Background
This suit has come up for pre-trial conference severally including 12.4.2023, 24.7.2023, 27.9.2023, 19.10.2023, 20.11.2023, 13.12.2023 and 13.1.2024.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This suit has come up for pre-trial conference severally including 12.4.2023, 24.7.2023, 27.9.2023, 19.10.2023, 20.11.2023, 13.12.2023 and 13.1.2024.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI
ELC CASE NO. E040 OF 2023
REUBEN SIAMETO KAMUKURU………..……..PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
SAMSON NJAU NDUNGU ………….….. 1ST DEFENDANT
JULIUS GITAU MBURU ………………… 2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
1. This suit has come up for pre-trial conference severally including 12.4.2023, 24.7.2023, 27.9.2023, 19.10.2023, 20.11.2023, 13.12.2023 and 13.1.2024.
2. On 12.2.2024, an application dated 10.2.2024 was filed seeking to join an interested party. It was allowed the same day and parties told to comply with orders II of Civil Procedure Rule.
3. By 28.3.2024 and 29.5.2024 and 6.6.2024. a hearing date was then given for 2.12.2024. the matter could not proved as the court was away on official duties .
4. Another hearing date was given for 24.3.2025. on the hearing date, the court was told that the plaintiff had passed on toward the end of 2024. the suit was adjourned to substitute the deceased plaintiff.
5. A mention date for 22.9.2025 was given . the court on that day was told by the defendant that though 60 days had been given and the court told of an application for a limited grant had been lodged, no evidence was forthcoming on the progress of the same or an application for substitution made.
6. The court in the interest of justice gave the plaintiff last chance to comply . A mention date for 5.11.2025 was given.
7. On 5.11.2025 the defendants expressed concerns for non-action on the part of the plaintiff. They sought for the dismissal of the suit. The court gave a hearing date for 27.4.2026.
8. On 27.4.2026 the plaintiff sought for another date. A hearing date of 12.10.2026 was given. The file was then send to this court for mention today.
9. Learned counsel Mr.Khalwale for the plaintiff now seek for time to substitute. He submits that the plaintiff passed on 5.11.2024 as per the certificate of death issued on 25.1.2025 on his possession .
10. Counsel for the defendants says that the plaintiff has made such an application severally since 2025.
11. Learned counsel submit that it is not clear why the application for substitution of the deceased/plaintiff has not been filed.He nevertheless submit that the plaintiff can be given a last chance.
12. Orders 24 Rule I of Civil Procedure Rules provides that the death of a plaintiff does not cause a suit to abate if the cause of actions survives.
13. Order 24 Rule 3 & 4 of Civil Procedure Rule provides for an application to be made, by the legal representative of the estate of the deceased/ plaintiff to be made a party to the suit for purposes of its progress and prosecution.
14. Orders 24 Rule 3(2) of Civil Procedure Rule provides that if the application is not made within one year, the suit shall abate, and on an application by the defendant, he can be granted cost incurred for defending the suit to be recovered from the estate of the deceased plaintiff.
15. Under that Rule the court, where there are good reasons on an applications may extend the time.
16. In Said Sweilem Gheithan Saanum v Commissioner of Lands (being sued through the Attorney General) & 5 others (Civil Appeal No. 16 of 2015) [2015] KECA 284 (KLR) (30 October 2015) (Judgment), the court said that the effect of an abated suit is that it ceases to exist in the eye of the law and that the abatement takes place on its won force by passage of time.
17. The court said that this is the legal consequence without flow from the omission to take necessary step within one year, to implied the legal representation of the deceased/plaintiff.
18. In Rebecca Mijide Mungole & another v Kenya Power & Lighting Company Ltd & 2 others [2017] eKLR, Civil Appeal No. 283 of 2015 (12 May 2017) (Judgment. The court said that by operation of law, a suit will automatically abate where a date plaintiff dies and the cause of action survives it no application is made within one year following his death.
19. In Kenya Farmers Co-operative Union Limited v Charles Murgor (Deceased) t/a Kaptabei Coffee Estate [2005] eKLR (Civil Case No. 1671 of 1994) (22 July 2005) (Ruling), the court said that if a suit has abated it deceased to exist, it and hence there is no suit upon which a trial can be conducted and judge pronounced.
20. Abatement under Black Laws Dictionary 4th Edition means the suspension or defeat of a pending action for reason unrelated to the merit of the claim.
21. There is admission that the plaintiff passed on 5.11.2024. no application was filed to substitute him by 5.11.2024.
22. Once that happened the suit was no more. It extinguished . The court thereafter lacked jurisdiction to sustain it.
23. There is nothing to sustain the suit as of today, unless the court was moved appropriately. If an act is void then in law is a nullity. There is no , for an order of court to entertain it.
24. As held in Benjamin Leonard Macfoy v United Africa Company Limited (West Africa) [1961] UKPC 49 (27 November 1961); [1962] AC 152; [1961] 3 All ER 1169; [1961] 3 WLR 1405 this suit automatically abated. An express order of abatement is not necessary as held in Elizabeth Mutuku & Nzioka Mutuku & 6 others v Aimi Ma Kilungu Company Ltd [2019] KEHC 2149 (KLR) (18 November 2019) (Ruling) and in Vamos & Partners v Hassan (S.F.) [1964] EA 644 (K).
25. Cost to the defendants in any event.
26. File marked closed.
Signed ,dated and delivered on this 10th day of November,2026
Hon. Justice C.K Nzili
Judge
In the presence of;
Mr. Khalwale for the plaintiff.
Gothia appearance for the defendant
Court assistant ; Julius