Land law

Kihuro v Wamai & another [2026] KEELC 7595 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Appeal E093 of 2025
Judgment date
9 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court is the Appellant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 30th June 2026, brought under Article 159 of the Constitution, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 79G of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 42 Rule 27 and Order 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Applicant seeks an order staying or postponing delivery of the judgment in the appeal, which had been scheduled for 2nd July 2026, and leave to adduce additional evidence, particularly a…

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Having considered the Application, the Supporting Affidavit, the Respondents’ Replying Affidavits and the written submissions on record, I find that the sole issue arising for determination is: Whether the Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant the admission of additional evidence on appeal.

Paragraph 21 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELC APPEAL NO. E093 OF 2025

JOSEPHAT MWANGI KIHURO ...........................................APPELLANT/APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

PAUL JAMES WARUTERE WAMAI ................................................1ST RESPONDENT

EMBAKASI RANCHING COMPANY LIMITED ...............................2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

The Application

1. Before this Court is the Appellant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 30th June 2026, brought under Article 159 of the Constitution, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 79G of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 42 Rule 27 and Order 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Applicant seeks an order staying or postponing delivery of the judgment in the appeal, which had been scheduled for 2nd July 2026, and leave to adduce additional evidence, particularly a copy of the Transfer of Share or Stock Form dated 23rd November 1994, by way of affidavit or in such other manner as the Court may direct. He also seeks costs of the Application.

2. The Application is premised on the grounds set out on its face and supported by the affidavit of Josephat Mwangi Kihuro sworn on 30th June 2026. The Applicant contends that the 2nd Respondent, being the allocating authority and custodian of records relating to ownership and transfer of land within its scheme, failed to produce material documents concerning the suit properties during the proceedings before the trial court.

3. He maintains that the only documents available to him at the time included a share certificate, an original letter of allocation to the previous owner, a survey report and other documents produced during the trial. He asserts that the Transfer of Share or Stock Form was not available to him despite his efforts to obtain the same.

4. In his Supporting Affidavit, the Applicant deposes that the transfer form was lodged with the 2nd Respondent’s company secretary at the time of the alleged transfer of shares and that he was subsequently issued with a share certificate reflecting the transaction. He further states that sometime in 2020, during the pendency of the suit, he presented his ownership documents to the 2nd Respondent’s board for verification, but no report or documentation was issued to him. He maintains that the 2nd Respondent frustrated his efforts to obtain the relevant records notwithstanding its knowledge of the dispute between the parties.

5. The Applicant further deposes that on 30th June 2026, at approximately 11.30 a.m., he visited the 2nd Respondent’s offices to inspect records relating to other plots he owns within the same scheme. While examining the files presented to him, he discovered a copy of the Transfer of Share or Stock Form, which he photographed and annexed to his affidavit as JKM1. He avers that the document could not have been obtained before the conclusion of the trial because the 2nd Respondent had declined to provide him with the relevant records.

6. According to the Applicant, the document is directly relevant to the dispute as it relates to the alleged transaction between himself and Rosemary Wambui Macharia, whom he identifies as the previous owner of the suit properties. He contends that the document bears the signatures of the parties to the alleged transfer and the stamp of the 2nd Respondent, thereby lending credibility to his claim.

7. He maintains that its admission would have a material bearing on the determination of the appeal and assist the Court in resolving the dispute. He further asserts that he does not seek to fill gaps in his case or introduce a fresh case on appeal, and that the Respondents would suffer no prejudice if the Application were allowed. He therefore urges the Court to grant the orders sought.

The 1st Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

8. The Application is opposed by the 1st Respondent through his Replying Affidavit sworn on 2nd October 2026. He deposes that he is the registered proprietor of land parcels NAIROBI/BLOCK 136/8131 and NAIROBI/BLOCK 136/8134, formerly Plot Nos. P1526 and P1527, which were allocated to him by the 2nd Respondent in 1988. He maintains that his ownership was confirmed by the 2nd Respondent's witness during the trial and that the Applicant's alleged purchase of Plot Nos. P3050 and P3051 from Rosemary Wambui Macharia in 1994 was unsupported by a sale agreement, proof of payment or testimony from the alleged seller.

9. The 1st Respondent contends that the Applicant has failed to demonstrate that the proposed additional evidence could not have been obtained through reasonable diligence during the trial. He states that the Applicant was aware of the existence of the alleged transfer form since 1994, having purportedly signed it, and could have sought its production from the 2nd Respondent through appropriate court processes. He further disputes the allegation that the 2nd Respondent frustrated the Applicant's efforts to obtain the document, arguing that no correspondence, demand or other evidence of such efforts has been produced. He maintains that the Application, having been filed shortly before the scheduled delivery of judgment, is intended to delay the determination of the appeal.

10. The 1st Respondent further challenges the authenticity and evidential value of the proposed transfer form, observing that it is an uncertified photographic copy whose source and custodian have not been established. He points to alleged discrepancies in the consideration stated in the document, the absence of particulars of the witnesses and the lack of identification of the person who purportedly executed it on behalf of the 2nd Respondent. He further contends that the form relates to Plot Nos. P3050 and P3051, whereas the suit properties were originally Plot Nos. P1526 and P1527, and that no evidence has been presented linking the respective plots. He maintains that the document does not establish the alleged purchase or displace his registered ownership of the suit properties.

11. The 1st Respondent avers that admitting the document at this stage would necessitate reopening the evidence, examining its authenticity and recalling witnesses, thereby occasioning further delay and prejudice in a dispute pending since 2008. He urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs. In the alternative, should the Court be inclined to allow it, he requests an opportunity to challenge the document through cross-examination of the alleged seller and relevant officers of the 2nd Respondent, and to adduce further evidence, including certified records and a forensic document examiner's report.

The 2nd Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

12. The 2nd Respondent similarly opposes the Application through the Replying Affidavit of Walter Kigera Waireri, its director, sworn on 24th September 2026. He deposes that the 2nd Respondent, being the allocating authority, had previously examined the competing claims to the suit properties and confirmed from its allocation records that the properties belonged to the 1st Respondent. He maintains that the properties were allocated to the 1st Respondent on 10th October 1988 and could not subsequently have been allocated to the Applicant in 1994.

13. The deponent further disputes the authenticity and relevance of the proposed Transfer of Share or Stock Form, contending that it bears no demonstrated connection to the suit properties and that the Applicant has not explained why the document was not produced during the trial. He asserts that the Applicant has failed to establish that the evidence could not have been obtained earlier through reasonable diligence or that its admission would have any material probative value in the determination of the appeal.

14. The 2nd Respondent further contends that the Application is intended to delay the conclusion of the proceedings and prolong the Applicant's occupation of the suit properties, which it alleges commenced in 2015 in disregard of existing injunctive orders. It maintains that the Applicant has previously been offered an alternative plot, subject to verification of his ownership documents and compliance with the applicable allocation requirements, but has declined the offer. The 2nd Respondent consequently urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs to pave the way for determination of the pending appeal.

Submissions

15. The Application was canvassed by way of written submissions pursuant to the directions of this Court. The Applicant did not file written submissions. Both Respondents filed their respective submissions in opposition to the Application.

The 1st Respondent’s Submissions

16. The 1st Respondent filed written submissions dated 2nd October 2026, identifying the principal issue as whether the Applicant has satisfied the legal threshold for admission of additional evidence on appeal under Order 42 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Rules. He submits that the Applicant has failed to demonstrate that the proposed evidence could not have been obtained through reasonable diligence during the trial. He adopts the 2nd Respondent’s submissions and the authorities cited therein. He further relies on Section 26 of the Land Registration Act, arguing that the proposed Transfer of Share or Stock Form does not establish any connection between Plot Nos. P3050 and P3051 and the suit properties, NAIROBI/BLOCK 136/8131 and 136/8134, formerly Plot Nos. P1526 and P1527, or displace his registered ownership.

17. On the prayer for postponement of judgment, the 1st Respondent submits that no independent basis has been established to warrant the orders sought. He argues that Article 159 of the Constitution and Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act do not dispense with the requirements of Order 42 Rule 27, while Section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act is inapplicable to the present Application. He urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs or, alternatively, to afford him an opportunity to challenge the proposed evidence through cross-examination and production of further evidence should leave be granted.

The 2nd Respondent’s Submissions

18. The 2nd Respondent filed written submissions dated 1st October 2026, identifying the central issue as whether the Applicant has met the threshold for admission of additional evidence on appeal. Relying on Section 78 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 42 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the 2nd Respondent submits that admission of additional evidence is a discretionary and exceptional measure. It cites Ladd v Marshall [1954] 1 WLR 1489, Gachuiki & Another Vs Njenga & 2 Others [2025] KECA 451 (KLR), and Dorothy Nelima Wafula Vs Hellen Nekesa Nielsen & Paul Fredrick Nelson [2017] KECA 654 (KLR), on the requirements of reasonable diligence, material influence on the outcome and apparent credibility of the proposed evidence.

19. The 2nd Respondent further relies on Mzee Wanje & 93 Others Vs A.K. Saikwa (1982–1988) 1 KAR, Ringi Vs Seif & Another [2019] KEHC 12498 (KLR), and Mohamed Abdi Mahamud Vs Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamad & 3 Others [2018] eKLR, submitting that additional evidence should not be admitted to enable a party to make a fresh case on appeal, remedy omissions or fill gaps in the evidence presented before the trial court. It also cites Safe Cargo Limited Vs Embakasi Properties Limited & 2 Others [2019] eKLR on the requirement that an applicant demonstrate the difficulties encountered and the diligence exercised in attempting to obtain the evidence during the trial.

20. The 2nd Respondent submits that the Applicant has neither demonstrated reasonable efforts to obtain the alleged transfer form during the trial nor established its authenticity, relevance or connection to the suit properties. It maintains that admission of the document would not materially influence the determination of the appeal but would occasion prejudice to the Respondents and further delay litigation pending since 2008. It consequently urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.

Analysis and Determination

21. Having considered the Application, the Supporting Affidavit, the Respondents’ Replying Affidavits and the written submissions on record, I find that the sole issue arising for determination is: Whether the Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant the admission of additional evidence on appeal.

22. The law governing the admission of additional evidence on appeal is found in Section 78(1)(d) of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 42 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Section 78(1)(d) empowers an appellate court to take additional evidence or require such evidence to be taken. However, Order 42 Rule 27(1) provides that parties to an appeal are not entitled, as of right, to produce additional evidence. The Rule permits admission where the trial court refused to admit evidence which ought to have been admitted, or where the appellate court requires a document or witness to enable it to pronounce judgment, or for any other substantial cause.

23. The principles governing the exercise of this discretion were set out by the Supreme Court in Mohamed Abdi Mahamud Vs Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamad & 3 Others [2018] eKLR. The Court held that additional evidence must be directly relevant to the matter, capable of influencing the outcome, credible and not reasonably obtainable through due diligence during the trial. The Court further emphasised that such evidence should not be admitted to fill gaps or remedy omissions in a party's case and that the Court must consider the prejudice likely to arise from its admission. The discretion is to be exercised sparingly and with caution.

24. Similarly, in Mzee Wanje & 93 Others Vs A.K. Saikwa & Others (1982–1988) 1 KAR 462, the Court of Appeal reiterated the principles in Ladd Vs Marshall [1954] 1 WLR 1489, namely that the proposed evidence could not have been obtained through reasonable diligence during the trial, would probably have an important influence on the result and must be apparently credible. The Court cautioned against admitting additional evidence merely to enable a litigant to strengthen a case that had already been presented and determined.

25. Applying these principles to the present Application, the Applicant seeks to introduce a Transfer of Share or Stock Form dated 23rd November 1994, allegedly executed between himself and Rosemary Wambui Macharia. He maintains that the document was in the custody of the 2nd Respondent and was only discovered on 30th June 2026 when he visited its offices. His explanation is that the 2nd Respondent had previously declined to provide him with the relevant records notwithstanding his efforts to obtain them.

26. The Applicant's own deposition, however, indicates that he was aware of the alleged transfer and the existence of the form at the time the transaction took place in 1994. Although he attributes his inability to produce it to the 2nd Respondent's failure to release the records, he has not furnished correspondence, a formal request for production or any material demonstrating the steps taken to obtain the document during the trial. Neither has he shown that he sought the intervention of the trial court to compel its production. The fact that the document was allegedly held by the 2nd Respondent does not, without more, establish that it could not have been obtained through reasonable diligence. I am therefore not satisfied that the Applicant has adequately explained why the document was not produced before the trial court.

27. On the relevance of the proposed evidence, the transfer form relates to Plot Nos. P3050 and P3051, whereas the suit properties are NAIROBI/BLOCK 136/8131 and 136/8134, formerly Plot Nos. P1526 and P1527. The Applicant has not presented material establishing how the plots referred to in the transfer form relate to the suit properties. While the form may relate to an alleged transfer of shares between the Applicant and Rosemary Wambui Macharia, its connection to the specific properties forming the subject of the appeal has not been sufficiently demonstrated. In those circumstances, the Court is not persuaded that its admission would have a material influence on the determination of the appeal.

28. Further, the authenticity of the document is disputed by both Respondents. The Applicant has annexed a photographic copy of the form, but has not furnished confirmation from its alleged custodian or other supporting material addressing the concerns raised regarding its execution and contents. Although the Court is not called upon at this stage to make a conclusive finding on the genuineness of the document, the unresolved questions concerning its provenance and connection to the suit properties are relevant to the exercise of discretion to admit it as additional evidence.

29. The Court must also consider whether the proposed evidence is necessary for the determination of the appeal. The Applicant's claim before the trial court was founded on the alleged acquisition of the properties through Rosemary Wambui Macharia. The proposed transfer form is intended to support that very transaction, which was already the subject of evidence and determination before the trial court. In the absence of a satisfactory explanation for its non-production during the trial, admitting the document at this stage would afford the Applicant a further opportunity to supplement the evidence upon which his case was determined. This would be inconsistent with the principles governing the admission of additional evidence on appeal.

30. The Application was also brought when the appeal had already been canvassed and reserved for judgment. The dispute has been pending since 2008, and the admission of the contested document would potentially require further evidence concerning its authenticity and the circumstances of its execution, thereby prolonging the proceedings. Having weighed the proposed evidence against the explanation for its late production, its disputed relevance and the prejudice likely to arise from reopening the evidentiary record, I find that the Applicant has not established sufficient cause to warrant the exercise of this Court's discretion in his favour.

31. Consequently, the prayer for stay or postponement of delivery of judgment, being consequential upon the request to adduce additional evidence, is equally without merit. The appeal can be determined on the basis of the record and submissions already before the Court.

32. In the circumstances, I find that the Notice of Motion dated 30th June 2026 lacks merit and is for dismissal.

Final Disposition

33. Accordingly, the Court makes the following orders:

i. The Notice of Motion dated 30th June 2026 is hereby dismissed.

iii. The costs of the Application are awarded to the Respondents.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 9th day of

November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

N/A for the Appellants

Mr. Inyangu for the 1st Respondent

Ms. Irungu for the 2nd Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder