Land law

Adhi & another v Portofino Properties Ltd & another [2026] KEELC 7485 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case E087 of 2026
Judgment date
5 November 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Court declined the interlocutory injunction in the terms sought but granted a preservatory status quo order pending trial: the 2nd Defendant remains in possession; the existing register, title and ownership position cannot be altered by transfer, charge, lease, subdivision, alienation, disposition or encumbrance; and no demolition or material structural alteration or development may occur. The orders do not determine either sale agreement, ownership, or contractual rights. Costs are in the cause.

Supporting judgment passages

42. The Court therefore, declines to grant the interlocutory injunction in the terms sought. However, in the interests of justice and to preserve the subject matter of the suit, the Court orders that the Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2026 is disposed of in the following terms:

Paragraph 42 →

A. That the status quo prevailing as at the date of this ruling be maintained in respect of Maisonette No. 429, Five Star Estate Phase III, erected on L.R. No. 209/12221/244 pending hearing and final determination of this suit.

Passage 64 →

B. In respect of possession and occupation, the 2nd Defendant shall remain in possession and occupation of the suit property. There shall be no eviction, dispossession or interference with his existing possession pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

Passage 65 →
Issue 1whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for the grant of a temporary injunction pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

Held. The Applicants showed a contractual interest and a genuine dispute about the purported termination sufficient to warrant preservation of the property. However, the Court declined an interlocutory injunction in the terms sought because it would be prejudicial to disturb the 2nd Defendant's existing possession, while the competing contractual claims remain for trial. The validity of termination, ownership, and the parties' contractual rights were not determined.

Ratio. Interlocutory injunction requirements are sequential: a prima facie case is required first, followed by irreparable injury and, if necessary, balance of convenience. At this stage the Court must not finally determine contested contractual or ownership questions; it considers only whether an arguable right merits protection. Although further dealings could prejudice effective relief, preservation had to be balanced against the prejudice of disturbing the subsequent purchaser's existing possession.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

21. Having considered the application, affidavits and submissions, the issues for determination are: (i) whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for the grant of a temporary injunction pending the hearing and determination of the suit.; and (ii) whether the alternative prayer for maintenance of the status quo should be granted.

Paragraph 21 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

35. The Court is consequently not persuaded that the circumstances justify an order that would interfere with the 2nd Defendant’s existing possession. Equally, the Court does not consider it appropriate to permit further dealings with the suit property that may alter its ownership or legal status before the dispute is resolved. The Court must maintain a fair balance between preserving the subject matter of the suit and avoiding the grant of orders that would effectively determine substantive rights at an interlocutory stage.

Paragraph 35 →

42. The Court therefore, declines to grant the interlocutory injunction in the terms sought. However, in the interests of justice and to preserve the subject matter of the suit, the Court orders that the Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2026 is disposed of in the following terms:

Paragraph 42 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

26. At this interlocutory stage, the Court must avoid making final findings on contested contractual questions. The Court is not called upon to determine disputed questions of ownership or make definitive findings of fact. That is the province of the trial Court after hearing oral evidence and testing the evidence through cross-examination. The Court’s duty is merely to determine whether the Applicant has demonstrated an arguable right deserving protection pending trial.

Paragraph 26 →

30. The Court is, however, mindful that the Plaintiffs’ failure to pay the balance of the purchase price by the stipulated completion date is a significant consideration. The mere existence of an Agreement for Sale and payment of a deposit do not, without more, entitle a party to an interlocutory injunction. Nevertheless, the Plaintiffs have demonstrated a contractual interest in the suit property and raised a genuine dispute regarding the validity and effect of the purported termination. I am therefore satisfied that they have demonstrated a case warranting preservation of the subject matter of the suit.

Paragraph 30 →

33. The balance of convenience presents a more difficult question. The 2nd Defendant is said to have entered into a subsequent Agreement for Sale with the 1st Defendant, paid the entire purchase price and taken possession of the suit property. The Plaintiffs’ claim arises from an earlier transaction, the validity and continued effect of which remain contested. It would therefore be prejudicial to the 2nd Defendant, at this stage, to make orders that would remove him from possession or otherwise determine his rights before the dispute is heard and determined.

Paragraph 33 →
Issue 2whether the alternative prayer for maintenance of the status quo should be granted.

Held. Granted. Status quo as at the ruling is to be maintained pending trial: the 2nd Defendant remains in possession without eviction, dispossession or interference; the existing register is preserved and no transfer, charge, lease, subdivision, alienation, disposition or encumbrance may occur; and no demolition or material structural alteration or development may be undertaken. Costs of the application are in the cause.

Ratio. A status quo order is a preservatory case-management measure that maintains an identifiable existing factual position; it cannot create a new state of affairs, confer possession, determine proprietary rights, or grant substantive relief. This order preserved the subject matter while avoiding interference with the 2nd Defendant's existing possession and without deciding the merits.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

21. Having considered the application, affidavits and submissions, the issues for determination are: (i) whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for the grant of a temporary injunction pending the hearing and determination of the suit.; and (ii) whether the alternative prayer for maintenance of the status quo should be granted.

Paragraph 21 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

A. That the status quo prevailing as at the date of this ruling be maintained in respect of Maisonette No. 429, Five Star Estate Phase III, erected on L.R. No. 209/12221/244 pending hearing and final determination of this suit.

Passage 64 →

B. In respect of possession and occupation, the 2nd Defendant shall remain in possession and occupation of the suit property. There shall be no eviction, dispossession or interference with his existing possession pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

Passage 65 →

C. In respect of title and ownership, the existing state of the register shall be maintained. There shall be no transfer, charge, lease, subdivision, alienation or other disposition or encumbrance of the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

Passage 66 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

39. An order for the maintenance of the status quo is intended to preserve an existing and ascertainable state of affairs pending the determination of a dispute. It is not an instrument for creating a new state of affairs, conferring possession, determining disputed proprietary rights or granting substantive relief under the guise of preservation. The Court must, therefore, be satisfied that the factual position sought to be preserved can be identified with reasonable certainty.

Paragraph 39 →

40. Having considered the rival submissions and the circumstances of this case, the Court is persuaded that an order for maintenance of the status quo would be the most appropriate means of preserving the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit. Such an order would safeguard the subject matter of the dispute while avoiding interference with the 2nd Defendant’s existing possession.

Paragraph 40 →

41. In making this determination, the Court has taken into account that the 2nd Defendant is said to have paid the full purchase price and taken possession of the suit property. The Court considers it inappropriate, at this interlocutory stage, to make an order that would disturb his possession. At the same time, permitting further dealings with the property may prejudice the Plaintiffs’ claim and potentially compromise the effectiveness of the eventual determination of the suit.

Paragraph 41 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Plaintiffs/Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2026 seeks the following orders;

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the application, affidavits and submissions, the issues for determination are: (i) whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for the grant of a temporary injunction pending the hearing and determination of the suit.; and (ii) whether the alternative prayer for maintenance of the status quo should be granted.

Paragraph 21 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the applicants met the threshold for a temporary injunction pending trial concerning Maisonette No. 429 on L.R. No. 209/12221/244, and whether a status quo order should instead preserve the property. The ruling was interlocutory and did not determine…

Material facts

The applicants asserted that the 1st respondent agreed by a 16 May 2024 letter of offer and a 29 November 2024 sale agreement to sell them the maisonette for KShs. 38,737,500. They paid KShs. 10,100,000, while the KShs. 28,637,500 balance was due by 31…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

MILIMANI LAW COURTS

ELC CASE NO. E087 OF 2026

TARRY ABDUB ADHI ........................................ 1ST PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT

FARIHIYA ALI SHARIFF ................................. 2ND PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT VERSUS

PORTOFINO PROPERTIES

LIMITED…………………….………………..1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

MAHIR ALI SHARIF....................................... 2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

RULING

1. The Plaintiffs/Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2026 seeks the following orders;

1) Spent

2) Spent

3) That pending the hearing and determination of this suit, this Honourable court be pleased to issue a temporary injuction restraining the defendant whether by itself, its servants, agents or otherwise howsoever from selling, transferring, charging, leasing or otherwise disposing of the property known as Maisonette No. 429 erected on L.R No. 209/12221/244

4) Spent and

5) THAT the costs of the application be provided for.

2. The suit herein was initially filed against the 1st Defendant. The 2nd Defendant was subsequently joined to the proceedings pursuant to the consent order of 12th May 2026, following the 1st Defendant’s disclosure that it had entered into a subsequent agreement for sale with the 2nd Defendant dated 24th February 2026 in respect of the suit property. The Court gave further orders, inter alia, that the current status quo on the suit property be maintained pending inter parties hearing. Subsequently, the Plaintiff filed an amended plaint dated 16th May 2026.

3. The application is supported by the affidavit of 1st Applicant sworn on 6th March 2026 and a further affidavit sworn on 2nd April 2026. The Applicants’ case is that, by a Letter of Offer dated 16th May 2024 and an Agreement for Sale dated 29th November 2024, the 1st Defendant agreed to sell the suit property to them for KShs. 38,737,500. They state that they paid KShs. 100,000 as a reservation fee and a further KShs. 10,000,000 on 27 June 2024, making a total payment of KShs. 10,100,000. Under clause 4.2 of the Agreement for Sale, the balance of KShs. 28,637,500 was payable by 31st December 2024.

4. The Applicants contend that, although they signed and returned the Agreement for Sale to the Advocate for the 1st Defendant in November 2024, the fully executed and stamped counterpart was not supplied to their advocates until 8th April 2025. They challenge the 1st Defendant’s purported termination of the agreement by a letter dated 1st April 2025, arguing that no valid completion notice was served and that the termination was premature. They further rely on the 1st Defendant’s subsequent forwarding of the executed agreement and demand for the balance, as well as correspondence of 17th April 2025, as conduct inconsistent with an effective termination. They maintain that they remain ready and willing to complete, subject to being provided with the completion documents for inspection.

5. The Applicants state that the 1st Defendant has since contracted to sell the property to the 2nd Defendant, thereby threatening the contractual and equitable interest they claim under the earlier agreement. They submit that the validity of the termination and the subsequent sale are disputed matters that should be determined at trial, and that the property ought to be preserved in the meantime.

6. The Applicants, for their part, maintain that the purported termination was invalid and that no refund of the sums paid has been made

The 1st Defendant’s Replying Affidavit

7. The 1st Defendant opposes the application and filed a replying affidavit by Janakan Murugesan sworn on 24th March 2026. It maintains that the Applicants failed to pay the balance of the purchase price by the agreed completion date despite repeated reminders and that a completion notice was issued on 1st April 2025 in accordance with clause 10 of the Agreement for Sale. It relies on the notice and alleged proof of service by registered post, and on correspondence showing that the Applicants’ advocates responded in April 2025. The 1st Defendant contends that the Applicants did not pay the balance or provide proof of payment after receiving the executed counterpart of the sale agreement and further demands, and that the agreement was consequently rescinded.

8. The 1st Defendant further states that it entered into a subsequent agreement for sale with the 2nd Defendant on 24th February 2026. It argues that the Applicants have not established an enforceable right capable of protection by injunction, that any loss is compensable in damages, and that the balance of convenience does not favour the Applicants. It also relies on clause 20 of the earlier agreement, claiming that the suit herein is premature since the clause provides for good-faith negotiations before court proceedings were instituted.

The Applicants’ Submissions

9. The Plaintiffs seek a temporary injunction restraining the Defendants from selling, transferring, charging, leasing or otherwise dealing with Maisonette No. 429 pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

10. The Plaintiffs contend that they have established a prima facie case, having entered into a Sale Agreement dated 29th November 2024 and paid KShs. 10.1 million towards the purchase price. They argue that the 1st Defendant’s purported termination of the agreement was irregular and that their contractual and equitable interests remain valid.

11. The Plaintiffs submit that they stand to suffer irreparable harm if the property is transferred to the 2nd Defendant, as this would defeat their claim for specific performance and render the suit nugatory. They maintain that damages would not be an adequate remedy.

12. The Plaintiffs further argue that the balance of convenience favours preservation of the property, as the Defendants would suffer no significant prejudice, whereas the Plaintiffs risk losing the property before the dispute is determined.

13. The Applicants rely on the cases of Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] Eklr; 2. Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR ;

14. Accordingly, the Plaintiffs urge the Court to grant the temporary injunction sought or, alternatively, issue orders maintaining the status quo pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

The 1st Respondent’s Submissions

15. The 1st Defendant contends that the Plaintiffs breached the Sale Agreement dated 29th November 2024 by failing to pay the outstanding balance of KShs. 28,637,500/= by the completion date of 31st December 2024, despite repeated reminders and a completion notice issued on 1st April 2025. The 1st Defendant consequently rescinded the Agreement and proceeded to sell the property to the 2nd Defendant.

16. The 1st Defendant submits that the Plaintiffs have failed to establish a prima facie case, having fundamentally breached the Agreement by failing to complete the purchase. It maintains that the rescission was lawful and that the 2nd Defendant subsequently entered into a valid sale agreement, paid the purchase price and took possession of the property.

17. The 1st Defendant argues that the Plaintiffs will not suffer irreparable harm if the injunction is declined, as any loss arising from the alleged breach can adequately be compensated through damages or a refund, as contemplated under the Sale Agreement.

18. On the balance of convenience, the 1st Defendant submits that it favours the Defendants, particularly the 2nd Defendant, who has fulfilled his contractual obligations and is already in possession of the property. Maintaining the status quo would unfairly prevent him from registering the property in his name and exercising his proprietary rights.

19. The 1st Defendant further argues that the Plaintiffs are not entitled to equitable reliefs as they have approached the Court with unclean hands, having failed to fulfil their contractual obligations.

20. Accordingly, the 1st Defendant urges the Court to dismiss the application for temporary injunction and status quo orders, with costs.

Analysis and Determination

21. Having considered the application, affidavits and submissions, the issues for determination are: (i) whether the Applicants have met the legal threshold for the grant of a temporary injunction pending the hearing and determination of the suit.; and (ii) whether the alternative prayer for maintenance of the status quo should be granted.

22. The jurisdiction of the Court to grant temporary injunctions is derived from Order 40 Rules 1 and 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which empower the Court to preserve property that is in danger of being wasted, damaged, alienated or wrongfully dealt with pending the determination of a suit.

23. The principles governing interlocutory injunctions are set out in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358. An applicant must first establish a prima facie case with a probability of success. If that threshold is met, the Court considers whether the applicant would otherwise suffer irreparable injury that cannot adequately be compensated by damages; if the Court remains in doubt, it determines the application on a balance of convenience.

24. The Court of Appeal in Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] KECA 606 (KLR) emphasised that these requirements are sequential and that failure to establish a prima facie case ends the inquiry into the injunction.

25. In Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] KLR 125, the Court of Appeal explained what a prima facie case is and stated that;

“A case which, on the material presented to the Court, a tribunal properly directing itself would conclude that there exists a right which has apparently been infringed by the opposite party so as to call for an explanation or rebuttal.”

26. At this interlocutory stage, the Court must avoid making final findings on contested contractual questions. The Court is not called upon to determine disputed questions of ownership or make definitive findings of fact. That is the province of the trial Court after hearing oral evidence and testing the evidence through cross-examination. The Court’s duty is merely to determine whether the Applicant has demonstrated an arguable right deserving protection pending trial.

27. The first question is whether the Plaintiffs have established a prima facie case. It is not disputed that the Plaintiffs paid a total of Kshs. 10,100,000/= towards the purchase of the suit property. It is also apparent from the parties’ respective submissions that a formal Agreement for Sale was entered into on 29th November 2024, requiring payment of the balance of the purchase price by 31st December 2024.

28. The 1st Defendant’s principal argument is that the Plaintiffs failed to pay the balance within the stipulated period and that it consequently exercised its right to rescind the agreement. The Plaintiffs, on the other hand, challenge the circumstances and validity of that purported termination. In particular, they rely on the fact that the 1st Defendant forwarded the executed and stamped Agreement for Sale to them on 8th April 2025, notwithstanding that the termination notice was dated 1st April 2025. They also rely on the subsequent correspondence between the advocates for the parties in which the Plaintiffs indicated their intention to arrange payment and the 1st Defendant’s advocates acknowledged that communication and indicated that they would await proof of payment.

29. In my view, the circumstances surrounding the purported termination of the Agreement for Sale raise questions that cannot properly be determined at this interlocutory stage. In particular, the effect of the 1st Defendant’s conduct after the date of the purported termination, including the forwarding of the executed agreement and the subsequent correspondence, requires examination at the full hearing. The Court would have to consider whether the agreement was validly terminated, whether the 1st Defendant’s subsequent conduct amounted to an affirmation or waiver of the right to terminate, and the legal consequences of the parties’ respective conduct.

30. The Court is, however, mindful that the Plaintiffs’ failure to pay the balance of the purchase price by the stipulated completion date is a significant consideration. The mere existence of an Agreement for Sale and payment of a deposit do not, without more, entitle a party to an interlocutory injunction. Nevertheless, the Plaintiffs have demonstrated a contractual interest in the suit property and raised a genuine dispute regarding the validity and effect of the purported termination. I am therefore satisfied that they have demonstrated a case warranting preservation of the subject matter of the suit.

31. On the question of irreparable injury, the Plaintiffs contend that unless the suit property is preserved, the 1st Defendant may complete the subsequent transaction with the 2nd Defendant, thereby complicating or defeating the relief of specific performance sought in the suit. The 1st Defendant argues that any loss suffered by the Plaintiffs can be adequately compensated by damages or a refund of the sums paid.

32. Although the Plaintiffs’ claim includes a monetary component, the subject matter of the suit is an identifiable parcel of land and a specific residential property. If the property is transferred to the 2nd Defendant or further dealings are undertaken before the competing contractual claims are determined, the nature of the dispute may be substantially altered. The Court must therefore consider not only the monetary value of the property but also the possibility that subsequent dealings may complicate the effective determination and enforcement of the reliefs sought. In the circumstances, preservation of the suit property is warranted. However, in the circumstances of this case, the Court has to determine the way in which the property may be preserved taking into account the interests of all parties involved.

33. The balance of convenience presents a more difficult question. The 2nd Defendant is said to have entered into a subsequent Agreement for Sale with the 1st Defendant, paid the entire purchase price and taken possession of the suit property. The Plaintiffs’ claim arises from an earlier transaction, the validity and continued effect of which remain contested. It would therefore be prejudicial to the 2nd Defendant, at this stage, to make orders that would remove him from possession or otherwise determine his rights before the dispute is heard and determined.

34. On the other hand, allowing the property to be transferred or further encumbered before the hearing of the suit may prejudice the Plaintiffs and undermine the effectiveness of the eventual judgment. The appropriate course, in my view, is to preserve the suit property without disturbing the 2nd Defendant’s existing possession. Such an order would protect the subject matter of the litigation while minimizing prejudice to both sides.

35. The Court is consequently not persuaded that the circumstances justify an order that would interfere with the 2nd Defendant’s existing possession. Equally, the Court does not consider it appropriate to permit further dealings with the suit property that may alter its ownership or legal status before the dispute is resolved. The Court must maintain a fair balance between preserving the subject matter of the suit and avoiding the grant of orders that would effectively determine substantive rights at an interlocutory stage.

36. The Applicant made an alternative prayer for maintenance of the status quo which warrants consideration. A status quo order is not necessarily identical to an injunction; it is a case-management and preservatory measure intended to hold a clearly identified state of affairs in place while the dispute is determined. In Thugi River Estate Limited & Another v National Bank of Kenya Limited & 3 Others [2015] eKLR and Fatuma Abdi Jillo v Kuro Lengesen & Another [2021] KEELC 2312 (KLR), the courts recognised the importance of defining the relevant status quo with sufficient precision and emphasized the need to describe the state of affairs to be preseved.

37. In Republic v National Environment Tribunal, Ex parte Palm Homes Limited & another, [2013] eKLR, the Court stated that an order maintaining the status quo preserves the existing state of affairs and must be interpreted by reference to the existing factual scenario. The order must therefore relate to an ascertainable factual position.

38. In Virginia Edith Wambui v Joash Ochieng Ougo, Civil Appeal No. 3 of 1987, the Court of Appeal recognised the general principle that where there are serious conflicts of fact, the trial court should maintain the status quo until the dispute is decided at trial.

39. An order for the maintenance of the status quo is intended to preserve an existing and ascertainable state of affairs pending the determination of a dispute. It is not an instrument for creating a new state of affairs, conferring possession, determining disputed proprietary rights or granting substantive relief under the guise of preservation. The Court must, therefore, be satisfied that the factual position sought to be preserved can be identified with reasonable certainty.

Conclusion

40. Having considered the rival submissions and the circumstances of this case, the Court is persuaded that an order for maintenance of the status quo would be the most appropriate means of preserving the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit. Such an order would safeguard the subject matter of the dispute while avoiding interference with the 2nd Defendant’s existing possession.

41. In making this determination, the Court has taken into account that the 2nd Defendant is said to have paid the full purchase price and taken possession of the suit property. The Court considers it inappropriate, at this interlocutory stage, to make an order that would disturb his possession. At the same time, permitting further dealings with the property may prejudice the Plaintiffs’ claim and potentially compromise the effectiveness of the eventual determination of the suit.

42. The Court therefore, declines to grant the interlocutory injunction in the terms sought. However, in the interests of justice and to preserve the subject matter of the suit, the Court orders that the Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2026 is disposed of in the following terms:

A. That the status quo prevailing as at the date of this ruling be maintained in respect of Maisonette No. 429, Five Star Estate Phase III, erected on L.R. No. 209/12221/244 pending hearing and final determination of this suit.

B. In respect of possession and occupation, the 2nd Defendant shall remain in possession and occupation of the suit property. There shall be no eviction, dispossession or interference with his existing possession pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

C. In respect of title and ownership, the existing state of the register shall be maintained. There shall be no transfer, charge, lease, subdivision, alienation or other disposition or encumbrance of the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

D. Neither party shall undertake any demolition or substantial structural alteration or development that materially changes the character or condition of the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

E. For avoidance of doubt, the order for maintenance of status quo is purely preservatory. It does not determine the validity of either Agreement for Sale, the question of ownership of the suit property, or the respective contractual rights of the parties, which shall be determined at the trial.

F. The costs of the application shall be in the cause.

Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 5th day of November 2026.

HON. L. G. KIMANI

JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

The Ruling read in the presence of-

M/s Odhiambo holding brief for Munyeri for Applicant

Gachai for 1st Defendant/Respondent

Kipkoech for 2nd Defendant/Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder