Land law

Acres and Homes Ltd v Attorney General [2026] KEELC 7662 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case 830 of 2013
Judgment date
10 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court for determination is the Defendant/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 20th July 2026, brought pursuant to Article 50(1) of the Constitution of Kenya, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 80 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 12 Rule 7 and Order 51 Rules 1 and 15 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Applicant seeks, inter alia, orders setting aside the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 and all consequential orders, stay of execution…

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Having considered the Application, the Grounds of Opposition and the rival written submissions, I find that the sole issue arising for determination is: Whether the Defendant/Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant setting aside the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 and reopening the proceedings.

Paragraph 17 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 830 OF 2013

ACRES AND HOMES LIMITED ........................................................................PLAINTIFF

-VERSUS-

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL ................................................DEFENDANT

RULING

THE APPLICATION

1. Before this Court for determination is the Defendant/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 20th July 2026, brought pursuant to Article 50(1) of the Constitution of Kenya, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 80 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 12 Rule 7 and Order 51 Rules 1 and 15 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Applicant seeks, inter alia, orders setting aside the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 and all consequential orders, stay of execution of the resultant decree pending the hearing and determination of the Application, reopening of the proceedings and leave to call its witnesses, cross-examine the Plaintiff's witnesses and prosecute its Defence and Counterclaim. The Applicant also seeks costs of the Application.

2. The Application is premised on the grounds set out on its face and is supported by the Affidavit of Grace Ajierh, State Counsel in the Ministry of Defence, sworn on 20th July 2026. The Applicant contends that it has actively participated in the proceedings, having entered appearance, filed its Defence and Counterclaim, witness statements and documents, and attended Court on various occasions. It maintains that it has consistently demonstrated its intention to defend the suit and prosecute its Counterclaim.

3. The Applicant avers that on 7th April 2025, the Court issued directions concerning the filing of pleadings and preparation for hearing. It further states that the matter was subsequently fixed for hearing on 7th April 2026, for which it served a hearing notice upon the Plaintiff. However, the said date fell within the Easter Court Vacation, and the matter did not proceed. It is the Applicant's contention that the matter was thereafter heard on 14th April 2026 without any fresh hearing notice or notification of the change of date being served upon it.

4. The Applicant further contends that on 14th April 2026, the Court proceeded to hear the Plaintiff's witness and closed the Plaintiff's case in its absence, thereby denying it the opportunity to cross-examine the witness, tender its evidence and prosecute its Defence and Counterclaim. It maintains that the proceedings culminating in the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 were procedurally irregular and violated its constitutional right to a fair hearing.

5. In her Supporting Affidavit, Grace Ajierh deposes that the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 declared the Department of Defence's entry into and continued occupation of L.R. No. 209/14030, Grant No. I.R. 83237, unlawful and directed it to vacate and yield vacant possession to the Plaintiff. The Court further declined the Plaintiff's claim for mesne profits, dismissed the Defendant's Counterclaim and awarded costs to the Plaintiff.

6. The Deponent reiterates that the Defendant had complied with the Court's directions and actively participated in the proceedings. She avers that the Defendant was unaware of the hearing conducted on 14th April 2026, having received no hearing notice or notification changing the date from 7th April 2026. She states that the Defendant subsequently learnt of the proceedings through a litigant acquaintance who informed it that the matter had been listed for Judgment. According to the Deponent, the Defendant had believed that the suit would be dismissed for want of prosecution, an issue she states had previously been raised before the Court.

7. The Deponent maintains that the Defendant has an arguable Defence and Counterclaim raising substantive issues concerning ownership and occupation of the suit property, which ought to be determined on their merits. She contends that allowing the Judgment to stand without affording the Defendant an opportunity to present its case would occasion substantial prejudice and injustice, particularly considering the nature of the dispute and the public interest involved. She further avers that the Plaintiff would suffer no prejudice incapable of redress if the Judgment were set aside and the matter reopened for hearing.

8. The Applicant consequently urges the Court to exercise its discretion in its favour, set aside the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026, stay its execution and reopen the proceedings to afford the Defendant an opportunity to be heard on its Defence and Counterclaim.

THE GROUNDS OF OPPOSITION

9. The Plaintiff opposed the Application through Grounds of Opposition dated 3rd September 2026, contending that the same is misconceived and devoid of merit. The Plaintiff maintains that the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 was not an irregular default judgment, as the Defendant had entered appearance, filed its Defence and Counterclaim, witness statements and documents, and actively participated in the proceedings. It is the Plaintiff's position that the Defendant cannot portray itself as having been unaware of the proceedings merely because it failed to attend the hearing conducted on 14th April 2026.

10. The Plaintiff further contends that the Defendant has failed to demonstrate sufficient cause for its non-attendance, arguing that the hearing notice exhibited by the Defendant fixed the matter for 7th April 2026, yet its Counsel failed to attend Court on that date and on 14th April 2026. The Plaintiff disputes allegations of procedural impropriety, fraud or concealment and maintains that the Defendant had an obligation to monitor the progress of its case. It further argues that the Defendant's expectation that the suit would be dismissed for want of prosecution did not excuse its failure to ascertain the status of the proceedings.

11. The Plaintiff maintains that the Defendant has failed to satisfy the legal requirements for setting aside or reviewing the Judgment under Order 12 Rule 7 and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It contends that no new and important evidence, error apparent on the face of the record or other sufficient reason has been demonstrated. The Plaintiff further argues that the Judgment followed a substantive hearing in which the Court considered the pleadings, evidence and issues raised by the parties, and that the Defendant's failure to call its witnesses does not, by itself, render the proceedings irregular.

12. The Plaintiff also opposes the prayers for stay of execution and reopening of the proceedings, contending that the Defendant has neither demonstrated substantial loss nor established exceptional circumstances warranting interference with the Judgment. It maintains that the suit has been pending since 2013 and that reopening the proceedings would occasion prejudice to the Plaintiff and undermine the principle of finality in litigation. The Plaintiff consequently urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs and uphold the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026.

SUBMISSIONS

13. The Application was canvassed by way of written submissions. The Defendant/Applicant filed submissions dated 6th October 2026, identifying four issues for determination: whether the hearing conducted on 14th April 2026 proceeded without service of a hearing notice; whether the resultant Judgment was irregular and liable to be set aside; whether sufficient cause had been demonstrated for the Court to exercise its discretion in favour of the Defendant; and whether the proceedings ought to be reopened and execution stayed. The Defendant submitted that the hearing proceeded without notice, thereby denying it an opportunity to cross-examine the Plaintiff's witness and tender evidence in support of its Defence and Counterclaim. It maintained that the resulting Judgment was procedurally irregular and ought to be set aside as a matter of right.

14. In support of its submissions, the Defendant relied on Shah Vs Mbogo & Another [1967] EA 116 on the exercise of judicial discretion to set aside proceedings and James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another Vs Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] eKLR on the distinction between regular and irregular default judgments. The Defendant further cited Ouma Vs Ondieki (Civil Appeal 076 of 2023) [2024] KEHC 7093 (KLR) on the exercise of discretion in favour of substantive justice and Richard Ncharpi Leiyagu Vs Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 2 Others [2013] eKLR on the right to a fair hearing. It urged the Court to set aside the Judgment, reopen the proceedings and grant stay of execution to preserve the subject matter pending determination of the dispute on its merits.

15. The Plaintiff/Respondent filed written submissions dated 3rd September 2026, identifying five issues for determination: whether the Judgment was irregular; whether sufficient cause had been demonstrated for the Defendant's non-attendance; whether the statutory threshold for review had been satisfied; whether the requirements for stay of execution had been met; and whether there existed exceptional circumstances warranting reopening of the concluded proceedings. The Plaintiff submitted that the Judgment was not an irregular default judgment, as the Defendant had actively participated in the proceedings and filed its Defence and Counterclaim. It contended that the Defendant had failed to sufficiently explain its absence on 14th April 2026 or demonstrate any procedural impropriety warranting interference with the Judgment.

16. In support of its position, the Plaintiff relied on James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another Vs Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] eKLR, Shah Vs Mbogo & Another [1967] EA 116 and Mbogo & Another Vs Shah [1968] EA 93 on the principles governing the setting aside of judgments and the exercise of judicial discretion. It further cited National Bank of Kenya Ltd. Vs Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR on the threshold for review, Kenya Shell Limited Vs Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1986] KLR 410 and Butt Vs Rent Restriction Tribunal [1982] KLR 417 on the requirements for stay of execution. The Plaintiff maintained that the Defendant had neither established sufficient grounds for review nor demonstrated substantial loss warranting stay of execution. It urged the Court to dismiss the Application with costs, emphasizing the need to uphold the finality of litigation, particularly in a dispute pending since 2013.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

17. Having considered the Application, the Grounds of Opposition and the rival written submissions, I find that the sole issue arising for determination is: Whether the Defendant/Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant setting aside the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 and reopening the proceedings.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

18. I have carefully considered the Application, the Supporting Affidavit, the Grounds of Opposition and the rival written submissions. The Defendant's principal contention is that the hearing conducted on 14th April 2026 proceeded without notice to it, thereby denying it an opportunity to cross-examine the Plaintiff's witness and present evidence in support of its Defence and Counterclaim. The Plaintiff maintains that the Defendant had actively participated in the proceedings and has not demonstrated sufficient cause for interfering with the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026. The Court must therefore examine the circumstances surrounding the Defendant's non-attendance and determine whether they justify the exercise of its discretion to set aside the Judgment.

19. The applicable law is Order 12 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which governs proceedings where only the Plaintiff attends the hearing. Under the Rule, the Court may proceed ex parte upon being satisfied that the Defendant was duly served with a hearing notice. Where notice was not duly served, the Court is required to direct service of a second notice, while insufficient notice or other sufficient cause preventing attendance calls for postponement of the hearing. The requirement for proper notice is therefore an essential consideration before a Court proceeds in the absence of a party.

20. Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules further empowers the Court, upon application, to set aside or vary a judgment or order made under that Order upon such terms as may be just. The exercise of this discretion is guided by established principles. In Shah Vs Mbogo & Another [1967] EA 116, the Court held that the discretion to set aside an ex parte judgment is intended to avoid injustice or hardship arising from accident, inadvertence or excusable mistake, but not to assist a party who has deliberately sought to obstruct or delay the course of justice.

21. In James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another Vs Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] eKLR, the Court of Appeal distinguished between regular and irregular default judgments, emphasizing that a judgment obtained without proper service cannot be permitted to stand where a party has been denied an opportunity to be heard. While that decision principally concerned default judgments, the underlying principle that a party should not be condemned without proper notice is relevant to proceedings conducted in the absence of a litigant.

22. Turning to the present Application, it is not disputed that the Defendant entered appearance, filed its Defence and Counterclaim, witness statements and documents, and participated in the proceedings. The Defendant has exhibited a hearing notice dated 19th February 2026 fixing the matter for hearing on 7th April 2026, together with an Affidavit of Service sworn on 27th February 2026 confirming service of that notice upon the Plaintiff's advocates. The Defendant contends that the matter did not proceed on the scheduled date, which fell within the Easter Court Vacation, and that the hearing was subsequently conducted on 14th April 2026 without any notification to it.

23. The Plaintiff disputes the Defendant's explanation and maintains that it was under an obligation to monitor the progress of the suit. However, the Plaintiff's Grounds of Opposition do not identify any hearing notice served upon the Defendant in respect of 14th April 2026 or demonstrate that the subsequent date was fixed in the presence of its Counsel. Neither do they identify any acknowledgment of service or other communication notifying the Defendant of the change of hearing date. The hearing notice exhibited by the Defendant relates specifically to 7th April 2026 and cannot, without further evidence, establish notification of the hearing conducted on 14th April 2026.

24. While I agree that parties have a duty to remain vigilant in the prosecution and defence of their cases, that obligation does not dispense with the requirement for proper notification of hearing dates. The fact that the Defendant had previously participated in the proceedings cannot, in itself, establish that it was aware of the subsequent hearing. Further, although the Defendant's expectation that the suit might be dismissed for want of prosecution was not a sufficient reason to disregard the proceedings, the central question remains whether it had notice of the hearing at which the Plaintiff's evidence was taken and its own case closed. On the material presented in support of and opposition to the Application, such notification has not been demonstrated.

25. I am mindful that the Judgment sought to be set aside was delivered following the presentation of the Plaintiff's evidence and consideration of the pleadings before the Court. It was therefore not a default judgment arising from failure to enter appearance or file a Defence. Nevertheless, the filing of pleadings and their consideration by the Court cannot substitute the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses and tender evidence where a party has not been duly notified of the hearing. Article 50(1) of the Constitution guarantees every person the right to have a dispute resolved in a fair and public hearing before an independent and impartial Court. The observance of that right is particularly important where the proceedings result in final orders affecting the rights and interests of the parties.

26. Beyond the question of notice, the Court must consider the nature of the Defence, the explanation for non-attendance, the promptness with which the Application was brought and the prejudice likely to be suffered by either party. In Mohammed & Another Vs Shoka [1990] KLR 463, the Court identified the existence of triable issues, the explanation for default and the prejudice to the parties as relevant considerations in an application to set aside judgment. Similarly, in Tree Shade Motors Limited Vs D.T. Dobie & Company (K) Limited & Another [1998] eKLR, the Court of Appeal emphasized the importance of considering whether the proposed Defence raises issues deserving trial.

27. In Patel Vs E.A. Cargo Handling Services Ltd [1974] EA 75, the Court explained that a defence on the merits need not necessarily succeed but should disclose a triable issue. In the present matter, the Defendant had already filed a Defence and Counterclaim contesting the Plaintiff's claim and raising questions concerning ownership, occupation and entitlement to the suit property. These are substantive matters whose ultimate determination depends upon the evidence presented before the Court. At this stage, the Court is not called upon to pronounce itself on the merits of those claims but to determine whether the circumstances warrant affording the Defendant an opportunity to present its case.

28. The Court must equally consider the prejudice likely to be occasioned to the Plaintiff, who has pursued this litigation since 2013 and obtained Judgment in its favour. The principle that a successful litigant is entitled to enjoy the fruits of judgment cannot be disregarded. However, that entitlement must be balanced against the right of the opposing party to a fair hearing.

29. In Hotenga Njeri Munga Vs Celina Wairimu & 2 Others [2021] eKLR, the Court considered the existence of triable issues, the explanation for non-attendance and the prejudice likely to be suffered by the parties in exercising its discretion under Order 12 Rule 7. The Court recognized that even where the explanation for non-attendance was unsatisfactory, the surrounding circumstances could justify setting aside the judgment where the absence was not shown to have been intended to obstruct the course of justice.

30. In the present circumstances, the Judgment directed the Department of Defence to vacate and yield vacant possession of the suit property and dismissed the Defendant's Counterclaim. These are substantial consequences arising from proceedings in which the Defendant did not present its evidence. Although reopening the proceedings would occasion further delay to the Plaintiff, that prejudice must be weighed against the consequence of maintaining a judgment following a hearing whose notification to the Defendant has not been established on the material before the Court. The inconvenience occasioned by reopening the proceedings can be addressed through appropriate directions on the expeditious hearing of the suit and costs.

31. I have further considered the Defendant's conduct following delivery of the Judgment. The Application was filed on 20th July 2026, five days after the Judgment was delivered. I find that the Defendant moved the Court without unreasonable delay. Further, although the Plaintiff has questioned the Defendant's diligence in monitoring the proceedings, there is insufficient material to establish that its absence on 14th April 2026 was deliberate or calculated to obstruct the course of justice. Equally, the Defendant's allegations that the Plaintiff acted improperly in procuring the Judgment have not been substantiated and do not form a basis for the Court's determination.

32. Having considered the circumstances of the Application in their entirety, I find that the question of service of the hearing notice for 14th April 2026 is fundamental. The Defendant has challenged notification of that hearing on oath and exhibited the earlier hearing notice fixing the matter for 7th April 2026. The Plaintiff's opposition does not demonstrate how the subsequent hearing date was communicated to the Defendant. In the absence of sufficient evidence establishing such notification, and considering the Defendant's prior participation in the proceedings, the existence of its Defence and Counterclaim and the promptness with which the Application was filed, I am persuaded that this is an appropriate case for the exercise of the Court's discretion under Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

33. As regards the prayer for review, the substance of the Application concerns the setting aside of a judgment arising from proceedings conducted in the Defendant's absence. The Court's determination therefore rests principally upon Order 12 Rule 7 rather than the grounds for review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Having found sufficient grounds to set aside the Judgment, a separate determination of the prayer for interim stay of execution pending determination of the Application would serve no useful purpose.

34. In the circumstances, I find that the Defendant/Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant setting aside the Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 and reopening the proceedings to afford the parties an opportunity to present their respective cases. The Application dated 20th July 2026 is accordingly merited.

FINAL DISPOSITION

35. In the upshot, I find that the Defendant/Applicant's Notice of Motion dated 20th July 2026 is merited and is hereby allowed in the following terms:

a) The Judgment delivered on 15th July 2026 and all consequential orders are hereby set aside.

b) The proceedings are hereby reopened, and the Plaintiff's witness shall be recalled for cross-examination, after which the Defendant shall be afforded an opportunity to present its evidence in support of its Defence and Counterclaim.

c) The matter be mentioned on 17th November, 2026 for directions.

d) Costs of the Application shall be in the cause.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED via e-mail at NAIROBI on this 10th day of

November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder