REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E674 OF 2022
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)
JAMES MACHEO ONSARIGO.........................................CLAIMANT
VS
OFFICE OF THE AUDITOR GENERAL........................RESPONDENT
RULING
Introduction
1 Judgment in this matter was delivered on 25th February 2025, wherein the Court found the Claimant's dismissal unfair and awarded him 1 month's salary in lieu of notice at Kshs. 220,000, 6 months' salary as compensation for the unfair termination at Kshs. 1,320,000, his terminal dues as per the employment contract, and costs of the suit plus interest at court rates with effect from the date of judgment. A decree to that effect was issued on 9th April 2025.
2 Vide an order dated 29th July 2026, this Court directed payments and ordered the parties to compute the amounts payable. The Claimant filed written submissions dated 6th September 2026, while the Respondent filed a computation of award dated 27th July 2026 and an affidavit sworn by Collins Kiptoo on 30th September 2026.
Respondent's Case
3 The Respondent's affidavit is sworn by Collins Kiptoo, a Manager in its Human Resources Directorate, in compliance with the Court's direction on computation and in opposition to the Claimant's submissions.
4 It is the Respondent's case that upon service of the decree, it became apparent that the salary of Kshs. 220,000 awarded was erroneous and inconsistent with the remuneration records it holds, thereby rendering the decree incapable of being settled.
5 The Respondent avers that by a memo dated 4th April 2025, its Director of Human Resources and Administration stated that the Claimant's last gross salary was Kshs. 101,588, paid in November 2013, and not Kshs. 220,000 as claimed and awarded.
6 The Respondent avers that the Claimant was last paid in November 2013, his application for study leave having been accepted by a letter dated 26th August 2013. It is stated that the said letter, which formed part of the trial record, notified him that he would not be entitled to any salary, allowances or benefits during the 25 months of his study leave.
7 It is the Respondent's further case that the Claimant, in his Statement of Claim dated 14th September 2022, relied on a payslip for December 2012 which included basic salary arrears, resulting in a gross sum of Kshs. 220,916, which he averred to be his last salary.
8 The Respondent states that in light of the discovery of this new and important evidence, it filed a Notice of Motion dated 15th July 2026 seeking review of the judgment, which is pending hearing and determination. The application seeks to vary the award of 1 month's salary in lieu of notice from Kshs. 220,000 to Kshs. 101,588, and consequently to amend the decretal sum from Kshs. 1,540,000 to Kshs. 711,116.
9 In its computation dated 27th July 2026, the Respondent tabulated the award as Kshs. 101,588 in lieu of notice, Kshs. 609,528 as compensation, Kshs. 3,136,530 as terminal benefits including pension, and Kshs. 374,925 as costs, making a total of Kshs. 4,222,571. It indicated that the pension benefits would be subject to confirmation by the National Treasury.
10 In the affidavit sworn on 30th September 2026, the Respondent computes the award as Kshs. 101,588 in lieu of notice, Kshs. 609,528 as compensation, Kshs. 2,009,592 as terminal benefits including the pension lump sum, and Kshs. 374,925 as costs, making a total of Kshs. 3,095,633.
11 The Respondent avers that the terminal benefits are computed as guided by the National Treasury pension formula, set out in a memo dated 29th September 2026 from its Director of Human Resources. Applying 247 months worked and a last salary of £39,052.80 per annum, divided by 480, it arrives at a lump sum pension of Kshs. 2,009,592 and a monthly pension of Kshs. 25,119.90.
12 It is the Respondent's case that the Claimant's computation is manifestly wrong. It avers that the PSSS is not applicable to the Claimant, as its pension scheme is under the National Treasury.
13 It further avers that the rates of 7.5% and 15% are incorrect, as the Claimant did not contribute to his pension, the Respondent having operated a defined benefit scheme.
14 The Respondent further avers that the Claimant was on unpaid study leave, that his last payslip was in November 2013, and that any calculation of pension is premised on the duration when monthly salary is paid.
15 It states that by a letter dated 24th March 2022, it terminated the Claimant's employment with effect from 1st October 2016, and that his last monthly salary of Kshs. 101,588 is the sum applicable in computing pension.
16 The Respondent thus prays that the Court gives directions for the hearing and determination of the Notice of Motion application dated 15th July 2026 and allows the computation as set out by it.
Claimant's Submissions
17 The Claimant submitted that following delivery of the judgment and service of the Notice of Entry of Judgment upon the Respondent, the matter proceeded before the taxing officer, whose ruling was delivered on 6th November 2025. He submitted that his monthly salary of Kshs. 220,000 was never challenged throughout the proceedings, including during taxation of the party and party Bill of Costs.
18 The Claimant submitted that the Respondent was directed to serve him and to file documents that would assist the Court in computing his terminal benefits. It is his case that the Respondent instead chose to file an application dated 15th July 2026. He contends that although the Court still directed the Respondent to comply and file the requisite documents, none had been filed as at the date of his submissions.
19 He submitted that the Respondent is not ready to provide the Court with the said documents, and that in the circumstances he is left with the only option of applying the Public Service Superannuation Scheme (PSSS) in computing his terminal benefits.
20 On that basis, the Claimant computes the employee's contribution at 7.5% of Kshs. 220,000, being Kshs. 16,500, and the employer's contribution at 15%, being Kshs. 33,000, making a total monthly contribution of Kshs. 49,500.
21 He submitted that he was employed in 1996 and unfairly terminated on 24th March 2022, having served the Respondent for 26 years. He therefore computes the total contribution for 312 months at Kshs. 15,444,000.
22 It is the Claimant’s submission that his total award is Kshs. 1,540,000 together with Kshs. 15,444,000, making Kshs. 16,984,000, plus costs and interest with effect from 25th February 2025. He thus urges the Court to so find.
23 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. From the submissions herein, the issue is computation of the award given by court in its judgment. The main point of contention is what was the claimants salary and which could aid the parties in computing what is payable to the claimant.
24 In this court’s judgment the court found the claimants last salary as kshs 220,000 which the respondents are disputing as being kshs 101,585/-. The claimant’s gross salary as at the time of proceedings for study leave was kshs 220,000/-. This is not disputed. The respondents however want his dues to be calculated from his basic salary excluding allowance.
25 Under section 49 (1) (c) of the Employment Act, 2007 any payment in regard to dues payable for wrongful termination or dismissal is usually paid based on gross amount. Section 50 of the Employment Act 2007 states as follows:
In determining a complaint or suit under this Act involving wrongful dismissal or unfair termination of the employment of an employee, the Industrial Court shall be guided by the provisions of section 49.
26 This being the position of the law the submissions by the respondents that the award of the claimant be based on basic pay is erroneous and the calculation should be based on his gross pay save for pension which is calculated differently.
27 In the circumstances, I do confirm that the claimant is entitled to the following dues as stated in this court’s judgment.
(1) 1 month’s pay in lieu of notice = kshs 220,000/-.
(2) 6 months salary as compensation for unlawful termination = 6x220,000 = Kshs 1,320,000/-.
(3) Terminal dues to be calculated under the pension scheme and to be pursued under the said scheme.
(4) Costs and interest with effect from 25/2/2025. Costs have already been taxed at kshs 374,925/-.
(5) Costs of this application are in the cause.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 12th Day of October 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE