REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT MILIMANI
ELC LAND MISC CASE NO. Е138 OF 2026
EDWARD NDUATI NJOROGE............................1st APPLICANT
GRACE NJERI NJOROGE..................................2nd APPLICANT
SARAH W. KAMAU ...........................................3rd APPLICANT
VERSUS
FUNAN CONSOLIDATED LTD .......................1st RESPONDENT
PICTURESQUE PROPERTIES LTD ...............2nd RESPONDENT
RULING
1. Vide the Motion dated 29th April, 2026, brought pursuant to the provisions of Sections 5 (1) of the Judicature Act, Part 81 of the Civil Procedure (Amendment No. 2) Rules, 2012 of England, and Section 29 of the Environment & Land Court Act, the Applicants seek the following reliefs:
i. That this Honourable Court do find the Respondents to be in Contempt of the Business Premises Tribunal Orders issued by Hon. Patricia May on 19th January 2026 in BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026 Grace Njeri Njoroge & Others vs Funan Consolidated Ltd & Another.
ii. That the directors of the 1st and 2nd Respondents be committed to Civil Jail for a period of not more than six months' jail for the said Contempt of Court and/or the Respondents be punished in any other manner that the court finds just.
iii. That costs of this Application be paid by the Respondents.
2. The Motion is supported by the affidavit of Edward Nduati Njoroge, the 1st Applicant, authorised by his co-Applicants to swear the affidavit on their behalf. He stated that the Applicants are tenants of the 1st Respondent on L.R. No. 209/1951, known as the Salvation Army Complex, situated at the junction of Race Course and River Road in Nairobi, although they have no written tenancy agreements; that the 2nd Respondent is the sole director and shareholder of the 1st Respondent, while the 3rd Respondent is its property agent and the 4th Respondent the sole director and shareholder of the 3rd Respondent.
3. According to Mr Njoroge, they operate various businesses on the premises, including the sale of electronics, electrical goods, mobile phones and accessories; that on 16th January 2026, the Respondents raided the Applicants’ premises using hired goons, removed their goods and locked the shops, thereby denying them access and that they were not informed of the basis for those actions, although they subsequently heard that the Respondents were purportedly levying distress for rent.
4. He maintained that no proclamation was issued before the goods were removed and that neither the Respondents nor their purported auctioneers left a schedule of the goods taken.
5. Following those events, they lodged a complaint against the 1st and 3rd Respondents in BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026; that on 19th January 2026, the Tribunal issued an order directing those Respondents and their agents to unconditionally restore all the goods taken from the Applicants and that despite the order having been served, the goods have not been restored. Instead, the Respondents filed an application dated 20th January 2026, seeking to set aside the order, which remains pending. Mr Njoroge stated that the Respondents’ action has occasioned them loss of business premises, loss of goods and income, and inconvenience.
6. He maintained that the restoration order had neither been stayed, set aside nor varied, yet the Respondents continued to disobey it. As advised by counsel, this continued disobedience constitutes contempt of the Tribunal and undermines the dignity and authority of the court, respect for due process and public confidence in the administration of justice.
7. The 1st and 2nd Respondents filed grounds of opposition dated 29th May, 2026 premised on the grounds that:
i. The application lacks merit is misconceived, incompetent and is a gross abuse of the court process, untenable and an escapade of forum shopping.
ii. The application is made in bad faith, and its frivolous, vexatious and with no basis in law and is intended to circumvent the due process of this honourable court.
iii. The Applicants are seeking the court to find the Respondents in contempt of Business Premises Tribunal orders issued by Hon. Patricia May on 19th January 2026 being BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026 without disclosing to this court that the Respondents distressed the Applicants via a judgement in BPRT Case No. E924 of 2024 which orders have not been vacated nor stayed way before the orders were issued.
iv. The Applicants have failed to inform the court that they have filed an appeal being Appeal Case No. E203 of 2025 where they sought for stay but the same was denied and as an afterthought marred with escapades of forum shopping, they duped the Business Tribunal Court by filing another new suit on the same subject matter without disclosing the other existing matter.
v. The said orders issued in BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026 are overtaken by events as the orders issued earlier by BPRT Case No. E924 of 2026 had already taken event and executed and are still in force as they have never been vacated or stayed.
vi. That the Applicants failed to incorporate the auctioneer being Ishmael Esikote T/A High Class Auctioneers who enforced the orders as party to the suit being E077 OF 2026 as the goods were not in the possession of the Respondent.
vii. The balance of convenience tilts in favor of the Respondents as the Applicants have never complied with court orders issued in BPRT E924 of 2026 which they appealed and are still in arrears of more than Kshs 10,000,000 million even after the distress.
8. The 1st and 2nd Respondents also filed a replying affidavit sworn by Benjamin Ndiangui Wanjohi on 29th May 2026. He deponed that he is the managing director of the 1st Respondent, duly authorised to swear the affidavit on behalf of both Respondents.
9. He stated that, following protracted proceedings instituted by the Applicants, the Business Premises Rent Tribunal delivered judgment in the Respondents’ favour on 12th September 2025 in BPRT Case No. E924 of 2024. According to him, the Respondents complied with the resulting orders, but the Applicants failed to do so and instead sought to set aside the judgment and lodged ELC Appeal No. E203 of 2025. He averred that the setting-aside application was subsequently withdrawn with costs to the Respondents, while the appeal remained pending and was scheduled for mention on 15th July 2026 to confirm the filing of submissions.
10. According to Mr Wanjohi, the Respondents instructed Ishmael Esikote trading as High Class Auctioneers to levy distress for rent pursuant to the Tribunal’s orders, which had neither been stayed nor vacated. He maintained that the auctioneer followed due process and sold the Applicants’ goods. He added that the removal of the goods was supervised by the OCS, Kamukunji Police Station, pursuant to an order issued in Milimani Miscellaneous Application No. E3084 of 2025.
11. He deponed that the Applicants are abusing the court process and engaging in forum shopping by instituting BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026 and seeking restoration of the goods through the application dated 19th January 2026. He contended that they obtained the ex parte restoration orders without disclosing the earlier proceedings, the judgment authorising distress or the pending appeal. He further averred that the Applicants deliberately omitted the auctioneer as a party, despite having been served with the proclamation notices and schedule of the goods removed and knowing that the goods were not in the Respondents’ possession.
12. Further, he urged, upon service of the restoration orders, the Respondents filed an application dated 20th January 2026 seeking to set them aside. They contended that the orders were incapable of enforcement because the earlier orders permitting distress remained in force and the goods were no longer in their possession.
13. According to him, after hearing both parties and considering the earlier proceedings, the Tribunal directed that the two matters be heard together through written submissions, with a ruling scheduled for 29th June 2026. He argued that the Tribunal’s continued grant of audience to the Respondents supported their position that they were not in contempt.
14. He further alleged that the Applicants remained in occupation of the premises but had failed to pay rent for more than two years, accumulating arrears exceeding Kshs. 10,000,000. He maintained that their repeated applications were intended to prevent the Respondents from enjoying the fruits of their judgment and had occasioned them considerable hardship. Invoking the equitable principles that a party seeking equity must do equity and approach the court with clean hands, he contended that the application was tainted by malice, unfairness and abuse of process.
15. Finally, he maintained that the Tribunal had dismissed the Applicants’ complaint and confirmed their status as the Respondents’ tenants, thereby entitling the Respondents to levy distress. He asserted that the distress and sale preceded the restoration orders, which had consequently been overtaken by events and could not be enforced against the Respondents. He therefore urged the court to dismiss the application as unmeritorious and brought in bad faith.
16. Both parties filed submissions which I have considered.
17. Having considered the Motion, responses and submissions, the issues that arise for determination are:
i. Whether the Motion constitutes an abuse of court process and if not?
ii. Whether the Respondents are in contempt of the orders of the BPRT dated the 19th January 2026 in BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026?
18. Black’s Law Dictionary, 10th Edition, defines abuse as “a departure from legal or reasonable use; misuse.” In the context of judicial proceedings, the concept concerns the misuse of the court’s process for an improper purpose.
19. The scope of such misuse was considered in Public Drug Co. vs Breyer Ice Cream Co., 347 Pa. 346, 32 A.2d 413, 415, where abuse of judicial process was described as an imprecise concept encompassing an infinite variety of circumstances. It may arise even where the process employed is procedurally proper, if a party uses it for an improper purpose, including causing irritation or annoyance to an opponent.
20. Illustrating the circumstances in which such misuse may arise, the High Court in Patrick Macharia Nderitu vs Director of Public Prosecutions & 2 Others; Dovey Pharma Limited (Interested Party) [2020] eKLR, drawing on various authorities, identified the following instances of abuse of court process:
“a. Instituting multiplicity of actions on the same subject matter, against the same opponent, on the same issues or multiplicity of actions on the same matter between the same parties even where there exists a right to begin the action.
b. Instituting different actions between the same parties simultaneously in different court even though on different grounds.
c.Where two similar processes are used in respect of the exercise of the same right.
d.Where an application for adjournment is sought by a party to an action to bring another application to court for leave to raise issue of fact already decided by court below.
e.Where there is no iota of law supporting a court process or where it is premised on recklessness. The abuse in this instance lies in the inconvenience and inequalities involved in the aims and purposes of the action.
f.Where a party has adopted the system of forum- shopping in the enforcement of a conceived right.
g.Where an appellant files an application in respect of a matter which is already subject of an earlier application.
h.Where two actions are commenced, the second asking for a relief which may have been obtained in the first.”
21. Speaking to the same, the Court of Appeal in Leitich vs Mwangi (Civil Appeal (Application) E147 of 2023) [2025] KECA 1279 (KLR) (11 July 2025) (Ruling) stated thus:
“Abuse of the Court process creates a factual scenario where a party is pursuing the same matter by two or more court processes. In other words, a party is involved in some gamble; a game of chance to get the best in the judicial process. Had the applicant obtained the orders sought in the first application, the second, and the third applications would not have been filed. The applicant is simply seeking to obtain from the Court the same orders she could not obtain in the first application. Adding the prayer for a conservatory order cannot change the colour or character of the earlier application which was dismissed. As was observed by the High Court in the above case, the multiplicity of actions on the same matter between the same parties even where there exists a right to bring the action is regarded as an abuse of Court process. The abuse lies in the multiplicity and manner of the exercise of the right rather than exercise of right per se. The abuse consists in the intention, purpose and aim of the person exercising the right, to harass, irritate, and annoy the adversary or interface with the administration of justice. The instant application is an abuse of court process.”
22. The Respondents assert that the present Motion is an abuse of process and forms part of a series of proceedings instituted by the Applicants to frustrate enforcement of the Tribunal’s judgment of 12th September 2025.
23. They contend that, after seeking to set aside that judgment and lodging ELC Appeal No. E203 of 2025, the Applicants instituted BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026 without disclosing the earlier proceedings or the subsisting orders pursuant to which distress had been levied. They further allege that the Applicants deliberately omitted to join the auctioneer who had removed and sold the goods, despite knowing that those goods were not in the Respondents’ possession.
24. In their view, the subsequent institution of these contempt proceedings, while the competing applications remain pending before the Tribunal, amounts to forum shopping and an abuse of the court process.
25. The court has examined the annexed judgments and affidavits. The earlier proceedings were BPRT Case No. E964 of 2024. In its judgment of 12th September 2025, the Tribunal dismissed the tenants’ reference, recognised Funan Consolidated Company Limited as their landlord and Picturesque Properties Limited as its rent-collection agent, and directed the release of deposited rent. However, it also required reconciliation of each tenant’s rent account before recovery measures and stayed distress for sixty days pending reconciliation.
26. On appeal, the ELC, in its judgment delivered on 18th September 2026 in ELC Appeal No. E203 of 2025, partially allowed the appeal and declared the rent-increase notice dated 1st October 2023 null and void for non-compliance with Section 4 of Cap. 301. It also vacated the reconciliation directions and sixty-day stay of distress, directed that deposited rent be computed at the initial monthly rate and released to Funan, and required the tenants to pay rent to Funan as their landlord.
27. Vide the present Motion, the Applicants allege contempt of the orders issued on 19th January 2026 in Nairobi BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026. In that matter, the Applicants challenged the Respondents’ removal of their goods and locking of their shops on L.R. No. 209/1951, on 16th January 2026. Pending the inter partes hearing, the Tribunal directed the Respondents to remove the locks and reopen the shops within twenty-four hours, failing which the Applicants were at liberty to break the locks and re-enter the premises.
28. The Respondents were further directed to unconditionally restore all the goods removed and restrained from interfering with the Applicants’ quiet possession, evicting them, altering the terms of their tenancies or levying distress without following the prescribed procedure. The OCS Kamukunji Police Station was directed to ensure compliance with those orders.
29. The court has considered the respective arguments. The Respondents’ objection rests on alleged non-disclosure, overlapping proceedings and inconsistency between the restoration order and earlier determinations. By their own account, those matters were raised in their application dated 20th January 2026 seeking to set aside the order and therefore fall for determination before the Tribunal.
30. The present Motion seeks enforcement of the orders of 19th January 2026. No stay, variation or setting aside has been demonstrated, and the pending challenge does not, by itself, render their enforcement an abuse of court process. Accordingly, the objection is rejected.
31. The Black’s Law Dictionary (Ninth Edition) defines contempt of court as:
“Conduct that defies the authority or dignity of a Court. Because such conduct interferes with the administration of justice, it is punishable usually by fine or imprisonment.”
32. Speaking to the same, the Supreme Court in Republic vs Ahmad Abolfathi Mohammed & another [2019] eKLR posited thus:
“There is no doubt that an act in contempt of the Court constitutes an affront to judicial authority; and the Court has the liberty and empowerment to mete out penalty for such conduct, in a proper case. The object is, firstly, to vindicate the Court’s authority; secondly, to uphold honourable conduct among Advocates, in their standing as officers of the Court; and thirdly, to safeguard its processes for assuring compliance, so as to sustain the rule of law and the administration of justice”
33. Due to the repeal of the Contempt of Court Act, 2016, [see The Kenya Human Rights Commission –versus- Attorney General & Another [2018] eKLR] the substantive law governing contempt proceedings is the Judicature Act Cap. 8. Section 5 of which provides:
“(1) The High Court and the Court of Appeal shall have the same power to punish for contempt of court as is for the time being possessed by the High Court of Justice in England, and such power shall extend to upholding the authority and dignity of subordinate courts.
(2) An order of the High Court made by way of punishment for contempt of court shall be appealable as if it were a conviction and sentence made in the exercise of the ordinary original criminal jurisdiction of the High Court.”
34. Additionally, Section 29 of the Environment and Land Court Act under the title offences provides as follows:
“Any person who refuses, fails or neglects to obey an order or direction of the Court given under this Act, commits an offence, and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding twenty million shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or to both.”
35. As a principle, courts do not act in vain and their orders must at all times be respected. This was articulated by the Court of Appeal in Shimmers Plaza Limited vs National Bank of Kenya Limited [2015]eKLR referenced by the parties which stated thus:
“We reiterate here that court orders must be obeyed. Parties against whom such orders are made cannot be allowed to trash them with impunity. Obedience of Court orders is not optional, rather, it is mandatory and a person does not choose whether to obey a court order or not. For as Theodore Roosevelt, the 26th President of the United States of America once said:-
“No man is above the law and no man is below it; nor do we ask any man’s permission to obey it. Obedience to the law is demanded as a right; not as a favour’’.
The courts should not fold their hands in helplessness and watch as their orders are disobeyed with impunity left, right and centre. This would amount to abdication of our sacrosanct duty bestowed on us by the Constitution. The dignity, and authority of the Court must be protected, and that is why those who flagrantly disobey them must be punished, lest they lead us all to a state of anarchy.”
36. It is trite that contempt proceedings are quasi-criminal in nature due to the severe consequences they attract. Consequently, the standard of proof in such proceedings is higher than the balance of probabilities in civil cases, although not as high as beyond reasonable doubt. As stated by the Supreme Court in Republic vs Ahmad Abolfathi Mohammed & another [2018] eKLR:
“The standard of proof in cases of contempt of Court is well established. In the case of Mutitika v. Baharini Farm Limited [1985] KLR 229, 234 the Court of Appeal held that:
“In our view, the standard of proof in contempt proceedings must be higher than proof on the balance of probabilities, almost but not exactly, beyond reasonable doubt...The standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt ought to be left where it belongs, to wit, in criminal cases. It is not safe to extend it to an offence which can be said to be quasi-criminal in nature.”
The rationale for this standard is that if cited for contempt, and the prayer sought is for committal to jail, the liberty of the contemnor will be affected. As such, the standard of proof is higher than the standard in civil cases. This power, to commit a person to jail, must be exercised with utmost care, and exercised only as a last resort. It is of utmost importance, therefore, for the respondents to establish that the alleged contemnor’s conduct was deliberate, in the sense that he or she willfully acted in a manner that flouted the Court Order.”
37. In order to succeed in civil contempt proceedings, the Applicant has to prove that the terms of the order were clear, unambiguous and binding on the Respondent, knowledge of these terms by the Respondent, failure by the Respondent to comply with the terms of the order and deliberate conduct by the Respondent.
38. By way of brief background, the Applicants instituted BPRT Case No. E077 of 2026 against Funan Consolidated Company Limited and Picturesque Properties Limited, seeking the reopening of their shops on L.R. No. 209/1951, restoration of the goods removed on 16th January 2026 and orders restraining unlawful interference with their tenancies.
39. It was their case that the Respondents had removed their goods and locked the premises without prior proclamation or a schedule of the goods taken, thereby effecting an unlawful eviction under the guise of distress for rent.
40. By its order issued on 19th January 2026, pending inter partes hearing, the Tribunal directed as follows:
i. That pending inter partes hearing, the Respondents are hereby directed to immediately and within 24 hours remove the locks they have placed on the subject premises and to reopen shops namely A1, F21, A3, A4, A20, A19, F19 and A20 within the premises known as L.R. No. 209/1951 aka Salvation Army Complex located along the junction of Race Course/River Road, failure to which the Applicants are at liberty to break the locks and re-enter the premises.
ii. That pending inter partes hearing, the Respondents by themselves, their servants and/or agents are hereby directed to unconditionally restore to the respective Applicants all the goods carted away on Friday 16th January 2026.
iii. That pending inter partes hearing, the Respondents are hereby restrained from interfering with the Applicants quiet possession of the suit premises or evicting them or altering their terms of the tenancies or levying distress without following the prescribed procedure.
iv. That the OCS Kamukunji Police Station to ensure compliance with the orders.”
41. The Applicants assert that despite the clear, express, and binding nature of the orders aforesaid, duly served upon the Respondents through their counsel, the Respondents have declined to abide by the same.
42. Beginning with clarity, the Tribunal’s order of 19th January 2026 expressly directed the Respondents, their servants and/or agents to restore unconditionally to the respective Applicants all goods removed on 16th January 2026. The obligation was specific as to the goods, their recipients and the action required. The court is therefore satisfied that the restoration order was clear and unequivocal.
43. As regards the Respondents’ knowledge of the orders, the affidavit of service dated 19th January 2026 indicates that they were served upon their advocates, T.W. Murage & Co. Advocates. In considering that service, the court is guided by Shimmers Plaza Limited v National Bank of Kenya Limited (Civil Appeal No. 33 of 2012) [2015] eKLR, in which the Court of Appeal affirmed that knowledge of a court order supersedes the strict requirement of personal service for purposes of contempt proceedings.
44. The Applicants however ask that the Respondents directors be cited for contempt. In Africa Management Communication International Limited vs Joseph Mathenge Mugo & another [2013] KEHC 7019 (KLR), the court, discussing the manner in which contempt proceedings may be sustained against a corporate entity and its officers, persuasively noted:
“Given that the 2nd Defendant is a company, the question that arises is how service of an order is to be effected upon a company if the directors of such a company are to be committed for disobedience of such an order. To my mind, in order to hold a corporation with liability for contempt, it is necessary to show that the corporation has been properly served or that service has been dispensed with on the basis that an appropriate officer of the company had knowledge of the order. In the same way, in order to hold the directors of such a corporation personally liable for breach of an order, such directors should be served with the order or it must be shown that they had personal knowledge of the same.”
45. In Geoffrey Kathuri Kison & 10 Others vs East Africa Portland Cement Company Limited & 5 Others [2021] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held:
“We also note that the 2nd to 6th respondents cited for contempt are directors and officers of a corporate entity not cited in the application, which begs the question whether in such case the directors of a company will be personally liable for contempt committed by and in the name of the company. In the persuasive authority of Katsuri Limited v Kapurchand Depar Shah [2016]eKLR, the High Court (Mativo, J.) in considering contempt by a director of a company observed and rightly so in our view that: “The alleged contemnor is a director of the company. He is not a party to these proceedings in his personal capacity. The company is a legal entity. The proper procedure for the applicant was first to apply to lift the corporate veil then go for the directors in their personal capacities.”
46. Guided by the foregoing authority, the court notes that the Applicants have neither identified the directors whose committal is sought nor sought to lift the corporate veil to establish their personal liability. The general reference to the “directors of the 1st and 2nd Respondents” is insufficient to sustain a prayer affecting individual liberty in proceedings of a quasi-criminal nature. The requisite basis for the committal sought has therefore not been laid.
47. Consequently, the Motion dated 29th April 2026 is struck with costs to the Respondents.
Dated, signed and delivered in Nairobi this 12th day of November, 2026.
O. A. Angote
Judge
In the presence of;
Ms Mbai for Applicants
Mr. Mwangi for Respondent
Court Assistant: Tracy