Land law

Royal Boulevard Resorts Co Ltd v Kuria & another [2026] KEELC 7591 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case E378 of 2025
Judgment date
9 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court for determination is the Plaintiff/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 11th December 2025, brought pursuant to Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A and 100 of the Civil Procedure Act and Orders 1, 8 and 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Applicant seeks leave to amend its Plaint dated 24th July 2025 in terms of the draft Amended Plaint annexed to the Application and marked BM-1, an order deeming the Amended Plaint duly filed…

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the proposed amendments are relevant to the questions in controversy and that the joinder of the intended defendants will facilitate the complete and effective determination of the dispute. The amendments can be accommodated without occasioning injustice to the existing parties, provided that the additional defendants are afforded an opportunity to participate in the proceedings.

Paragraph 31 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO. E378 OF 2025

ROYAL BOULEVARD RESORTS CO. LIMITED ……………………PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

CATHERINE WANGUI KURIA……………………………..1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

CASAMIA HOLDINGS LIMITED………………………….2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

RULING

The Application

1. Before this Court for determination is the Plaintiff/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 11th December 2025, brought pursuant to Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A and 100 of the Civil Procedure Act and Orders 1, 8 and 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Applicant seeks leave to amend its Plaint dated 24th July 2025 in terms of the draft Amended Plaint annexed to the Application and marked BM-1, an order deeming the Amended Plaint duly filed upon payment of the requisite filing fees, and costs of the Application being in the cause.

2. The Application is premised on the grounds that the Applicant became aware, through the Defendants' Replying Affidavit served, that Apartment B6 had been subleased to Beleza Management Company Limited and subsequently charged to NCBA Bank Kenya PLC on 24th February 2022.

3. The Applicant further contends that the Defendants had, through a Sale Agreement dated 15th July 2020, purportedly sold Apartment B5 to Franken Limited. It is the Applicant's case that the proposed amendments are necessary to bring the said parties before the Court for the effective determination of the dispute. The Applicant maintains that the pleadings have not closed and that the Defendants will suffer no prejudice as they are yet to file their Statement of Defence.

4. The Application is supported by the Affidavit of Byaruhanga McRonald, an Advocate of the High Court of Kenya acting for the Applicant. He depones that the information concerning the dealings with Apartments B5 and B6 was disclosed in the Defendants' earlier Replying Affidavit. In particular, he states that Apartment B6 was subleased to Beleza Management Company Limited on 25th August 2021 and thereafter charged to NCBA Bank Kenya PLC on 24th February 2022, while Apartment B5 was purportedly sold to Franken Limited pursuant to a Sale Agreement dated 15th July 2020.

5. The deponent further states that sometime in 2014, the 2nd Defendant undertook the development of twenty apartments on L.R. Nos. 2/390 and 389 along Kirichwa Gardens in Kilimani, Nairobi, known as the Casamia Apartments development project. He avers that the 1st Defendant approached the Applicant to participate as a bridging financier and investor in the project. According to the deponent, the Applicant supplied M/s Avco Agencies Limited with cash and building materials, which was converted into credit towards the purchase of Apartments B5 and B6, as reflected in a Certificate of Credit dated 19th January 2015.

6. The deponent maintains that the proposed amendments are necessary to place the relevant parties and transactions before the Court to facilitate the substantive determination of the dispute. He further avers that the Defendants have not filed their Defence and will therefore suffer no prejudice if leave to amend is granted. He consequently urges the Court to allow the Application as prayed.

The Response

7. The Application is opposed through the Replying Affidavit sworn on 25th May 2026 by Catherine Wangui Kuria, the 1st Defendant/Respondent and a Director of the 2nd Defendant/Respondent, Casamia Holdings Limited. She depones that the Application is misconceived, incompetent and an abuse of the Court process. She contends that although the Applicant seeks leave to amend its Plaint, the proposed amendments effectively seek to introduce new parties to the suit, a procedure which, in her view, ought to be pursued through an application for joinder. She maintains that the proposed parties ought to be served and afforded an opportunity to be heard before any orders for their joinder are made.

8. The 1st Respondent avers that the dispute arises from the development of twenty residential apartments known as Casamia Apartments, comprising eight one-bedroom units and twelve two-bedroom units. She states that the project involved dealings between herself and QS Robinson Kariguh of Quanti-Bill Consults Company Limited, who served as the project's Quantity Surveyor.

9. According to her, discussions concerning the acquisition of Apartments B5 and B6 were between herself and the said Quantity Surveyor and never culminated in executed sale agreements. She denies having entered into any agreement with the Applicant for the sale of the two apartments and maintains that the project was financed through her personal and family resources, including a loan obtained from Co-operative Bank of Kenya.

10. She further disputes the Applicant's assertion that it supplied construction materials through Avco Agencies Limited, contending that the Respondents neither received nor handled such materials. She alleges that the Quantity Surveyor failed to disclose a conflict of interest arising from his involvement with the contractor. She further states that any monies paid towards the proposed acquisition of the apartments were refunded and disputes the validity of the Certificate of Credit dated 19th January 2015, maintaining that it cannot constitute a contract for the sale of land. Consequently, she contends that, in the absence of any binding sale agreement with the Applicant, the subsequent sale and dealings involving Apartments B5 and B6 were lawful.

11. The 1st Respondent reiterates that the Applicant has not adopted the proper procedure for introducing new parties into the proceedings. She maintains that the Applicant ought to have brought a substantive application for joinder and served the proposed parties rather than seeking their inclusion through an amendment of the Plaint. She therefore urges the Court to dismiss the Application dated 11th December 2025 with costs.

The Supplementary Affidavit

12. The Plaintiff filed a Supplementary Affidavit sworn by Elisha Kuria Kariguh, a Director of the Plaintiff Company, in response to the Defendants' Replying Affidavit. He depones that the proposed amendments arise from disclosures made by the Defendants in their earlier Replying Affidavit concerning the sale of Apartment B5 to Franken Limited, the sublease of Apartment B6 to Beleza Management Company Limited and the subsequent registration of a charge in favour of NCBA Bank Kenya PLC. He maintains that these transactions were previously unknown to the Plaintiff and that the proposed parties are necessary for the effective adjudication of the dispute.

13. The deponent further states that the Plaintiff had previously sought leave to amend the Plaint and that the Court subsequently issued directions concerning the filing and service of the present Application. He maintains that the proposed amended pleadings were served upon the intended Defendants and disputes the allegation that the Application was brought belatedly or in disregard of the applicable procedure. He contends that the matters raised by the Defendants concerning the existence of a sale agreement, financing of the project and alleged refunds relate to the substantive dispute and ought to be determined at trial. He consequently urges the Court to allow the proposed amendments.

The Parties’ Submissions

14. The Plaintiff filed written submissions dated 9th February 2026. The Defendants subsequently filed written submissions dated 15th October 2026, identifying the issue for determination as whether the Application dated 11th December 2025 is merited. They submitted that although the Application is framed as one seeking leave to amend the Plaint, its substantive effect is to introduce three new defendants against whom substantive reliefs are sought.

15. They argued that the Applicant ought to have invoked Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules and demonstrated that the proposed parties are necessary for the effective determination of the dispute. They relied on Departed Asians Property Custodian Board Vs Jaffer Brothers Limited [1999] 1 EA 55 and Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission Vs Andrew Biketi Musuya T/A Mukuyu Petroleum Dealers & 6 Others [2019] on the principles governing joinder of parties.

16. The Defendants further submitted that the proposed parties had not been afforded an opportunity to be heard, notwithstanding that the intended amendments seek reliefs directly affecting their proprietary interests, including the discharge of a charge registered in favour of NCBA Bank Kenya PLC. They relied on Judicial Service Commission Vs Mbalu Mutava & Another [2015] eKLR on the right to be heard and Central Kenya Ltd. Vs Trust Bank Ltd [2000] 2 EA 365 on the principles governing amendment of pleadings. They maintained that the proposed amendments would occasion prejudice and substantially alter the character of the suit, and urged the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.

17. In response, the Plaintiff filed Supplementary Submissions dated 19th October 2026, pursuant to leave granted on 7th October 2026. The Plaintiff disputed the Defendants' contention that the Application was procedurally defective, submitting that Order 8 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules permits amendments notwithstanding that their effect may be to add or substitute parties. It argued that Orders 1 and 8 are complementary rather than mutually exclusive and that the pleadings had not closed. The Plaintiff further invoked Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act, maintaining that any procedural irregularity ought not to defeat the substantive determination of the dispute.

18. The Plaintiff further submitted that the proposed joinder arose from the Defendants' disclosures concerning the sale, sublease and charging of Apartments B5 and B6. It maintained that Beleza Management Company Limited, Franken Limited and NCBA Bank Kenya PLC had acquired interests directly connected to the subject matter of the suit, making their participation necessary for the complete adjudication of the dispute. The Plaintiff argued that the proposed amendments would enable the Court to determine the real questions in controversy while affording the affected parties an opportunity to be heard. It consequently urged the Court to allow the Application.

Issue for Determination

19. I have considered the Application, the affidavits filed by the respective parties and the written submissions. The sole issue arising for determination is: Whether the Application dated 11th December 2025 is merited.

Analysis and Determination

20. The principles governing amendment of pleadings are set out under Order 8 Rule 3(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, which provides that: “Subject to Order 1, rules 9 and 10, Order 24, rules 3, 4, 5 and 6 and the following provisions of this rule, the Court may at any stage of the proceedings, on such terms as to costs or otherwise as may be just and in such manner as it may direct, allow any party to amend his pleadings.”

21. Further, Order 8 Rule 5(1) provides that: “For the purpose of determining the real question in controversy between the parties, or of correcting any defect or error in any proceedings, the Court may either of its own motion or on the application of any party order any document to be amended in such manner as it directs and on such terms as to costs or otherwise as are just.”

22. The Court's discretion to allow amendments is intended to facilitate the determination of the real questions in controversy between the parties. In Central Kenya Ltd. Vs Trust Bank Ltd & 5 Others [2000] eKLR, the Court of Appeal stated that: “The settled rule with regard to amendment of pleadings has been concisely stated in Vol.2, 6th Ed. at P.2245, of the AIR Commentaries on the Indian Civil Procedure Code by Chittaley and Rao, in which the learned authors state: ”that a party is allowed to make such amendments as maybe necessary for determining the real question in controversy or to avoid a multiplicity of suits, provided there has been no undue delay, that no new or inconsistent cause of action is introduced, that no vested interest or accrued legal right is affected and that the amendment can be allowed without injustice to the other side.’”

23. Similarly, in Elijah Kipngeno Arap Bii Vs Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2013] eKLR, the Court of Appeal reiterated that amendments should generally be allowed where they are made in good faith, are necessary for the determination of the substantive dispute and do not occasion prejudice incapable of being compensated by costs. The Court further observed that an amendment introducing a new case may be permitted provided it does not transform the proceedings into an action of a substantially different character.

24. In the present Application, the Plaintiff seeks to amend its Plaint dated 24th July 2025 to introduce Beleza Management Company Limited, Franken Limited and NCBA Bank Kenya PLC as additional defendants. The proposed amendments arise from transactions concerning Apartments B5 and B6, which are the subject matter of the original suit. According to the Plaintiff, the transactions were disclosed in the Defendants' earlier Replying Affidavit and necessitated the proposed amendments.

25. The Defendants' principal objection is that the Plaintiff seeks to introduce new parties through an application for amendment rather than a substantive application for joinder. The applicable provision on joinder is Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, which empowers the Court, at any stage of the proceedings, either upon application or on its own motion, to add a person whose presence is necessary to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all questions involved in the suit.

26. Notably, Order 8 Rule 3(1) expressly makes the Court's power to allow amendments subject to Order 1 Rules 9 and 10. The two provisions must therefore be considered together where a proposed amendment entails the addition of parties. The mere fact that the Plaintiff has approached the Court through an application for leave to amend does not, of itself, render the Application incompetent. The determining consideration is whether the proposed parties satisfy the requirements for joinder and whether the amendments are necessary for the effective determination of the dispute.

27. Upon examining the draft Amended Plaint, I note that the proposed 3rd Defendant is alleged to have acquired an interest in Apartment B6 through a sublease, while the proposed 4th Defendant is alleged to have purchased Apartment B5. The proposed 5th Defendant is identified as the holder of a registered charge affecting the disputed apartments. The Plaintiff seeks reliefs touching on these transactions and the respective interests of the proposed parties. Their presence is therefore material to the determination of the questions raised in the suit, particularly where the reliefs sought may affect their respective interests.

28. The Defendants have further objected to the proposed amendments on the ground that the intended parties have not been afforded an opportunity to be heard. The Supplementary Affidavit annexes an Affidavit of Service referring to an earlier Notice of Motion dated 26th November 2025 and related documents. That affidavit does not conclusively establish service of the present Application dated 11th December 2025. Nevertheless, Order 1 Rule 10(2) permits the Court to order joinder even on its own motion, while Order 1 Rule 10(4) provides for amendment of the Plaint and service of the amended summons and Plaint upon an added defendant. The procedural rights of the proposed parties can therefore be secured through appropriate directions for service and an opportunity to respond to the claims against them.

29. I have also considered whether the proposed amendments would occasion prejudice to the existing Defendants. The amendments arise from the same properties and transactions forming the subject matter of the original proceedings. Although the proposed pleading introduces additional parties and reliefs, it does not transform the dispute into one of a substantially different character. The Defendants will retain the opportunity to respond to the amended pleading, and no prejudice incapable of being addressed through appropriate procedural directions has been demonstrated.

30. The Defendants have raised substantive objections concerning the existence of an enforceable agreement for the sale of Apartments B5 and B6, the alleged financing arrangements, the Certificate of Credit and the subsequent dealings with the apartments. These are contested matters requiring examination of the parties' evidence. They do not, at this stage, provide sufficient grounds for refusing an amendment intended to place the relevant transactions and parties before the Court.

31. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the proposed amendments are relevant to the questions in controversy and that the joinder of the intended defendants will facilitate the complete and effective determination of the dispute. The amendments can be accommodated without occasioning injustice to the existing parties, provided that the additional defendants are afforded an opportunity to participate in the proceedings.

32. Accordingly, I find that the Application dated 11th December 2025 is merited.

Final Disposition

33. Consequently, I make the following orders:

a) The Notice of Motion dated 11th December 2025 is hereby allowed.

b) The Plaintiff is granted leave to amend its Plaint in terms of the draft Amended Plaint annexed to the Application, joining Beleza Management Company Limited, Franken Limited and NCBA Bank Kenya PLC as the 3rd , 4th and 5th Defendants, respectively. The Amended Plaint shall be filed within fourteen (14) days from the date of this Ruling.

c) The Plaintiff shall serve the Amended Plaint upon the existing Defendants and, together with the requisite summons, upon the newly joined Defendants within fourteen (14) days of filing. The Defendants shall be at liberty to respond in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules.

d) Costs of the Application shall be in the cause.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on 9th day of November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Macdonald for the Applicant

Ms. Nyaguthie for the Respondents

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder