Small Claims

Mohamed v Mahat [2026] SCC 177 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Lamu
Judgment date
22 July 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The claim was allowed for Kshs.50,000 for the two fishing-boat management trips. The claimant was also awarded Kshs.5,000 costs and interest at court rates on the principal sum from filing until full payment.

Supporting judgment passages

a) The claimant’s claim contained in the statement of claim dated 10/6/2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.50,000/=.

Passage 29 →

b) Costs of Kshs.5,000/= and interest of the amount in (a) above at court rates from the date of filing until payment in full are awarded to the claimant as well.

Passage 30 →
Issue 1Whether the claim is merited.

Held. Decided. The claim was merited and allowed for Kshs.50,000. The parties agreed that the claimant undertook two trips at Kshs.25,000 each; the respondent was contractually bound to pay. The respondent's asserted prior payments and demand for an account of other monies did not defeat liability: he did not prove payment, failed to produce allegedly favourable chats, and the admitted chats showed his admission of the debt and promises to pay. The accountability allegations were raised too late and were outside the pleaded defence.

Ratio. A party who admits communications showing liability cannot deny that liability without evidence rebutting the admission. Where a party asserts that unproduced chats support its case but does not produce them, the court may draw an adverse inference that they would harm that party's case and support the opponent. Parties are bound by their pleadings and cannot introduce an unpleaded defence by ambush.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

a) Whether the claim is merited.

Passage 15 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

13) The two trips having been taken and both parties having agreed that each trip would cost kshs.25,000/=, I do find and hold the respondent is bound to pay for the 2 trips as agreed in the contract between them.

Paragraph 13 →

a) The claimant’s claim contained in the statement of claim dated 10/6/2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.50,000/=.

Passage 29 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

10) When a party asserts that there are messages and/or chats that are favourable to him but he fails to produce the said chats to counter what the opposing party has filed, the court as of necessity has to draw a negative inference that if such chats were availed by the complaining party they would be injurious to his/her case and would infact support the opposing party’s case and that is why they are not on the record. Such is the situation obtaining in this matter.

Paragraph 10 →

11) A look at the chats in question as filed by the claimant, it is clear without regurgitating the exact words that the respondent admits the claim and infact makes several promises to pay unfortunately he never kept any of them. The respondent after admitting that the chats are between him and the claimant he is estopped from denying such liability when he has clearly admitted the claim in question.

Paragraph 11 →

12) The issues being raised now on accountability of the moneys sent to the claimant are an afterthought and a desperate move to deny liability and deflect issues. They are not genuine concerns in my view. If indeed they were, he ought to have raised them in the chats as a precondition to the debt being paid and not raise it at the hearing not even in his pleadings. I should add at this point that parties are bound by their pleadings and there is no trial by ambush in this day and age.

Paragraph 12 →
Issue 2Who bears costs of the claim.

Held. Decided. The respondent was ordered to pay the claimant's costs, assessed at Kshs.5,000, because the claimant succeeded. The claimant was additionally awarded interest at court rates on the Kshs.50,000 principal sum from filing until payment in full.

Ratio. Costs follow the event and are awarded to the successful party.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

b) Who bears costs of the claim.

Passage 16 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

14) On the 2nd issue of costs, it is evident with the finding above this claim is one for allowing and given the fact that costs follow events and are awarded to the successful party, costs are hereby awarded to the claimant.

Paragraph 14 →

15) The said costs are hereby assessed at Kshs.5,000/= payable by the respondent.

Paragraph 15 →

b) Costs of Kshs.5,000/= and interest of the amount in (a) above at court rates from the date of filing until payment in full are awarded to the claimant as well.

Passage 30 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

14) On the 2nd issue of costs, it is evident with the finding above this claim is one for allowing and given the fact that costs follow events and are awarded to the successful party, costs are hereby awarded to the claimant.

Paragraph 14 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

It is the claimant’s case that the respondent has not paid him Kshs.50,000/= an agreed amount for managing his 2 fishing boats namely MV Al-hajj and Aran for 2 trips. It was an agreement between the 2 of them that the cost per trip would be Kshs.25,000/=

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The respondent in principle does not deny that the trips were taken by the claimant and that the agreed price per trip was Kshs.25,000/=. He seems to have an issue with other businesses they had with the claimant in terms of boat repairs which both agree are distinct and separate from the issue of trips and infact the respondent asserts those other businesses he used to pay the claimant in a different account from those of the trips.

Paragraph 2 →

Reasoning passage

He takes the view that the claimant has to account for all those moneys amounting to Kshs.573,000/=. I find this strange as the amounts in the statement were not an issue until the debt fell due and immediately after the contract was terminated.

Paragraph 7 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether Thanaan Allah Mohamed had proved his claim for Kshs.50,000 for managing the respondent’s two fishing boats on two trips, and which party should bear costs.

Material facts

Mohamed stated that Yusuf Ali Mahat engaged him to manage MV Al-hajj and Aran for two trips at an agreed Kshs.25,000 per trip. The parties’ contract was signed on 6 November 2025 and was later mutually terminated. Mahat did not dispute that the trips occurred…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT AT LAMU

SCC COM NO. E023 OF 2026.

THANAAN ALLAH MOHAMED........................................................................CLAIMANT

-VERSUS-

YUSUF ALI MAHAT………………………………………………..…………..….RESPONDENT

JUDGEMENT.

BRIEF FACTS.

1) It is the claimant’s case that the respondent has not paid him Kshs.50,000/= an agreed amount for managing his 2 fishing boats namely MV Al-hajj and Aran for 2 trips. It was an agreement between the 2 of them that the cost per trip would be Kshs.25,000/=

2) The respondent in principle does not deny that the trips were taken by the claimant and that the agreed price per trip was Kshs.25,000/=. He seems to have an issue with other businesses they had with the claimant in terms of boat repairs which both agree are distinct and separate from the issue of trips and infact the respondent asserts those other businesses he used to pay the claimant in a different account from those of the trips.

3) The dispute arose after the parties mutually agreed to terminate the contract between them. The contract in question was signed by both parties on 6th November 2025.

4) The matter proceeded by oral evidence. I have considered the testimonies of both parties as well as the exhibits produced.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

5) The issues that are for determination are as follows;

a) Whether the claim is merited.

b) Who bears costs of the claim.

6) On the first issue, the respondent denies the claim on the basis that the claimant has to account for all the monies sent to him from the time they entered into the agreement and the respondent has produced an Mpesa statement for Kshs.573,000/=.

7) He takes the view that the claimant has to account for all those moneys amounting to Kshs.573,000/=. I find this strange as the amounts in the statement were not an issue until the debt fell due and immediately after the contract was terminated.

8) The respondent in his testimony seemed to be shifting goal posts and the court was at a loss as to what exactly was the position with regards to this debt. At one point he claims he has already paid him but when asked to show proof of the money paid he was unable to do so. The respondent was then tasked to make sense of the conversation between him and the claimant if that was indeed the case. The respondent admitted the chats were between him and the claimant but was quick to add that the claimant has only filed portions of the chats that were favourable to his case.

9) I mean any litigant would do that and it is incumbent upon the other party to also file those that are favourable to his case. That is the whole essence of evidence in a civil and criminal trial. It is only after such an exchange in terms of evidence that a court is able to make a conclusive determination as to the merits or otherwise of the claim or any defence thereto.

10) When a party asserts that there are messages and/or chats that are favourable to him but he fails to produce the said chats to counter what the opposing party has filed, the court as of necessity has to draw a negative inference that if such chats were availed by the complaining party they would be injurious to his/her case and would infact support the opposing party’s case and that is why they are not on the record. Such is the situation obtaining in this matter.

11) A look at the chats in question as filed by the claimant, it is clear without regurgitating the exact words that the respondent admits the claim and infact makes several promises to pay unfortunately he never kept any of them. The respondent after admitting that the chats are between him and the claimant he is estopped from denying such liability when he has clearly admitted the claim in question.

12) The issues being raised now on accountability of the moneys sent to the claimant are an afterthought and a desperate move to deny liability and deflect issues. They are not genuine concerns in my view. If indeed they were, he ought to have raised them in the chats as a precondition to the debt being paid and not raise it at the hearing not even in his pleadings. I should add at this point that parties are bound by their pleadings and there is no trial by ambush in this day and age.

13) The two trips having been taken and both parties having agreed that each trip would cost kshs.25,000/=, I do find and hold the respondent is bound to pay for the 2 trips as agreed in the contract between them.

14) On the 2nd issue of costs, it is evident with the finding above this claim is one for allowing and given the fact that costs follow events and are awarded to the successful party, costs are hereby awarded to the claimant.

15) The said costs are hereby assessed at Kshs.5,000/= payable by the respondent.

CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION.

16) The upshot of the foregoing and having considered the evidence and material before me I make the following final orders;

a) The claimant’s claim contained in the statement of claim dated 10/6/2026 is allowed in the sum of Kshs.50,000/=.

b) Costs of Kshs.5,000/= and interest of the amount in (a) above at court rates from the date of filing until payment in full are awarded to the claimant as well.

17) Orders accordingly.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT VOI SMALL CLAIMS COURT THIS…22nd ..DAY OF …July…2026.

F.M. MULAMA

ADJUDICATOR/RM

In the presence of:

Court Assistant:- Abuswaleh

Thanaan Allah Mohamed.

Yusuf Ali Mahat.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder