Land law

Nthenya v Aleri & another [2026] KEELC 7805 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Miscellaneous Application E260 of 2026
Judgment date
12 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mohammed N. Kullow

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this Court for determination is the Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, brought pursuant to Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and Articles 50(1) and 165(6) and (7) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010. The Applicant principally seeks an order staying execution of the judgment and decree delivered on 31st July 2026 in Milimani Commercial Magistrate’s…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have carefully considered the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, the affidavits filed by the parties, the written submissions and the authorities relied upon. The sole issue for determination is whether the Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant the grant of the orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026.

Paragraph 23 →

Reasoning passage

The Court further recognised that the trial court should determine the regularity of its judgment and the merits of the proposed defence before those matters are considered on appeal. I find that the same reasoning is applicable to the present circumstances.

Paragraph 28 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. E260 OF 2026

CATHERINE NTHENYA ................................................................................APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

CALISTAS CRINIS ALERI ...........................................................................RESPONDENT

AND

NAIROBI CITY COUNTY .................................................................INTERESTED PARTY

RULING

The Application

1. Before this Court for determination is the Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, brought pursuant to Order 50 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and Articles 50(1) and 165(6) and (7) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010. The Applicant principally seeks an order staying execution of the judgment and decree delivered on 31st July 2026 in Milimani Commercial Magistrate’s Court MCELC/E507/2024, pending the hearing and determination of her application dated 17th August 2026 before the subordinate Court. She further seeks orders restraining the Respondent, his agents, servants or representatives from taking any further steps in execution of the said judgment, preservation of the status quo and costs of the Application.

2. The Application is premised on the grounds set out on its face and the Supporting Affidavit sworn by Catherine Nthenya on 20th August 2026. The Applicant contends that judgment was entered against her without affording her an opportunity to present her defence or adduce evidence. She avers that although she entered appearance and instructed advocates to defend the suit, her former advocates failed to file a Statement of Defence or adequately represent her interests. She further maintains that she was not served with the requisite hearing and judgment notices and that the judgment was consequently delivered without her participation.

3. In her Supporting Affidavit, the Applicant states that she is the occupant of House No. 20, a three-bedroom flat situated at Kariokor Estate, Nairobi, which she claims was given to her late husband, Crispus Wafula Wanabule, in 1985. She avers that following her husband's demise, she continued occupying the premises and meeting the expenses associated with its maintenance, including payment of rent and utility bills. She maintains that the suit property has remained her home and that of her family.

4. The Applicant further deposes that she had initially instructed the firm of Kioko Mwende & Company Advocates to represent her in the proceedings before the subordinate Court. However, despite issuing instructions, no Statement of Defence was filed on her behalf. She also disputes having instructed the firm of Musyoki & Company Advocates, which subsequently purported to act for her in the proceedings. She attributes the failure to defend the suit to the inadvertence, omission or default of her former advocates and maintains that she should not be denied an opportunity to have her defence heard on merit.

5. The Applicant avers that following delivery of the judgment on 31st July 2026, which directed her to vacate the suit premises within 30 days and awarded the Respondent Kshs.100,000 as general damages for trespass, together with costs and interest, she moved the subordinate Court through an application dated 17th August 2026 seeking to set aside the judgment, stay execution and obtain leave to defend the suit. She contends that the subordinate Court declined to grant interim orders staying execution pending determination of that application, thereby exposing her to imminent eviction before her substantive application could be heard.

6. The Applicant maintains that unless the orders sought are granted, she stands to suffer substantial and irreparable prejudice through eviction from her home and loss of her personal belongings, rendering her pending application before the subordinate Court nugatory. She contends that the Application was brought without unreasonable delay and that the preservation of the prevailing status quo is necessary to safeguard her right to a fair hearing. She consequently urges this Court to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction and grant the orders sought in the interests of justice.

The Replying Affidavit

7. The Application is opposed through the Replying Affidavit sworn by Calistas Crinis Aleri on 31st August 2026. The Respondent contends that the Application is misconceived, incompetent and an abuse of the Court process, having been instituted as a standalone miscellaneous application seeking to stay execution of the judgment delivered on 31st July 2026 in MCELC/E507/2024.

8. He maintains that the Applicant cannot circumvent the prescribed appellate procedure by invoking this Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 165(6) and (7) of the Constitution. He further contends that the Applicant has neither filed a Memorandum of Appeal nor demonstrated compliance with the applicable appellate procedure, rendering the Application procedurally defective.

9. The Respondent further avers that the Applicant has failed to satisfy the requirements for stay of execution under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, particularly the demonstration of substantial loss and provision of security for the due performance of the decree. Regarding the alleged application dated 17th August 2026 before the subordinate Court, he states that neither he nor his advocates have been served with the said application and that no copy has been placed before this Court. He disputes the Applicant's assertion that the subordinate Court declined to grant interim orders, maintaining that no sufficient material has been presented to establish the existence, contents or status of that application.

10. On the allegation that the Applicant was denied an opportunity to be heard, the Respondent maintains that she was duly represented in the subordinate Court proceedings by the firm of Musyoki & Company Advocates, which filed an application dated 7th May 2026 seeking, among other reliefs, to arrest the delivery of judgment and obtain leave to defend the suit.

11. He avers that the application was heard and dismissed through a ruling delivered on 24th June 2026, following which the matter was scheduled for judgment on 30th July 2026, which was subsequently delivered on 31st July 2026. He contends that the Applicant was aware of the proceedings and has not produced any correspondence or complaint demonstrating that she withdrew instructions from the said advocates or challenged their representation before the subordinate Court.

12. Concerning the suit property, the Respondent denies the Applicant's assertion that he transferred the house to her late husband, Crispus Wafula Wanabule. He maintains that the property remains in his name and that no transfer has been effected in favour of the Applicant's late husband. He further contends that the rent receipts relied upon by the Applicant bear his name and do not establish ownership or any proprietary interest in favour of the Applicant or her family. He avers that he has continued paying rent in respect of the premises and that the Applicant has remained in occupation without his consent.

13. The Respondent consequently maintains that the Applicant has not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances warranting the exercise of this Court's supervisory jurisdiction or the grant of the orders sought. He contends that the Application is an attempt to suspend the execution of a lawful judgment without following the prescribed appellate procedure and that the Applicant cannot rely on alleged mistakes or omissions by her former advocates to invalidate proceedings already concluded before the subordinate Court. He therefore urges the Court to dismiss the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026 with costs.

The Further Affidavit

14. In response to the Replying Affidavit, the Applicant swore a Further Affidavit in which she reiterates that the present Application properly invokes this Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 165(6) and (7) of the Constitution, rather than its appellate jurisdiction. She maintains that the Application is intended to preserve the subject matter pending determination of her application dated 17th August 2026 before the subordinate Court.

15. She avers that she moved the subordinate Court seeking to set aside the ex parte judgment delivered on 31st July 2026, but interim stay orders were declined, exposing her to imminent eviction. She further contends that the absence of a Memorandum of Appeal does not defeat the Court's supervisory jurisdiction and that the circumstances warrant intervention to prevent her pending application from being rendered nugatory.

16. The Applicant further disputes the Respondent's assertion that she was duly represented by Musyoki & Company Advocates, maintaining that she neither instructed nor authorised the said firm to act on her behalf. She contends that the mere filing of an application by an advocate does not establish the existence of instructions and that she should not be prejudiced by proceedings undertaken without her knowledge or consent.

17. Regarding the suit property, she maintains that her late husband, Crispus Wafula Wanabule, occupied the premises from 1985 and that she and her family continued residing therein after his demise, meeting the attendant expenses. She acknowledges that the rent receipts bear the Respondent's name but contends that they do not conclusively establish ownership or extinguish her family's asserted interest in the premises. She reiterates that execution of the judgment would occasion substantial prejudice and urges the Court to preserve the prevailing status quo pending determination of her application before the subordinate Court.

Written Submissions

18. The Application was canvassed by way of written submissions. The Applicant filed her submissions dated 8th September 2026, in which she identified five issues for determination, namely whether this Court has supervisory jurisdiction to grant stay of execution pending determination of the application dated 17th August 2026 before the subordinate Court; whether the ex parte judgment delivered on 31st July 2026 violated her constitutional rights under Articles 50(1) and 43(1) of the Constitution; whether she had established substantial loss warranting stay of execution; whether the intended challenge would be rendered nugatory if stay was declined; and who should bear the costs. She submitted that the Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 165(6) and (7) of the Constitution, read together with Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, empowers the Court to intervene and preserve the subject matter without requiring the prior institution of an appeal.

19. In support of her submissions, the Applicant relied on Ondigo Vs Alenga & another; Nzuki & another (Interested Parties) [2026] KEELC 276 (KLR) and Mbaki & others Vs Macharia & Another [2005] 2 EA 206 on the right to be heard. On stay of execution and substantial loss, she cited Butt Vs Rent Restriction Tribunal [1979] KECA 22 (KLR), GNB Vs RWG [2020] KEHC 45 and Ngetich Vs Goren & another [2025] KECA 565 (KLR). On costs, she relied on Rai & 3 Others Vs Rai & 4 Others [2014] KESC 31 (KLR) and Muhammad & another Vs Kenya Copyright Board & 2 others; Kenya Association of Music Producers & 2 others (Interested Parties) [2025] KEHC 4229 (KLR). She urged the Court to grant the orders sought to preserve the suit premises pending determination of her application before the subordinate Court.

20. The Respondent filed his written submissions dated 13th October 2026, identifying five issues for determination, namely whether the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, instituted as a standalone miscellaneous application, is procedurally competent in the absence of an appeal; whether the Applicant had established a sufficient evidential foundation for the orders sought by relying on the application dated 17th August 2026; whether the requirements for stay of execution under Order 42 Rule 6 had been satisfied; whether the Applicant had demonstrated that she was denied an opportunity to be heard before the subordinate Court; and whether there was a legal basis for restraining execution of the judgment. He submitted that the Applicant had failed to invoke the appropriate appellate procedure and could not rely on the Court's supervisory jurisdiction to circumvent the requirements for challenging a judgment of the subordinate Court.

21. In support of his position, the Respondent relied on Wanja & another Vs Roothaert [2022] KEHC 10255 (KLR), Photo Energy Limited Vs Hashi Energy Limited, Miscellaneous Application No. 180 of 2018, and Scope Telematics International Sales Limited Vs Stoic Company & Another [2017] eKLR on the proper institution of proceedings. He further cited Musembi & another Vs Chembe & another [2023] KEHC 24151 (KLR) and Kensilver Services Limited Vs Mugambi & another [2024] KEHC 8733 (KLR) on the necessity of an appeal as a foundation for stay pending appeal.

22. On the requirements for stay, he relied on Karumba Vs Watatua [2022] KEHC 16019 (KLR), Butt Vs Rent Restriction Tribunal [1979], James Wangalwa & Another Vs Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR and Arun C Sharma Vs Ashana Raikundalia t/a Raikundalia & Co Advocates & 2 Others [2014] eKLR. He maintained that the Applicant had neither established substantial loss nor addressed the requirement for security and urged the Court to dismiss the Application with costs.

Analysis and Determination

23. I have carefully considered the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026, the affidavits filed by the parties, the written submissions and the authorities relied upon. The sole issue for determination is whether the Applicant has established sufficient grounds to warrant the grant of the orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026.

24. The Applicant has invoked this Court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 165(6) and (7) of the Constitution, seeking to stay execution of the judgment delivered by the subordinate Court. The Environment and Land Court is established under Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution, while Section 13(1) and (4) of the Environment and Land Court Act confers upon it original and appellate jurisdiction over disputes falling within its mandate. Although Article 165(6) and (7) expressly refers to the High Court, the Environment and Land Court exercises supervisory jurisdiction over subordinate courts handling environment and land disputes. In Eveready Security Guards Limited Vs Etseem Energy Limited [2024] KEELC 1145 (KLR), the Court affirmed that the Environment and Land Court has supervisory jurisdiction over magistrates' courts and tribunals in matters falling within its jurisdiction. The question is therefore whether the circumstances of this case warrant the exercise of that jurisdiction.

25. From the material placed before me, it is not disputed that the subordinate Court delivered judgment on 31st July 2026 in MCELC/E507/2024, directing the Applicant to vacate the suit premises and awarding the Respondent Kshs.100,000 as general damages for trespass. It is also evident that prior to the delivery of judgment, an application dated 7th May 2026 had been filed by advocates purporting to represent the Applicant, seeking, among other reliefs, leave to defend the suit. That application was heard and dismissed through a ruling delivered on 24th June 2026. The Applicant disputes having instructed those advocates and maintains that she was denied an opportunity to defend the suit.

26. Following delivery of judgment, the Applicant states that she moved the subordinate Court through an application dated 17th August 2026, seeking to set aside the judgment, stay execution and obtain leave to defend the suit. She contends that the subordinate Court declined to grant interim stay orders, prompting the present Application. The question arising is whether this Court should intervene and suspend execution of a judgment whose setting aside is being pursued before the Court that delivered it.

27. Under Order 10 Rule 11 and Order 12 Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules, as applicable to the circumstances in which judgment was entered, the Court may set aside or vary a judgment entered in default or in the absence of a party upon such terms as may be just. The determination of whether the Applicant was properly served, whether her advocates acted upon instructions and whether sufficient grounds exist to set aside the judgment therefore falls, in the first instance, within the jurisdiction of the subordinate Court. In Jackline Nyokabi Karara & another Vs Jeremiah Kariuki Kagema; Dominic Munene Njogu (Interested Party) [2022] KEHC 2537 (KLR), the Court held that: “It is only the trial court which is best placed in the first instance to look at the issue of the service of summons"

28. The Court further recognised that the trial court should determine the regularity of its judgment and the merits of the proposed defence before those matters are considered on appeal. I find that the same reasoning is applicable to the present circumstances.

29. The Applicant has not instituted an appeal against the judgment delivered on 31st July 2026, although she maintains that the present proceedings invoke supervisory rather than appellate jurisdiction. The absence of an appeal does not, in itself, defeat the exercise of supervisory jurisdiction. However, that jurisdiction is not intended to provide a parallel avenue for challenging decisions of the subordinate Court where the appropriate procedures for obtaining relief remain available. The Applicant must demonstrate an irregularity or other sufficient reason calling for supervisory intervention.

30. In the present case, the principal complaint is that the subordinate Court declined to grant interim orders staying execution pending determination of the application dated 17th August 2026. The refusal to grant interim relief does not, without more, establish that the subordinate Court acted outside its jurisdiction or denied the Applicant an opportunity to be heard. There is no sufficient material demonstrating that the subordinate Court refused to entertain the substantive application, prevented the Applicant from presenting her case or otherwise acted in a manner requiring this Court's supervisory intervention. The allegations concerning the conduct of the Applicant's former advocates and her right to defend the suit are matters that can be examined upon consideration of the application to set aside the judgment.

31. I have considered the Applicant's apprehension that execution will result in her eviction from premises she claims to have occupied with her family for several years. I also note that she approached the subordinate Court on 17th August 2026 and filed the present Application on 20th August 2026, shortly after delivery of judgment. While the apprehended loss and the promptness with which she sought relief are relevant considerations, they do not, by themselves, establish a proper basis for supervisory intervention. The Court must also consider the Respondent's entitlement to the fruits of his judgment and the fact that the subordinate Court remains competent to determine the Applicant's challenge to that judgment.

32. In the circumstances, I find that the Applicant has not demonstrated sufficient grounds for this Court to intervene in the proceedings before the subordinate Court. The application seeking to set aside the judgment should be determined by the Court that delivered it, which is best placed to examine the procedural history, the disputed representation and the reasons advanced for reopening the proceedings. It would be inappropriate for this Court to grant orders that effectively suspend the subordinate Court's judgment through separate proceedings without a demonstrated legal basis warranting such intervention.

33. Consequently, I am not persuaded that the Applicant has established sufficient grounds for the grant of stay of execution or the consequential orders sought in the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026. The Application therefore lacks merit.

Final Disposition

34. In the upshot, I find that the Applicant has failed to establish sufficient grounds to warrant the grant of the orders sought. Consequently, the Notice of Motion dated 20th August 2026 is hereby dismissed.

35. The costs of the Application shall be borne by the Applicant.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 12th day of November, 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Waweru for the Applicant

Mr. Odero for the Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder