REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLMISC E342 OF 2025
ADMASS VENTURES LIMITED ............................................................1ST APPLICANT
ERMIAS AYENEKULU BETEMARIAM ................................................2ND APPLICANT
KIDIST ADMASS AMBIE .....................................................................3RD APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
SAIF PROPERTIES LIMITED.................................................................RESPONDENT
RULING
The Application
1. Before this Court for determination is the Applicants’ Notice of Motion dated 30th May 2026, brought pursuant to Section 80 and Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Applicants seek, inter alia, the review, variation and/or setting aside of the orders contained in paragraphs 10(i) and 10(ii) of the Ruling delivered by Hon. Justice Mohammed N. Kullow on 29th April 2026, on the ground that the said orders contradict the reasoning and findings of the Court and thereby disclose an error apparent on the face of the record.
2. Specifically, the Applicants seek orders substituting the impugned disposition with orders dismissing the Respondent’s Preliminary Objection dated 16th January 2026, allowing the Applicants’ Preliminary Objection dated 3rd February 2026, and striking out the Respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 16th January 2026 seeking to set aside the arbitral award. They further pray that their Chamber Summons dated 27th October 2025, seeking recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award dated 12th February 2025, be set down for hearing and determination on a priority basis, together with an order for costs.
3. The Application is premised on the grounds that, in its reasoning, the Court found that it had jurisdiction to entertain the application for recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award, thereby rejecting the Respondent’s objection to its jurisdiction. The Applicants further contend that the Court found the Respondent’s application to set aside the award to have been filed outside the statutory period prescribed under Section 35(3) of the Arbitration Act, and consequently held that it lacked jurisdiction to entertain the same. Notwithstanding those findings, the Court, in its final disposition, allowed the Respondent’s Preliminary Objection, dismissed the Applicants’ Preliminary Objection and allowed the Respondent’s application to set aside the award. The Applicants maintain that this contradiction constitutes a self-evident error apparent on the face of the record, warranting review.
4. The Application is supported by the affidavit of Kidist Admass Ambie, the 3rd Applicant, sworn on 30th May 2026. The deponent avers that she is a director and/or duly authorised officer of the 1st Applicant and is authorised by the 2nd Applicant to swear the affidavit on his behalf.
5. She deposes that the Applicants instituted proceedings for recognition and enforcement of an arbitral award dated 12th February 2025, made by Hon. Connie Martina Gumo in their favour. She further states that the Respondent filed a Preliminary Objection dated 16th January 2026 challenging the Court's jurisdiction, alongside an application of the same date seeking to set aside the award. The Applicants subsequently filed a Preliminary Objection dated 3rd February 2026 challenging the latter application as time-barred. Both preliminary objections were canvassed jointly by way of written submissions and determined in the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026.
6. The deponent further avers that the Court's final orders are directly inconsistent with its express findings on jurisdiction and limitation of time. She maintains that the inconsistency constitutes an error apparent on the face of the record, capable of correction through review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. She contends that unless the orders are reviewed, the Applicants stand to suffer prejudice by being denied the benefit of the Court's findings in their favour. She concludes that the Application was brought without unreasonable delay and urges the Court to grant the orders sought.
The Response
7. The Respondent opposed the Application through a Statement of Grounds of Opposition dated 15th June 2026, filed pursuant to Order 51 Rule 14(1)(c) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Respondent contends that the Application is misconceived, incompetent and an abuse of the Court process, as it fails to satisfy the threshold for review prescribed under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
8. The Respondent maintains that the alleged contradiction between the reasoning and the final disposition of the Ruling does not constitute an error apparent on the face of the record. It argues that such an error must be obvious, self-evident and capable of identification without elaborate argument or a prolonged process of reasoning. According to the Respondent, establishing the alleged inconsistency would require the Court to examine and interpret its reasoning, compare it with the operative orders and draw inferences as to the Court's intended determination, an exercise which falls outside the scope of review.
9. The Respondent further contends that the Applicants are, in substance, challenging the correctness of the Ruling on its merits and are improperly invoking the review jurisdiction as a substitute for an appeal. It argues that the Applicants' acknowledgment that the reasoning of the Ruling was comprehensive and legally sound demonstrates that their grievance concerns the outcome of the decision, for which the appropriate remedy lies in an appeal to the Court of Appeal.
10. The Respondent also invokes the doctrine of functus officio, arguing that the Court has already determined the matters raised in the impugned Ruling and cannot reopen them under the guise of review. It maintains that the Applicants have failed to establish any recognised ground for review and consequently urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.
Parties' Submissions
Applicants' Submissions
11. The Applicants filed their written submissions dated 16th September 2026, identifying one issue for determination: whether the orders contained in paragraphs 10(i) and 10(ii) of the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026, being inconsistent with the reasoning and findings in paragraphs 8 and 9, constitute an error apparent on the face of the record warranting review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. They submitted that the contradiction is self-evident and that the review sought is intended to reconcile the operative orders with the Court's findings rather than reopen the merits of the decision.
12. In support of their position, the Applicants relied on National Bank of Kenya Limited Vs Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR, Kirema Vs Kaikai [2026] KEHC 9021, and Karanja Vs Murigi [2025] KECA 517 (KLR), on the principles governing review and errors apparent on the face of the record. They maintained that the Application is neither a disguised appeal nor barred by the doctrine of functus officio, and urged the Court to allow it with costs.
Respondent's Submissions
13. The Respondent filed written submissions dated 8th October 2026, identifying three issues for determination: whether the alleged inconsistency constitutes an error apparent on the face of the record under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules; whether the Application is a disguised appeal against the merits of the Ruling; and whether the doctrine of functus officio bars the Court from reviewing and varying its earlier orders. The Respondent submitted that establishing the alleged error would require substantive interpretation of the Ruling and that the Applicants' grievance properly falls within the appellate jurisdiction.
14. In advancing its position, the Respondent relied on Nyamogo & Nyamogo Advocates Vs Kago [2001] 1 EA 173, Maingi Mbinzu & 314 Others Vs County Council of Kitui & Another [2017] KECA 95 (KLR), and Paul Mwaniki Vs National Hospital Insurance Fund Board of Management [2020] eKLR, on the distinction between an error apparent on the face of the record and an erroneous decision. The Respondent maintained that the orders sought would amount to a substantive reconsideration of matters already determined and urged the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.
Issue for Determination
15. Having considered the Application, the Grounds of Opposition and the rival submissions, I find that the sole issue arising for determination is: Whether the Applicants have established sufficient grounds for review of the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026.
Analysis and Determination
Whether the Applicants have established sufficient grounds for review of the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026.
16. I have carefully considered the Application, the Grounds of Opposition, the rival submissions and the authorities relied upon by the parties. The Applicants seek review of the orders contained in paragraphs 10(i) and 10(ii) of the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026, contending that the said orders contradict the Court's express findings. The Respondent maintains that the alleged inconsistency does not constitute an error apparent on the face of the record and that the Applicants are improperly invoking the review jurisdiction to challenge the merits of the decision.
17. The jurisdiction of this Court to review its decisions is provided for under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. Section 80 empowers a person aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed but has not been preferred, or from which no appeal is allowed, to seek review before the Court that made the order.
18. Order 45 Rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 provides that review may be sought upon discovery of new and important matter or evidence which could not, despite due diligence, have been produced when the order was made, or: on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason The provision further requires that an application for review be brought without unreasonable delay. In the present case, the Applicants rely on the existence of an error apparent on the face of the record.
19. The Court of Appeal in National Bank of Kenya Limited Vs Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR addressed the scope of review and held that: “The error or omission must be self-evident and should not require an elaborate argument to be established.” The Court further distinguished an apparent error from an erroneous conclusion of law, holding that a misapprehension or incorrect interpretation of the law is ordinarily a ground for appeal rather than review.
20. Similarly, in Nyamogo & Nyamogo Advocates Vs Kago [2001] 1 EA 173, the Court of Appeal emphasized the distinction between an erroneous decision and an error apparent on the face of the record. The Court held that an error requiring a prolonged process of reasoning, particularly where more than one interpretation is reasonably possible, does not qualify as an error apparent on the face of the record.
21. The foregoing authorities establish that the jurisdiction of review is confined to the grounds prescribed by law. A distinction must therefore be drawn between an application challenging the correctness of a judicial determination and one seeking correction of an apparent inconsistency within the determination itself. The former ordinarily falls within appellate jurisdiction, while the latter may warrant review where the error is evident from the record without reconsideration of the substantive issues.
22. Turning to the impugned Ruling, I have examined paragraph 8, in which the Court addressed the Respondent's Preliminary Objection dated 16th January 2026 challenging the jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court to entertain the application for recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award. Having considered the jurisdiction of the Court under Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution, the Court found that the Environment and Land Court was vested with jurisdiction to determine disputes relating to land and the environment, including arbitration proceedings arising from such disputes. However, in paragraph 10(i) of the same Ruling, the Court declared the Respondent's Preliminary Objection meritorious and allowed it.
23. I have equally examined the Court's determination concerning the Applicants' Preliminary Objection dated 3rd February 2026. In paragraph 9 of the Ruling, the Court expressly found that the Respondent's application dated 16th January 2026 seeking to set aside the arbitral award was time-barred under Section 35(3) of the Arbitration Act and that the Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain it. Notwithstanding that finding, paragraph 10(ii) declared the Applicants' Preliminary Objection unmeritorious and proceeded to allow the Respondent's application as prayed.
24. The contradiction between the findings and the operative orders is evident from the Ruling itself. The Court's finding that it possessed jurisdiction to entertain the application for recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award is inconsistent with the order allowing an objection founded on the absence of that jurisdiction. Equally, the finding that the Respondent's application to set aside the award was time-barred and could not be entertained is incompatible with the order allowing that same application.
25. In my view, the inconsistencies are not matters requiring a fresh interpretation of the law or reconsideration of the evidence and submissions previously presented. The findings recorded in paragraphs 8 and 9 are express and unambiguous. The operative orders, however, produce conclusions directly opposite to those findings. The error is therefore ascertainable from the Ruling itself without the necessity of reopening the substantive issues previously determined.
26. I have considered the Respondent's contention that the Applicants are seeking to substitute the Court's orders with an entirely different disposition and that such relief can only be obtained through an appeal. While the proposed correction would alter the operative orders, that consequence does not, of itself, render the Application an appeal. The material consideration is whether the correction would require a fresh determination of the matters already decided. In this case, the Court had already expressed its findings on jurisdiction and limitation of time. The review sought does not require those findings to be reconsidered but rather seeks to reconcile the operative orders with them. It is therefore distinguishable from an attempt to persuade the Court to reverse its reasoning or arrive at a different conclusion on the merits.
27. Regarding the Respondent's objection founded on the doctrine of functus officio, the Court of Appeal in Telkom Kenya Limited Vs John Ochanda & 996 Others [2014] eKLR explained that the doctrine does not bar every subsequent engagement by a Court with a matter it has determined, but prohibits the reopening of its final decision for a fresh determination on the merits. The doctrine must be considered alongside the express statutory jurisdiction of review conferred by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Where the statutory requirements for review are satisfied, the Court is not precluded from correcting an apparent error in its decision.
28. As regards timeliness, the impugned Ruling was delivered on 29th April 2026, while the present Application was filed on 2nd June 2026. Having considered the period between the delivery of the Ruling and the filing of the Application, I am satisfied that there was no unreasonable delay within the meaning of Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
29. In the circumstances, I find that the inconsistency between the Court's findings in paragraphs 8 and 9 and the operative orders in paragraphs 10(i) and 10(ii) constitutes an error apparent on the face of the record. The Applicants have therefore established sufficient grounds to warrant review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
Final Disposition
30. In the upshot, the Notice of Motion dated 30th May 2026 is merited and is hereby allowed in the following terms:
a) The orders contained in paragraphs 10(i) and 10(ii) of the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026 are hereby reviewed and set aside.
b) In substitution thereof, the following orders shall issue:
I. The Preliminary Objection dated 16th January 2026 is hereby dismissed.
II. The Preliminary Objection dated 3rd February 2026 is hereby allowed.
III. The Notice of Motion dated 16th January 2026 seeking to set aside the arbitral award is hereby struck out for being time-barred.
c) The Applicants' Chamber Summons dated 27th October 2025 seeking recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award shall be listed for hearing on a priority basis.
d) The order on costs contained in paragraph 10(iii) of the Ruling delivered on 29th April 2026 shall remain undisturbed.
e) Each party shall bear its own costs of the present Application.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 9th day of
November, 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
N/A for the Applicants
N/A for the Respondent
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant