Background
A declaration that the termination of employment of the Claimant was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Claim allowed in part. The court declined the unpursued and unproved declaration that termination was wrongful, unfair and unlawful. It ordered the Respondent to pay Kshs. 3,598,634.24 severance for service from 12 October 1988 to 1 October 2000, with interest at court rates from judgment until full payment, and to bear costs.
In the result, I am inclined to allow the claim in part and order as follows:
Conclusion and orders →
i) The prayer for a declaration that the termination was wrongful, unfair and unlawful is declined, the same not having been pursued or established.
Passage 27 →
ii) The Respondent shall pay to the Claimant severance pay in the sum of Kshs. 3,598,634.24 in respect of the period between 12th October, 1988 and 1st October, 2000.
Passage 28 →
Held. Decided for the Claimant. He was entitled to severance pay for the unionisable-service period, notwithstanding that gratuity had already been paid for that period. The Respondent was ordered to pay Kshs. 3,598,634.24.
Ratio. Under section 40(1)(g) of the Employment Act, redundancy severance is payable for each completed year of service and does not distinguish by cadre, grade, or seniority. Gratuity and redundancy severance arise from different legal sources and serve different purposes; they are not mutually exclusive. The Respondent's unqualified notices promising 30 days' severance for every completed year, and the CBA provision making severance additional to gratuity, reinforced entitlement for the full period.
Issue
1. Whether the Claimant is entitled to severance pay for the period he served under the Union between 12th October, 1988 and 1st October, 2000.
Passage 21 →
Held
The Respondent’s contention that payment of severance pay for the period 1988 to 2000, in addition to the gratuity already paid, would amount to double compensation is not established in law. The Claimant has established on a balance of probabilities that he is entitled to severance pay for that period in the sum of Kshs. 3,598,634.24.
Passage 24 →
ii) The Respondent shall pay to the Claimant severance pay in the sum of Kshs. 3,598,634.24 in respect of the period between 12th October, 1988 and 1st October, 2000.
Passage 28 →
Ratio
The sole issue for determination is whether the Claimant is entitled to severance pay for the period he served under the Union. Section 40(1)(g) of the Employment Act provides that an employer shall not terminate a contract of service on account of redundancy unless it has paid to an employee declared redundant severance pay at the rate of not less than fifteen days’ pay for each completed year of service. The provision draws no distinction between an employee’s cadre, grade or level of seniority. Its language, referring simply to “each completed year of service,” contemplates the entirety of an employee’s tenure.
Court’s reasoning →
The Respondent’s Notice of 7th August, 2019 and Notice of Termination of 19th September 2019 promised affected staff severance pay of thirty days for every completed year of service, without qualification as to cadre. The distinction between gratuity and severance pay is well settled. In Pathfinder International Kenya Limited v Stephen Ndegwa Mwangi [2019] KECA 759 (KLR), the Court of Appeal approved and applied the position that gratuity is a gratuitous payment made by an employer in appreciation of service, whereas severance pay is a distinct entitlement payable only under Section 40(1)(g) where an employee is terminated on account of redundancy. The two benefits arise from different legal sources, serve different purposes, and are not mutually exclusive. The CBA produced by the Claimant at Clause 22(f)(iv) likewise entitles a redundant employee to “severance pay of twenty-five days per year of service” as an addition to, not a substitute for, gratuity. The evidence of the Claimant’s witness, Elijah Mukise, that he was paid both gratuity and severance pay in full upon his own redundancy was not seriously challenged.
Passage 23 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
A declaration that the termination of employment of the Claimant was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.
Paragraph 1 →Whether Harun Kiptarus Tanui was entitled to severance pay for his unionisable service between 12 October 1988 and 1 October 2000, despite having received gratuity for that period and later being declared redundant while in management.
The claimant was employed as a Sample Man on 12 October 1988 under a collective bargaining agreement between the respondent and the Kenya Chemical and Allied Workers Union. He was promoted to Quarry Foreman, a non-unionisable management role, on 1 October…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. 62 OF 2023
(Before D. K. N. Marete.)
HARUN KIPTARUS TANUI ………………………………………………… CLAIMANT
VERSUS
EAST AFRICAN PORTLAND CEMENT PLC ………………………… RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
This matter came to court by way of a Statement of Claim dated 8th April, 2021. It does not disclose any issue in dispute on its face.
The Respondent in a Response to Memorandum of claim dated 4th June, 2021 later amended on 24th June, 2021 denies liability and prays that the claim be dismissed with costs.
The Claimant’s case is that he was employed by the Respondent as a Sample Man by a letter dated 12th October, 1988. His terms of service during this period were governed by the Collective Bargaining Agreement between the Respondent and the Kenya Chemical and Allied Workers Union, of which the Claimant was a member. On 1st October, 2000 he was promoted to the position of Quarry Foreman, a non-unionisable management position. He rose through the ranks to the position of Manager of Quarries and served in that capacity until 19th September, 2019 when his employment was terminated on account of redundancy.
Prior to the termination, the Respondent issued a Notice on the Intended Company Restructuring and Staff Rationalization dated 7th August, 2019 and a Notice of Termination dated 19th September 2019. Both notices indicated that affected employees would receive severance pay of thirty days for every completed year of service. When the Claimant’s terminal dues were computed and paid, the Respondent paid severance pay only in respect of the 19.06 years he served under the management cadre, from 1st October 2000 to 19th September 2019. No severance pay was paid in respect of the period between 12th October 1988 and 1st October 2000, when the Claimant served under the Union.
She prays thus;
1. A declaration that the termination of employment of the Claimant was wrongful, unfair and unlawful.
2. Ksh. 3,598,634.24 being severance pay for the period served between October 1988 to December 2000.
3. Interest accrued on prayer (3), above
4. Cost of the suit, and
5. Any other relief deemed reasonable in the circumstance of this case.
The Respondent’s case is that for the period 1988 to 2000 the Claimant was entitled to and was paid gratuity in accordance with the negotiated agreement between the Respondent and the Kenya Chemical and Allied Workers Union and the Respondent’s Human Resource Manual. The Respondent’s witness testified that the Claimant’s terminal dues comprised notice pay, unutilised leave, severance pay for the management period, gratuity for the union period and interest on gratuity amounting to some fifteen times the gratuity sum itself. The Respondent contends that a further claim for severance pay in respect of the same period would amount to double compensation for the same years of service. The Respondent further distinguished the Claimant’s circumstances from those of the Claimant’s witness, Elijah Mukise, contending that Mukise remained in a unionisable position throughout his employment whereas the Claimant had exited the unionisable cadre upon promotion.
The issue for determination therefore is;
1. Whether the Claimant is entitled to severance pay for the period he served under the Union between 12th October, 1988 and 1st October, 2000.
The sole issue for determination is whether the Claimant is entitled to severance pay for the period he served under the Union. Section 40(1)(g) of the Employment Act provides that an employer shall not terminate a contract of service on account of redundancy unless it has paid to an employee declared redundant severance pay at the rate of not less than fifteen days’ pay for each completed year of service. The provision draws no distinction between an employee’s cadre, grade or level of seniority. Its language, referring simply to “each completed year of service,” contemplates the entirety of an employee’s tenure.
The Respondent’s Notice of 7th August, 2019 and Notice of Termination of 19th September 2019 promised affected staff severance pay of thirty days for every completed year of service, without qualification as to cadre. The distinction between gratuity and severance pay is well settled. In Pathfinder International Kenya Limited v Stephen Ndegwa Mwangi [2019] KECA 759 (KLR), the Court of Appeal approved and applied the position that gratuity is a gratuitous payment made by an employer in appreciation of service, whereas severance pay is a distinct entitlement payable only under Section 40(1)(g) where an employee is terminated on account of redundancy. The two benefits arise from different legal sources, serve different purposes, and are not mutually exclusive. The CBA produced by the Claimant at Clause 22(f)(iv) likewise entitles a redundant employee to “severance pay of twenty-five days per year of service” as an addition to, not a substitute for, gratuity. The evidence of the Claimant’s witness, Elijah Mukise, that he was paid both gratuity and severance pay in full upon his own redundancy was not seriously challenged.
The Respondent’s contention that payment of severance pay for the period 1988 to 2000, in addition to the gratuity already paid, would amount to double compensation is not established in law. The Claimant has established on a balance of probabilities that he is entitled to severance pay for that period in the sum of Kshs. 3,598,634.24.
The prayer for a declaration that the termination was wrongful, unfair and unlawful was not pursued, argued or supported by evidence in the Claimant’s submissions, which confined the dispute entirely to the question of severance pay. That prayer, not having been established, cannot be granted.
In the result, I am inclined to allow the claim in part and order as follows:
i) The prayer for a declaration that the termination was wrongful, unfair and unlawful is declined, the same not having been pursued or established.
ii) The Respondent shall pay to the Claimant severance pay in the sum of Kshs. 3,598,634.24 in respect of the period between 12th October, 1988 and 1st October, 2000.
iii) The said sum shall attract interest at court rates from the date of this judgment until payment in full.
iv) The costs of this cause shall be borne by the Respondent.
Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
Miss Njiru instructed by Mulondo & Company Advocates LLP for the Claimant.
Miss Nkatha instructed by Mwaniki Gachoka & Company Advocates for the Respondent.