Ope t/a Disel Turbo Charging Services v Fintel Limited (Environment and Land
Appeal E002 of 2025) [2026] KEELC 7612 (KLR) (9 November 2026) (Ruling)
Neutral citation: [2026] KEELC 7612 (KLR)
REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ENVIRONMENT AND LAND APPEAL E002 OF 2025
MN KULLOW, J
NOVEMBER 9, 2026
BETWEEN
MATHEWS ODHIAMBO OPE T/A DISEL TURBO CHARGING
SERVICES .................................................................................................. APPELLANT
AND
FINTEL LIMITED ................................................................................ RESPONDENT
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is a Notice of Motion application dated 2nd May 2026, which seeks
the following orders:
a. Spent
b. That the honourable court be pleased to issue an order of unconditional release of his stolen
items/stocks by the Respondent as in the schedule listed in the application.
c. That the Appellant in the alternative is seeking for compensation of the lost goods amounting
to Ksh.3,759,000 as set out in the stolen items /list of stocks.
2. The Application is premised on grounds as inthe annexed supporting afidavit of Mathews Odhiambo
Ope. He deponed that the Respondent through the auctioneers has seized the Appellants good worth
Ksh.6,482,200/= in execution of the court order.
3. That the Appellant proceeded to the Respondent’s premises for the release of the goods and received
only part of the goods in the inventory.
4. The Appellant is therefore seeking for an order of unconditional release of his stolen items/stock by
the Respondent
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7612/eng@2026-11-09 1
5.
The Appellant is further seeking in the alternatively for compensation of the lost goods amounting to
Ksh.3, 579,000/=
6.
The Respondent in opposing the application ffiled a replying afidavit sworn by Mary Njeri Muturi.
7.
She deponed that by an order of the tribunal in BPRT Case No E691 of 2025 the Respondent
proceeded to execute the orders which necessitated the eviction of the Appellant but chose to remove
the Appellant’s goods and store them rather than evict him. That the Appellant later sort to have
his good released to him which goods were released after an inventory had been signed by both the
Respondent and Appellant in the presence of two witnesses
8.
That the Respondent did not levy for distress as the Applicant claims despite the Applicant being in
rent arrears. That this application is mischievous as the Applicant is seeking g to strike back at the
Respondent insinuating loss of goods by seeking orders in the alternative for monetary compensation
9.
The Respondent deponed that, issues raised by the Applicant cannot be canvassed through an
application in this appeal which has no direct connection as to the issues raised in the notice of motion.
10.
That the issues raised will require the Appellant to testify on oath and the Respondent given cross
examination and not canvassed by way of an afidavit
Applicant/Appellant’s submissions
11.
The Appellant reiterated the contents of his supporting afidavit that the goods had been seized by
auctioneers. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent had failed in their duties to protect the
Appellant’s items hence violating section 23 of the Auctioneers cap 526 and that the court should ffind
them professionally liable for the lost items worth Ksh.3,759,000/=. He relied in the case of Wairimu
Githua Vs Peter Mugo Ngángá & another Civil case No 5258 of 1989
Respondent’s submissions
12.
Counsel submitted that this court had refused an order of stay of execution of the tribunal’s orders
that had the Appellant evicted and hat being the case, we any cause of action that may have accrued to
the Appellant arising from the eviction process of the Appellant by the Respondent ought to be the
subject of a fresh suit, which should be a separate suit from the Appeal case herein
13.
That matters pleaded in the Appellant’s Notice of Motion application are contested cannot be rightly
determined by this Court on the basis of Afidavit evidence only.
Analysis and determination
14.
Having looked at the application, the responses thereto, the submissions and cited authorities, the issue
for determination will be whether the application is merited.
15.
The Respondent has argued that the issues sought to be canvassed are nit related to this appeal and will
require interrogation of evidence at a full trial.
16.
I do agree with the Respondent being that the application is seeking for release of alleged stolen
goods and in the alternative compensation for the alleged stolen goods. These orders are founded
on the Appellant’s asserted rights under section 23 of the Auctioneers cap 526 and are not merely
interlocutory reliefs ancillary to this appeal. The Appellant further seeks monetary compensation in
the sum of Ksh.3,759,000/=. These are, in my view, substantive issues which cannot be raised and
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7612/eng@2026-11-09
2
ffinally determined in a claim originated in a notice of motion application as the court will need to
interrogate the evidence for compensation to happen.
17. I therefore ffind the Notice of Motion application dated 2nd June 2026 as incompetent and dismiss it
with it with no order as to costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI ON THIS 9TH DAY OF
NOVEMBER 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULL
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
N/A for the Appellants
Mr. Kangethe __ for the Respondent
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant
https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2026/7612/eng@2026-11-09 3