REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELC PETITION NO. E107 OF 2025
THOMAS NYANGERI MOGAKA ............................................................ 1ST PETITIONER
BRIAN OMARI MOGAKA .................................................................... 2ND PETITIONER
GEORGE KENYANYA MOGAKA ............................................................3RD PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE ...............................................1ST RESPONDENT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL ................................................................2ND RESPONDENT
OFFICER COMMANDING STATION,
KAREN PLAINS POLICE STATION .......................................................3RD RESPONDENT
OFFICER COMMANDING STATION,
KAREN POLICE STATION .................................................................. 4TH RESPONDENT
ZACHARIA BARAZA T/A SIUMA AUCTIONEERS ................................5TH RESPONDENT
ROSELINE DOLA OUKO .....................................................................6TH RESPONDENT
AARON TAFARI OUKO .....................................................................7TH RESPONDENT
PETER KARANJA, DEPUTY OFFICER COMMANDING STATION,
KAREN PLAINS POLICE STATION .......................................................8TH RESPONDENT
BUSINESS PREMISES RENT TRIBUNAL ............................................... 9TH RESPONDENT
RULING
The Preliminary Objection
1. Before this Court is a Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 2nd June 2026, filed by the 6th and 7th Respondents, through the firm of Marende and Nyaundi Advocates. The objection is raised in relation to the Petition and the Notice of Motion dated 19th December 2025 and is premised on three grounds.
2. Firstly, the 6th and 7th Respondents contend that the Petition, as presented, does not raise any constitutional question warranting determination by this Court. Secondly, they aver that the Petition offends the doctrines of constitutional avoidance and ripeness, as the Petitioners’ grievances concerning ownership, title, eviction and trespass over the suit properties ought to be canvassed through an ordinary civil claim rather than a constitutional petition.
3. Thirdly, the 6th and 7th Respondents contend that the Petition fails to plead with reasonable precision the specific constitutional provisions allegedly violated, the rights threatened or infringed, and the manner in which the alleged violations were occasioned. They further contend that the alleged infringements have neither been sufficiently particularised nor substantiated against them, thereby inhibiting their ability to understand and respond to the constitutional grievances raised.
Submissions
4. The Preliminary Objection was canvassed by way of written submissions filed by the respective parties, wherein the 6th and 7th Respondents urged the Court to uphold the objection, while the Petitioners opposed the same.
6th and 7th Respondents’ Submissions
5. In their written submissions dated 10th August 2026, the 6th and 7th Respondents identified three issues for determination, namely, whether the Preliminary Objection was merited, whether the Petition offended the doctrines of constitutional avoidance and ripeness, and whether the Petition had been pleaded with reasonable precision.
6. Counsel submitted that the objection raised pure points of law capable of disposing of the Petition without requiring an examination of contested facts. Reliance was placed on Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd. Vs West End Distributors Ltd. [1969] EA 696 and Attorney General & Another Vs Andrew Mwaura Githinji & Another [2016] eKLR. It was further submitted that the Petitioners’ grievances predominantly concerned ownership, title, eviction and trespass over L.R. Nos. 3589/37 and 3589/38, matters which ought to be determined through ordinary civil proceedings. In support of this position, Counsel cited Bernard Murage Vs Fineserve Africa Limited & 3 Others [2015] eKLR, Communications Commission of Kenya & 5 Others Vs Royal Media Services Limited & 5 Others [2014] eKLR and CNM Vs WMG [2018] eKLR.
7. On the doctrines of constitutional avoidance and ripeness, Counsel submitted that the Petitioners were improperly invoking the constitutional jurisdiction of the Court to ventilate grievances capable of determination under the ordinary legal framework governing land ownership and eviction. Reliance was placed on Brookside Dairy Limited Vs Mohamed & Another, Uhuru Muigai Kenyatta Vs Nairobi Star Publications Limited and Total Energies Marketing Kenya PLC & Another Vs National Land Commission & 6 Others.
8. Counsel further contended that the Petition failed to disclose with reasonable precision the constitutional provisions allegedly infringed, the nature of the violations and the manner in which the 6th and 7th Respondents were implicated. In support of this argument, Counsel relied on Anarita Karimi Njeru Vs Republic [1979] KLR 154 and Mumo Matemu Vs Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 Others [2013] eKLR. The Court was consequently urged to uphold the Preliminary Objection with costs.
Petitioners’ Submissions
9. In opposition, the Petitioners identified three corresponding issues for determination, namely, whether the Petition raised constitutional questions, whether it offended the doctrines of constitutional avoidance and ripeness, and whether the alleged constitutional violations had been pleaded with reasonable precision.
10. Counsel submitted that the Petition was not merely concerned with ownership of the suit properties but also challenged the alleged forcible eviction, destruction of property, unlawful arrests and participation of police officers in the events of 20th to 26th November 2025. It was argued that these allegations raised distinct constitutional questions under Articles 26, 27, 29 and 40 of the Constitution, which could not be dismissed merely because an underlying land dispute existed. Counsel relied on County Secretary of Kajiado, Francis Ole Sakude & 46 Others Vs Salaries and Remuneration Commission, Lemita Ole Lemien Vs Attorney General & 2 Others, Kassam & 12 Others Vs Shah & 16 Others [2025] KEELC 5354 (KLR) and Hassan Vs Mainga & 5 Others [2024] KEHC 6616 (KLR) to support the contention that the existence of an ordinary civil dispute did not necessarily exclude constitutional questions arising from the conduct complained of.
11. On constitutional avoidance and ripeness, Counsel submitted that the alleged violations had already occurred and that the Petition therefore presented a live controversy requiring judicial determination. It was argued that the earlier proceedings in ELC Civil Suit No. 282 of 2011 concerned ownership of the suit properties and did not determine the legality of the subsequent eviction or the conduct of the police officers involved.
12. Reliance was placed on National Assembly of Kenya Vs Kina & Another [2022] KECA 548 (KLR), Anytime Limited Vs Hussein & 2 Others [2025] KEHC 3944 (KLR) and Kisuani Bridge Limited Vs Kenya Urban Roads Authority & The Minister for Roads. On the question of precision, Counsel submitted that the Petition sufficiently identified the rights allegedly violated, the persons responsible, the material events and the reliefs sought, thereby satisfying Rule 10(2) of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013. Counsel cited Mumo Matemu Vs Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 Others, Hussein Khalid & 16 Others v Attorney General & 2 Others [2019] KESC 93 (KLR) and Ogolo & 5 Others Vs Kiamokama Tea Factory & Another [2022] KECA 825 (KLR). The Petitioners consequently urged the Court to dismiss the Preliminary Objection with costs and allow the Petition to proceed to hearing on its merits.
Analysis and Determination
13. I have considered the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 2nd June 2026, the Petition and the rival submissions filed by the parties. The sole issue arising for determination is whether the Preliminary Objection is merited.
14. The law governing preliminary objections is well settled. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd. Vs West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, Law JA stated as follows: “So far as I am aware a preliminary objection consists of pure point of law which has been pleaded, which it argued as a preliminary point, will dispose of the suit. Examples are objection to jurisdiction of the Court, a plea of limitation, or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the matter to arbitration.”
15. Similarly, in John Musakali Vs Speaker County of Bungoma & 4 Others [2015] eKLR, the Court held that: “The position in law is that a preliminary objection should arise from the pleadings and on the basis that facts are agreed by both sides. Once raised, the preliminary objection should have the potential to disposing of the suit at that point without the need to go to trial. If, however, facts are disputed and remain to be ascertained, that would not be a suitable preliminary objection on a point of law.”
16. Guided by the foregoing principles, a preliminary objection must arise from a pure point of law and be capable of determination without the Court interrogating contested facts or evaluating evidence. The objection before this Court challenges the competence of the Petition on the grounds that it raises no constitutional question, offends the doctrines of constitutional avoidance and ripeness, and fails to plead the alleged violations with reasonable precision. These grounds must therefore be examined against the pleadings to establish whether they warrant the preliminary termination of the Petition.
17. Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution establishes the jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court to hear and determine disputes relating to the environment and the use and occupation of, and title to, land. Section 13(1) and (2) of the Environment and Land Court Act further confers upon this Court jurisdiction over disputes concerning land ownership, occupation, title, tenure and other interests in land. The jurisdiction of this Court extends to constitutional questions arising within matters falling under its specialised jurisdiction.
18. From the Petition, the Petitioners claim proprietary interests in L.R. Nos. 3589/37 and 3589/38 and challenge the alleged invasion and eviction from the suit properties between 20th and 26th November 2025. They further allege that the eviction was carried out with the assistance of police officers and was accompanied by destruction and removal of property, assault, arrests and detention. The Petitioners consequently allege violations of their rights under Articles 26, 27, 29 and 40 of the Constitution. These allegations extend beyond the question of ownership of the suit properties and raise questions concerning the manner in which the alleged eviction was undertaken and the conduct of the persons involved.
19. The 6th and 7th Respondents contend that the dispute is essentially one of ownership, eviction and trespass, which ought to be determined through ordinary civil proceedings. While the Petition undoubtedly raises questions relating to ownership and occupation of land, the existence of such questions does not, of itself, exclude consideration of alleged constitutional violations arising from the same circumstances. The Court must distinguish between the determination of proprietary rights and the alleged infringement of constitutional rights in the course of enforcing or asserting those rights. Whether the conduct complained of amounted to constitutional violations is a question that requires consideration of the circumstances under which the alleged acts occurred.
20. On the doctrine of constitutional avoidance, the Court is required to consider whether the dispute can be adequately determined through an available ordinary legal process without invoking constitutional adjudication. The record discloses that the dispute concerning ownership of the suit properties was previously the subject of ELC Civil Suit No. 282 of 2011 (OS), in which judgment was delivered on 13th March 2025. However, the Petitioners' present grievances also concern events alleged to have occurred in November 2025, subsequent to that judgment. Whether those events constituted unlawful eviction, misuse of police authority or infringement of constitutional rights presents questions distinct from the determination of ownership. The mere existence of the earlier civil proceedings does not conclusively resolve those allegations.
21. As regards ripeness, the Petitioners have pleaded specific events which they contend resulted in violations of their constitutional rights. The allegations concern acts said to have already occurred, rather than anticipated or hypothetical infringements. The dispute is therefore not rendered premature merely because questions relating to the ownership of the suit properties have been the subject of separate proceedings. The legality of the alleged eviction and the involvement of the Respondents remain matters requiring determination upon consideration of the evidence.
22. The 6th and 7th Respondents further contend that the Petition fails to meet the threshold of reasonable precision required in constitutional litigation. Rule 10(2) of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013 requires a petition to disclose, among other particulars, the facts relied upon, the constitutional provisions allegedly violated, the nature of the injury suffered or threatened, details of related proceedings and the reliefs sought.
23. In the present Petition, the Petitioners have identified the constitutional provisions allegedly infringed, set out the events said to constitute the violations, identified the Respondents and particularised the reliefs sought. The Petition further sets out the alleged involvement of the 6th and 7th Respondents in the events surrounding the disputed eviction. Whether the allegations against each Respondent are supported by sufficient evidence to establish liability is a matter for determination at the hearing. The requirement of reasonable precision does not call upon the Court, at this preliminary stage, to determine the truth or evidentiary sufficiency of the allegations.
24. Furthermore, determining whether the eviction was lawful, whether the orders relied upon authorised the actions complained of, and whether the Respondents participated in the alleged constitutional violations would require the Court to examine evidence and resolve contested factual questions. Such an inquiry falls outside the scope of a preliminary objection as established in the authorities cited above.
25. In the circumstances, I find that although the Preliminary Objection raises questions concerning the competence of the Petition, its determination cannot properly be divorced from the disputed factual matters underlying the Petitioners' claims. The Petition discloses constitutional grievances which cannot be conclusively disposed of on the grounds advanced without an examination of the evidence. Accordingly, I find that the Preliminary Objection dated 2nd June 2026 is without merit.
Final Disposition
26. In the upshot, the Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 2nd June 2026 is hereby dismissed with costs in the cause. The Petition shall proceed to hearing and determination on its merits.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED via e-mail at NAIROBI on this 10th day of
November, 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE