REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC EP PETITION NO. E022 OF 2026
PETER NJOGU & 10 OTHERS............................PETITIONERS
VERSUS
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.......................... 1st RESPONDENT
NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION................. 2nd RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEMBER,
LANDS, BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND URBAN
PLANNING, NAIROBI CITY COUNTY….........3rd RESPONDENT
MATHARE NATIONAL GOVERNMENT CONSTITUENCIES
DEVELOPMENT FUND BOARD…….….……...4th RESPONDENT
THE FUND MANAGER, NATIONAL
GOVERNMENT CONSTITUENCIES
DEVELOPMENT FUND BOARD ………….……. 5th RESPONDENT
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is the 3rd Respondent’s/ Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 18th July, 2026, brought pursuant to the provisions of Articles 10, 50 and 259 of the Constitution and Sections 2, 9, and 31 of the Advocates Act seeking the following reliefs:
a) That this Honourable Court be pleased to find and declare that Waringa Wa Wahome, Advocate, is an unqualified person within the meaning of Section 2 of the Advocates Act, and that his purported conduct of these proceedings was undertaken in violation of the mandatory provisions of the said Act.
b) That, flowing from the foregoing finding, this Honourable Court be pleased to strike out the Petition herein and all proceedings consequential thereto, the same having been conceived, instituted and prosecuted by a person bereft of the legal capacity to act as an advocate before this Honourable Court, and therefore being incapable, in law, of properly invoking this Court's adjudicative jurisdiction.
c) That this Honourable Court be pleased to forthwith discharge, set aside and vacate all interim, conservatory and consequential orders issued in these proceedings obtained by an unqualified person.
d) That the costs of and incidental to this Application be borne personally by Waringa Wa Wahome.
e) That this Honourable Court be pleased to grant such further or other orders as it may deem fit, just and expedient for the ends of justice and for the preservation of the dignity, authority and integrity of its process.
2. The Motion is supported by the affidavit of W.S. Ogola, the County Solicitor of Nairobi City County Government, who depones that he is conversant with the facts of the matter and duly authorised to swear the affidavit on behalf of the 3rd Respondent. He stated that the Petitioners instituted these proceedings through a Petition dated 27th March 2026, and a Notice of Motion dated 27th April 2026, both filed through Waringa Wa Wahome, Advocate.
3. He explained that inquiries conducted through the Law Society of Kenya’s official Advocates Search platform revealed that the said advocate does not hold a valid practising certificate for the year 2026. He stated that as advised by counsel, Sections 2, 9 and 31(1) of the Advocates Act require an advocate to hold a valid practising certificate and prohibit an unqualified person from instituting or conducting proceedings on behalf of another person. As such, the advocate lacked the requisite statutory capacity to institute and continue conducting these proceedings on behalf of the Petitioners.
4. According to the deponent, the application concerns the legal capacity of the person who instituted the proceedings, as distinct from the validity of the pleadings as documents. He referenced the decision in HCCHRPET/E015/2026-Benjamin Okumu VS Board OF Directors OF Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Ltd and Ministry of Energy and National Cohesion and Intergration Commission And 6 Others, where a petition filed by an unqualified advocate was struck out on the ground that the defect was incurable and went to the root of the proceedings.
5. Mr Ogola asserted that the continued pendency of the Petition prejudices the 3rd Respondent, which must defend proceedings whose competence is disputed while remaining subject to conservatory and status quo orders issued therein. He adds that those orders affect the discharge of the 3rd Respondent’s constitutional and statutory mandate concerning land use, physical planning and urban development within Nairobi City County. He consequently urged the court to allow the application.
6. In response, the 1st Petitioner, Mr Peter Njogu, filed a replying affidavit sworn on 27th July 2026. He deponed that the 3rd Respondent’s account of the proceedings is selective and overlooks the substantive constitutional and legal grievances raised in the Petition, which remain pending determination. He denied that the alleged absence of a valid practising certificate on the part of the Petitioners’ advocate renders the Petition incompetent or automatically invalidates the proceedings.
7. According to Mr Njogu, the Petitioners instructed an advocate whom they believed to be duly qualified and entitled to practise law. They did not knowingly engage an unqualified person nor participate in any professional misconduct. He asserted that the 3rd Respondent has failed to distinguish between the professional consequences attaching to an advocate who lacks a practising certificate and the validity of documents prepared and filed on behalf of a client.
8. He relied on Section 34B of the Advocates Act, which, he maintained, expressly preserves the validity of legal documents prepared by an advocate without a valid practising certificate, including pleadings, affidavits, depositions and applications. He urged that the statutory provisions invoked by the 3rd Respondent must be read together with Section 34B and cannot support the automatic nullification of the Petition.
9. Mr Njogu distinguished the present circumstances from the decision in Benjamin Okumu vs Board of Directors of Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Limited & Others(supra) on the ground that it concerned an advocate who was a full-time public officer. He stated that as advised by Counsel, the Court of Appeal’s decision in Otieno & another vs Bodo [2025] KECA 73 (KLR), which is directly applicable to these proceedings supports the continued validity of the Petition and the proceedings.
10. He further denied that the pendency of the Petition occasions any prejudice warranting its striking out, noting that the 3rd Respondent remains at liberty to defend it on the merits. He maintained that the interim, conservatory and status quo orders were issued in the exercise of the court’s jurisdiction and that the allegation concerning the advocate’s practising certificate does not, by itself, provide a lawful basis for setting them aside.
11. The Petitioner urged that striking out the Petition will prejudice the Petitioners and potentially necessitate fresh proceedings, thereby increasing the expenditure of judicial time and resources. He accordingly urged the court to dismiss the application with costs and allow the Petition to proceed to a hearing on the merits.
Submissions
12. The parties made oral submissions on 5th October 2026. Mr Karanja, appearing for the 3rd Respondent, submitted that the institution and prosecution of the Petition by an advocate without a valid practising certificate contravenes Section 2, 9 and 31 of the Advocates Act. He argued that the Petitioners have not denied that Ms Waringa Wahome lacks a practising certificate. Their response, he urged, did not cure the resulting illegality. He maintained that an unqualified person cannot properly invoke the court’s jurisdiction on behalf of a litigant and that the Petition and all consequential proceedings are a nullity.
13. In response, Ms Wahome submitted that the provisions relied upon by the 3rd Respondent cannot not be read in isolation from Section 34B of the Advocates Act, which preserves the validity of legal documents prepared by an advocate without a valid practising certificate. She stated that she held a practising certificate at the time of the submissions, her application having been accepted on 27th July 2026.
14. Relying on the Court of Appeal’s decision in Otieno & another vs Bodo [2025] KECA 73 (KLR), Civil Appeal No. 195 of 2019, she argued that an advocate’s failure to hold a practising certificate does not automatically invalidate proceedings or documents filed on behalf of a client. she urged that an innocent litigant should not be penalised for counsel’s non-compliance.
15. In rejoinder, Mr Karanja submitted that Section 34B must be read together with the other provisions of the Advocates Act. He maintained that it protects the validity of legal documents prepared by an advocate without a practising certificate, whereas Section 31 regulates the advocate’s conduct in instituting and prosecuting proceedings.
16. Referring to the National Bank of Kenya Ltd vs Anaj Warehousing Ltd (Petition 36 of 2014) [2015] KESC 4 (KLR), he argued that the court had distinguished between the validity of documents and the advocate’s capacity to conduct proceedings. He further referred to the decision in Benjamin Okumu vs Board Of Directors of Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Ltd And Ministry Of Energy and National Cohesion and Intergration Commission And 6 Others in which a petition was struck out and a fresh petition admitted. He urged that the motion be allowed.
Analysis and Determination
17. Having considered the Motion, response and submissions, the issues that arise for determination are:
i. Whether a declaration should issue that Waringa Wa Wahome, Advocate, is an unqualified person within the meaning of Section 2 of the Advocates Act and whether his conduct in these proceedings contravened the Act?
ii. Whether, as a consequence, the Petition and all consequential proceedings, including the interim and conservatory orders should be discharged?
iii. Whether the costs of the application should be borne personally by the advocate?
18. The 3rd Respondent seeks a declaration that Mr Waringa Wa Wahome, Advocate, is an unqualified person within the meaning of Section 2 of the Advocates Act. That section defines an “unqualified person as a person who is not qualified under Section 9 and includes an advocate who is not qualified under Section 9, is not exempt under Section 10 and fails to take out a practicing certificate.
19. Section 9, in turn, provides that, subject to the Act, a person is qualified to act as an advocate only if he has been admitted as an advocate, his name is for the time being on the Roll and he has a practising certificate in force. These requirements are cumulative.
20. In the present case, it is conceded that Ms Waringa Wahome did not hold a valid practising certificate when she instituted these proceedings. During oral submissions, however, she stated that she subsequently applied for a practicing certificate, that her application was accepted on 27th July 2026 and that she now holds a valid practising certificate. The question therefore requires a distinction between her qualification at the commencement of the proceedings and her present status.
21. The subsequent acquisition of a practising certificate does not retrospectively satisfy the requirements of Section 9. At the time counsel instituted these proceedings sometime in April, 2026 and her appearances in May, counsel lacked a practising certificate and, was an unqualified person within the meaning of Section 2. Her acting as an advocate during that period consequently contravened Section 31(1) of the Act which provides thus:
“Subject to Section 83, no unqualified person shall act as an advocate, or as such cause any summons or other process to issue, or institute, carry on or defend any suit or other proceedings in the name of any other person in any court of civil or criminal jurisdiction.”
22. That finding is however confined to the period during which she practised without a valid certificate. Accordingly, the court declines to declare Ms Waringa Wahome presently unqualified, as she now holds a valid practising certificate. It nevertheless finds that she was unqualified when she instituted these proceedings and during the period in which she acted without one.
23. The 3rd Respondent seeks the dismissal of the Petition and all consequential proceedings, together with the discharge of the interim and conservatory orders, on the ground that Ms Waringa Wahome lacked a valid practising certificate when she instituted the proceedings and during several subsequent appearances. That absence is conceded. The question is whether counsel’s non-compliance invalidates the Petition, the proceedings undertaken and the orders issued therein.
24. Section 34(1)(f) of the Advocates Act prohibits an unqualified person from taking instructions or drawing or preparing any document or instrument relating to legal proceedings. That prohibition must, however, be read alongside Section 34B, which expressly addresses the consequences of an advocate’s failure to obtain a practising certificate.
25. Under Section 34B (1), such failure constitutes professional misconduct. Section 34B (2) nevertheless provides that, notwithstanding any other provision of the Act, nothing shall affect the validity of a legal document drawn or prepared by an advocate without a valid practising certificate.
26. Section 34B (3) expressly includes pleadings, affidavits, depositions, applications, deeds and other related instruments filed in a registry as legal documents whose validity can be affected just because they were drawn by an advocate without a practicing certificate. The Act thus distinguishes between the advocate’s professional default and the validity of the documents prepared for the client.
27. Speaking to the same, the Court of Appeal in Amigos Nuts and Commodities Limited vs Kam Hung Tsui [2020] KECA 108 (KLR) noted thus:
“The issue of an advocate drawing pleadings and preparing documents without possessing a current practicing certificate was conclusively addressed by the Supreme Court in the case of National Bank Limited v Anaj Warehousing Limited [2015] eKLR. We are also guided by this Court’s decision in Peterson Ndung’u, Stephen Gichanga Gituro, N. Ojwang, Peter Kariuki, Joseph M. Kyavi & James Kimani v Kenya Power & Lighting Company Ltd [2018] eKLR where it expressed as follows:
“23. Regarding the validity of instruments or documents other than of conveyance, prepared by an advocate who at the time was not holding a current practising certificate, we are persuaded by the decision of Ngugi, J. in the case of R V Resident Magistrate’s Court at Kiambu Ex-Parte Geoffrey Kariuki Njuguna & 9 Others [2016] eKLR where the learned Judge stated as follows:
“...The Supreme Court reasoned that the basis for the Court of Appeal reasoning in the Wilson Ndolo Ayah Case was not the text of the statute but public policy – public policy that declaring all documents signed by a lawyer without a practicing certificate as null and void creates a disincentive for lawyers to defy statutory provisions on taking of practicing certificates and creates a general public disposition that courts do not condone or encourage illegalities. The Supreme Court faulted this reasoning as applied to the case of admitted lawyers (who are in the roll of advocates) because it exacts a huge penalty on innocent clients who had plausible and reasonable basis for believing that the lawyer in question was duly qualified. Instead, the Supreme Court urges the Court, in line with the new Constitutional ethos, to take the lived realities of Kenyans into consideration in interpreting the statutory provision in question.”
The learned Judge continued as follows:
“The Supreme Court held that since the statute did not expressly state that any documents signed by a lawyer who did not have a practicing certificate were invalid, that interpretation was unwarranted. The court called on the overriding principles of equity in reaching the opposite conclusion. Even then, it is important to note, the Supreme Court neither limited nor announced the outer limits of the categories of documents which would be covered by the flexible rule the court announced in Anaj Warehousing Limited Case. First, the Court announced that with respect to conveyancing or other contractual documents identified in section 34 of the Advocates Act, even the flexible interpretation it had embraced would not cover documents drawn by non-lawyers or advocates who had been disbarred or suspended from practice. Secondly, the Court did not expressly provide that the flexible interpretation it announced would cover pleadings and submissions drawn by a lawyer who did not have a practicing certificate. This latter question is, of course, the question squarely facing us in the present application…As I stated above, however, I believe that the reasoning of the Supreme Court in the Anaj Warehousing Limited Case can easily be extended to the situation presented by application of section 31 of the Advocates Act where a lawyer instructed by a client who is acting in good faith draws pleadings and addresses the court on a matter only for it to be discovered later that the lawyer did not have a practicing certificate.”
This Court then concluded in Peterson Ndu’ngu Stephen (supra) that:-
“24. By parity of reasoning of the Supreme Court decision in the Anaj Warehousing Case, we find and hold that no pleadings, documents or submissions become invalid under Section 31 of the Advocates Act only by dint of their having been prepared by an advocate who at the time was not holding a current practising certificate. The contrary effect is that documents prepared by other categories of unqualified persons such as non-advocates whose names have been struck off the roll of advocates shall be void for all purposes.”
28. The distinction is therefore material. An admitted advocate whose name remains on the Roll but who lacks an annual practising certificate does not fall into the same category as a person who has never been admitted, or an advocate who has been suspended or struck off the Roll.
29. Although the absence of a certificate renders the advocate unqualified to practise during the relevant period, it does not, by itself, invalidate the pleadings prepared or filed. Here, the established default concerns Ms Wahome’s failure to take out a practising certificate.
30. The 3rd Respondent relies on Benjamin Okumu vs Board of Directors of Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Limited & others, Constitutional Petition No. E015 of 2026. In this case, the court struck out a Petition because the advocate’s public employment prohibited him from undertaking private practice.
31. No comparable restriction has been established against Ms Wahome. That decision is therefore distinguishable, as the present objection concerns the absence of a current practising certificate, whose consequences are governed by Section 34B of the Advocates Act and the applicable appellate authorities.
32. The court is also unpersuaded by the proposed distinction between Sections 31 and 34B. The same must be read harmoniously. To preserve the initiating pleading but nullify the entire proceeding solely because of the same default would deprive that statutory protection of practical effect.
33. The request to discharge the interim and conservatory orders rests on the same alleged nullity and consequently fails with it. Those orders were issued by the court and are not rendered invalid solely by the professional default of the advocate who moved it.
34. The 3rd Respondent asks that Ms Wahome personally bear the costs of the application. It is conceded that she instituted these proceedings and subsequently appeared before the court without a valid practising certificate. Section 31(1) of the Advocates Act prohibits an unqualified person from acting as an advocate or conducting proceedings on behalf of another person.
35. Under subsection (2)(a), a person who contravenes that prohibition is deemed to be in contempt of the court before which he/she acts. Ms Wahome’s conduct was therefore contemptuous within the meaning of that provision and cannot be dismissed as a mere procedural lapse.
36. The obligation to hold a valid practising certificate rested upon Ms Wahome, and her subsequent acquisition of one does not excuse her earlier conduct. Her failure occasioned the objection and necessitated consideration of the validity of the proceedings. The resulting costs should therefore fall upon her personally rather than her client. This is notwithstanding the fact that the Respondent’s application fails.
37. In the end, the Motion is found to be unmerited and is dismissed. Costs of the application shall be born by Ms. Waringa Wa Wahome, the Petitioners’ counsel.
Dated, signed and delivered virtually in Nairobi this 12th day of November, 2026.
O. A. Angote
Judge
In the presence of;
Mr. Karanja for 3rd Respondent
Ms Warenga Wahome for petitioners.
Court Assistant: Tracy