Land law

Ngwareini v Embakasi Ranching Company Ltd [2026] KEELC 7773 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
9 November 2026

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

A party seeking temporary orders of injunction must submit to the ingredients set out in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358. A prima facie case was described in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] KECA 175 (KLR), as more than an arguable case. It is established if looking at the material before court a right or interest has been infringed by opposite sides to call for a rebuttal. A party need not…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Applying the foregoing case law, what is before court is a plaint dated 29.9.2026 and not an originating summons .

Paragraph 12 →

Reasoning passage

The upshot is that I find the notice of motion dated 29.9.2026 lacking merit.

Paragraph 19 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC LC E479 OF 2026

ROSE WANGARI NGWAREINI …………. PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

EMBAKASI RANCHING CO. LTD ………DEFENDANT

RULING

1. A party seeking temporary orders of injunction must submit to the ingredients set out in Giella v Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358. A prima facie case was described in Mrao Ltd v First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others [2003] KECA 175 (KLR), as more than an arguable case. It is established if looking at the material before court a right or interest has been infringed by opposite sides to call for a rebuttal. A party need not establish title to the land. All what is required is established or demonstration of a bona fide issue or annextures to be traced at the hearing as to the right or interest infringed or threatened with breach.

2. Irreparable loss or damage must be incapable or monetary compensation, apparent , real, imminent and not speculative as held in Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] KECA 606 (KLR), Civil Appeal No. 77 of 2012.

3. Balance of convenience on the other hand refers to the inconvenience to the plaintiff in the absence of an injunction being more compared to the defendant of the injunction is not availed and the suit ultimately becoming successful as held in Jena v Kogo [1972] EA 198.

4. The three hurdles must be established logically, sequentially and distinctly . A court in establishing whether or not the tests have been met need not conduct a mini-trial. All what is required is to see to it that on a balance of probabilities and based on affidavit evidence, the plaintiffs is entitled to orders to preserve the subtraction of the suit, as provided under Order 40 Rule 1& 2 of civil procedure rule and section 63 (e ) of the Civil Procedure Act.

5. The plaintiff by the plaint dated 29.9.2026 seek to be declared as entitled to adverse possession of LR No. 44/4 Ruai also known as LR No. 10904/2, which they claim have occupied for the last 25 years, under section 7 & 38 of the Limitation of Actions Act.

6. Actual, continuous and uninterrupted ,open and notorious ,exclusive and non-permissive, non consent and peaceful possession to be met by the claimants are the ingredients of adverse possession as held in Lewa v Mwagandi [2015] KECA 532 (KLR), Civil Appeal No. 56 of 2014.

7. The procedure governing such claims is order 37 Rule 7 of Civil Procedure Rule, which requires that an originating summons and a supporting affidavit be filed attaching a copy of the extract of the title to the land and evidence of continuous occupation.

8. In Kakuzi PLC v Makuyu Club (Suing through Joel Wanyoike, Irungu Ndirangu & S.K. Kirubi as Trustees of the Club) [2026] KESC 69 (KLR), Supreme Court Petition No. E035 of 2025, the Supreme court cited with approval Malcolm Bell v Daniel Toroitich Arap Moi & Another [2013] KESC 23 (KLR), Application No. 1 of 2013, on the proposition that adverse possession is normally proved through interrogation of evidence in a particular case and that the statutory provisions governing it in their breath and clarity, leave no room for conjecture .

9. The court said that for adverse possession to arise, there must be an apparent dispossession of the land owner, accompanied by animus possidendi and discontinued of possession as held in Sisto Wambugu v Kamau Njuguna [1983] KLR 172, that the occupation must be either with permission by/or dispossession, for the two concept cannot co-exist. The court said that a claimant must show that he entered the land as a trespasser as opposed to by consent of the owner, because occupation by consent or licence does not accrue any right of adverse possession as held in Samuel Miki Waweru v Jane Njeri Richu [2007] eKLR, Civil Appeal No. 122 of 2001. The court said that adverse possession or continuous occupation must not be broken for any temporary purposes as held in Francis Gicharu Kariri v Peter Njoroge Mairu [2005] eKLR, Civil Appeal No. 293 of 2002 . The court said that consent may be oral or written, but if terminated and the claimant does not leave, and the owner takes no step to evict him for over 12 years, such an applicant can sue for adverse possession.

10. Interruption according to the supreme court citing with approval Kiritu v Kairu [1986] KLR 211, occurs when the true owner assert his rights or when the claimant admits the right by taking of legal proceeding or by way of an effective entry.

11. Adverse possession may also step in an aborted sale as held in Okul & Another v Ondieki & 3 Others (Civil Appeal E041 of 2021) [2026] KECA 882 (KLR).

12. Applying the foregoing case law, what is before court is a plaint dated 29.9.2026 and not an originating summons .

13. Entry into the land is alleged to have occurred on 2000 through the authority of the 2nd ,3rd & 4th defendants as per paragraph 7 & 10 of the plaint.

14. Paragraph 14 of the plaint speaks to issuance of title to the 1st , 2nd & 3rd defendants . A copy of the title or extract of the register has not been attached to the supporting affidavit which is against orders 37 Rule 7 of Civil Procedure Rules.

15. In the notice of motion dated 29.9.2021 seeking for temporary orders, the supporting affidavit does not attach a title copy or copy of the records. The court is unable to know whether the parcel of land is registered in the name of the defendants or not.

16. A party who has admitted the entry into a disputed land was consensual or permissive, cannot alleged adverse possession without stating when he became a trespasser or intruder as opposed to permissive entry.

17. The photos attached to the affidavit are not in compliance with the law. No valuation report has been attached to show where developments are in relation to the suit property. Each of the claimants have not particularized how much of the land they occupy. There cannot in law be mass or wholesale claim of adverse possession. The exact size, acreage and boundaries of each claimant has to be particularised. See Kilimo Shutu & 6 others v Godfrey Karume [2017] eKLR, Civil Appeal No. 85 of 2015 .

18. The applicant have also invoke the wrong procedure. They filed a plaint instead of an originating summons. See Mariba v Mariba & another [2007] 1 EA 175 (CAK).

19. The upshot is that I find the notice of motion dated 29.9.2026 lacking merit.

20. Failure to attach the official search under order 37 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rule is fatal a held in Benson Mwangi Cherere v Charles Francis Kimindiri Wandarwa [2018] eKLR, ELC No. 234 of 2017 (OS) .

21. Bringing a claim by a plaint instead of a originating summons as provided by order 37 of Civil procedure rule makes the suit inconsiderately bad in law as held in in Wilson Kenyenga v. Joel Ombwori [2001] 1 KLR 103 (CAK).

22. In the instant case the plaintiffs were not faced with a plaint where they were the defendants so as to file a defendant & counterclaim as an exception as held in Jonathan O. Oyalo Wabala & Another v. Cornelius Otaya Okumu 1997 LLR 609 and in Gulam Mariam Noordin v. Julius Charo Karisa [2015] eKLR civil appeal no. 262 of 2016 and in Stephen Kaguku Mariba v. Kibe Mariba (Legal Representative of the Estate of Margaret Magiri - Deceased) & Another [2007] eKLR civil appeal no. 188 of 2002.

23. The upshot is I also find the suit incompetent . It is struck out with no orders as to cost.

24. File closed.

Signed , Dated and Delivered on this 9th day of November ,2026

….………………….

Hon .Justice C.K Nzili

Judge

In the presence of ;

Mr. Lumasai for the plaintiff

Julius - court assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder