Land law

Oyugi & 2 others (Suing as the Administrators of the Estate of Hezekiah Nelson Oyugi - Deceased) v Sherman & another [2026] KEELC 7800 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Civil Suit 1517 of 1998
Judgment date
12 November 2026
Judge(s)
O. A. Angote

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Notice of Motion dated 29 July 2025 was allowed. All funds and accrued interest in joint Account No. 01109173762700 at Co-operative Bank were ordered released to O&M Law LLP Advocates for onward transmission to the 1st Defendant. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs of the application.

Supporting judgment passages

34. For those reasons, the Notice of Motion dated 29th July 2025 is allowed in the following terms:

Paragraph 34 →

a) All monies standing to the credit of Account No. 01109173762700 at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch, held in the joint names of Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. & Co., together with all interest accrued thereon, shall be released to O&M Law LLP Advocates for onward transmission to the 1st Defendant.

Passage 50 →

b) Each party shall bear its own costs of the application.

Passage 51 →
Issue 1Whether the monies held at Cooperative Bank, University Way Branch, Account Number 01109173762700 in the joint names Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. Co should be released to the 1st Defendant.

Held. Decided. Yes. The court held that the original deposit arrangement preserved rental income only pending determination of the applications to set aside the initial judgment; it did not give the Plaintiffs an entitlement to the income or require indefinite retention. That judgment was set aside, the suit was reheard and dismissed in the 1st Defendant’s favour, and no order preserving the deposits pending appeal existed. The court therefore ordered release of all funds and accrued interest to O&M Law LLP Advocates for onward transmission to the 1st Defendant. Each party was to bear its own application costs.

Ratio. Interlocutory preservation orders lapse upon final determination of the matter, so continued retention of preserved funds requires a subsisting order or another sufficient basis beyond the original deposit arrangement. A pending appeal alone does not warrant retaining the funds; an injunction against disposal of the suit property does not extend to the separate deposited rental income absent an order specifically preserving it.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

21. Having considered the Motion, the affidavits and the submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the monies held at Cooperative Bank, University Way Branch, Account Number 01109173762700 in the joint names Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. Co should be released to the 1st Defendant.

Paragraph 21 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

33. Ultimately, the judgment in favour of the 1st Defendant remains operative, and no order preserving the deposits pending appeal has been demonstrated. The release of the said funds will not interfere with the injunction restraining disposal of the suit property. There is, therefore, no sufficient basis for their continued retention.

Paragraph 33 →

a) All monies standing to the credit of Account No. 01109173762700 at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch, held in the joint names of Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. & Co., together with all interest accrued thereon, shall be released to O&M Law LLP Advocates for onward transmission to the 1st Defendant.

Passage 50 →

b) Each party shall bear its own costs of the application.

Passage 51 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

19. On the relevance of the pending appeal, Counsel acknowledged that the filing of an appeal does not, of itself, operate as a stay of execution. Counsel nevertheless maintained that the absence of an automatic stay did not render the appeal irrelevant to the exercise of the court’s discretion. Citing Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, counsel urged the court to consider the orders governing the deposit of the funds in the joint advocates’ account and the consequences of their release before determination of the appeal.

Paragraph 19 →

20. Counsel further submitted that the affidavit sworn by Hellen Wambui on 6th July, 2026 confirmed that the funds remained identifiable and preserved at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch. Their continued retention, counsel argued, neither constituted execution against the 1st Defendant nor determined the substantive appeal, but preserved the existing position pending determination of the appropriate relief. Counsel therefore urged the court to consider preservation of the funds pending appeal, or appropriate protective directions, and concluded by seeking dismissal of the application with costs to the Plaintiffs.

Paragraph 20 →

Analysis and Determination

Passage 35 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Vide the Motion dated 29th July 2025, brought pursuant to the provisions of Order 51, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the 1st Defendant/Applicant seeks the following reliefs:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the Motion, the affidavits and the submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the monies held at Cooperative Bank, University Way Branch, Account Number 01109173762700 in the joint names Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. Co should be released to the 1st Defendant.

Paragraph 21 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether monies and accrued interest held in Co-operative Bank Account No. 01109173762700 in the joint names of Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. & Co. Advocates, as preserved rental income, should be released to the 1st Defendant following the fresh judgment and the…

Material facts

The Plaintiffs, administrators of Hezekiah Nelson Oyugi’s estate, had challenged the transfer of L.R. No. 209/4491 to Timdhar Said Sherman and sought, among other reliefs, rental income. After the initial 13 May 2016 judgment, consensual orders required…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

CIVIL SUIT NO. 1517 OF 1998

JOB OKUNA OYUGI...………………..………………....1st PLAINTIFF

DOUGLAS ODHIAMBO OYUGI……………...…..…..2nd PLAINTIFF

JOSHUA ONYANGO……………………………………..3rd PLAINTIFF

(Suing as the Administrators of the Estate of Hezekiah Nelson Oyugi deceased)

VERSUS

TIMDHAR SAID SHERMAN………………….…......1st DEFENDANT

THE COMMISSIONER OF LANDS…………..…...2nd DEFENDANT

RULING

1. Vide the Motion dated 29th July 2025, brought pursuant to the provisions of Order 51, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the 1st Defendant/Applicant seeks the following reliefs:

i. That this Honourable Court be pleased to order the release of all the monies deposited and held at Cooperative Bank, University Way Branch, Account Number 01109173762700 in the joint name OCHWO & CO./NYIHA M. CO, being rental income from the suit property herein, plus all interest accrued thereon, to the firm of O&M LAW LLP Advocates for onward transmission to the 1st Defendant.

ii. That the costs of this application be provided for.

2. The Motion is supported by the affidavit of Timdhar Said Sherman, the 1st Defendant/Applicant sworn on even date. She deponed that judgment was initially delivered in favour of the Plaintiffs on 13th May 2016, following which she filed applications dated 21st and 27th June 2016 seeking to set it aside and that by orders issued on 4th July 2016, as varied by consent on 9th September 2016, she was required, as a condition for stay of execution, to deposit the rental income from the suit property into a joint account held in the names of the parties’ advocates, commencing on 1st January 2017.

3. Subsequently, she explained, the advocates opened Account No. 01109173762700 at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch, in the name of Ochwo & Co/Nyiha M. & Co into which she deposited approximately Kshs. 3,400,000.

4. According to Ms Sherman, the initial judgment was subsequently set aside and the suit heard afresh, culminating in the judgment delivered on 10th July 2025, which upheld her equitable and legal interest in the suit property and dismissed the Plaintiffs’ suit with costs. As advised by Counsel, she stated, there is no order staying execution of that judgment or restraining her from dealing with the property and, consequently, no basis for retaining the rental income in the joint account.

5. She therefore seeks the release of the funds, together with all accrued interest, through her current advocates, O&M Law LLP Advocates, who took over conduct of the matter from Nyiha, Mukoma & Company Advocates on or about 23rd September 2020. She maintains that the Plaintiffs will suffer no prejudice, as the suit was determined in her favour and they no longer have any claim to the funds.

6. In response to the Motion, the 2nd Plaintiff, Douglas Odhiambo Oyugi, swore a replying affidavit dated 20th October 2025 on his own behalf and with the authority of the 1st and 3rd Plaintiffs. He deponed that the Plaintiffs, being aggrieved by the entire judgment and decree, lodged Civil Appeal No. E707 of 2025, Job Okuna Oyugi & 2 Others v Timdhar Said Sherman & the National Land Commission and that they also filed an application for stay of execution in Civil Application No. E476 of 2025, whose ruling was scheduled for delivery on 19th December 2025.

7. He further stated that pending that ruling, the Court of Appeal had issued an interim order dated 27th August 2025, staying the sale of the suit property. He urged the court to defer the hearing of the present Motion pending the Court of Appeal’s determination of the stay application.

8. The 1st Defendant filed a supplementary affidavit sworn on 3rd May 2026. She acknowledged that the Plaintiffs had appealed against the judgment and filed an application under Rule 5(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2022, seeking an injunction restraining disposal of the suit property and a stay of further proceedings before this court pending determination of the appeal.

9. She deponed that the Court of Appeal determined that application by a ruling delivered on 13th February 2026, granting the injunction but declining to stay further proceedings. Consequently, the Plaintiffs’ request to defer consideration of the present Motion pending the appellate ruling has consequently been overtaken by events. In her view, the refusal to stay proceedings supports her position that releasing the funds will neither prejudice the Plaintiffs nor render their appeal nugatory. She therefore reiterated that there is no basis for retaining the funds in the joint account and urged the court to allow the Motion.

10. In an affidavit sworn on 6th July 2026, Hellen Wambui, a Service Desk Officer at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch, duly authorised to swear the affidavit on the Bank’s behalf stated that, on 29th May 2026, the court had directed the Branch Manager to attend court and explain the status of the funds deposited in Joint Account No. 1109173762700.

11. She produced an account statement as at 22nd June 2026, and noted that as per the same, the account is maintained at the branch, remains active and last recorded a transaction on 31st May 2026. She maintained that having complied with the court’s directions, the bank ought to be discharged from the proceedings.

Submissions

12. The 1st Defendant filed submissions dated 6th October 2026. Counsel submitted that the Motion dated 29th July 2025 seeks consequential orders flowing from the judgment delivered on 10th July 2025, which dismissed the Plaintiffs’ suit with costs. The funds sought to be released had been deposited in a joint advocates’ account as a condition for stay of execution of the initial judgment delivered on 13th May 2016. Counsel maintained that compliance with the deposit orders was undisputed and that the affidavit sworn by Hellen Wambui on 6th July 2026 confirmed that the funds remained with Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch.

13. Counsel submitted that the initial judgment was subsequently set aside and the suit heard afresh, culminating in a determination in the 1st Defendant’s favour. Although the Plaintiffs lodged Civil Appeal No. E707 of 2025 and sought interim relief in Civil Application No. E476 of 2025, the Court of Appeal, by its ruling of 13th February 2026, only restrained disposal of the suit property and expressly declined to stay further proceedings before this court.

14. Invoking the doctrine of res judicata, counsel argued that the Plaintiffs could have sought preservation of the funds before the Court of Appeal but did not do so. He maintained that since the appellate ruling had neither been reviewed nor appealed against, the question of whether the post-judgment proceedings would render the appeal nugatory had been conclusively determined and could not be reopened before this court. He further submitted that the Plaintiffs’ request to await that ruling had been overtaken by its delivery.

15. Counsel argued that, in any event, the pendency of an appeal does not automatically operate as a stay or justify continued retention of the funds. He relied on Spire Properties (K) Limited v Gikandi Ngibuini t/a Gikandi & Co Advocates & 12 others [2023] KECA 464 (KLR) and Transnational Bank Limited v Jackson Ngibuini Gikandi t/a Gikandi & Co Advocates & 10 others; NCBA Bank Limited (Interested Party) [2023] KECA 463 (KLR), in which the Court of Appeal recognised that consequential orders should ordinarily follow the substantive determination unless a stay has been sought and granted.

16. Counsel maintained that the deposit orders issued on 4th July 2016, as varied by consent on 9th September 2016, were tied to the initial judgment and ceased to have a basis once that judgment was set aside and the suit ultimately determined in the 1st Defendant’s favour. Further relying on Hakika Transport Services Limited & another v Maghema & 2 others [2026] KEHC 4270 (KLR), he submitted that, in the absence of an order preserving the funds, there is no justification for their continued retention. He therefore urged the court to allow the Motion as prayed.

17. The Plaintiffs filed submissions dated 21st October, 2026. Counsel submitted that the 1st Defendant had misconstrued the scope and effect of the Court of Appeal’s ruling delivered on 13th February, 2026 in COACAPPL/E476/2025. Counsel explained that the Court of Appeal had been invited to restrain the disposal of the suit property and stay further proceedings before this court pending appeal. Although it granted the injunction, it declined to stay the proceedings on the ground that the continuation of post-judgment proceedings would not render the appeal nugatory. This finding neither directed the release of the funds nor determined the merits of the application dated 29th July, 2025.

18. Relying on Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, counsel submitted that the requirements of res judicata had not been established. Whereas the Court of Appeal had determined whether further proceedings should be stayed, the question before this court is whether the deposited funds should be released in light of the orders governing their deposit, the subsequent judgment and the pending appeal. Counsel contended that, although related, these questions are distinct, and the refusal to stay proceedings neither predetermined the application nor automatically entitled the 1st Defendant to the funds.

19. On the relevance of the pending appeal, Counsel acknowledged that the filing of an appeal does not, of itself, operate as a stay of execution. Counsel nevertheless maintained that the absence of an automatic stay did not render the appeal irrelevant to the exercise of the court’s discretion. Citing Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, counsel urged the court to consider the orders governing the deposit of the funds in the joint advocates’ account and the consequences of their release before determination of the appeal.

20. Counsel further submitted that the affidavit sworn by Hellen Wambui on 6th July, 2026 confirmed that the funds remained identifiable and preserved at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch. Their continued retention, counsel argued, neither constituted execution against the 1st Defendant nor determined the substantive appeal, but preserved the existing position pending determination of the appropriate relief. Counsel therefore urged the court to consider preservation of the funds pending appeal, or appropriate protective directions, and concluded by seeking dismissal of the application with costs to the Plaintiffs.

Analysis and Determination

21. Having considered the Motion, the affidavits and the submissions, the sole issue for determination is whether the monies held at Cooperative Bank, University Way Branch, Account Number 01109173762700 in the joint names Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. Co should be released to the 1st Defendant.

22. The 1st Defendant seeks the release to her of the funds held in Account Number 01109173762700 in the joint names of Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. Co Advocates, contending that the purpose for which they were deposited has been exhausted. She states that the judgment giving rise to the deposit arrangement was set aside, following which the suit was heard afresh and dismissed in her favour on 10th July, 2025. She therefore maintains that no subsisting order requires the continued retention of the funds.

23. The Plaintiffs opposed the Motion on the basis that they had appealed against the judgment and sought interim relief before the Court of Appeal. In his replying affidavit, the 2nd Plaintiff principally asked this court to defer consideration of the Motion pending determination of the appellate application.

24. By way of background, the Plaintiffs, suing as administrators of the estate of the late Hezekiah Nelson Oyugi, instituted this suit seeking, inter alia, nullification of the transfer of L.R. No. 209/4491 to the 1st Defendant, reversal of the corresponding entries in the land register, an account and payment of rental income, and a permanent injunction restraining further dealings with the property or receipt of rent.

25. Upon hearing the Plaintiffs’ evidence, the court, in its initial judgment delivered on 13th May 2016, found that the transfer had been affected through a forged transfer instrument and court order and that payment of the outstanding purchase price had not been proved. It consequently nullified the transfer, directed reversal of the relevant registration entries and surrender of the original title, and ordered the 1st Defendant to account for rent from 1998 to the date of judgment at Kshs.100,000 per month, together with interest, less the Kshs.4,800,000 already paid. The court also granted a permanent injunction restraining dealings with the property or receipt of rent and awarded costs against the 1st Defendant.

26. Following the judgment delivered on 13th May 2016, the 1st Defendant filed applications dated 21st and 27th June 2016 seeking to set it aside. On 4th July 2016, the parties entered into a consent pending the hearing and determination of those applications, providing, among other matters, for preservation of the rental income from the suit property in a joint account held by their advocates.

27. By a further consent adopted on 9th September 2016, the earlier order was varied. In particular, the requirement that the tenant deposit monthly rent of Kshs.200,000 from 1st August 2016 was varied so that the deposits would commence on 1st January 2017 in the joint account of the Plaintiffs’ and the 1st Defendant’s advocates. The advocates subsequently opened Account No. 01109173762700 at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch, in the names of Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. & Co.

28. On that account, the initial judgment was set aside and the dispute heard afresh. In the judgment delivered on 10th July 2025, the court upheld the 1st Defendant’s equitable and legal interest in L.R. No. 209/4491 and dismissed the Plaintiffs’ suit with costs. In particular, the court found that the 1st Defendant’s interest, arising from payment of the full purchase price, possession and subsequent registration, was binding upon the Plaintiffs and the deceased’s estate.

29. Having considered the background as set out herein, the deposit arrangement must be understood in its proper context. The consent of 4th July 2016, as varied on 9th September 2016, preserved the rental income pending determination of the applications to set aside the initial judgment. It neither conferred entitlement to that income upon the Plaintiffs nor required its indefinite retention. The initial judgment was subsequently set aside and, following a fresh hearing, the suit was determined in the 1st Defendant’s favour. The purpose for which the funds were preserved has therefore been exhausted.

30. Indeed, in Transnational Bank Limited v Jackson Ngibuini Gikandi t/a Gikandi & Co Advocates & 10 others; NCBA Bank Limited (Interested Party) [2023] KECA 463 (KLR), the Court of Appeal endorsed its decision in Eastland Hotel Limited v Wafula Simiyu & Co Advocates [2015] eKLR, explaining that interlocutory preservation orders lapse upon final determination of a matter. Applying that principle, continued retention of these funds requires a subsisting order or other sufficient basis beyond the original deposit arrangement.

31. The pendency of the Plaintiffs’ appeal does not, of itself, justify continued retention of the funds. By its ruling of 13th February, 2026, the Court of Appeal restrained disposal of the suit property but declined to stay further proceedings before this court.

32. If the Plaintiffs wished to secure preservation of the deposited funds pending appeal, they ought to have specifically sought their continued retention as part of the interim relief sought before the Court of Appeal. Having failed to do so, they cannot rely on the injunction preserving the suit property as a basis for retaining the rental income in the joint account, as that injunction does not extend to those funds.

33. Ultimately, the judgment in favour of the 1st Defendant remains operative, and no order preserving the deposits pending appeal has been demonstrated. The release of the said funds will not interfere with the injunction restraining disposal of the suit property. There is, therefore, no sufficient basis for their continued retention.

34. For those reasons, the Notice of Motion dated 29th July 2025 is allowed in the following terms:

a) All monies standing to the credit of Account No. 01109173762700 at Co-operative Bank, University Way Branch, held in the joint names of Ochwo & Co./Nyiha M. & Co., together with all interest accrued thereon, shall be released to O&M Law LLP Advocates for onward transmission to the 1st Defendant.

b) Each party shall bear its own costs of the application.

Dated, signed and delivered virtually in Nairobi this 12th day of November, 2026.

O. A. Angote

Judge

In the presence of;

Mr. Wachira for 1st Defendant

Ms Adongo for Ochwo for Plaintiff

Court Assistant: Tracy

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder