud, stating that it was never raised during his employment and that mileage claims were subject to checks and counter-checks by his superiors and the Accounts Department.
The Claimant seeks Judgment in the following terms:
1. The termination of the contract of employment between the Claimant and the Respondent was unlawful, illegal and unfair to the Claimant;
2. Following (I) above, this Court be pleased to find that the Claimant is entitled to terminal benefits as particularised at paragraph 24 above for:
3. Compensation for unfair/unlawful and illegal termination
of employment Kshs.3,960,000
4. Salary in lieu of notice Kshs.990,000
5. Unpaid days Kshs.110,000
6. Accumulated leave days Kshs.1,848,000
7. Severance pay Kshs.1,650,000
TOTAL Kshs.8,558,000
In evidence, the claimant testified that he was employed by the Respondent from 28 January 2008 until his summary dismissal on 8 December 2018, and that he rose to the position of Senior Manager at a monthly salary of Kshs. 330,000. He argued that the dismissal was unlawful and unfair, and he seeks compensation, notice pay, unpaid salary, accrued leave, severance pay, and a refund of Kshs. 1,400,000 paid towards motor vehicle KCD 929K, damages for defamation, and a certificate of service, costs and interest.
In evidence, the claimant testified that after being employed by the respondent, he worked diligently and rose to senior manager. However, the respondent terminated his employment following various allegations and complaints lacking proof or evidence. These were intended to force the claimant to resign, and when he declined, the respondent officers began coercion through the CEO, Rupe, and Nishil. His work emails were deleted on 6 November 2018, and he was completely locked out of the official email communications. He was also removed from the official WhatsApp group, and the group members were advised to exit; the claimant was effectively replaced as team leader.
The claimant testified that the respondent constructively dismissed him by making his working environment hostile. He was forced to start a WhatsApp group to secure justice. The respondent directed him not to contact any employee during the notice-to-show-cause period. However, faced with false allegations, he needed to secure justice and therefore started the WhatsApp group, which included several employees.
The claimant testified that he was invited to attend the disciplinary hearing and to attend with an employee of his choice. However, the employees had been warned against talking to him, so none were willing to accompany him. He asked to bring an independent witness, his advocate, but the respondent declined. He faced a hostile panel in the disciplinary hearing, composed of his peers and juniors, regardless of his position. Ultimately, he was dismissed with notice, terminating his employment unfairly and without justification.
During his employment, the claimant admitted that he took a loan and purchased motor vehicle KCD 929K, secured by the respondent. He had not fully paid the loan, and the respondent kept the logbook. However, the respondent frustrated the claimant's possession of the vehicle through police harassment and his arrest, and eventually broke it at the garage where it was being repaired, then used auctioneers to take it. The respondent alleged that the claimant changed ownership of the vehicle while retaining the logbook.
The claimant is seeking a refund of what he paid the respondent for the vehicle.
The claimant is also seeking the orders set out in his claim.
The claimant called Jael Asibiko, formerly employed by the respondent and who worked with the claimant. She testified that the claimant was a good manager and offered his team training and guidance. The claimant faced challenges with parallel imports, which led to significant growth for the respondent. In November 2018, some employees made false allegations against the claimant meant to make him resign. The witness stated that some employees, Flavia and Hilda, alleged that she was harsh with them, which was not true. Similarly, the claimant faced false allegations of using abusive language, but there was no evidence.
Asibik testified that she resigned in September 2019 after the claimant had left. She was aware of his disciplinary hearing, which involved concerned witnesses. The CEO also tried to coerce her to write a false statement against the claimant, but she declined.
The claimant also called Peter Gitau Kimethu, who previously worked for the respondent and currently works in Tanzania. He testified that he worked well with the claimant as the head of department and learned a lot, which led him to secure new opportunities. He was surprised to learn of the complaints made against the Claimant by some employees since he knew him as a diligent employee keen to train and support his team members.
Response and Counterclaim
The Respondent filed a response and counterclaim.
The Respondent’s case is that the Claimant was its employee and was assigned to the team handling Vitabiotics. The Respondent admitted that both parties executed an addendum to the employment agreement and that, at the time of termination, the Claimant earned a gross salary of Kshs. 330,000.
The Respondent denies the allegations that there was employment progression. Salary changes and promotions were part of normal career progression. The Claimant had a difficult relationship with his colleagues and was accused of harassment and inappropriate conduct. The Respondent received complaints from female employees, including allegations of sexual harassment and a rape complaint that was reported to the police.
At the Claimant’s request, the Respondent financed the purchase of motor vehicle registration number KCD 929K, valued at Kshs. 1,790,000, which was jointly registered in the names of the Claimant and the Respondent. The Claimant remained indebted to the Respondent in the sum of Kshs. 470,000 and subsequently and unlawfully transferred the vehicle to Carlos Auto Spares Limited. The transfer was fraudulent and intended to defeat its interest in the vehicle.
The Respondent terminated the Claimant’s employment for misconduct. It was substantively justified and procedurally fair. The Respondent received several complaints from members of the Claimant’s team, which it investigated and supported with employee statements. On 6 November 2018, the Claimant was called to a meeting with the Respondent’s Directors and his assistant and was informed of concerns relating to the management of the Vitabiotics sales team, use of resources, entertainment allowances and his conduct towards colleagues. Instead of addressing the concerns, the Claimant threatened members of his team and accused the Respondent’s Director of attempting to force him to resign. The Respondent subsequently issued him a Notice to Show Cause dated 21 November 2018, which raised various allegations against him. Investigations had revealed complaints of abusive language, intimidation, poor management, misuse or misappropriation of resources, irregular handling of product samples and mileage allowance, and other misconduct.
The Claimant responded to the notice to show cause largely through denials and accusations against the Respondent.
On 24 November 2018, the Claimant created a WhatsApp group in which he threatened to take members of his team to court for defamation because they had made statements against him. This resulted in a second Notice to Show Cause and his being placed on compulsory leave pending further investigations.
A disciplinary hearing was held on 5 December 2018. The Claimant was informed of his right to be accompanied by a fellow employee but chose not to exercise that right and instead sought to be accompanied by an Advocate. He was nevertheless allowed to make representations on the allegations against him. He failed to explain satisfactorily, among other matters, how he used the product samples entrusted to him.
The response is that while still in employment, the Claimant communicated with one of its clients and made statements concerning the Respondent’s business and its relationship with Vitabiotics. The Claimant thereafter continued making defamatory statements about the Respondent to its suppliers and on social media, thereby damaging its business relationships. The Respondent consequently published a newspaper notice informing the public that the Claimant had ceased to work for it.
Investigations established, among other things, that the Claimant used abusive language and intimidated employees, mismanaged product samples and other resources, and contributed to a high attrition rate within his department. The Claimant’s conduct was inconsistent with the company's zero-tolerance policy on harassment.
By letter dated 8 December 2018, the Claimant was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct under section 44 of the Employment Act. He was accorded due process, given an adequate opportunity to respond to the allegations and participate in the disciplinary process, and the hearing was conducted fairly and professionally.
The Respondent consequently denies liability for the reliefs sought by the Claimant and maintains that the summary dismissal was lawful and justified. It particularly disputes the Claimant’s claim for refund of Kshs.1,400,000 allegedly paid towards reducing his indebtedness in respect of the financed motor vehicle.
Counterclaim
In counterclaim, the Respondent claims Kshs.470, 000, being the outstanding amount owed by the Claimant in respect of the motor vehicle financing. The Claimant unlawfully and fraudulently transferred motor vehicle registration number KCD 929K to Carlos Auto Spares Limited to defeat the Respondent’s interest.
The Respondent therefore seeks the following remedies as against the Claimant:
1. The sum of Kshs. 470,000/- together with interest thereupon at the Court rate from the date of filing the claim until payment in full;
2. Damages for the said wrongful and fraudulent transfer;
3. General Damages for Defamation;
4. Costs of this claim and interest thereon at the court's rate from the date of judgment until payment in full; and
5. Such further or other reliefs as may be appropriate in the circumstances.
To support its case, the respondent called Jyoti Chana, the administrator, who testified that the claimant’s employment was terminated for inappropriate conduct, use of abusive language, and mismanagement of resources. Several employees made complaints, and the respondent conducted investigations. It was established that the claimant had a habit of disrespecting his team members and speaking to them in a manner that was disrespectful, harassing, and condescending.
Chana testified that the respondent received 2 complaints of sexual harassment against the claimant. These were from female employees who had left his department. One of them had filed suit against the claimant.
On 6 November 2018, the directors and the claimant's assistant met with the claimant. The director informed the claimant of the complaints made against him and concerns about the operations of the Vitabiotics sales team, the management of resources allocated to the team, improper use of the entertainment allowance, and his general conduct towards colleagues in discharging his duties. This was a normal meeting to resolve the issues amicably, given the seriousness of the allegations. Instead, the claimant threatened his team for raising complaints against him and then wrote to the director, accusing him of pushing him to resign.
On 22 November 2018, the claimant was issued with a notice to show cause. The issues related to:
1. The claimant received product samples for use during conferences, but his teammates were not aware of these conferences, and the samples were never disbursed.
2. The claimant claimed to be giving samples to Generic Africa, yet this client is a distributor who purchases at discounted prices and therefore does not need samples.
3. The claimant constantly used abusive language while addressing his teammates, causing fear and intimidation by alluding that his words were final and threatening to have their employment terminated.
4. The claimant was an insurrectionist, a bully and created insubordination.
5. The claimant misappropriated resources, including CME had budgeted for head operations, yet he requested money from his juniors/supervisees.
6. The claimant requested double the amount for the Good Life Back to School promotion, but only half reached the clients.
7. Car mileage allowance fraud.
Chana testified that the claimant responded to the notice to show cause with mere denials and false accusations against the respondent, and complained that the respondent wanted to remove him from the company. He showed no remorse for the distress he had caused his teammates.
On 24 November 2018, the claimant formed a WhatsApp group called “court case” to intimidate the respondent employees. He stated that he would take them to court and charge them for defamation of character as they had all written statements against him. This intimidation necessitated the issuance of a second notice to show cause on 28 November 2018. The claimant was then set on compulsory leave pending investigations. He was given a chance to file his responses, which he did, and admitted to setting up the WhatsApp group.
Chana testified that a disciplinary hearing was held on 5 December 2018, where the claimant could attend with another employee of his choice. At the hearing, the claimant chose not to exercise this right. Instead, he demanded to bring an outsider, his advocate. He was informed that this was not permitted under the Employment Act.
The claimant was taken through the allegations made against him, but he offered no valid responses and, in other cases, chose not to comment. In one instance, the claimant was asked to explain how he utilised the samples availed for various presentations. As team leader, he was accountable for sample product management. He did not give a satisfactory explanation.
The claimant was found to be a poor manager in handling company products, was of poor conduct towards his colleagues, and went against the company policy on zero tolerance for sexual harassment.
Chana testified that, unknown to the respondent, on 5 December 2018, the claimant, while in its employment, wrote to its clients warning:
I wish to let you know that I am no longer working for Harleys. A difference arose between Nishil and me because of my close relationship with Vitabiotics and how I dedicated my time to grow VB sales in Kenya and Tanzania.
Going forward, it will be extremely hard for Harleys to sell GBP 500,000 per year for your product. Competing brands will overtake your brands like yesterday.
Chana testified that this communication portrayed the respondent as incompetent and unable to service its suppliers professionally and effectively. The statements were published on the claimant’s social media account to portray the respondent and its officers as not law-abiding and amounted to defamation. The claimant further published defamatory statements against the respondent on his Facebook account.
A few suppliers had investigated and established the claimant’s conduct. Vitabiotics officers wrote to the respondent about the claimant's communications and expressed their shock at the allegations that the respondent was selling substandard products. They noted that the claimant admitted he was no longer working for the respondent and that, on the issues he had raised with them, he should have been professional and should desist from such communication.
The claimant continued by making false allegations against the respondent, forcing the respondent to issue a notice in the newspaper and notify the public that he had ceased his employment. This was meant to cease the damage occasioned to the respondent.
By notice dated 8 December 2018, the claimant was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct. The reasons were justified under the contract and the Employment Act. The claimant was directed to return company property but declined.
On the counterclaim, Chana testified that the claimant applied for a loan to purchase a vehicle with registration KCD 929K at Ksh. 1,790,000. The request was accepted on the condition that it would be jointly registered in the names of the respondent and the claimant to secure the loan. The claimant is yet to pay the full amount, and a balance of Ksh. 470,000 remains unpaid.
The claimant’s employment was terminated for gross misconduct. The claim to be refunded Ksh. 1,400,000 paid for the vehicle is not justified since he transferred it to a third party while the respondent held the logbook. The matter had to be reported to the police. The motor vehicle balance is therefore due and owing with interest from the date due and until paid in full.
On substantive fairness, the Claimant submitted that the dismissal was premeditated. He contends that before the disciplinary process commenced, the Respondent had frustrated him by deleting his work emails, locking him out of the official email system, removing him as administrator of his team’s WhatsApp groups, directing employees not to communicate with him and appointing another team leader. He argues that these actions made it impossible for him to perform his duties and were evidence of an intention to force him out of employment. In Nathan Ogada Atiagaga v David Engineering Limited [2015] KEELRC 75 and Emmanuel Mutisya Solomon v Agility Logistics (Industrial Court Cause No 1448 of 2011), the court, in addressing constructive dismissal and breach of the implied term of trust and confidence, held that the employee is entitled to due process and substantive fairness.
The Claimant submitted that the allegations of his using abusive language, poor performance, and poor management were false, fabricated, and unsubstantiated, having been raised after the Respondent’s alleged attempts to procure his resignation had failed. He testified to the facts, and his witness, Jael Irene Asibiko, confirmed that employees were coached or threatened to make allegations against him. Therefore, the notices to show cause and subsequent disciplinary proceedings were merely intended to create reasons for a predetermined dismissal.
The Respondent failed to establish a valid and justified reason for termination of employment as required under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act (the Act), as held in Thika Coffee Mills Ltd v Mwangi [2026] KEELRC 1898 (KLR) and H Young Company (EA) Limited v Kenya Building, Construction, Timber & Furniture Industries Employees Union [2026] KECA 1020 (KLR).
On procedural fairness, the Claimant submitted that the disciplinary process was fundamentally defective. First, the disciplinary committee was improperly constituted because, under the Respondent’s HR Policy, disciplinary proceedings involving a Senior Manager had to be chaired by the Managing Director, whereas Ms Jyoti Chana chaired his hearing.
Second, he contends that he was denied the right to call a witness of his choice. His request to have an external witness was rejected despite his explanation that internal employees were unwilling to testify because they feared victimisation. In Seii v LVCT Health [2024] KEELRC 2162 (KLR), the Court held that an employee should have an opportunity to call witnesses necessary to support his defence.
Third, the Claimant submitted that he was denied an opportunity to cross-examine the employees whose statements formed the basis of the allegations against him. The employees were not present at the disciplinary hearing, yet the committee relied on their statements. In Ashoro v Cargil Kenya Limited [2026] KEELRC 478 (KLR), which affirmed the principles in Shollei v Judicial Service Commission & another [2022] KESC 5 (KLR), on the importance of disclosure, a genuine opportunity to be heard, impartiality and the right to question witnesses whose evidence is relied upon.
On defamation, the Claimant submitted that the Respondent’s publication in the Daily Nation on 14 December 2018, warning the public against dealing with him, was false, malicious and damaging to his reputation. He argues that the publication suggested that he lacked integrity and was still purporting to represent the Respondent. No evidence justified the publication, and he seeks an unqualified apology and Kshs. 5,000,000 as general damages. Reliance is placed on Jacqueline Arkle v Five Forty Aviation Limited [2018] KEELRC 933 (KLR) and Radio Africa Limited & another v Nicholas Sumba & another [2015] eKLR.
Regarding the counterclaim, the Claimant disputes the Respondent’s claim for Kshs. 470,000 said to be the balance due for motor vehicle KCD 929K. He submitted that the Respondent had already repossessed the vehicle and therefore could not simultaneously recover the alleged outstanding balance. He also relies on the criminal proceedings in Republic v Charles Kuria Maina, Milimani MCCR/E556 of 2022, in which he was acquitted of the alleged fraudulent transfer of the vehicle. He therefore argues that the Respondent’s claim for the balance and damages for fraudulent transfer is unsustainable and that he should instead be refunded the Kshs. 1,400,000 already paid.
The Claimant also denies the Respondent’s allegations of defamation, contending that no evidence links him to the alleged defamatory emails and WhatsApp messages. He consequently urges the Court to dismiss the counterclaim with costs.
Termination of employment was both substantively and procedurally unfair, and the Court should grant the reliefs sought, save that the prayer for refund of Kshs. 1,400,000 in respect of KCD 929K should take into account the fact that the vehicle has already been repossessed. He further asks the Court to dismiss the Respondent’s counterclaim with costs.
The Respondent submitted that the Claimant’s employment was terminated for valid and fair reasons and that he was accorded a fair disciplinary process in accordance with the Employment Act. Several complaints were raised against the Claimant in November 2018 by members of the Vitabiotics sales team concerning his conduct, including the use of abusive language and intimidation of employees who had raised concerns with the Human Resource Manager. Attempts to resolve the complaints amicably were unsuccessful. The complaints were sufficiently serious to warrant disciplinary action. On 21 November 2018, the Claimant was issued a show cause letter, together with the written complaints, and was allowed to respond. Instead, on 24 November 2018, he created a WhatsApp group titled “COURT CASE”, added members of his team and threatened to take them to court for defamation. The Respondent contends that this conduct intimidated the affected employees and led to further complaints. The Company then issued a second show cause letter on 28 November 2018 and placed the Claimant on leave pending investigations. The Claimant responded to both show cause letters.
He was thereafter invited to a disciplinary hearing scheduled for 5 December 2018 and was expressly informed of his right to be accompanied by an employee of his choice. Although he requested someone from outside the Respondent to accompany him, the Respondent declined the request on the basis that the disciplinary process was internal. The hearing proceeded on 5 December 2018, at which the Claimant was allowed to respond to the allegations. After considering his representations, the disciplinary committee found his responses unsatisfactory, and it terminated his employment on 8 December 2018.
Under sections 43 and 47(5) of the Employment Act, while an employee bears the initial burden of establishing that an unfair termination occurred, the employer bears the burden of proving the reason for termination once that foundation has been laid, as held in Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited [2017] eKLR. In Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited v Aggrey Lukorito Wasike [2017] eKLR, the Court held that employers, like employees, are entitled to the protection of the law and that the Court should ensure justice to both parties.
The Respondent further submitted that the Court ought not to substitute its own view for that of the employer but should determine whether a reasonable employer, acting on the facts available at the time, could have decided to terminate, as held in Magdalene M. Ngea v National Cereals and Produce Board [2017] eKLR and Evans Kamadi Misango v Barclays Bank of Kenya Limited [2015] eKLR. In Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019] eKLR, the court held that an employer is not required to undertake a criminal or forensic investigation before taking disciplinary action; the applicable standard is proof on a balance of probabilities, and the employer must demonstrate the reasons it genuinely believed existed.
Applying those principles, the Respondent submitted that the written complaints, coupled with the Claimant’s subsequent conduct in creating the “COURT CASE” WhatsApp group and threatening his colleagues, provided reasonable grounds for disciplinary action. The Respondent maintains that it genuinely believed the complaints to be well founded and that the Claimant’s conduct amounted to gross misconduct as held in Ondieki v Teachers Service Commission, ELRC Appeal E040 of 2024 [2026] KEELRC 976 (KLR) and Kichinda v Kenya Power & Lighting Co. Limited, Cause E046 of 2022 [2025] KEELRC 2314 (KLR) on the requirement of a genuine belief founded on reasonable grounds.
The Respondent submitted that an employer is entitled to maintain a harmonious working environment and to take disciplinary action against an employee whose conduct is incompatible with that objective. In Dede Esi Arnie Amanor Wilks v Action Aid International [2014] eKLR, the court held that employers may address insubordination and conduct inconsistent with the workplace environment.
On procedural fairness, the Respondent complied with section 41 of the Employment Act. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR, the court addressed the requirements of notice of the allegations, an explanation of the grounds for termination, the right to be accompanied by another employee, and consideration of the employee’s representations.
The chronology of events demonstrates compliance with section 41. The Claimant received the complaints and show-cause letters, responded, was invited to a disciplinary hearing, was informed of his right to representation, and was heard before the decision to terminate was made. In Standard Group Limited v Jenny Luesby [2018] eKLR and George Musamali v G4S Security Services Kenya Limited [2016] eKLR, the court held that a disciplinary hearing need not assume the form or rigour of a court trial, provided the employee is informed of the allegations and allowed to respond.
The Respondent submitted that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was both substantively and procedurally fair. The Claimant is not entitled to the 12 months’ compensation sought because the termination was based on valid reasons and was procedurally fair.
The termination was a summary dismissal for valid reasons and followed due process. No notice pay is due.
On the claim for unpaid salary, the Respondent acknowledges that the Claimant is entitled to payment for days actually worked, subject to clearance and return of company property.
In relation to accrued leave, the claim for Kshs.1, 848,000 represents approximately eight years of accumulated leave. Relying on section 28(4) of the Employment Act and Vipingo Workers Co-operative Savings and Credit Society Limited v Ziro & 4 others [2026] KEELRC 1300 (KLR), the Respondent submitted that leave cannot be accumulated beyond 18 months. The Claimant would, at most, be entitled to 32 days’ accrued leave amounting to Kshs. 352,000, or such amount as the Court may properly calculate.
The claim for severance pay: the Claimant was not declared redundant. There is no liability for service gratuity. The respondent had no gratuity scheme and NSSF deductions were made on the Claimant’s salary, thereby excluding service pay under section 35(6) of the Employment Act.
With respect to motor vehicle registration number KCD 929K, the Respondent submitted that it financed the vehicle at Kshs. 1,790,000, of which the Claimant had paid only Kshs. 1,320,000, leaving a balance of Kshs.470, 000. The Respondent therefore disputes the Claimant’s demand for release of Kshs.1, 400,000 or the logbook, which remains registered in the Respondent’s name. It further contends that the Claimant had attempted to transfer the vehicle contrary to the Respondent’s interest and that the vehicle was subsequently vandalised.
The Respondent also denies liability for the Claimant’s claim for an apology and damages for defamation. It submits that following the Claimant’s termination, he made false and defamatory statements about the Respondent to its clients and suppliers through Facebook. The Respondent consequently published a notice informing the public that the Claimant was no longer its employee and lacked authority to represent it. The Respondent maintains that the notice contained no defamatory statement and that the Claimant did not establish the elements of defamation.
The Respondent acknowledges that the Claimant is entitled to a certificate of service under section 51 of the Employment Act, but states that he has not returned to collect it. It further submits that costs should follow the event since the claim has not been proved and the Respondent complied with both substantive and procedural requirements of the law.
On the counterclaim, the Respondent submitted that the vehicle was financed at Kshs. 1,790,000 and the Claimant had paid only Kshs. 1,320,000, leaving a balance of Kshs.470, 000. The Claimant admitted the outstanding balance during cross-examination. The Respondent relies on evidence concerning the attempted transfer of the vehicle to Carlos Auto Spares Limited and the subsequent criminal proceedings, submitting that although the Claimant was acquitted for want of proof beyond reasonable doubt that he personally hacked the NTSA system, the evidence established that the transfer itself was fraudulent.
The Respondent therefore submitted that the Claimant remains liable for the outstanding Kshs.470, 000 and asks the Court to allow the counterclaim and, pursuant to section 19 of the Employment Act, permit recovery of the amount from any terminal dues found payable.
From the foregoing, the Respondent urges the Court to dismiss the claim with costs, allow the counterclaim and recognise that the Claimant remains entitled only to such terminal dues as are lawfully payable, including salary for days worked and any leave properly due under section 28(4) of the Employment Act.
Determination
The issues which emerge for determination in this case are whether there was unlawful and unfair termination of employment; whether the claimant has established a case of defamation; whether the claimant is entitled to the remedies sought; whether the counterclaim is justified; and who should pay costs.
Through notice dated 8 December 2018, the respondent terminated the claimant’s employment by summary dismissal. The reasons were that, following a disciplinary hearing, his conduct and behaviour towards his team members were found inappropriate, leading to termination of employment. The respondent noted that the claimant had been invited to various discussions with management about his conduct, which led to the disciplinary hearings. His explanations were found unsatisfactory.
Section 47(5) of the Employment Act (the Act) places the burden of proof on the employee to prove the unlawfulness of the termination of employment, and on the employer to justify the termination. To discharge the burden of proof, the employee must place before the court prima facie evidence that a termination of employment has occurred and that the termination lacks substantive justification or is procedurally flawed. Once the employee makes a prima facie case, the burden of proof shifts onto the employer to justify the termination of employment. See Galgalo Jarso Jillo v Agricultural Finance Corporation [2021] KEELRC 323 (KLR) and Omollo v International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) [2026] KEELRC 2652 (KLR).
Did the claimant discharge his burden of proof to warrant the respondent's justification for terminating the employment?
Through a notice to show cause dated 21 November 2018, the respondent stated that, following investigations, it had been established that the management of resources allocated to the Vitabiotics sales team under his supervision had not been properly utilised. He improperly used the entertainment allowance, and his general conduct was wanting. He was required to respond to various matters including:
1) Product samples for clients received but not used for the purpose. The claimant provided a list of names for a women’s conference at Thika Baptist held in May 2018, and no samples were issued there.
2) For three months, the claimant claimed to have given samples to Generic Africa, yet the client is a distributor who purchases at discounted prices and does not need any samples. The client returned samples a month after the claimant claimed to have given it samples. This defied business logic.
3) Using abusive language while addressing the claimant, causing fear and intimidation by alluding to the fact that his word was final.
The claimant was directed to respond by 9 November 2018.
Under the same notice to show cause, there were other allegations against the claimant including:
1) Resources, and that on 4 August 2018 the claimant asked for Ksh. 70,000, whereas under CME had the allocation. He had asked for money from his junior staff.
2) Goodlife back-to-school promotion: the claimant requested double the amount to be used as an incentive, whereas half the money was used and there was no accountability.
3) Nia Pharmaceuticals: on two occasions, the team members contributed towards alleged procurement activities, yet a budget was allocated. On 14 August 2018, the claimant solicited and received Ksh. 11,000 from his junior staff Edwin Kariega and Ksh. 11,000 from Daniel Miriti through the supervisor, Wilson Maina.
4) Rangechem, the claimant collected money purporting to be an entertainment allowance for the organisation, yet the organisation confirmed there was no meeting.
5) On 19 September 2018, the claimant received money from his junior staff, Gidraf Edwin Kariuki, for a CME at Outspan, which the operations director had already allocated in the budget. He also asked Daniel Miriti for money, and he paid Ksh. 8,790, which was not reimbursed.
6) CBK, the operations director had allocated a budget for this, yet the claimant went ahead and collected money from the medical representative, Rachael Wanjiku.
On these allegations, the claimant was directed to respond by 26 November 2018.
As this was pending, the claimant initiated a WhatsApp group “court case”. In evidence, the claimant admitted to forming this group, including his workmates. What was the purpose?
Morning, you agreed to be used by people who wanted a position. You recorded statements against me, and none of the old team members did. Please be prepared to substantiate your statements in court; this amounts to defamation. NB, Ida, Kariuki, Miriti, and Edwin didn’t make any statements, so I can’t take them to court since I have no evidence; all they said was verbal. Harley’s Limited, by playing safe, released your statements to me.
On this basis, a second notice to show cause was issued, dated 28 November 2018. The claimant was directed to respond by 1 December 2018.
The claimant provided an undated response to the notices to show cause. He denied all allegations and reiterated his complaint that the respondent wanted to terminate his employment. He stated that the employees in his team were coerced to make the statements they did with regard to harassment and use of abusive language. He said these were meant to assassinate his character and were therefore unjustified.
The claimant admitted setting up the WhatsApp group. He justified this by saying he had been removed from the office group and wanted to seek justice for the defamatory matters the respondent instigated.
Some of the respondent's employees filed a complaint. This included James Radolo. He complained that the claimant added him to a WhatsApp group on 24 November 2018. He was threatened with legal action, together with other colleagues, for making complaints against the claimant to the respondent. His complaint was about harassment and the use of abusive language by the claimant against him.
Maureen Muriithi also filed a complaint. She too was added to the WhatsApp group and threatened for making a complaint to the respondent against the claimant.
Hilda Kima, Grace Njenga, and Flavia also filed complaints.
The claimant's admission that he initiated the WhatsApp group and used threatening language toward fellow employees placed the respondent, as the employer, in a precarious position. As the employer, once the complaints were received from the various employees, they had a legitimate expectation of protection.
In Kaudo v DFG Kenya Limited t/a DFG Africa & another [2026] KEELRC 178 (KLR), the court, in addressing a case of sexual harassment at work, outlined the attendant principles and held that once an employer receives a complaint of harassment or sexual harassment by an employee while on the shop floor, it must discharge its obligations on the matter by ensuring that it has a clear policy against sexual harassment. It further ensures that the policy is enforced against the officer who sexually harassed the employee in terms of section 6 of the Act.
The court further emphasised that the affected employee has a right to pursue the offending employee directly for compensation. Where the employer fails to discharge its protection duties, a claim may also arise. The employer's only protection is to deal with any such complaint firmly and decisively.
In AWK v Bureau Veritas Kenya Limited [2025] KEELRC 3622 (KLR), the court held that Section 6 of the Act outlaws any form of harassment at the workplace. It is harassment where an employee's rights at work are violated by a co-worker when:
(a) directly or indirectly requests that employee for sexual intercourse, sexual contact or any other form of sexual activity that contains an implied or express—
(i) promise of preferential treatment in employment;
(ii) threat of detrimental treatment in employment; or(iii)threat about the present or future employment status of the employee;
(b) uses language whether written or spoken of a sexual nature; …
So serious is a case of alleged sexual harassment that the burden of proof shifts from the employer to the person alleged to have committed such acts. In Osok v Parliamentary Service Commission & another [2024] KEELRC 582 (KLR), the court held that bullying and harassment at work are acts of gross misconduct and specifically outlawed under section 6 of the Act.
In the case of P O v Board of Trustees, A F & 2 others [2014] KEELRC 623 (KLR), the court defined harassment at the workplace and held that:
[harassment at work is] the most prevalent human rights violation in the world. Of the varied ways in which sex discrimination manifests itself across the globe, such violence is exceptionally dehumanising, pervasive and oppressive. No other form of sex discrimination violates so many fundamental human rights as articulated in the 1948 United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
This is aptly captured in AWK v Bureau Veritas Kenya Limited [2025] KEELRC 3622 (KLR), where the court, in addressing a case of sexual harassment at the workplace, held:
There can be no doubt that harassment of any form at the workplace is a heinous and horrendous conduct since it undermines the dignity of an employee and the values enshrined in our Constitution under Article 41 of the Constitution and the Employment Act section 6. At the workplace, the employer should ensure that all employees are protected and secured from any form of harassment by fellow employees. This can be through workplace policies and training. Once such conduct is detected, cautionary measures or immediate action should be taken.
Although it is practically impossible for an employer to ensure, with certainty, that employees do not contravene section 6 of the Act, once an incident of harassment is reported, it should be addressed firmly and immediately. This builds employees' confidence that the working environment is safe and conducive.
In this case, management summoned the claimant about his conduct after receiving reports of harassment of colleagues. Instead of stopping, he escalated the harassment by opening a WhatsApp group to intimidate his workmates further. This was gross abdication of duty.
On his admission of setting up the WhatsApp group and sending threatening messages, the respondent should have sanctioned the claimant accordingly. In Shimanyula v Kenya Industrial Estates Ltd [2026] KEELRC 2411 (KLR), the court held that once an employee admits to misconduct, it is unnecessary to invite him to a disciplinary hearing. In Ongoro v SGA Guarding Ltd & another [2026] KEELRC 2403 (KLR), the employee attended a disciplinary hearing, admitted to the accusation of theft, and pleaded for leniency.
An admission constitutes direct and sufficient evidence upon which the respondent was entitled to form a reasonable belief that the misconduct had occurred. The admission in court further compounds the claimant's gross misconduct.
However, believing the claimant should be afforded due process, the respondent invited him to a disciplinary hearing. He was heard, and his response was found unsatisfactory.
The termination of employment for gross misconduct is hereby found justified and warranted. There were reasonable and valid grounds that justified the decision for summary dismissal under section 44 of the Act.
The claimant is not entitled to notice pay or compensation.
On whether the respondent defamed the claimant, the case is that on 14 December 2018, the respondent published in the Daily Nation newspaper a warning to members of the public not to deal with him. The case is that this was defamatory, malicious and meant to harm and injure his reputation.
Employment terminated through notice dated 8 December 2018. This fact is admitted.
Upon cessation of employment, the respondent was justified in protecting its business by alerting members of the public not to deal with the claimant as its employee. There was a justification.
The claimant does not deny publishing various matters with the respondent's clients and suppliers, urging them not to deal with the respondent. The response has outlined the letter written to some suppliers and clients, including communication on 5 December 2018, in which the claimant, while in his employment, wrote to its clients warning:
I wish to let you know that I am no longer working for Harleys. A difference arose between Nishil and me because of my close relationship with Vitabiotics and how I
dedicated my time to grow VB sales in Kenya and Tanzania.
Going forward, it will be extremely hard for Harleys to sell GBP 500,000 per year for your product. Competing brands will overtake your brand like yesterday.
This is gross misconduct as defined under section 44(4) of the Act. Where the employee conducts himself in a manner detrimental to the employer, causes loss of business, and makes representations that amount to criminal conduct, summary dismissal is justified.
The resulting notice, dated 14 December 2018, warning members of the public not to deal with the claimant as the respondent's employee, was justified.
The publication contains no defamatory matter.
The respondent filed a counterclaim but has not claimed or quantified economic sabotage arising from the claimant's conduct.
The claimant claimed that, during his employment, he secured a loan with the respondent and purchased motor vehicle KCD 929K. He paid Ksh. 1,400,000, and the respondent repossessed the vehicle. He claims a refund of what was paid.
There is a counterclaim on the loan balance of Ksh. 470,000, with interest, because the claimant admitted to securing a loan facility to purchase vehicle KCD 929K but failed to pay the full amount. He attempted to transfer the vehicle to a third party while the respondent held the logbook. The matter was reported to the police, resulting in a criminal case.
In a ruling delivered on 24 November 2022, the court addressed possession of motor vehicle KCD 929K, where the claimant alleged contempt of court and that the respondent’s officers had taken possession. The court held that the vehicle was in the claimant's custody and that the respondent had secured it for an unpaid loan. The vehicle was registered in the respondent's name. The claimant left the vehicle at Carlos Auto Spares without the registered owner's knowledge. The matter resulted in Nairobi Criminal Case No. E556 of 2022.
In evidence, the claimant testified that he no longer wants the vehicle. Not wanting the vehicle does not relieve the claimant of the duty to repay his loan facility to the respondent. His effort to alienate the vehicle after employment itself shows he had no intention of repaying the work benefit. Such practice is not allowed under section 19(1) (h) of the Act:
(h) an amount due and payable by the employee under and in accordance with the terms of an agreement in writing, by way of repayment or part repayment of a loan of money made to him by the employer, not exceeding fifty per cent of the wages payable to that employee after the deduction of all such other amounts as may be due from him under this section;
At the end of employment, the total due loan facility becomes due. The only exception is where employment is terminated unfairly. Such exception does not apply in this case.
Did he pay the loan amount that he had secured for the vehicle? The balance of Ksh. 470,000 is due and owing to the respondent with interest from the date due at the end of employment on 8 December 2018 until payment in full.
On the claim for unpaid working days, the respondent admitted that for days actually worked, the claimant is entitled to his pay subject to clearance and return of company property. This shall be processed accordingly in terms of section 18(4) and (5) of the Act and paid.
On the claim for accumulated leave days, as correctly submitted by the respondent, under section 28(4) of the Act, accrued leave being regulated in law, for the period claimed, only 32 days are due at Ksh. 352,000, less what the claimant owes the respondent under the unpaid loan facility.
On the claim for severance pay and gratuity, this was not a redundancy claim, and the contract of employment did not provide a gratuity benefit. The claimant was registered with the NSSF.
On the claim for issuance of a certificate of service, the claimant must clear the outstanding dues in the loan facility and attend the shop floor to obtain the certificate.
On costs, under section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, the court awards costs at its discretion. Where costs are awarded, these must be justified. The claim is found to be without merit, and the respondent is justified in seeking costs.
The counterclaim is with merit, and the costs award is justified.
Accordingly, the claim is without merit and is hereby dismissed with the following orders:
1. Payment of Ksh. 352,000 in leave pay and accrued and unpaid days worked, to be paid less what the claimant owes the respondent.
2. Costs to the respondent.
The counterclaim is allowed;
3. The balance of Ksh. 470,000 is due and owing to the respondent with interest from the date due at the end of employment on 8 December 2018 until payment in full.
4. The respondent is awarded costs of the counterclaim.
Delivered in open court this 9th day of October 2026
M. MBARŨ
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Court Assistant: Kemboi
……………………………………………… and …………………………………..………