REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. E551 OF 2025
ANTHONY MBITHI MUTUKU ....................................................PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
-VERSUS-
BENJAMIN MUOKI .......................................................1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
PIUS KATISO .................................................................2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
JAMUHURI TECHNICAL SECONDARY LIMITED ............3RD DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
RULING
The Application
1. Before this Court for determination is the Plaintiff/Applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 14th September 2026, brought pursuant to Order 40 Rule 3 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, Section 29 of the Environment and Land Court Act, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, and all other enabling provisions of the law.
2. The Applicant seeks, principally, an order finding the 3rd Defendant/Respondent in contempt of the orders issued by this Court on 16th July 2026, lifting the 3rd Respondent’s corporate veil and summoning its directors and company secretary to show cause why they should not be held personally liable for contempt. The Applicant further seeks orders compelling the immediate cessation of construction and development activities on the suit property, removal of the structures allegedly erected in breach of the Court's orders, restoration of the property to its previous condition, police assistance in enforcing the orders, and costs of the Application.
3. The Application is premised on the grounds set out on its face and the Supporting Affidavit sworn by Anthony Mbithi Mutuku on 14th September 2026. The Applicant deposes that, by a Ruling delivered on 16th July 2026, this Court issued status quo orders restraining the Plaintiff and the 3rd Defendant from selling, transferring, mortgaging or leasing the suit property to third parties and further directed that neither party should change the character of the land. He maintains that the orders were issued in the presence of the parties, were brought to the attention of the 3rd Respondent and remain valid and binding, having neither been varied nor set aside.
4. The Applicant contends that, notwithstanding knowledge of the said orders, the 3rd Respondent deliberately proceeded to undertake construction and development activities on the suit property, including the erection of a perimeter wall, thereby materially altering its physical character and condition. He relies on photographs annexed to his Supporting Affidavit and marked AMM-1 as evidence of the alleged construction activities. According to the Applicant, these activities constitute wilful and deliberate disobedience of the Court's orders requiring the preservation of the suit property pending determination of the dispute.
5. The Applicant further avers that the directors of the 3rd Respondent, particularly Eng. Isaac Gathungu Wanjohi and Isabella Nyaguthii Wanjohi, knowingly permitted, authorised or facilitated the alleged acts of disobedience. He consequently urges the Court to lift the corporate veil of the 3rd Respondent and hold the responsible officers personally accountable for the alleged contempt. He maintains that unless the Court intervenes, the continued construction and development activities will defeat the purpose of the status quo orders and prejudice the determination of the substantive dispute.
The Replying Affidavit
6. The Application is opposed through the Replying Affidavit sworn by Eng. Isaac Gathungu Wanjohi on 30th September 2026, in his capacity as a Director of the 3rd Defendant/Respondent. The deponent denies the allegations of contempt and maintains that the Application is founded on false, misleading and misconceived allegations intended to create an erroneous impression that the 3rd Respondent has disobeyed the orders of this Court.
7. The deponent acknowledges that this Court issued orders on 16th July 2026 preserving the status quo in respect of the suit property and restraining the parties from undertaking activities that would alter its character pending determination of the suit. He avers that the 3rd Respondent, which remains in possession of the suit property, has fully complied with the said orders and has not undertaken or authorised any development, construction, excavation, subdivision, sale, transfer or other dealings contrary to the Court's directions.
8. He contends that the photographs relied upon by the Applicant depict developments taking place on an adjoining parcel of land belonging to a third party and not on the suit property. He relies on photographs annexed to his Affidavit and marked SGW-1 to distinguish the suit property from the adjoining parcel. He maintains that the Applicant has failed to establish that the alleged construction activities occurred on the suit property or that the 3rd Respondent undertook any acts in breach of the Court's orders.
9. The deponent further avers that the Applicant included Isabella Nyaguthii Wanjohi, a former director of the 3rd Respondent, among the alleged contemnors despite her demise on 21st June 2026, prior to the issuance of the orders complained of. He annexes a copy of her death certificate marked SGW-2 and contends that her inclusion demonstrates the misleading nature of the Application. He further states that the Applicant had previously filed an application dated 15th June 2026 seeking to join Premier Bank Limited to the proceedings, but failed to take the necessary steps towards its joinder and service despite the Court's directions.
10. The deponent maintains that contempt proceedings are quasi-criminal in nature and require cogent and credible evidence of deliberate disobedience. He contends that the present Application is frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court's process, intended to divert attention from the substantive dispute and delay its determination. He therefore urges the Court to dismiss the Application with costs and direct the parties to proceed with the hearing and determination of the main suit.
The Further Affidavit
11. In response, the Applicant filed a Further Affidavit sworn on 12th October 2026, in which he reiterates that the 3rd Respondent has deliberately disobeyed the Court's orders of 16th July 2026 by undertaking construction and development activities on the suit property, thereby altering its character contrary to the prevailing status quo orders. He disputes the 3rd Respondent's contention that the photographs depict an adjoining property and maintains that the developments complained of are situated on the suit property.
12. He relies on additional photographs annexed and marked AMM-1 and AMM-2, which he contends demonstrate the state of the property before the proceedings and the subsequent construction activities. The Applicant further maintains that the 3rd Respondent has failed to substantiate its allegation that the developments are on a separate parcel of land. He contends that the death of Isabella Nyaguthii Wanjohi and the issues concerning the proposed joinder of Premier Bank Limited do not diminish the alleged disobedience of the Court's orders. He consequently urges the Court to intervene to preserve the suit property pending determination of the substantive dispute.
Submissions
Applicant’s Submissions
13. The Applicant filed written submissions dated 16th October 2026, wherein he identified three issues for determination, namely: whether the Court should lift the corporate veil of the 3rd Respondent and hold its directors, shareholders and company secretary personally liable for disobedience of the Court's orders; whether the 3rd Respondent and its officers should be cited and punished for contempt; and the appropriate remedies. On the issue of personal liability, the Applicant relied on John Warungu Wanjeru Vs Family Bank Limited & 5 Others [2021] eKLR, submitting that the corporate veil may be lifted where directors knowingly facilitate or permit disobedience of court orders. He maintained that the death of one of the directors does not prevent the Court from considering the liability of the remaining officers.
14. On contempt, the Applicant relied on Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance Vs Cabinet Secretary for Devolution and Planning & 3 Others [2017] KEHC 8755 (KLR) and Shimmers Plaza Limited Vs National Bank of Kenya Limited [2015] KECA 945 (KLR), submitting that court orders must be obeyed and that the 3rd Respondent had knowledge of the orders issued on 16th July 2026. He further invoked Sections 107, 109 and 112 of the Evidence Act and the decision in Ambogo Vs Ogutu & 4 Others [2025] KEELC 5152 (KLR), arguing that the 3rd Respondent had failed to establish that the construction activities depicted in the photographs occurred on an adjoining parcel rather than the suit property. He consequently urged the Court to allow the Application with costs.
3rd Defendant/Respondent’s Submissions
15. The 3rd Respondent filed written submissions dated 3rd November 2026, identifying two issues for determination, namely: whether the Applicant had established a sufficient basis for the grant of contempt orders and whether the Application constituted an abuse of the Court's process. On the first issue, the 3rd Respondent relied on Mutitika Vs Baharini Farm Limited [1985] KLR 229, Republic Vs Ahmad Abolfathi Mohammed & Another [2018] eKLR, Samuel M. N. Mweru & Others Vs National Land Commission & 2 Others [2020] eKLR and Jihan Freighters Limited Vs Hardware & General Stores Limited [2015] eKLR. It submitted that contempt must be established to a standard higher than the balance of probabilities and that the Applicant had failed to demonstrate deliberate disobedience of the Court's orders, particularly because the photographs relied upon allegedly depicted activities on an adjoining parcel of land.
16. On abuse of court process, the 3rd Respondent relied on Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and the decisions in Muchanga Investments Limited Vs Safaris Unlimited (Africa) Limited & 2 Others [2009] eKLR, D.T. Dobie & Company (Kenya) Limited Vs Joseph Mbaria Muchina & Another [1980] eKLR, Kirobon Farmers Co. Ltd Vs Nyarangi [2023] KECA 1194 (KLR) and Satya Bhama Gandhi Vs Director of Public Prosecutions & 3 Others [2018] eKLR. It submitted that the Applicant had invoked contempt proceedings without sufficient evidence, failed to comply with earlier directions concerning the proposed joinder of Premier Bank Limited and included a deceased director among the alleged contemnors. The 3rd Respondent consequently urged the Court to dismiss the Application with costs and issue directions for the expeditious determination of the substantive suit.
Analysis and Determination
17. I have carefully considered the Application, the Supporting Affidavit, the Replying Affidavit, the Further Affidavit, the rival submissions and the authorities relied upon by the parties. The principal issue arising for determination is whether the 3rd Defendant/Respondent is in contempt of the Court orders issued on 16th July 2026 and whether the consequential orders sought by the Applicant should issue.
18. The Black’s Law Dictionary, 9th Edition, defines contempt of court as: “Conduct that defies the authority or dignity of a court or legislature. Because such conduct interferes with the administration of justice.”
19. Section 29 of the Environment and Land Court Act provides that: “Any person who refuses, fails or neglects to obey an order or direction of the Court given under this Act, commits an offence, and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding twenty million shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or to both.”
20. In Samuel M. N. Mweru & Others Vs National Land Commission & 2 Others [2020] eKLR, the Court set out the essential elements that must be established in civil contempt proceedings, namely, that the terms of the order were clear and unambiguous, that the alleged contemnor had knowledge of the order, that there was a breach of its terms and that the breach was deliberate. The Court further emphasised that contempt jurisdiction serves not merely to enforce court orders but also to safeguard the authority and legitimacy of the judicial system.
21. On the applicable standard of proof, the Supreme Court in Republic Vs Ahmad Abolfathi Mohammed & Sayeed Mansour Mousavi [2018] KESC 51 (KLR) affirmed that contempt proceedings are quasi-criminal in nature and that the standard of proof is higher than the balance of probabilities, though not beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the Court must be satisfied by cogent evidence that the alleged contemnor knowingly and deliberately acted in breach of a clear and binding court order.
22. Applying the foregoing principles to the present Application, it is not disputed that this Court issued orders on 16th July 2026, restraining the Plaintiff and the 3rd Defendant from selling, transferring, mortgaging or leasing the suit property to third parties and directing that neither party should change the character of the land. It is equally not disputed that the 3rd Respondent had knowledge of the said orders. The first two requirements for establishing contempt are therefore satisfied. What remains contested is whether the 3rd Respondent acted in breach of those orders and whether any such breach was deliberate.
23. The Applicant alleges that the 3rd Respondent undertook construction and development activities on the suit property, including the erection of a perimeter wall, thereby altering its physical character in violation of the Court's orders. In support of these allegations, the Applicant relies on photographs annexed to the Supporting and Further Affidavits. The 3rd Respondent, however, denies undertaking any construction on the suit property and maintains that the developments depicted in the photographs are situated on an adjoining parcel of land belonging to a third party.
24. The Court has examined the respective affidavits and photographic evidence placed before it. While the photographs depict structures and development activities, the central difficulty lies in establishing whether the developments complained of are situated on the particular parcel of land that is the subject of the orders issued on 16th July 2026. The parties have presented conflicting accounts regarding the location of the developments, and the photographic evidence does not, by itself, sufficiently resolve that dispute.
25. Sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act place the burden of proving a fact upon the party asserting its existence. In the present circumstances, it was incumbent upon the Applicant to demonstrate that the alleged construction activities occurred on the suit property and constituted a breach of the Court's orders. Although the Applicant contends that the 3rd Respondent has failed to establish that the developments are situated on an adjoining parcel, that contention does not relieve the Applicant of the primary burden of proving the alleged contempt.
26. The Applicant has not placed before the Court sufficient independent or verifiable evidence connecting the developments depicted in the photographs to the suit property. Neither has the evidence adequately established when the particular structures complained of were erected or that the 3rd Respondent undertook or authorised their construction after the issuance of the Court's orders. The existence of construction activities, without a sufficiently established connection to the property governed by the orders and the alleged contemnor, cannot constitute proof of disobedience.
27. This distinction is particularly material given the serious consequences that may follow a finding of contempt. As held in Samuel M. N. Mweru & Others Vs National Land Commission & 2 Others (supra), an applicant must demonstrate not only the existence and knowledge of a court order but also a deliberate breach of its terms. In the present case, the conflicting evidence regarding the location of the alleged developments leaves a material evidential gap that cannot be resolved through inference or speculation. The Court is therefore not satisfied that the alleged disobedience has been established to the requisite standard.
28. The Applicant has further invited the Court to lift the corporate veil of the 3rd Respondent and hold its directors and company secretary personally accountable for the alleged contempt. However, personal liability for contempt cannot arise merely from an individual's position as a director or officer of a company. There must be a sufficient evidential basis demonstrating that the individual knowingly participated in, authorised or facilitated the disobedience complained of. Having found that the alleged breach has not been sufficiently established against the 3rd Respondent, the Court finds no basis for lifting the corporate veil or invoking contempt proceedings against its officers.
29. Further, the evidence presented establishes that Isabella Nyaguthii Wanjohi, one of the directors named in the Application, passed away on 21st June 2026, before the issuance of the orders complained of. She could not therefore have personally disobeyed orders issued on 16th July 2026. As regards the remaining officers, the Applicant has not established the specific acts or omissions attributable to them that would warrant their being summoned to answer allegations of contempt.
30. The 3rd Respondent has also urged the Court to find that the Application constitutes an abuse of the Court's process. However, the mere fact that an application for contempt has not been proved does not necessarily render it an abuse of process. A party who reasonably believes that a subsisting court order has been violated is entitled to seek its enforcement. The failure of the present Application arises from the insufficiency of the evidence tendered to establish contempt, and the Court finds no necessity to make a further finding of abuse of process.
31. In the circumstances, the Court finds that the Applicant has not discharged the burden of establishing that the 3rd Respondent knowingly and deliberately disobeyed the orders issued on 16th July 2026. Consequently, the orders seeking a finding of contempt, the lifting of the corporate veil, personal liability of the 3rd Respondent's officers and the removal of the alleged structures cannot issue on the evidence presently before the Court.
Final Disposition
32. In the upshot, I find that the Plaintiff/Applicant has failed to establish contempt of the Court orders issued on 16th July 2026 to the requisite standard of proof. Consequently, the Notice of Motion dated 14th September 2026 is hereby dismissed with costs to the 3rd Defendant/Respondent.
33. The status quo orders issued on 16th July 2026 shall remain in force pending the hearing and determination of the substantive suit or until further orders of this Court.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 12th day of
November, 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Ms. Omukoko for the Plaintiff/Applicant
Mr. Mahadi for the 3rd Respondent
N/A for the 1st and 2nd Respondents
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant