Employment law

Samba v Kenya National Police DT Sacco Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14676 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause E066 of 2023
Judgment date
13 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Whether the Respondent had a valid reason to terminate the Claimant’s employment within the meaning of section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. E066 OF 2023

(Before D. K. N. Marete)

BETWEEN

BRIAN OLUOCH SAMBA …………………………………………………… CLAIMANT

VERSUS

KENYA NATIONAL POLICE DT SACCO LIMITED …………….…… RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

This matter was originated by way of a Statement of Claim dated 23rd September, 2020. It does not disclose any issue in dispute on its face.

The Respondent in a Statement of Response dated 8th May, 2023 denies the claim and prays that it be dismissed with costs.

This judgment is rendered on the basis of the pleadings, the witness statements, the documentary exhibits and the rival written submissions.

The Claimant’s case is that he was employed by the Respondent on 3rd May, 2019 as an IT Systems Administrator at a basic salary of Kshs. 165,000.00 per month. His employment was terminated on 30th November, 2022 in connection with a mobile banking fraud incident that the Respondent alleged he had perpetrated or participated in. He was paid his certificate of service upon termination.

The Claimant’s other case is that he was the person who first identified and reported the suspicious mobile banking activities to management and that his subsequent involvement in reviewing the transactions was entirely investigative. He contends that the forensic evidence gathered by PricewaterhouseCoopers Limited (PWC) was misinterpreted and that no credible direct finding of personal culpability was made against him.

The Claimant further avers that the Respondent failed to follow due process. Specifically, no formal show cause notice specifying the charges against him was issued before the disciplinary hearing of 18th November, 2022. He was placed on compulsory leave from 27th April, 2022 subsequently interdicted from 27th July, 2022 at half salary, and terminated on 30th November, 2022. During the interdiction period the Respondent withheld half of his basic salary of Kshs. 165,000.00 amounting to Kshs. 330,000.00 over four months. He submits that this was unlawfully withheld.

The Respondent’s case is that the Claimant’s employment was lawfully terminated following an elaborate mobile banking fraud perpetrated on its information technology infrastructure between 3rd February, 2022 and 16th April, 2022 resulting in the theft of Kshs. 29,287,530.00 belonging to eighty-one of its members. The fraud was committed through unauthorised backend access to the Respondent’s Profits Core Banking System and M-TAWI mobile banking databases using an account impersonating the internal Database Administrator, Ms Elizabeth Gacheru.

The Respondent engaged PWC on 27th April, 2022 to conduct an independent forensic investigation. On that date it also placed the Claimant on thirty days’ compulsory leave to facilitate the investigation. The leave was extended by sixty days on 27th May, 2022 that extension letter expressly referenced: the incidents currently under investigation in which the society lost money. The Claimant was subsequently summoned by SASRA investigators in July, 2022 and following the PWC investigation and the SASRA inquiry, was placed on interdiction on 27th July, 2022 at half salary, extended on 27th August, 2022 pending conclusion of investigations.

The PWC forensic investigation identified multiple digital artefacts and unexplained activities on the Claimant’s machine pointing to his direct or indirect involvement in the fraud. These included: emails establishing that the Claimant was elevated to Database Administrator rights by Ms. Gacheru on four occasions between June, 2021 and 14th April, 2022 the last elevation occurring one day before the final and largest fraud window. This is besides a browser artefact establishing that on 15th April, 2022 at 4:11 pm the Claimant accessed the M-TAWI unblock/PIN-reset feature and specifically searched for mobile number 254795338248, a number used in fraudulent transactions the following day, for which he could provide no explanation; a pseudonymously named file on his machine containing SQL queries tied to specific fraudulent transactions; a file listing inactive FOSA accounts created on his machine on 23rd November, 2021 more than two months before the first fraud incident. Other incidents include a separate file listing deceased SACCO members with account balances created on 27th January, 2022 seven days before the first incident — precisely the categories of accounts targeted; a Windows shortcut in the Claimant’s user path on the SMTP virtual server through whose IP address all fraudulent database access was effected, last accessed on 15th April, 2022 and digital forensic evidence establishing that his machine was never off at any point during the windows of suspicious activity.

On procedure, the Respondent says it invited the Claimant to a disciplinary hearing on 11th November, 2022 scheduled for 18th November, 2022 informing him of his right to be accompanied by a fellow employee. The Claimant attended, made representations, and those representations were heard and considered by the disciplinary committee. He was thereafter terminated by written notice on 30th November, 2022 and paid all final dues including a certificate of service. The Respondent further notes that by the time disciplinary action was taken the Claimant had already been charged in Milimani Criminal Case No. E920 of 2023, Republic v Brian Oluoch & 3 Others, arising from the same events.

The matter came to court variously until the 28th October, 2025 and 1st December, 2025 when it was heard inter partes. This culminated in each party presenting an oral rendition of the respective cases.

The issues for determination therefore are;

1. Whether the Respondent had a valid reason to terminate the Claimant’s employment within the meaning of section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007.

2. Whether the procedure leading to the termination was fair within the meaning of section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 and what, if any, relief flows from any breach found.

3. What reliefs, if any, the Claimant is entitled to.

The 1st issue for determination is whether the Respondent had a valid reason for termination. Section 43(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 requires the employer to demonstrate that it had a valid reason connected with the employee’s conduct, capacity, or compatibility. Section 47(5) places the burden of proof on the employer. In Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & 2 others [2019] eKLR, the Court of Appeal clarified that the employer need establish only the reasons it genuinely believed to exist at the time of termination, assessed on a balance of probabilities.

The fraud was by all means real and substantial. Between 3rd February, 2022 and 16th April, 2022 Kshs. 29,287,530 was stolen from eighty-one of the Respondent’s members through unauthorised backend database access. The forensic evidence established that the access required specific knowledge of the Respondent’s IT architecture, familiarity with the database schema developed during the June, 2020 system migration and the ability to execute parameterised SQL queries against specific tables. At the time of the incidents, only two persons held the elevated DBA access required: Ms Gacheru and the Claimant. The Claimant was elevated to DBA rights by Ms Gacheru on four separate occasions, the last on 14th April, 2022 one day before the final and largest fraud window. He therefore had both the access and the technical capability throughout the relevant period.

The most significant piece of evidence against the Claimant is the browser artefact of 15th April, 2022. Digital forensics established that at 4:11 pm that day the Claimant accessed the unblock customer account feature on the M-TAWI web portal and searched specifically for mobile number 254795338248. That number was used in fraudulent transactions the following day. When interviewed by PWC the Claimant stated he could not recall why he had accessed that feature for that specific number. That is not an explanation. The precision of the number, the timing, and the function accessed which permits PIN reset and account unblocking are not consistent with routine administrative activity.

Several other artefacts compound this inference. The pseudonymously named SQL query file on the Claimant’s machine contained queries tied to specific fraudulent transactions. The inactive FOSA accounts listing created on his machine on 23rd November, 2021 and the deceased accounts file created on 27th January, 2022 correspond precisely to the categories of accounts the fraudsters targeted. The first of these was created more than two months before the first incident, the second only seven days before it. His user path appears in the shortcut record on the SMTP virtual server through whose IP address all fraudulent database access was made. His machine was never off at any point during the fraud windows.

The Claimant advances three principal answers. First, that the fraud was executed using an account impersonating Ms. Gacheru rather than one attributed to him. This is true but does not avail him. The perpetrator’s use of her impersonated account is equally consistent with an insider seeking to deflect suspicion. Second, that a shared local administrator account existed that others could have exploited. This is a theoretical possibility, not an established route. Third, that he was the first to report the fraud. This is also consistent with a person controlling the flow of information about an incident he had foreknowledge of.

The Claimant’s strongest explanations that the allBalances.log and listings of fraudulent phone numbers were generated during the joint investigation with Ms. Gacheru were accepted by PWC as plausible for those two specific files. This court accepts those explanations for those files. But they do not reach the pseudonymously named SQL query file, the inactive FOSA accounts listing from November, 2021 the deceased accounts file from January, 2022 the M-TAWI browser search of 15th April, 2022 or the SMTP server shortcut. These remain unexplained.

On a balance of probabilities, the cumulative weight of the forensic evidence establishes that the Respondent had a genuine and well-grounded belief that the Claimant was directly or indirectly involved in the fraud. The Respondent had a valid reason for termination within the meaning of section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007. The 1st issue is determined in the Respondent’s favour.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether the procedure was fair. Section 41(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 requires that before terminating employment on grounds of misconduct the employer must inform the employee of the allegations in specific terms, afford the employee an opportunity to respond in the presence of a fellow employee or union representative of the employee’s choice, and thereafter consider the employee’s representations. In the authority of Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR, the Court of Appeal identified four elements of a fair procedure: an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language the employee understands; the reason the employer is considering termination; entitlement to accompaniment; and the hearing and consideration of the representations made.

DW-1 confirmed under cross-examination that no formal show cause notice specifying the charges against the Claimant was issued prior to the disciplinary hearing of 18th November, 2022. The Respondent relies on the hearing invitation letter of 11th November, 2022 as satisfying the notice requirement. Strictly, an invitation letter is not a written charge notice, and to that narrow extent the Respondent did not formally satisfy every element of section 41.

The defect must, however, be assessed in its full context. The purpose of a show cause notice is to ensure that the employee knows the case he has to meet before he enters the hearing room. By November, 2022 the Claimant had been placed on compulsory leave since 27th April, 2022 explicitly because of the fraud investigation. The extension of that leave on 27th May, 2022 expressly referenced to the incidents currently under investigation in which the society lost money. He was summoned by SASRA investigators in July, 2022. He was placed on interdiction on 27th July, 2022 extended on 27th August, 2022 pending the conclusion of the same investigations. He participated in two rounds of interviews with PWC forensic investigators and was directly confronted with the digital artefacts found on his machine. By the time the hearing invitation arrived on 11th November, 2022 he had been living inside this investigation, as a named person of interest, for approximately six months. He knew precisely what he was being investigated for.

The Claimant attended the hearing on 18th November, 2022 without objection. He raised no challenge to the adequacy of notice, made no request for additional time to prepare and made representations which were heard and considered by the committee. He has not demonstrated and cannot now demonstrate that the outcome would have been different had a formal written charge sheet been issued separately from the hearing invitation. The absence of that document caused him no material prejudice.

In considering the appropriate relief, this court is directed by section 49(4) of the Employment Act, 2007 and in particular section 49(4)(k), which requires the court to take into account any conduct of the employee which to any extent caused or contributed to the termination. The conduct established against the Claimant on a balance of probabilities is not peripheral. The forensic evidence points to direct or indirect involvement in a fraud that cost the Respondent’s members Kshs. 29,287,530. His contribution to the circumstances that brought about his termination was, on the evidence, total. To award compensation for a technical procedural defect that caused no prejudice, in a matter where the employee’s own conduct was the root cause of the termination, would be inequitable and would not serve the remedial purpose of section 49. In Kenfreight (EA) Limited v Benson Nguti Ooko [2019] KESC 79, the Supreme Court confirmed that the court retains a broad discretion including the power to decline any compensatory award where the circumstances warrant.

This court finds that while a formal show cause notice was not issued, the Claimant was at all material times constructively aware of the charges against him, suffered no material prejudice from the absence of a written charge notice and by his own conduct contributed entirely to the termination. Just and equitable compensation for the termination is nil. The 2nd issue is determined accordingly.

The 3rd issue for determination is the appropriate relief. On compensation for unfair termination, for the reasons set out on the 2nd issue, the just and equitable award is nil or no award at all.

On the withheld half-salary, the Claimant was placed on interdiction from 27th July, 2022 at half salary. The interdiction ran until his termination on 30th November, 2022 a period of four months. The Respondent withheld the other half of his basic salary of Kshs. 165,000.00 per month, amounting to Kshs. 82,500.00 per month, for a total of Kshs. 330,000.00. The claimant pleaded arrears of Kshs. 370,811.00 but the provable figure on the evidence before the court is Kshs. 330,000.00. This sum represents salary earned and not paid. It is a contractual debt, not discretionary compensation for unfair termination and the finding of a valid reason for termination does not extinguish accrued salary entitlements that arose before termination. The Claimant is entitled to recovery of Kshs. 330,000.00.

On costs, this is a dispute between an employer and a former employee. The Claimant has succeeded on one head only, and the Respondent has substantially prevailed. This is not a case that justifies a costs order either way. Let each party bear their costs of the claim.

I am therefore inclined to partially allow the claim and order as follows:

i) The termination of the employment of the Claimant by the Respondent was substantively fair and lawful.

ii) This court declines to award any compensation for the termination of employment.

iii) The Respondent shall pay the Claimant Kshs. 330,000.00 being withheld salaries during the period of interdiction.

iv) Each party shall bear their costs of their claim.

Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Mr. Oginga instructed by Roba and Associates Advocates for the Claimant.

2. Mr. Gakiria instructed by Anthony Gikaria and Company Advocates for the Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder