Employment law

Gichiu v Abyssinia Iron Steel Mills Limited [2026] KEELRC 2379 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Machakos
Case number
Appeal E031 of 2025
Judgment date
7 August 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbarũ

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The appeal succeeded. The court reviewed the trial judgment, found that the appellant was working for the respondent and was injured in the workplace accident, apportioned liability equally at 50% to each party, upheld general damages of Ksh. 300,000 subject to that apportionment, and awarded the appellant 50% of the costs of the appeal.

Supporting judgment passages

In the circumstances, the appeal lodged by the appellant is with merit. There was an employment relationship, and the appellant suffered injury and paid damages. Liability is hereby apportioned at 50%:50% on the award of damages at Ksh. 300,000, and therefore review the judgment in Mavoko MCCC No. 415 of 2017. Quantum assessed shall reflect the reviewed liability ratio.

Passage 62 →

50% of the costs of the appeal awarded to the appellant.

Passage 63 →
Issue 1Whether the appellant established that he was working for the respondent and suffered the pleaded workplace injury, notwithstanding the absence of formal employment records.

Held. Decided. The appellant's evidence was accepted: the respondent assigned him work lifting metal rods, and he was injured while performing it. The respondent failed to produce shop-floor records that could establish who was authorised to be present or rebut the appellant's account. The trial magistrate therefore erred by rejecting the claim solely on the employment-relationship question rather than addressing the work-injury claim as a whole.

Ratio. Where a claimant presents evidence that the respondent assigned work and that injury occurred on the shop floor, the respondent bears a duty to produce the necessary shop-floor records to clarify the claimant's status; failure to do so permits the claimant's evidence to be accepted on the facts presented.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

The learned magistrate erred in not addressing the claim by the appellant as a whole and solely relied on the existence or non-existence of an employment relationship in the context of the work injury claim.

Passage 40 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

In the given circumstances, under work relations as presented by the appellant, being present and having been injured, upon his claim, the respondent had a duty to submit the necessary shop-floor records to confirm the status. This was not done. The evidence by the appellant is taken as presented; the respondent assigned him duties, and while at it, he suffered injury and broke 5 teeth which had to be removed.

Passage 37 →

The learned magistrate erred in not addressing the claim by the appellant as a whole and solely relied on the existence or non-existence of an employment relationship in the context of the work injury claim.

Passage 40 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

In the given circumstances, under work relations as presented by the appellant, being present and having been injured, upon his claim, the respondent had a duty to submit the necessary shop-floor records to confirm the status. This was not done. The evidence by the appellant is taken as presented; the respondent assigned him duties, and while at it, he suffered injury and broke 5 teeth which had to be removed.

Passage 37 →
Issue 2Whether the respondent was liable for negligence and breach of its safety duty, and whether the appellant contributed to the injury.

Held. Decided. The respondent owed the appellant a common-law duty to ensure safety while he was on duty and failed to provide safety or adequate protective gear or precautions for the metal-rod-lifting work. The appellant also had a duty to protect his own safety. Both parties were at fault, so liability was apportioned equally, 50% to the respondent and 50% to the appellant.

Ratio. An employer must take reasonable care to avoid exposing workers to unnecessary risk, including providing necessary safety devices, gear, or protective clothing. An employee must also take reasonable precautions for personal safety. Where both failures contribute to the injury, liability may be apportioned by causation and blameworthiness.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

Was the respondent negligent and was there a breach of statutory duty?

Passage 41 →

In this regard, each party at fault, one failing to ensure the common law duty of care and the other exposing himself to injury, on both causation and capability, a 50%:50% liability ought to have applied in this case.

Passage 55 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

In this case, the court finds that the respondent owed a common-law duty of care to ensure the appellant's safety while the appellant was on duty. Whereas the employee was under a duty to ensure his own safety and health and avoid acts or omissions leading to injury pursuant to section 13 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, 2007.

Passage 46 →

In this regard, each party at fault, one failing to ensure the common law duty of care and the other exposing himself to injury, on both causation and capability, a 50%:50% liability ought to have applied in this case.

Passage 55 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

On the shop floor, the employer has a duty to take reasonable care for the safety of employees in all the circumstances, so as not to expose them to unnecessary risk. Where then an employee is injured simply because the employer has not taken such reasonable measures to provide the necessary safety devices, gear or protective clothing, it is sufficient and, in general, satisfactory to say that the employer has not fulfilled its duty.

Passage 44 →

In this case, the court finds that the respondent owed a common-law duty of care to ensure the appellant's safety while the appellant was on duty. Whereas the employee was under a duty to ensure his own safety and health and avoid acts or omissions leading to injury pursuant to section 13 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, 2007.

Passage 46 →

In this regard, each party at fault, one failing to ensure the common law duty of care and the other exposing himself to injury, on both causation and capability, a 50%:50% liability ought to have applied in this case.

Passage 55 →
Issue 3What general damages should be awarded for the appellant's dental injury.

Held. Decided. The court held that Ksh. 300,000 was a fair and reasonable assessment for the injury, subject to the 50:50 liability apportionment. The evidence supported loss of one central incisor tooth, with pain in the jaws and inability to chew, rather than loss of two teeth.

Ratio. No distinct ratio identified in the judgment. The court made an evaluative assessment of quantum from the medical evidence and comparator awards but did not state a distinct governing legal rule for the amount.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

On the quantum assessed, it is not in dispute that the respondent suffered injury to his 5 teeth. He was assessed by a dentist, Charles Mwiti and a medical report was issued dated 6 September 2016. It was noted that he had injuries to the mouth and lost one central incisor tooth. He had pain in the upper and lower jaws with an inability to chew food.

Passage 56 →

The assessment by the learned magistrate on the award of Ksh. 300,000 is fair and reasonable subject to the 50%:50% apportionment of liability.

Passage 61 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The learned magistrate analysed the facts and the referenced cases and held that, had the matter been proved, an award of Ksh. 300,000 would have been issued for the loss of two teeth. However, the appellant lost a single tooth.

Passage 58 →

The assessment by the learned magistrate on the award of Ksh. 300,000 is fair and reasonable subject to the 50%:50% apportionment of liability.

Passage 61 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The learned magistrate erred in law and fact in not giving sufficient consideration to the weight of the evidence by the appellant.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the trial magistrate erred by finding that the appellant had not proved an employment relationship with the respondent and therefore declining to determine the work-injury claim; whether the respondent breached its duty of care and statutory duty…

Material facts

Charles Mwiti Gichiu alleged that on 22 February 2016, while assigned to carry metal rods at the respondent’s premises with another worker, the other worker dropped his end without notice. The rods allegedly jerked upwards and struck the appellant’s mouth. He…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS

APPEAL NO. E031 OF 2025

CHARLES MWITI GICHIU APPELLANT

VERSUS

ABYSSINIA IRON STEEL MILLS LIMITED RESPONDENT

[Being an appeal from the judgment of Hon. Grace Omodho delivered on 29 April 2025 in Machakos MCCC No. 415 of 2017]

JUDGMENT

The appeal arises from the judgment delivered on 29 April 2025 in Machakos MCCC No. 415 of 2017. The appellant is seeking that the judgment be set aside on the grounds:

1) The learned magistrate erred in law and fact in not giving sufficient consideration to the weight of the evidence by the appellant.

2) The learned magistrate reached a wrong decision in law and fact contrary to the weight of the evidence.

3) The learned magistrate erred in law and fact by finding that there was no sufficient evidence to support that the appellant was an employee of the respondent, a fact which is contrary to the weight of the evidence.

The background to the appeal is a claim filed by the appellant before the trial court. His case was that the respondent employed him and agreed to take all reasonable precautions for safety during work, and hence not to expose the appellant to the risk of damage, injury, or loss. There was an agreement that the respondent would ensure the provision of adequate and suitable plant and appliances to enable the appellant to carry out his work safely and in accordance with a safe system of work. However, on 22 February 2016, the appellant, while at work, the respondent provided an unsafe working system and while carrying metal rods in the company premises, a fellow worker recklessly and without notice dropped his end of the metallic rods, making the end the appellant was holding jerk up, hitting him on the mouth; as a result, he sustained serious injuries. He suffered loss, damage and pain due to the negligence, carelessness, breach of statutory duty and breach of contract by the respondent.

The appellant’s case was also that the breaches arose from being placed in an unsafe system of work, failure to warn him of the dangers and being exposed to dangers which the respondent ought to have addressed. He thus suffered severe pain and bleeding and 5 broken teeth which had to be removed. He thus claimed the following:

a) General damages.

b) Special damages for the medical report Ksh. 3,000.

c) Costs of the suit plus interest.

In reply, the respondent denied the appellant's allegations and stated that no accident was reported on the premises on 22 February 2016. The appellant did not sustain any injuries while working for the respondent as alleged. The appellant was neither denied a safe working environment nor exposed to injury, loss, or damage, as alleged.

Without prejudice, the response was that, while at work, the appellant exposed himself to injury by failing to wear the protective gear provided. He failed to take proper precautions and pay attention to his work by engaging in meaningless chitchat with others instead of concentrating on his work. The appellant exposed himself by taking the mobile phone while working in a busy industry. The claims made are not justified.

In the judgment, the learned trial magistrate held that the claim that the appellant was injured while working for the respondent lacked support of any employment relationship. The case of being injured while at work did not arise. The alleged injury on 22 February 2016 is not probable because a hospital visit was not made until the next day. Such serious injuries should have been addressed immediately, but they were not. Hence, without establishing the employment relationship, the trial court could not determine the claims. The case was dismissed with costs to the respondent.

On appeal, the appellant submitted that the judgment of the trial court should be set aside on the finding that there was no employment relationship, and hence the court failed to assess the claims made by the appellant. To establish whether there is an employment relationship, the court in Wasilwa v Judicial Service Commission; Kenya Union of Domestic, Hotels, Educational Institutions, Hospital and Allied Workers & others (interested parties) Petition E237 of 2023 held that one must establish the existence or non-existence of an oral or written contract of service. The provision of a service to a real or legal person and receipt of wage or salary for the service.

In this case, the appellant proved that the respondent employed him at the time of the accident

on 22 February 2016. The respondent did not challenge the evidence presented in court. The employer had the duty to produce work records, which it failed to do.

In his evidence in chief, the appellant testified to the fact that he was injured while working for the respondent. His wages were paid in cash, and the employer, the respondent, kept the records. There were no statutory dues paid for the benefits of the appellant to assist in corroborating his evidence. The injuries suffered by the appellant align with the medical report and evidence. The respondent did not call any evidence or produce gate logs, CCTV coverage or medical records. The claims made should be assessed and awarded as pleaded.

The respondent did not file any written submissions on the appeal.

Determination

This is a first appeal. The court is required to review the record, reassess the findings, and make a conclusion. However, consider that the trial court had a chance to see and hear the witnesses and hence make this provision.

The appellant’s case is premised on assertions that on 22 February 2016, while working for the respondent, he suffered a work injury. He does not define the nature of his employment save that he was carrying metal rods with another unnamed employee.

The appellant denied the employment relationship. There are no work records produced as required under section 10(6) and (7) of the Employment Act.

It is the word of the appellant claiming to be an employee against the respondent, sued as the employer.

It is important to review the history of work injury claims, such as the one filed by the appellant before the trial court on 27 March 2017.

At the time of filing the claim, pending was Supreme Court Petition No. 4 of 2019 – Law Society of Kenya v Attorney General and COTU following judgment of the Court of Appeal delivered on 17 November 2017 allowing in part Civil Appeal No. 133 of 2011 Attorney General v Law Society of Kenya & another [2017] KECA 176 (KLR).

The matter pending before the Court of Appeal related to a High Court Judgment delivered on 4 March 2009 in H.C. Petition 185 of 2008 Law Society of Kenya v Attorney General & another. The High Court declared the various provisions of the Work Injury Benefits Act unconstitutional, including the hearing of claims before the Director.

Within this background, the appellant asserts he was injured while at work with the respondent on 22 February 2016. The judgment before the High Court in Petition 185 of 2008 applied to his case, as it was the subsisting lawful order of the court.

Work injury connotes the presence of a claimant at the shop floor. One may be an employee, a casual employee, or, as the case may be, be found present on the shop floor at the time of the accident.

Whereas the appellant claimed to have been employed by the respondent, he did not state in the pleadings his position or terms and conditions or in his evidence the nature of his employment. The respondent, too, did not keep work records to confirm the persons permitted to be present on the shop floor on 22 February 2016, to justify that the appellant was not among those lifting metal rods and hence was injured.

In the given circumstances, under work relations as presented by the appellant, being present and having been injured, upon his claim, the respondent had a duty to submit the necessary shop-floor records to confirm the status. This was not done. The evidence by the appellant is taken as presented; the respondent assigned him duties, and while at it, he suffered injury and broke 5 teeth which had to be removed.

While on the shop floor, the employer, such as the respondent, had a legal duty to protect employees and persons assigned work, including those involved in lifting metal rods. This is the purpose of the Work Injury Benefits Act: to secure all persons in the workspace, such as the appellant.

The appellant claimed that he suffered injury due to the respondent's negligence and breach of contract and statutory duty. The respondent failed to take measures to ensure his safety while at work.

The learned magistrate erred in not addressing the claim by the appellant as a whole and solely relied on the existence or non-existence of an employment relationship in the context of the work injury claim.

Was the respondent negligent and was there a breach of statutory duty?

In the case of Makala Mailu Mumende v Nyali Golf County Club [1991] KLR 13, the court held:

… no employer in the position of the defendant would warrant the total continuous security of an employee engaged in the kind of work the plaintiff was engaged in, but inherently dangerous. An employer is expected to reasonably take steps in respect of the employment to lessen danger or injury to the employee. It is the employer’s responsibility to ensure a safe working place for its employees.

On the shop floor, the employer has a duty to take reasonable care for the safety of employees in all the circumstances, so as not to expose them to unnecessary risk. Where then an employee is injured simply because the employer has not taken such reasonable measures to provide the necessary safety devices, gear or protective clothing, it is sufficient and, in general, satisfactory to say that the employer has not fulfilled its duty.

In this case, the appellant testified that he was allocated duties in lifting metal rods. He was not provided with any safety or adequate protective gear. No precautions were put in place or brought to the employee's attention. The accident and injury to the appellant, as the employee, caused him injury, pain and damage.

In this case, the court finds that the respondent owed a common-law duty of care to ensure the appellant's safety while the appellant was on duty. Whereas the employee was under a duty to ensure his own safety and health and avoid acts or omissions leading to injury pursuant to section 13 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, 2007.

Section 13(1)(a) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act, which provides;

13(1) Every employee shall, while at the workplace: -

(a) Ensure his own safety and health and that of other persons who may be affected by his acts or omissions at the workplace.

The rationale is that an employer cannot keep watch over an employee continuously to undertake his duties, as held in Amalgamated Saw Mills versus David K. Kariuki [2016] eKLR;

An employer cannot babysit an employee, especially for manual tasks that require no special training or supervision. He must work and at the same time take precautions on

his own security and safety. …

Therefore, in apportioning liability, the trial court ought to have considered the above and the principles in the case of Peter Bernard Makau versus Prime Steel Limited [2018] eKLR that;

It is true that there are two possible ways a court can apportion liability for negligence. One is on causation; secondly, on blameworthiness. The appellant sued the respondent for negligence arising from a breach of the care owed as a term of employment; a trial court should make clear what the appellant's negligence entails: Does it involve the events that caused the injury or the severity of the injury? These questions must be answered if no provisions exist in the statute.

In this regard, each party at fault, one failing to ensure the common law duty of care and the other exposing himself to injury, on both causation and capability, a 50%:50% liability ought to have applied in this case.

On the quantum assessed, it is not in dispute that the respondent suffered injury to his 5 teeth. He was assessed by a dentist, Charles Mwiti and a medical report was issued dated 6 September 2016. It was noted that he had injuries to the mouth and lost one central incisor tooth. He had pain in the upper and lower jaws with an inability to chew food.

On this evidence, it is clear that the major injury was to the central incisor tooth. At the trial, both counsels made submissions relying on various authorities on the award of damages for pain and suffering.

The learned magistrate analysed the facts and the referenced cases and held that, had the matter been proved, an award of Ksh. 300,000 would have been issued for the loss of two teeth. However, the appellant lost a single tooth.

In Moiz Motors Limited & another v Harun Ngethe Wanjiru [2021] KEHC 8702 (KLR) and in Maintenance Ltd & another v W A (A minor suing through next friend and father S K H [2015] eKLR, the claimants had multiple injuries including loss of a tooth and were awarded Ksh. 1,000,000.

In Watu Credit Co Limited v Matere [2025] KEHC 2608 (KLR), in a case of complex multiple fractures to the head and teeth, an award of Ksh. 750,000 was made. In Kavavu v Muli [2026] KEHC 11214 (KLR) and Limiri v Murungi [2026] KEHC 10067 (KLR) for various injuries including loss of a tooth, the court awarded Ksh. 400,000.

The assessment by the learned magistrate on the award of Ksh. 300,000 is fair and reasonable subject to the 50%:50% apportionment of liability.

In the circumstances, the appeal lodged by the appellant is with merit. There was an employment relationship, and the appellant suffered injury and paid damages. Liability is hereby apportioned at 50%:50% on the award of damages at Ksh. 300,000, and therefore review the judgment in Mavoko MCCC No. 415 of 2017. Quantum assessed shall reflect the reviewed liability ratio.

50% of the costs of the appeal awarded to the appellant.

Delivered in open court this 7 day of August 2026

M. MBARŨ

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Court Assistant: Kemboi

……………………………………………… and …………………………………..……… 

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder