Land law

Njoroge v Mwaniki [2026] KEELC 7802 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc L Case 6 of 2023
Judgment date
12 November 2026
Judge(s)
Christine Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Plaintiff commenced this suit vide the plaint dated 3rd February 2023. She averred that together with her late husband, they purchased the parcel of land known as Title Number Nairobi Block/136/12241, situated at Ruai, on diverse dates between the year 2002 and 2003, hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit property’. Further, that upon the demise of her husband, she completed the transaction by paying an additional Kshs.106,000/= and…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have considered the pleadings, testimonies of the witnesses, exhibits and submissions, the following are the issues for determination:

Paragraph 26 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC L CASE NO. 6 OF 2023

LILIAN NJERI NJOROGE …………..………………………… PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

KENNEDY MWANGI MWANIKI ……………………..…. DEFENDANT

JUDGEMENT

1. The Plaintiff commenced this suit vide the plaint dated 3rd February 2023. She averred that together with her late husband, they purchased the parcel of land known as Title Number Nairobi Block/136/12241, situated at Ruai, on diverse dates between the year 2002 and 2003, hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit property’. Further, that upon the demise of her husband, she completed the transaction by paying an additional Kshs.106,000/= and was then issued with a Certificate of Lease but on 19th August 2022, she discovered that the Defendant had trespassed thereon and has refused to vacate despite being served with an eviction notice.

2. The Plaintiff prayed for judgement against the Defendant for:

a) A permanent injunction against the Defendant, his servants and /or agents from interfering with the suit property.

b) An order of eviction of the Defendant, his agents and/or servants from the suit property herein.

c) General damages for trespass.

d) Interest on (c) until payment in full.

e) Costs of this suit.

f) Any other relief this Honourable Court may deem fit to grant in the premises.

Response

3. In opposition, the Defendant filed a statement of defence and Counterclaim. He averred that he is the legal /beneficial owner of Plot C311 (C346) now LR 136/12241, having acquired it from a Mr. David Macharia Thiga and that he has been in peaceful and open occupation without any interruption since 2016. He accused the Plaintiff of fraud and collusion with Embakasi Ranching Company Limited to illegally acquire her alleged title.

4. In the Counterclaim, he sought judgement against the Plaintiff for:

a) For order of declaration that the Defendant is the bonafide legal/beneficial owner of Plot No. 311 (C346) alias LR 136/12241.

b) An order of permanent injunction restraining the Plaintiff, her agents/servants or any other person from entering, trespassing and /or interfering with the Plaintiff’s possession of the suit plot.

c) An order of cancellation of the Plaintiff’s certificate of lease and rectification of the register to read the Defendant’s name.

d) Cost of the suit.

5. The suit was heard through viva voce evidence.

Evidence of the Plaintiff

6. The Plaintiff as PW1 testified that between year 2002 and 2003, together with her husband, George Kamau Kibera (now deceased), they purchased Nairobi Block 136/12241 from Embakasi Ranching Group Company Limited. Further, that upon her husband’s demise, whilst performing her obligation as the legal administrator of his estate, she was on 23rd May 2019 instructed by the vendor to complete purchase of the suit property by paying an additional sum of Kshs.106,000/= being the appreciated value of the suit property as at the time. The vendor further instructed her to pay site visit fees of Kshs.20,000/= on 11th May 2019, Kshs.75,000/= being transfer fees and Kshs.5,100/= being the vendor’s advocate’s fees to facilitate registration. Thereafter, she was issued with a Certificate of Lease on 4th September 2020.

7. It was her testimony that since she became the registered proprietor of the suit property, she has been unable to access it or have quiet enjoyment as it is in the possession of the Defendant who refused to vacate even after being served with an eviction notice of 7th October, 2022. She produced the list and bundle of documents dated 3rd February 2023 as P. Exhibits 1-9.

8. In cross-examination, PW1 confirmed that they were paying the purchase price in bits and that receipts thereof were issued in her sole name in respect of money paid after her husband died and others are in their joint names. She was emphatic that her late husband was issued with a non-member certificate from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited. However, she did not have an allocation letter from the said company. She explained that the Lease was issued in her name because her husband had died. She confirmed having submitted the late husband’s Death Certificate and a letter from the Chief to Embakasi Ranching Company Limited and insisted that she acquired her documents legally. Further, that the said company had made a radio announcement that purchasers were to be issued with their titles. She insisted that she reported the trespass by the Defendant to Embakasi Ranching Company Ltd and Ruai Police station vide OB No. 17/2022 but no action was taken.

9. In re-examination she stated that she has not been sued on allegations of acquiring title fraudulently and reiterated that Embakasi Ranching Company Limited asked for a letter from the Chief and her late husband’s Death Certificate before they gave her title.

Evidence of the Defendant

10. The 1st Defendant testified that on 25th May 2016, he purchased Plot No. G379 alias (C311), which later changed to C346 and is now Nairobi Block 136/12241, from David Macharia Thiga for Kshs.1.8 million, inclusive of all improvements therein. Further, that the said David Macharia had in turn purchased the said land from Benson Gitura Kahihu who was the original shareholder of the said plot from Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd vide share Certificate no. 1986. It was also his testimony that before purchase, he conducted due diligence at Embakasi Ranching Company Limited’s offices, paid for a site visit and he was assured that the title was clean. He stated that subsequently, he started following up on his title and paid Kshs.20, 000/= on 7th October, 2020 and Kshs. 31, 200/= on 21st May 2020 respectively being site visit, inspection of record and transfer fees. However, he was informed that the parcel had been allocated to someone else, prompting him to report to the DCI-Ruai on 14th May 2021 under OB No. 43/14/5/21. Thereafter, the Plaintiff was summoned but she failed to appear and has also ignored summons by Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd. He produced his list and bundle of documents dated 7th March 2023 as P. Exhibit 1-8.

11. In cross-examination, he confirmed that he had the Share Certificate in the name of Benson Gitura Kahihu. Further, that the suit property number changed from G379 to C346 on 21st April 2016, as per the said Share Certificate and that the face of the said Certificate shows that the changes were signed by the surveyor.

12. While he maintained that he executed a sale agreement on 25th May

2016, he confirmed that the sale agreement before the Court is dated 28th August 2016 and it does not indicate the plot number. He insisted that he paid survey fees and was taken to site by a surveyor from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited, as the only due diligence at the time was site visit. He claims that a purchaser would only execute a sale agreement when given greenlight that the Beacons were in order. He also confirmed that he paid the full purchase price in three installments.

13. Upon re-examination, DW1 reiterated his evidence in cross examination and contended that the suit property was changed from G379 to C346 before he purchased it, as indicated in map “C”. Further, that there was a three roomed house with electricity and a fence when he purchased the said suit property.

14. DW2 was David Macharia Thiga. He testified that about 25th May 2016, he entered into a sale agreement with the Defendant, for the sale of Plot No. G379 (C311), which was later changed to (C346) by Embakasi Co. Ltd. He confirmed that the Defendant paid full consideration of Kshs.1.8 million. Further, that he acquired the suit property in the year 2008 from Benson Gitura Kahihu who was a shareholder, of Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd and conducted due diligence at the said company since the property had no title. He claimed that the said company required him to pay Kshs. 2,000/= for site visit which he paid on 19th June 2008, then its directors/ surveyor pointed out the suit property in his presence and that of Benson Gitura Kahihu during a site visit.

15. It was his testimony that after the site visit, Embakasi Ranching Company Limited’s surveyor, Mr. Nyika confirmed the site of the suit property on the rear side of the vendor’s Share Certificate but changed the plot no. from C311 to C346 on map. He testified that after purchase, he was issued with his own Share Certificate on 8th July 2008 and that Mr. Gitura Kahihu gave him the following documents: his original Share Certificate, copy of his ID, copy of Beacon Certificate and site visit receipt. He confirmed that he then took possession and put up a two (2) bedroomed house which was occupied by one of his son’s known as John Thiga Macharia upto the year 2016 when he sold it to the Defendant.

16. In cross-examination, DW2 confirmed that he built a three (3) roomed house on the suit property and installed water and electricity by 2012 though he had no receipts to that effect. Further, that the sale agreement between Benson Gitura Kahihu and himself was not produced and there was no proof he went to Embakasi Ranching Company Ltd to conduct due diligence. He also stated that he sold the suit property to the Defendant on 25th May 2016 and later on they executed the sale agreement dated 28th August 2016.

17. Parties thereafter filed written submissions.

Submissions

18. The Plaintiff submits that having been issued with a Lease, pursuant to Section 24(a) of the Land Registration Act, she has absolute ownership rights over the suit property. Further, that her registration was preceded by an extensive verification exercise ordered by the Ministry of Lands and Physical Planning in collaboration with Embakasi Ranching Company Limited and having sat back and failed to assert any claim during the public verification process, the Defendant is legally estopped from challenging the outcome of that exercise or mounting a collateral attack against her title. She argues that official administrative acts performed by public officers and statutory bodies are presumed to have been done regularly unless proven otherwise and that the Defendant has not produced evidence to demonstrate any defect in the ministry’s verification process.

19. She also submits that her root of title is verifiable as she has a Share Certificate, evidence of payment of requisite fees, and a letter dated 21st November 2023 from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited confirming her ownership. She insists that while the Defendant alleged collusion and fraud, there is no evidence to impeach her title in terms of Section 26 of the Land Registration Act.

20. It is also the Plaintiff’s submission that no title could pass from DW2 as a seller who lacks a registered title or verified statutory allocation has zero legal interest to pass. Further, that the Defendant’s alleged long possession as a trespasser does not extinguish a registered proprietor’s title and having been wrongfully deprived of the use and quiet enjoyment of her land, she is entitled to general damages for trespass.

21. To buttress her averments, the Plaintiff relied on the following decisions: Peter Kariuki Mwangi v Land Registrar & Another [2024] eKLR; Makau v Kianda Foundation Educational Trust & 4 Others [2025] KEELC 18236 (KLR); Arthi Highway Developers Limited v West lands Waterfront Properties Limited & 6 Others [2015] eKLR; Eliud Njoroge Gachiri v Stephen Kamau Ng'ang'a [2018] eKLR and Keiyan Group Ranch v Samuel Oruta & 9 Others [2021] eKLR.

22. On his part, the Defendant submits that he is the lawful owner of the suit property, vide purchase from David Macharia Thiga, who had acquired it from one Benson Gitari Kahihu, the original shareholder of Embakasi Ranching Company Limited. Further, that his documents produced in evidence form a verifiable chain of ownership.

23. He submits that on the other hand, the Plaintiff has failed to trace a lawful root of title since she did not produce evidence of the original allocation, transfer documents, correspondence from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited or evidence of her husband's membership in the company or Letters of Administration and a Confirmation of Grant relating to her late husband's estate. Further, that she failed to call a representative of the Embakasi Ranching Company Limited to verify the alleged purchase and there is no evidence that she conducted due diligence or physically inspected the suit property before the alleged purchase, as he was already in occupation.

24. He further argues that the Plaintiff has not explained the lengthy delay between the alleged purchase in 2002/2003 and the issuance of her Certificate of Lease in 2020, given that Embakasi Ranching Company Limited distributed its properties to original shareholders by 2002. He urges the Court to find that the Plaintiff's title is tainted by fraud and illegality and cancel it under Section 80 of the Land Registration Act.

25. To buttress his averments, the Defendant relied on the following decisions: Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 5 Others [2023] KESC 30 (KLR); Daniel Kiplagat Maiwa v Rebecca Chepkurui Maina [2019] eKLR; Won & 3 Others v WEL & 30 Others and ELC No. 221 of 2019 [2025] KEELC 959 (KLR).

Analysis and Determination

26. I have considered the pleadings, testimonies of the witnesses, exhibits and submissions, the following are the issues for determination:

• Whether the Plaintiff has demonstrated the root of

title to LR No. Nairobi Block/136/12241 and whether she is entitled to damages for trespass.

• Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the Orders as sought in the Plaint.

• Whether the Defendant is entitled to Orders as sought in his Counterclaim.

27. The Plaintiff contends that together with her late husband, George Kamau Kibera, they purchased Nairobi Block 136/12241, from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited between 2002 and 2003 and upon her husband’s demise, she completed the purchase by paying additional purchase price and the requisite fees including: site visit, transfer and vendor’s advocate fees and was subsequently issued with a Certificate of Lease on 4th September 2020. She confirms that she has never taken possession owing to the Defendant’s trespass.

28. On its part, the Defendant contends that he purchased the suit property from David Macharia Thiga, who in turn purchased it from Benson Gitari Kahihu, the original shareholder of Embakasi Ranching Company Limited. Further, that he conducted due diligence before purchasing the property and took possession, where he found existing developments, including a three roomed house.

29. As things stand, the Plaintiff’s title is under challenge by the Defendant, on grounds that it was fraudulently acquired. It is only evidence of fraud, illegality or procedural impropriety that can impeach title. This is the import of Section 26 of the Land Registration Act which provides as follows:

“26. Certificate of title to be held as conclusive evidence of proprietorship

(1) The certificate of title issued by the Registrar upon registration, or to a purchaser of land upon a transfer or transmission by the proprietor shall be taken by all courts as prima facie evidence that the person named as proprietor of the land is the absolute and indefeasible owner, subject to the encumbrances, easements, restrictions and conditions contained or endorsed in the certificate, and the title of that proprietor shall not be subject to challenge, except—

(a) on the ground of fraud or misrepresentation to which the person is proved to be a party; or

(b) where the certificate of title has been acquired illegally, unprocedurally or through a corrupt scheme.”

30. When a title to land is challenged, the proprietor of such land has the burden to prove its title. The requirement for proof of root of title was discussed by the Court of Appeal which held as follows in the case of Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina [2013] KECA 94 (KLR):

“We state that when a registered proprietor root of title is under challenge, it is not sufficient to dangle the instrument of title as proof of ownership. It is this instrument of title that is in challenge and the registered proprietor must go beyond the instrument and prove the legality of how he acquired the title and show that the acquisition was legal, formal and free from any encumbrances including any and all interests which would not be noted in the register.”

31. Further, in Dina Management Ltd v County Government of Mombasa & 5 Others, Pet. No. E010 of 2021 [2023] KESC 30 (KLR), the Supreme Court stated that:

“…where the registered proprietor’s root title is under challenge, it is not enough to dangle the instrument of title as proof of ownership. It is the instrument that is in challenge and therefore the registered proprietor must go beyond the instrument and prove the legality of the title and show that the acquisition was legal, formal and free from any encumbrance including interests which would not be noted in the register.”

32. In this instance, PW1 confirmed that between year 2002 and 2003, together with her husband, George Kamau Kibera (now deceased), they purchased Nairobi Block 136/12241 from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited. Further, that upon her husband’s demise, on 23rd May 2019 she was instructed by the vendor to complete purchase of the suit property by paying an additional sum of Kshs.106,000/= being the appreciated value of the suit property as at the time. The vendor further instructed her to pay site visit fees of Kshs.20,000/= on 11th May 2019, Kshs.75,000/= being transfer fees and Kshs.5,100/= being the vendor’s advocate’s fees to facilitate registration. Thereafter, she was issued with a Certificate of Lease on 4th September 2020. In cross-examination, PW1 confirmed that she paid purchase price in bits and receipts were issued in her name.

33. On perusal of the exhibits she produced, I note there is non-member Certificate from Embakasi Ranching Company Limited. I further note there is a Lease issued in her name. PW1 explained that since the husband died, she submitted his Death Certificate and a letter from the Chief to Embakasi Ranching Company Limited and she was issued with the Lease. She insisted that she reported the trespass by the Defendant to Embakasi Ranching Ltd and Ruai Police station vide OB No.17/2022 but no action was taken. I note PW1 also produced a demand letter issued to the Defendant.

34. The 1st Defendant as DW1 claimed that on 25th May 2016, he purchased Plot No. G379 alias (C311), which later changed to C346 and is now Nairobi Block 136/12241, from David Macharia Thiga for Kshs.1.8 million, inclusive of all improvements therein. He explained that the vendor David Macharia had in turn purchased the said land from Benson Gitura Kahihu who was the original shareholder of the said plot from Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd vide Share Certificate no. 1986.

35. It was also his testimony that before purchase, he conducted due diligence at Embakasi Ranching Company Limited’s offices, paid for a site visit and he was assured that the title was clean. He subsequently paid, Kshs.20,000/= and Kshs.31,200/= on 7th October, 2020 and 21st May 2020 respectively being site visit, inspection of record and transfer fees. Since he was informed that the suit property had been allocated to someone else, he reported to the DCI-Ruai on 14th May 2021 under OB No. 43/14/5/21 and Plaintiff was summoned but she failed to appear and also ignored summons by Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd.

36. During cross examination DW1 confirmed that he had the share certificate in the name of Benson Gitura Kahihu but the number for the suit property changed from G379 to C346 on 21st April 2016, which changes were signed by the surveyor. I note he claimed to have executed a sale agreement on 25th May 2016, but produced sale agreement dated 28th August 2016 which does not even indicate the plot number. He also confirmed that he paid the full purchase price in three installments.

37. DW2 confirmed that on 25th May 2016, he entered into a sale agreement with the Defendant, for the sale of Plot No. G379 (C311), which was later changed to (C346) by Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd and he paid the full purchase price of Kshs.1.8 million. It was his testimony that he acquired the suit property in the year 2008 from Benson Gitura Kahihu who was a shareholder, of Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd and conducted due diligence at the said company since the property had no title. Further, he paid Kshs.2,000/= for site visit on 19th June 2008, then its directors/ surveyor pointed out the suit property in his presence and that of Benson Gitura Kahihu. He claimed that after purchase, he was issued with his own share certificate on 8th July 2008 and that Mr. Gitura Kahihu gave him: his original share certificate, copy of his ID, copy of Beacon Certificate and site visit receipt. He confirmed that he then took possession and put up a house which was occupied by one of his son’s known as John Thiga Macharia upto the year 2016 when he sold it to the Defendant.

38. During cross-examination, DW2 claimed that he installed water and electricity by 2012 though he never produced receipts to that effect. Further, that the sale agreement between Benson Gitura Kahihu and himself was not produced and there was no proof he went to Embakasi Ranching Co. Ltd to conduct due diligence. He explained that he sold the suit property to the Defendant on 25th May 2016 and later on they executed the sale agreement dated 28th August 2016.

39. From the evidence presented, it emerges that the Defendant’s plot number was changed twice. Further, there is a discrepancy on the date of the sale agreement in respect to the Defendant’s parcel of land since DW1 claimed to have executed it on the 25th May 2016, but produced a sale agreement dated 28th August 2016 instead.

40. It is worthnoting that from the sale agreement, there is no indication of the plot number. I note the Defendant paid for transfer on the 21st May, 2021 when the Plaintiff had already been issued with the Certificate of Lease on the 4th September, 2020 as evident in the Lease which was produced as an exhibit. I note Embakasi Ranching Company Limited that was the allotting authority vide its letter dated the 21st November, 2023 confirmed that the Plaintiff is the owner of Nairobi Block 136/12241 which is plot No. V 2675 (C346). Further, the Plaintiff produced Certificate of Lease, Lease, various receipts including one nonmember certificate indicating plot is number V 2675.

41. For the Defendant, DW1 produced Share Certificate for plot changed from G 379 to C 346 on 21st April, 2016. However, in a receipt dated the 7th October, 2020, plot is again indicated as G 379. On share certificate in the name of Benson Gitari Kahihu, it indicates plot no. G379. Further, on Share Certificate in the name of David Macharia, it indicates Plot No. G379 (C 311). On hand written note dated 1st July, 2008, it indicates Defendant’s plot is G379, but there is also C 311.

42. On a receipt dated the 19th June, 2008, it indicates the Defendant’s plot is G 379. Yet in another receipt issued to Kennedy Mwangi Mwaniki and David Macharia Thiga, which is for site visit, it indicates Plot No. G 379, yet this is issued after the Plaintiff’s title had already been issued. It is worthnoting that in a receipt dated 21st May, 2021 issued to Kennedy Mwangi Mwaniki it indicates Cert No. 2456 / 3593, but does not indicate the plot number. It seems to me, the Defendant took possession of a wrong plot.

43. Based on the facts before Court including the exhibits I have analyzed, while associating myself with the decisions cited, I find that no fraud has been demonstrated on the part of the Plaintiff. I hence find that the Plaintiff has demonstrated the root of title to LR No. Nairobi Block/136/12241.

44. On whether the Plaintiff is entitled to damages, the Defendant contends that he has been living on the suit property since 2016. In Kenya Power & Lighting Company Limited vs. Fleetwood Enterprises Limited [2017] KECA 358 (KLR), the Court held that:

“It is trite law and as correctly submitted by counsel for the respondent that trespass to land is an actionable tort per se and proof of damage is not necessary or required. In other words, where trespass is proved as in this case, the affected party such as the respondent need not prove that it suffered any damage or loss as a result so as to be awarded damages…”

45. From the evidence tendered noting that both DW1 and DW2 admitted to be on the suit property, I find that the Plaintiff has indeed demonstrated trespass on the part of the Defendant and suffered damage. I hence find that she is entitled to an award of general damages of Kshs.50,000/=.

46. The Defendant challenges the Plaintiff's title as being fraudulent and irregularly acquired and seeks a declaration that he is the bona fide legal and beneficial owner. He counterclaims for: a permanent injunction restraining the Plaintiff from interference, and orders cancelling the Certificate of Lease together with rectification of the land register to reflect his name as the registered proprietor. However, from the evidence tendered, I find that the Defendant has failed to demonstrate fraud on the part of the Plaintiff. In the circumstances, I find that the Plaintiff has proved her case on a balance of probability and will enter judgement in her favour. I however find that the Defendant has failed to prove its case on a balance of probability and will proceed to dismiss the Counterclaim. I will proceed to make the following Orders:

a. A permanent injunction be and is hereby issued against the Defendant, his servants and /or agents from interfering with the suit property.

b. An eviction Order be and is hereby issued against the Defendant, his agents and/or servants from the suit property after Ninety (90) days from the date of this judgement.

c. General damages for trespass awarded at Kshs. 50,000/=.

d. Interest on (c) until payment in full.

e. Costs of this suit is awarded to the Plaintiff.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Olaka for Mrs. Kinyua for Plaintiff

Nganga for Defendant

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder