Land law

Bishoftu Plc v Ondoro [2026] KEELC 7611 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elcl Appeal E188 of 2026
Judgment date
9 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court is the Appellant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 24th August 2026, brought under Articles 22, 23, 40, 47, 48, 50 and 165 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, Section 15 of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap 301, the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Orders 40 Rules 1, 2, 3, 4, 42 Rule 6 and 51 of the Civil…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the Application, the affidavits filed in support of and in opposition thereto, the rival submissions and the authorities relied upon by the parties. The sole issue for determination is whether the Applicant has established a legal basis for the grant of the orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 24th August 2026.

Paragraph 22 →

Reasoning passage

The impugned orders were issued on 14th August 2026, while the present Application was filed on 24th August 2026, a period of ten days. I am satisfied that the Application was brought without unreasonable delay. On substantial loss, the Applicant alleges continued exclusion from the premises, inability to access stock and equipment, business interruption and loss of goodwill.

Paragraph 36 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELCL APPEAL NO. E188 OF 2026

BISHOFTU PLC ........................................................................ APPELLANT/APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

MARY ATIENO ONDORO ...................................................................... RESPONDENT

RULING

The Application

1. Before this Court is the Appellant/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 24th August 2026, brought under Articles 22, 23, 40, 47, 48, 50 and 165 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, Section 15 of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap 301, the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Orders 40 Rules 1, 2, 3, 4, 42 Rule 6 and 51 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, the applicable Judiciary Vacation Rules and all other enabling provisions of the law.

2. The Applicant seeks, principally, an order of stay of execution, implementation, enforcement and further proceedings arising from the orders issued by the Business Premises Rent Tribunal on 14th August 2026 in Nairobi BPRT Case No. E935 of 2026. It further seeks orders quashing or setting aside the said orders, reinstating the Tribunal's earlier orders of 11th August 2026 granting access to the premises, and restraining the Respondent from interfering with its quiet possession, use and occupation of the premises situated on Land Reference Number 1870/III/539, Matundu Lane, Westlands, pending the determination of the application, appeal or reference, as specified in the respective prayers. The Applicant also seeks leave to file and serve the Memorandum and Record of Appeal within such time as the Court may direct, police assistance in enforcing the orders, costs and other appropriate relief.

3. The Application is premised on the grounds that the Tribunal, having issued orders on 11th August 2026 restoring the Applicant's access to the premises, lacked jurisdiction to revisit those orders and effectively sit on appeal over its own decision. The Applicant contends that the subsequent orders of 14th August 2026 were issued in violation of the rules of natural justice, without affording it an opportunity to be heard. It further maintains that the Respondent's remedy lay in an appeal under Section 15 of Cap 301 and that the continued enforcement of the subsequent orders would occasion substantial loss and render the intended appeal nugatory.

4. The Application is supported by the affidavit of George Kariuki Njoroge, sworn on 24th August 2026, who describes himself as a director of the Applicant and a tenant of the suit premises. He depones that a dispute arose between the parties in August 2026 concerning interference with quiet possession and an attempt to terminate the tenancy without due process, prompting the Applicant to institute proceedings before the Business Premises Rent Tribunal. He avers that on 11th August 2026, the Tribunal issued orders directing the Respondent to reopen the premises and restore the Applicant's access, following which the Applicant resumed occupation and business operations. He annexed the tenancy agreement and the Tribunal's orders as GKN 1 and GKN 2, respectively.

5. The deponent further avers that the Respondent, being dissatisfied with the orders of 11th August 2026, returned to the Tribunal instead of pursuing an appeal before this Court. Consequently, on 14th August 2026, the Tribunal issued orders staying the enforcement of its earlier orders pending an inter partes hearing. He contends that the Tribunal had become functus officio and lacked jurisdiction to entertain the subsequent application, particularly without affording the Applicant an opportunity to be heard. He maintains that the subsequent orders were therefore unlawful and ought to be set aside. He annexed the orders of 14th August 2026 as GKN 3.

6. He further depones that the subsequent orders have deprived the Applicant of access to its business premises, stock and equipment, resulting in loss of daily income, goodwill and customer relationships, financial distress and the risk of permanent loss of the tenancy. He maintains that the Applicant has continued to meet its rental obligations and that the Respondent would suffer no prejudice if the orders sought were granted. He consequently urges the Court to grant the relief sought to preserve the Applicant's interests pending the hearing and determination of the appeal.

The Response

7. The Application is opposed through the Replying Affidavit of Mary Atieno Ondoro, sworn on 30th September 2026. She depones that she is the registered proprietor and landlord of the premises known as Town House, situated on Land Reference Number 1870/III/539, Matundu Lane, Westlands, and annexes a copy of the title as MAO1.

8. She avers that the orders issued by the Business Premises Rent Tribunal on 11th August 2026 were expressly interim orders, directing her to unlock the premises and restore the Applicant's access pending an inter partes hearing scheduled for 26th August 2026. She maintains that the subsequent orders of 14th August 2026 merely stayed the enforcement of those mandatory orders pending the scheduled hearing and did not constitute a final determination of the dispute.

9. The Respondent disputes the Applicant's contention that the Tribunal became functus officio upon issuing the orders of 11th August 2026. She maintains that the Tribunal retained jurisdiction to reconsider its interlocutory orders while the proceedings remained pending and that Section 15 of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap 301, did not preclude such reconsideration.

10. She further contends that the Applicant has failed to demonstrate substantial loss or offer security as required under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules. According to her, the allegations of business interruption, loss of goodwill and financial loss are unsupported by cogent evidence. She also maintains that the prayers seeking to quash the Tribunal's orders, reinstate the earlier orders and restrain her from interfering with the premises amount to substantive appellate and injunctive relief which cannot properly be granted through the present interlocutory application.

11. The Respondent further avers that the premises are residential in nature and not controlled business premises within the meaning of Cap 301. She contends that the Applicant failed to disclose this material fact when obtaining the initial mandatory orders from the Tribunal. In support of her position, she annexes photographs of the premises and notices identifying Matundu Villas as a strictly residential area, collectively marked MAO4.

12. She maintains that the Applicant approached the Court without disclosing the true nature and use of the premises and that the Tribunal's jurisdiction over the underlying tenancy dispute remains contested.

13. The Respondent further depones that the proceedings before the Tribunal remain pending and that the Applicant had been directed to attend the inter partes hearing scheduled for 26th August 2026. She states that she subsequently filed a Chamber Summons dated 28th August 2026, seeking to challenge the interim orders issued by this Court, which had stayed enforcement of the Tribunal's orders of 14th August 2026. She maintains that the Applicant's application was improperly brought during the Court vacation without complying with the prescribed procedure and that the relief sought would effectively determine the question of possession before the substantive dispute is heard. She consequently urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.

Submissions

The Applicant's Submissions

14. The Application was canvassed by way of written submissions. The Applicant identified three issues for determination, namely, whether the Respondent's challenge to the Tribunal's jurisdiction was properly before this Court at the interlocutory stage; whether the circumstances in which the orders of 14th August 2026 were issued warranted the Court's intervention; and whether the Applicant had satisfied the threshold for interim relief.

15. It submitted that the question concerning the residential character of the premises was pending determination before the Tribunal and ought not to be determined in the present application. It further argued that although the Tribunal retained jurisdiction over its interlocutory orders, it improperly stayed the earlier mandatory orders without affording the Applicant an opportunity to be heard, notwithstanding that an inter partes hearing had been scheduled for 26th August 2026.

16. On the threshold for stay, the Applicant submitted that its continued exclusion from the premises occasioned substantial loss through disruption of business operations, loss of goodwill and inability to access its equipment, while the Application had been filed without unreasonable delay. It maintained that the nature of the dispute justified the Court's discretion on security and that the balance of justice favoured restoration of access pending appeal.

17. In support of its submissions, the Applicant relied on Kenya Towers Limited Vs Omboga & 7 Others [2025] KECA 686 (KLR), Republic Vs Chairman, Business Premises Rent Tribunal & 3 Others ex parte Mobitel Express Limited [2018] eKLR, Primrose Management Limited Vs Chairman of the Business Premises Rent Tribunal, Nairobi & Another [2015] eKLR, RWW Vs EKW [2019] eKLR and Butt Vs Rent Restriction Tribunal [1982] KLR 417.

The Respondent's Submissions

18. The Respondent identified several issues for determination, principally whether there was a competent appeal before this Court; whether the Applicant had satisfied the requirements for stay under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules; whether the Tribunal was functus officio when it issued the orders of 14th August 2026; whether those orders amounted to a final reversal of the earlier orders; and whether the Applicant was entitled to the mandatory and injunctive relief sought.

19. The Respondent also raised the alleged material non-disclosure concerning the residential character of the premises, the propriety of combining distinct remedies in one application and the question of costs. She submitted that no Memorandum of Appeal had been filed, that the Tribunal's orders of 11th August 2026 were interlocutory and that the subsequent orders merely stayed their enforcement pending an inter partes hearing. She further argued that the Application did not comply with the prescribed vacation procedure.

20. The Respondent submitted that the Applicant had neither demonstrated substantial loss nor offered security for the due performance of the orders and had failed to establish a basis for the mandatory and injunctive relief sought. She maintained that the premises were residential, that the Tribunal's jurisdiction remained contested and that granting the relief sought would substantially determine the parties' rights before the underlying dispute was heard.

21. In support of her position, she relied on Butt Vs Rent Restriction Tribunal [1982] KLR 417, Kenya Shell Limited Vs Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1982–1988] 1 KAR 1018, Monalisa Hotel Limited Vs Elizabeth Habin Telephone & Another [2020] eKHC 8036 (KLR), Telkom Kenya Limited Vs John Ochanda [2014] eKLR, Waithira v Mwangi [2025] KEHC 12232 (KLR), Giella Vs Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358, Mrao Limited Vs First American Bank of Kenya Limited & 2 Others [2003] KLR 125, Kenya Breweries Limited & Another Vs Washington O. Okeyo [2002] eKLR, Owners of the Motor Vessel “Lillian S” Vs Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1, Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya Vs Kenya Airways Limited & 3 Others [2015] eKLR and Wambua Vs Wambua & 4 Others [2023] KECA 1180 (KLR). She urged the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.

Analysis and Determination

22. I have considered the Application, the affidavits filed in support of and in opposition thereto, the rival submissions and the authorities relied upon by the parties. The sole issue for determination is whether the Applicant has established a legal basis for the grant of the orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 24th August 2026.

23. The Respondent has challenged the competence of the Application on the ground that no Memorandum of Appeal has been filed before this Court. This objection must be considered first, as the Applicant invokes the appellate jurisdiction of this Court to seek a stay of the Tribunal's orders and injunctive relief pending appeal. Section 15(1) of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap 301, provides as follows:

“Any party to a reference aggrieved by any determination or order of a Tribunal made therein may, within thirty days after the date of such determination or order, appeal to the Environment and Land Court: Provided that the Environment and Land Court may, where it is satisfied that there is sufficient reason for so doing, extend the said period of thirty days upon such conditions, if any, as it may think fit.”

24. Section 15(4) of the Act further provides that the procedure relating to civil appeals from subordinate courts to the Environment and Land Court shall govern appeals under the Act. Order 42 Rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that: “Every appeal to the High Court shall be in the form of a memorandum of appeal signed in the same manner as a pleading.”

25. Further, Order 42 Rule 6(6), which governs temporary injunctions pending appeal, provides that: “Notwithstanding anything contained in subrule (1) of this rule the High Court shall have power in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction to grant a temporary injunction on such terms as it thinks just provided the procedure for instituting an appeal from a subordinate court or tribunal has been complied with.”

26. In In Glaxo Smithkline Pharmaceutical (K) Limited & Another Vs Joseph Mulinge Kiilo [2021] eKLR, the Court held that the exercise of appellate jurisdiction under Order 42 Rule 6(1) and (6) presupposes the existence of an appeal instituted in accordance with the prescribed procedure. The Court distinguished an application for stay pending appeal from an application for enlargement of time to appeal, holding that whereas the former requires an instituted appeal, the latter may be entertained before a Memorandum of Appeal is filed, provided sufficient grounds are established. Similarly, in Said Hamisi Kazimzuri Vs North Coast Development Company Limited [2022] eKLR, the Environment and Land Court reiterated that compliance with the prescribed procedure for instituting an appeal is a prerequisite to the grant of an injunction pending appeal.

27. In the present matter, the Respondent has specifically challenged the absence of a Memorandum of Appeal from the Court record. The Applicant has not produced a filed Memorandum of Appeal or demonstrated compliance with Order 42 Rule 1. Indeed, prayer 8 of the Notice of Motion seeks liberty to file and serve the Memorandum and Record of Appeal within such time as the Court may direct.

28. The designation of the proceedings as ELC Appeal No. E188 of 2026 does not, of itself, constitute the institution of an appeal. Consequently, the Applicant has not established the procedural foundation necessary for the exercise of this Court's appellate jurisdiction to grant stay or an injunction pending appeal.

29. The prayer seeking liberty to file and serve the Memorandum and Record of Appeal must be considered separately. Although the absence of a filed appeal does not, in itself, preclude an application for enlargement of time, the exercise of that discretion under Section 15(1) of Cap 301 requires sufficient reason.

30. In the present case, the Notice of Motion was filed within the statutory period for lodging an appeal. However, no Memorandum of Appeal has been placed before the Court, and the Applicant has not demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant an extension of time. The general prayer for liberty to file the Memorandum and Record of Appeal within such time as the Court may direct cannot, without a sufficient factual basis, substitute for compliance with the prescribed appellate procedure. I therefore find no basis for granting that prayer.

31. The Court has also considered the nature of the orders giving rise to the present Application. On 11th August 2026, the Tribunal issued a mandatory injunction directing the Respondent to unlock the premises and restore the Applicant's access within ninety minutes of service. The order expressly provided that it was to operate pending the inter partes hearing and determination of the application and reference. On 14th August 2026, following the Respondent's application dated 13th August 2026, the Tribunal stayed the execution, implementation and enforcement of the earlier orders pending an inter partes hearing scheduled for 26th August 2026.

32. The Applicant contends that by issuing the subsequent orders, the Tribunal became functus officio and improperly reversed its earlier decision. However, the orders of 11th August 2026 were interlocutory and did not finally determine the dispute. The orders of 14th August 2026 did not set aside or vacate the earlier orders but temporarily suspended their enforcement pending an inter partes hearing. In Telkom Kenya Limited Vs John Ochanda [2014] eKLR, the Court of Appeal explained that the doctrine of functus officio does not bar every further engagement by a court with proceedings before it but prevents merit-based reconsideration after final determination. Since the Tribunal had not finally determined the application or reference, the doctrine did not preclude its consideration of the subsequent interlocutory application.

33. The Applicant further complains that the orders of 14th August 2026 were issued without affording it an opportunity to be heard. The record, however, shows that both sets of orders were issued at the interlocutory stage and that an inter partes hearing had been scheduled for 26th August 2026. The Applicant approached this Court on 24th August 2026, before that scheduled hearing.

34. Although the Applicant complains that the suspension of the earlier orders deprived it of the benefit of those orders without a prior hearing, the subsequent orders did not finally determine the parties' rights or dispose of the proceedings before the Tribunal. Whether the circumstances justified the issuance of the subsequent interim orders is a question that may properly arise in competent appellate proceedings. It does not, however, dispense with the requirement that the Court's appellate jurisdiction be properly invoked.

35. As regards stay of execution, Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules provides as follows:

“No order for stay of execution shall be made under subrule (1) unless—

a) the court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and

b) such security as the court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the applicant.”

36. The impugned orders were issued on 14th August 2026, while the present Application was filed on 24th August 2026, a period of ten days. I am satisfied that the Application was brought without unreasonable delay. On substantial loss, the Applicant alleges continued exclusion from the premises, inability to access stock and equipment, business interruption and loss of goodwill.

37. However, beyond these assertions, no documentary evidence has been placed before the Court establishing the nature or extent of the alleged business losses. The Applicant has also not proposed security, although the Court retains discretion to determine the appropriate form of security. In Kenya Shell Limited Vs Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1982–1988] 1 KAR 1018, the Court of Appeal emphasised the centrality of substantial loss in applications for stay of execution. The Applicant has not sufficiently established that requirement.

38. The prayers seeking reinstatement of the orders of 11th August 2026 and restraint against interference with the Applicant's occupation must equally be considered in light of their practical effect. The Tribunal's earlier orders compelled the Respondent to restore access to the premises, with police assistance in enforcement. Reinstating those orders would therefore require the Respondent to permit occupation notwithstanding that the nature of the tenancy, its alleged expiry and the Tribunal's jurisdiction remain contested. The Applicant relies on the tenancy agreement, while the Respondent maintains that the premises are residential and has exhibited title documents and photographs in support of her position. These competing claims have not been conclusively determined in the proceedings before the Tribunal.

39. In Kenya Breweries Limited & Another Vs Washington O. Okeyo [2002] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that a mandatory injunction at an interlocutory stage requires special circumstances and a clear case. The present dispute raises contested questions concerning the character of the premises, the subsistence of the tenancy and the Applicant's entitlement to continued occupation. The Applicant has not established a sufficiently clear basis for the mandatory restoration of possession sought. Neither has it demonstrated compliance with the procedural requirement under Order 42 Rule 6(6) for the grant of an injunction pending appeal.

40. The Applicant also seeks orders quashing or setting aside the Tribunal's orders of 14th August 2026. Such relief would require the Court to determine the validity of those orders in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction. In the absence of a duly instituted appeal, the Applicant cannot obtain substantive appellate relief through the present interlocutory Motion. The dispute concerning whether the premises constitute controlled business premises under Cap 301 likewise remains undetermined, and the material presented does not warrant a final determination of that question in these proceedings.

41. Having considered the Application, the applicable statutory provisions and the evidence presented, I find that the Applicant has not demonstrated compliance with the procedure for instituting an appeal. Further, no sufficient grounds have been established for enlargement of time or for granting the interim and substantive relief sought. The Notice of Motion dated 24th August 2026 therefore fails.

Final Disposition

42. In the result, I make the following orders:

a. The Notice of Motion dated 24th August 2026 is hereby dismissed.

b. The interim orders issued by this Court on 25th August 2026 are hereby discharged.

c. The costs of the Application shall be borne by the Applicant.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 9th day of

November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Ms. Mwikuyu for the Applicant

Ms. Swaka for the Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder