Land law

Wanyoike v Njonde & 2 others [2026] KEELC 7606 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elcl Case E308 of 2025
Judgment date
9 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court is the 1st Defendant/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026, brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 2 Rule 15(b), (c) and (d) and Order 40 Rules 1, 2, 3(1), 3(3) and 4(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Pursuant to the directions issued on 28th September 2026, the application was disposed of by way of written submissions. Only the 1st Defendant/Applicant filed submissions dated 30th September 2026. The Applicant identified five issues for determination, namely, whether his registered title is entitled to protection under the Land Registration Act; whether the Plaintiff's failure to provide consideration defeats her claim to the suit…

Paragraph 15 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances, I find and hold that the Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026 is not barred by the doctrine of res judicata. The application is therefore properly before this Court for determination on its merits.

Paragraph 28 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELCL CASE NO. E308 OF 2025

NATASHA WAITHERA WANYOIKE ...................................PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

-VERSUS-

SAMUEL KAIRU NJONDE ............................................. 1ST DEFENDANT/APPLICANT

YANAAN COMPANY LIMITED ............................... 2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

MWANGI WAWERU ............................................... 3RD DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

RULING

The Application

1. Before this Court is the 1st Defendant/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026, brought under Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 2 Rule 15(b), (c) and (d) and Order 40 Rules 1, 2, 3(1), 3(3) and 4(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules.

2. The Applicant seeks, inter alia, a temporary injunction restraining the Plaintiff/Respondent from entering, occupying, leasing, renting out or otherwise dealing with Apartment No. A8-2 in Silver Oak Apartments, Othaya Road, erected on Title No. Nairobi Block 13/348, pending the hearing and determination of the suit. He further seeks an order compelling the Plaintiff to render accounts of rental income received from the property and to pay him Kshs.30,000 per month from 24th October 2024 until surrender of the property.

3. In the alternative, the Applicant seeks an order compelling the Plaintiff to pay Kshs.19,517,500, comprising the purchase price of Kshs.18,500,000, stamp duty of Kshs.740,000 and conveyancing fees of Kshs.277,500, within seven days, failing which the suit be dismissed. He further seeks the striking out of the suit or, alternatively, an order requiring the Plaintiff to furnish security for costs and damages in the sum of Kshs.3,000,000, together with costs of the application.

4. The application is premised on the grounds that the Applicant is the registered proprietor of the suit property, having paid the entire purchase price of Kshs.18,500,000 pursuant to an Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022, under which the parties were to contribute towards its acquisition. He contends that the Plaintiff failed to make her contribution despite being afforded sufficient time, necessitating the transfer and registration of the property in his name in 2025.

5. He further alleges that the Plaintiff has continued occupying and leasing out the property to third parties at a monthly rent of Kshs.130,000 without accounting for the proceeds, thereby unjustly enriching herself at his expense. He maintains that the Plaintiff's suit discloses no reasonable cause of action and constitutes an abuse of the Court process.

Replying Affidavit

6. The application is opposed through the Replying Affidavit sworn on 18th September 2026 by Natasha Waithera Wanyoike, the Plaintiff/Respondent. She depones that the application seeks to disturb the position preserved by the Court in its Ruling delivered on 16th February 2026, wherein the Defendants were restrained from interfering with her quiet possession of the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit.

7. She further avers that the Court directed rental proceeds to be deposited into a joint interest-earning account and found that the Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022 disclosed a prima facie proprietary interest on her part, while the question of the parties' respective financial contributions was reserved for trial.

8. The Respondent depones that the apartment was purchased pursuant to the Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022, which she executed jointly with the 1st Defendant, with the 2nd Defendant being directly involved in the transaction. She avers that the 2nd Defendant's records recognised both parties as purchasers and relies on a receipt dated 29th November 2022 acknowledging payment of Kshs.1,073,880 in their joint names towards closing fees.

9. She maintains that she subsequently took possession of the apartment with the knowledge of the 1st and 2nd Defendants and continued paying the applicable service charges. Notwithstanding this, the 2nd Defendant transferred and registered the property solely in the 1st Defendant's name, contrary to the Agreement for Sale.

10. She further depones that the matters raised in the present application, particularly the Agreement for Sale, the alleged payment of the purchase price and the subsequent registration of the property in the 1st Defendant's name, were before the Court when it delivered its Ruling of 16th February 2026. According to her, no subsequent material development has occurred to warrant disturbing the interlocutory protection granted.

11. She states that the third-party tenant vacated the apartment at the end of February 2026, whereupon she resumed personal occupation, a position communicated to the 1st Defendant's Advocates by a letter dated 8th April 2026. She maintains that no rental income has been received since the tenant vacated and that she has complied with the existing Court orders.

12. The Respondent contends that granting the injunction sought would effectively reverse the protection afforded by the earlier Ruling before trial. She further avers that the prayers seeking payment of Kshs.19,517,500, striking out of the suit and other substantive reliefs concern matters that remain contested in the main suit. She maintains that the competing rights arising from the Agreement for Sale, the subsequent transfer and registration of the property, and the parties' respective interests are matters for determination at trial. She consequently urges the Court to dismiss the application with costs.

Further Affidavit

13. In response, the 1st Defendant/Applicant filed a Further Affidavit sworn on 30th September 2026, in which he reiterates the averments in his Supporting Affidavit sworn on 6th September 2026. He maintains that the Plaintiff made no financial contribution towards the acquisition of the suit property and therefore has no legal right to rely on the Agreement for Sale or occupy the property without his express consent. He further contends that the Plaintiff remains in possession of the property without accounting to him for the income attributable to it, and that whether she previously leased the property to third parties is immaterial to his claim for an account.

14. The Applicant further depones that the sum of Kshs.1,073,880, reflected in the receipt produced by the Plaintiff as evidence of payment of closing costs, was paid from his own bank account and does not constitute proof of any contribution by the Plaintiff towards the acquisition of the property. He also disputes the contention that the application raises matters already determined by the Court, maintaining that the issues raised have neither been previously canvassed nor determined and are therefore not res judicata.

Submissions

15. Pursuant to the directions issued on 28th September 2026, the application was disposed of by way of written submissions. Only the 1st Defendant/Applicant filed submissions dated 30th September 2026. The Applicant identified five issues for determination, namely, whether his registered title is entitled to protection under the Land Registration Act; whether the Plaintiff's failure to provide consideration defeats her claim to the suit property; whether the Plaintiff should account for and refund rental income received from the property; whether the Plaintiff's suit should be struck out for being frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court process; and whether the orders sought in the application ought to be granted.

16. In support of his submissions, the Applicant relied on Joseph Arap Ngok Vs Justice Moijo Ole Keiwua & 5 Others [1997] eKLR, Wreck Motors Enterprises Vs Commissioner of Lands & 3 Others [1997] eKLR, Elijah Makeri Nyangw'ra Vs Stephen Mungai Njuguna & Another [2013] eKLR, Arthi Highway Developers Limited Vs West End Butchery Limited & 6 Others [2015] eKLR and Dina Management Limited Vs County Government of Mombasa & 5 Others [2023] KESC 30 (KLR) on the protection of registered title.

17. He further cited National Bank of Kenya Ltd. Vs Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & Another [2001] eKLR and Funzi Island Development Limited & 2 Others Vs County Council of Kwale & 2 Others [2014] eKLR on contractual obligations and proprietary interests; Samuel Kamau Macharia Vs Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd. & Another [2003] eKLR on unjust enrichment; Kivanga Estates Limited Vs National Bank of Kenya Limited [2017] KECA 591 (KLR) on striking out suits; and Justine Masolo Nyakundi Vs Attorney General & Another [2022] KEHC 26958 (KLR) and Republic of the Philippines Vs Ramon Yu et al, G.R. No. 157557 on the doctrine of res judicata. He urged the Court to allow the application with costs.

Issues for Determination

18. I have considered the application, the affidavits filed by the respective parties and the Applicant's written submissions. In my view, the following issues arise for determination:

a) Whether the application is barred by the doctrine of res judicata in light of the Court's Ruling delivered on 16th February 2026.

b) Whether the Applicant has established sufficient grounds for the grant of the orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026.

Analysis and Determination

Issue No:1 Whether the application is barred by the doctrine of res judicata in light of the Court's Ruling delivered on 16th February 2026.

19. Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act embodies the rule of res judicata. Its purpose is not merely procedural. It protects the conclusiveness of judicial decisions, shields parties from repeated litigation and preserves the authority of courts. The statutory command is expressed in the following terms:

“No court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such court.”

20. In Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd & another Vs Muiri Cofee Estate Ltd & 3 others [2016] KESC 6 (KLR), the Supreme Court underscored the substantive character of the doctrine and the conclusiveness it attaches to judicial determinations. The Court stated:

“Res judicata is a doctrine of substantive law, its essence being that once the legal rights of parties have been judicially determined, such edict stands as a conclusive statement as to those rights.”

21. The controlling test was restated by the Supreme Court in John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another Vs Cabinet Secretary for Transport & Infrastructure & 3 others (Petition 17 of 2015) [2021] KESC 39 (KLR). The Court identified the cumulative elements in these terms:

“For res judicata to be invoked in a civil matter, the following elements must be demonstrated: (a) there is a former judgment or order which was final; (b) the judgment or order was on merit; (c) the judgment or order was rendered by a court having jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties; and (d) there must be between the first and the second action identical parties, subject matter and cause of action.”
The four cumulative elements for determination are therefore whether there is a former Judgment or order which was final; whether that Judgment or order was on the merits; whether it was rendered by a court having jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties; and whether the former and present proceedings involve identical parties, subject matter and cause of action. The application of these principles requires an examination of what was determined in the earlier proceedings against the issues raised in the present application.

22. In the present case, this Court delivered a Ruling on 16th February 2026 concerning the Plaintiff's Notice of Motion dated 20th June 2025. The Plaintiff had sought an injunction restraining the Defendants from interfering with her quiet possession of the suit property pending the hearing and determination of the suit. In determining that application, the Court considered the Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022, the Applicant's contention that he had solely financed the acquisition of the property and the subsequent registration of the property in his name. The Court found that the Plaintiff had established a prima facie proprietary interest deserving protection and granted the injunction sought. It further directed that rental proceeds from the property be deposited into a joint interest-earning account pending determination of the suit.

23. The earlier Ruling was delivered by a Court of competent jurisdiction following consideration of the parties' respective positions and the applicable law. It conclusively determined the Plaintiff's entitlement to interlocutory protection on the material then before the Court. However, it did not finally determine the ownership of the property, the parties' respective financial contributions or their ultimate entitlement to rental income. Those matters remained in dispute and were left for determination at trial.

24. Although the parties and the suit property are the same, the present application raises additional questions which were not the subject of determination in the earlier proceedings. The Applicant seeks an injunction against the Plaintiff, rendition of accounts, payment of rental income, reimbursement of the purchase price and associated expenses, striking out of the suit and, alternatively, security for costs and damages. The earlier application concerned the Plaintiff's entitlement to protection of her possession pending trial. It did not involve an adjudication of the Applicant's monetary claims, the sufficiency of the Plaintiff's pleadings or the necessity for security for costs.

25. Further, the Applicant's present application was brought following the Plaintiff's resumption of personal occupation after the departure of her tenant in February 2026. Although the earlier Ruling protected the Plaintiff's possession, the present application also raises questions concerning the Applicant's entitlement to rental proceeds and the financial obligations arising from the disputed transaction. These questions were not finally resolved by the Court in its earlier determination.

26. The doctrine of res judicata requires satisfaction of all the cumulative elements identified by the Supreme Court in John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another Vs Cabinet Secretary for Transport & Infrastructure & 3 others (supra). The existence of an earlier Ruling between the same parties concerning the same property does not, without identity of the matters determined, establish the bar.

27. In this case, the earlier Ruling determined the Plaintiff's entitlement to interlocutory protection but did not adjudicate the substantive reliefs now pursued by the Applicant. The requirement that the matters directly and substantially in issue must have been previously heard and finally determined has therefore not been satisfied in respect of the present application.

28. In the circumstances, I find and hold that the Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026 is not barred by the doctrine of res judicata. The application is therefore properly before this Court for determination on its merits.

Issue No:2 Whether the Applicant Has Established Sufficient Grounds for the Grant of the Orders Sought in the Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026

29. The Applicant seeks an injunction restraining the Plaintiff from entering, occupying, leasing or otherwise dealing with Apartment No. A8-2 in Silver Oak Apartments, Othaya Road. He relies on his registration as proprietor and maintains that he paid the entire purchase price of Kshs.18,500,000. The Plaintiff, however, relies on the Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022, under which both parties were named as purchasers, and challenges the subsequent registration of the property solely in the Applicant's name.

30. The principles governing the grant of temporary injunctions were considered in Anita Cheleagat O'Donovan & 2 Others Vs Fredrick Kwame Kumah & 2 Others [2015] KEHC 581 (KLR), where the Court cited Giella Vs Cassman Brown & Co Ltd [1973] EA 358, which stated: “The conditions for the grant of an interlocutory injunction are now, I think, well settled in East Africa. First, an applicant must show a prima facie case with a probability of success. Secondly, an interlocutory injunction will not normally be granted unless the applicant might otherwise suffer irreparable injury, which would not adequately be compensated by an award for damages. Thirdly, if the Court is in doubt, it will decide an application on a balance of convenience.”

31. In the present matter, this Court had previously considered the parties' competing claims in its Ruling delivered on 16th February 2026. The Court found that the Plaintiff had established a prima facie proprietary interest arising from the Agreement for Sale and granted an injunction restraining the Defendants from interfering with her quiet possession pending determination of the suit. It further directed that, rental proceeds from the property be deposited into a joint interest-earning account. The Applicant's registration as proprietor and his contention that he had paid the entire purchase price were among the matters considered in that Ruling. The parties' respective proprietary interests were, however, left for determination at trial.

32. The Plaintiff has since confirmed that the third-party tenant vacated the apartment at the end of February 2026, whereupon she resumed personal occupation. Her Advocates communicated that development through the letter dated 8th April 2026. The earlier injunction was granted when the apartment was occupied by a tenant, and the Court had considered the risk of losing rental income in assessing the Plaintiff's claim for interlocutory protection. Following her resumption of personal occupation, the Plaintiff maintains that no further rental income is being received from the premises.

33. Order 40 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides:

“Any order for an injunction may be discharged, or varied, or set aside by the court on application made thereto by any party dissatisfied with such order.”

Further, Order 40 Rule 2(2) provides:

“The court may by order grant such injunction on such terms as to an inquiry as to damages, the duration of the injunction, keeping an account, giving security or otherwise, as the court deems fit.”

34. In Samuel O. Tima & Another v Housing Finance Company of Kenya & Another [2012] KEHC 599 (KLR), the Court considered an application by a registered proprietor seeking discharge or variation of an existing injunction which had prevented him from enjoying the rental income generated by the disputed property. The plaintiffs maintained that the transfer of the property had been fraudulent, while the applicant asserted his rights as registered proprietor. The Court found that the parties had raised serious triable issues concerning ownership and, in addressing the rental proceeds, held:

“In the final analysis, if the suit is decided in favour of the applicant, it may prove difficulty for the plaintiffs to pay the applicant damages. In the circumstances, I find it fair and proper to grant the prayer for the rent collected to be deposited in a joint interest earning account to be opened by the parties’ respective advocates pending the hearing and determination of the suit in terms of prayer 5 of the application by Notice of Motion dated 29th March, 2011. Costs in the cause.”

35. In the present case, the Applicant relies on his registration as proprietor of the suit property and his assertion that he paid the entire purchase price. The Plaintiff, on the other hand, relies on the Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022, under which both parties were identified as purchasers. The Court considered these competing interests in its Ruling delivered on 16th February 2026 and granted an injunction protecting the Plaintiff's quiet possession pending determination of the suit. The question of the parties' respective proprietary rights remains unresolved.

36. The Applicant now seeks to restrain the Plaintiff from occupying or otherwise dealing with the property. However, the material placed before the Court does not establish sufficient grounds for setting aside the existing injunction. The Plaintiff's continued occupation, following the departure of the tenant, does not of itself establish that she is unlawfully in possession. Granting the injunction sought would effectively reverse the protection previously granted before the substantive dispute is determined. I therefore decline this prayer.

37. Regarding rental income, the Applicant contends that the Plaintiff leased the apartment to third parties at Kshs.130,000 monthly without accounting for the proceeds. The Plaintiff acknowledges the previous tenancy but states that the tenant vacated at the end of February 2026, whereupon she resumed personal occupation. She maintains that no rental income has been received since then.

38. The earlier Ruling directed that, rental proceeds be deposited into a joint interest-earning account pending determination of the suit. However, the Plaintiff's resumption of personal occupation has altered the circumstances under which those orders were made. Although no rental income is presently being generated, the Plaintiff continues to enjoy exclusive occupation of the property while the Applicant remains excluded from its use. The Court must therefore balance the protection afforded to the Plaintiff with the Applicant's competing interest in the property without determining the parties' respective rights prematurely.

39. In my view, the Plaintiff's continued occupation should be accompanied by reasonable financial safeguards to preserve the competing interests pending trial. The evidence of the previous tenancy establishes that the apartment generated Kshs.130,000 monthly, and no alternative rental valuation has been placed before the Court. I therefore find it appropriate that, with effect from the date of this Ruling, the Plaintiff's continued occupation shall be subject to depositing Kshs.130,000 monthly into a joint interest-earning account in the names of the parties' Advocates. The deposits shall be held pending determination of the suit or further orders of the Court and shall not constitute payment of rent to the Applicant or a determination of ownership. This requirement shall operate prospectively and shall not impose any retrospective liability in respect of the Plaintiff's personal occupation before the date of this Ruling.

40. As regards the rental income previously received, the Applicant has demonstrated sufficient grounds for requiring an account of the proceeds generated during the tenancy. The Plaintiff shall therefore render a comprehensive statement of accounts covering the period from 24th October 2024 to 28th February 2026, indicating the rental income actually received, the dates of receipt, expenditure claimed and amounts deposited pursuant to the existing Court orders. The Applicant's prayer for direct payment of those proceeds is declined, as the parties' respective entitlement thereto remains undetermined.

41. The Applicant further seeks payment of Kshs.19,517,500, comprising the purchase price, stamp duty and conveyancing fees, failing which the suit should stand dismissed. However, the alleged obligation to reimburse those amounts arises from the disputed transaction forming the subject of the suit. Determining that liability at this stage would effectively resolve substantive questions before trial. I therefore decline this prayer.

42. As regards the prayer for striking out the suit, the Plaintiff's claim arises from the Agreement for Sale dated 3rd November 2022 and the subsequent registration of the property solely in the Applicant's name. The legal consequences of that transaction and the parties' respective interests remain contested. These are matters requiring determination at trial, and I find no sufficient basis for striking out the suit.

43. The Applicant also seeks Kshs.3,000,000 as security for costs and damages. Having considered the material presented, I am not satisfied that sufficient grounds have been established to justify requiring the Plaintiff to furnish the security sought. Accordingly, this prayer is declined.

44. In the circumstances, I find that the Applicant has established sufficient grounds for rendition of accounts and variation of the existing interlocutory orders to provide financial safeguards for the Plaintiff's continued occupation. The remaining substantive prayers are declined, and the parties' competing proprietary rights shall be determined at trial.

Final Disposition

45. Accordingly, the Notice of Motion dated 6th September 2026 is partly allowed in the following terms:

a) The Plaintiff shall, within thirty (30) days, file and serve a statement of accounts of all rental income received from the suit property between 24th October 2024 and 28th February 2026, together with supporting records.

b) With effect from the date of this Ruling, the Plaintiff's continued occupation of the suit property shall be subject to a monthly deposit of Kshs.130,000 into a joint interest-earning account in the names of the parties' Advocates, pending determination of the suit or further orders of the Court. The first deposit shall be made within thirty (30) days, and subsequent deposits monthly thereafter.

c) The orders of 16th February 2026 shall otherwise remain in force.

d) The remaining prayers are declined.

e) Costs shall be in the cause.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 9th day of

November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

N/A for the Applicants

Ms. Mideva for the Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder