Background
Whether the Respondent as named is a legal entity with capacity to be sued.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Whether the Respondent as named is a legal entity with capacity to be sued.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E086 OF 2022
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
KENYA UNION OF DOMESTIC, HOTELS, EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS, HOSPITALS AND ALLIED WORKERS (KUDHEIHA WORKERS) …………………………………………………………………………...……… CLAIMANT
VERSUS
KITUI TEACHERS TRAINING COLLEGE …………………………… RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
This matter was brought to court by way of a Memorandum of Claim dated 8th February, 2022 and filed on 10th instant. The issue in dispute is therein cited as:
Refusal by the Board of Governors to negotiate conclude and sign a collective contrary to Section 57 of the Labour relation Act, 2007 and Article 41(5) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
The Respondent in a Memorandum of Response dated 20th February, 2025 denies the claim and prays that it be dismissed with costs.
The Claimant in a Reply to Memorandum of Response dated 20th March, 2025 reiterates the claim and prays that the Respondents defence and assertions be considered a failure and dismissed in entirety.
The Claimant’s case is that it is a trade union registered under the Labour Relations Act, 2007 with the mandate to represent, among others, non-teaching employees of the Respondent. It pleads that the Respondent is a tertiary institution established under the Basic Education Act, 2013 whose Board of Governors is a corporate body with the power to sue and be sued. It avers that they and the Respondent signed a Recognition Agreement on or about 12th October, 2017 pursuant to Section 57 of the Labour Relations Act, 2007. It thereafter presented a Collective Bargaining Agreement proposal under cover of a letter dated 21st May, 2018.
The Claimant contends that despite repeated efforts the Respondent frustrated the negotiation process, and that having reported a trade dispute to the Cabinet Secretary on 24th June, 2019 a conciliator was appointed who issued a Certificate of Non-Resolution on 18th November, 2021. The Claimant prays for orders compelling the Respondent to negotiate, conclude, sign and forward a Collective Bargaining Agreement to this court for registration within 30 days of judgment as well as with costs of the claim.
The Respondent’s case, filed under protest, is a denial of each allegation in the Memorandum of Claim save as expressly admitted and also a denial that any valid Recognition Agreement exists. Its primary objection, developed in its written submissions, is that as a learning institution established under the Basic Education Act, 2013 and it does not in itself possess the legal capacity to sue or be sued, that capacity vesting in its Board of Management.
The issues for determination therefore are;
1. Whether the Respondent as named is a legal entity with capacity to be sued.
2. If so, whether the Claimant has established a valid Recognition Agreement entitling it to compel negotiations.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the Respondent as named, “Kitui Teachers Training College,” is a legal entity with capacity to be sued. Institutions of the character of the Respondent, established under the Basic Education (Board of Management) framework and now the Basic Education Act, 2013, do not as a rule possess legal personality distinct from their constituting instrument. That personality, where it exists, vests in the Board of Management, not in the institution’s name simpliciter. This is precisely the position the Claimant itself pleads in its own Memorandum of Claim, where the Respondent is described as a tertiary institution established under the Basic Education Act, 2013 whose Board of Governors is a corporate body with the power to sue and be sued. Notwithstanding this pleaded position, the suit as drawn names the Respondent as “Kitui Teachers Training College” and not as its Board of Management.
The Respondent’s authority most directly in point is Kenya Union of Domestic, Hotels, Educational Institutions and Hospitals Workers (KUDHEIHA) v Kaplong Mission Hospital (Board of Management) & Another [2023] KEELRC 2349 (KLR), a ruling of this court involving the same claimant union advancing the same category of claim, which found that a suit against a respondent named simpliciter rather than through its Board of Management was incompetent. This court finds that decision squarely applicable to the present suit. The authority of Kenya Union of Employees of Voluntary and Charitable Organisations (KUEVACO) v Board of Governors & Maina Wanjigi Secondary School, Cause No. 744 of 2013 [2015] eKLR, also relied upon by the Respondent, is of more limited assistance.
As consistently applied in later decisions of this court, that decision turned on the claimant union’s own want of standing for want of a recognition agreement, a question distinct from whether the named respondent possessed the capacity to be sued. I do not find it authority for the broader proposition for which the Respondent cites it. The finding on this issue rests on the Kaplong Mission Hospital decision and on the Claimant’s own pleaded admission.
It is further noteworthy that the Respondent, while flagging this objection in its Memorandum of Response, never filed any formal application and instead proceeded to engage with the merits of the dispute. Capacity to be sued, however, is not a mere procedural irregularity that a respondent’s conduct can cure. It is trite law that a suit against a party lacking capacity is incompetent regardless of the stage at which the defect is raised.
This court finds that the Respondent as named does not possess the legal capacity to be sued in this suit. This finding is dispositive. The Board of Management, in which capacity vests, was never joined, has not been served, and has had no opportunity to be heard. I accordingly make no finding on the validity of the Recognition Agreement, on any duty to conclude a Collective Bargaining Agreement, or on any other matter going to the substance of the dispute, all of which remain open for determination in any suit properly constituted against the Board of Management. The 2nd issue accordingly does not arise.
On costs, the suit has had an unusual history. It lay dormant for three years before any response was filed. The Respondent intimated but never formally pursued its objection on the basis of capacity to be sued. This objection was only raised in their written submissions filed more than three years after institution and now principally disposes off the matter. In these circumstances, it is not opportune to make an order for costs in favour of either party.
In the result, I am inclined to strike out the suit and order as follows:
i) The suit herein, as constituted against “Kitui Teachers Training College,” is struck out for want of legal capacity of the named Respondent to be sued.
ii) This order is made without prejudice to the Claimant’s right to institute fresh proceedings against the proper party, being the Board of Management, Kitui Teachers Training College.
iii) Each party shall bear its own costs of the claim.
Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Charles N. Mbau for the Claimant Union.
2. Mrs. Mutua instructed by M. M. Kimuli & Co. Advocates for the Respondent.