Employment law

Republic v Machakos County Assembly Service Board & 2 others; Mutisya & 16 others (Ex parte Applicants) [2026] KEELRC 2668 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Machakos
Case number
Judicial Review Application E003 of 2026
Judgment date
30 September 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbarũ

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application succeeded. The respondents were directed to pay the ex parte applicants Ksh. 37,716,975.75 within 90 days, with interest at court rates from 21 June 2023 until full payment. The court would monitor compliance; after 90 days the parties were to report back, failing which the 3rd respondent, Anne M. Kiusya, and the 2nd respondent were required to attend personally. Mention was set for 18 January 2027, and costs were awarded to the ex parte applicants.

Supporting judgment passages

a) The respondents are hereby directed to pay the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 to the ex parte applicants within 90 days from the date hereof. The sum shall bear interest at court rates from 21 June 2023 until paid in full. Accordingly, the court shall monitor the payment process.

Passage 48 →

b) At the lapse of the 90 days, the parties shall report to the court full compliance. Where this is not adequately addressed, the court directs the personal attendance of the 3rd respondent and Anne M. Kiusya, together with the 2nd respondent.

Passage 49 →

d) Costs of the instant application to the ex parte applicants.

Passage 51 →
Issue 1Whether the respondents should be compelled to settle the decree and Certificate of Order Against the Government in Machakos ELRC Case No. 4 of 2018 (consolidated with 106 others), including payment of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 with interest and a payment timeline, notwithstanding their stated intended appeal.

Held. Yes. The court found that the decree, certificate, and demands had been served and were uncontested, but the respondents had not complied. Their intended appeal did not bar enforcement: no appeal had been filed and no stay application existed. The court held that they had wilfully and deliberately disobeyed the judgment and tabulation orders, and directed payment of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 within 90 days, with interest at court rates from 21 June 2023 until payment in full.

Ratio. A party served with valid court orders must comply with them. An unactualised notice or intention to appeal, without a filed appeal or an application for stay of execution, does not excuse non-compliance with an enforceable money decree. The respondents' failure to make payment or engage on payment modalities, despite service of the decree and Certificate of Order Against the Government, amounted to deliberate refusal to discharge their public duty.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

The essence of the instant application is to compel the respondents to settle the decree and certificate of orders against the County Assembly Service Board of Machakos in Machakos ELRC Case No. 4 of 2018, which consolidated 106 others for the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75, with interest, and a timeline for making the payment. The respondents assert that the issues herein are complex and have taken time to determine, and that they intend to file an appeal, which should be allowed to be completed before these proceedings.

Passage 31 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

To this extent, the court is satisfied that the respondents have wilfully and deliberately disobeyed orders herein issued on 14 October 2022 and failed to pay the tabulated amounts as directed on 21 June 2023. The decree in Machakos ELRC Cause No. 4 of 2018 remains unsettled, despite the respondents' awareness.

Passage 45 →

a) The respondents are hereby directed to pay the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 to the ex parte applicants within 90 days from the date hereof. The sum shall bear interest at court rates from 21 June 2023 until paid in full. Accordingly, the court shall monitor the payment process.

Passage 48 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

These averments by the 3rd respondent are out of context. To begin with, judgment was delivered on 14 October 2022. There is no appeal. No appeal has been filed. The Notice of Appeal dated 4 July 2023 is not the subject of the appeal but merely an intention that has not been actualised.

Passage 41 →

Fundamentally, no application seeks a stay of execution to allow any appellant to apply for procedures. The respondents' response is thus a sheer abuse of court process. The respondents have failed to take accountability for a public duty vested in them. Valid decrees, orders, and certificates have been issued against the government, and it has deliberately refused to settle.

Passage 43 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

An order of mandamus be granted directed to the respondents herein by themselves and/or their successor in office to settle the decree/certificates of orders against the County Assembly Service Board of Machakos in Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018 as consolidated with 106 others by paying the ex parte applicants the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 with interest from the date of the decree and further interest until the date of full payment.

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

Costs of the application be granted to the ex parte applicants.

Paragraph 3 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether mandamus should issue to compel the Machakos County Assembly Service Board and related officials to satisfy decrees and Certificates of Order Against the Government arising from Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018, consolidated with 106 others; whether a…

Material facts

The 17 ex parte applicants sought payment of Ksh. 37,716,975.75, plus interest, for terminal dues decreed in their favour. They stated that employment ended in August 2017; judgment in the underlying matter was delivered on 14 October 2022 and tabulations…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS

JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION NO. E003 OF 2026

REPUBLIC APPLICANT

VERSUS

MACHAKOS COUNTY ASSEMBLY SERVICE BOARD 1ST RESPONDENT

THE CLERK OF THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY

SERVICE BOARD – MACHAKOS 2ND RESPONDENT

THE SPEAKER OF MACHAKOS COUNTY ASSEMBLY 3RD RESPONDENT

AND

NELLY ITUMBI MUTISYA & 16 OTHERS EX PARTE APPLICANTS

RULING

The ex parte applicants filed an application dated 16 March 2026 under the provisions of Order 53 Rule 1(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules and seeking orders that:

1. An order of mandamus be granted directed to the respondents herein by themselves and/or their successor in office to settle the decree/certificates of orders against the County Assembly Service Board of Machakos in Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018 as consolidated with 106 others by paying the ex parte applicants the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 with interest from the date of the decree and further interest until the date of full payment.

2. The court do limit the time within which the said payment will be made, failure of which a Notice to Show Cause shall be issued.

3. Costs of the application be granted to the ex parte applicants.

The application is supported by the Supporting Affidavit of Nelly Itumbi Mutisya, one of the ex parte applicants. It is based on the fact that the respondents have all been served with decrees against the Machakos County Assembly Service Board in respect of Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018, consolidated with 106 others. The respondents' accounting officers have a specific public legal obligation, imposed under section 21 of the Government Proceedings Act, to pay the total decretal amount with interest upon service of decrees and certificates of order against the 1st respondent. However, despite service and existence of liability, the respondents have refused and failed to settle the decretal sum.

In the Supporting Affidavit, Mutisya avers that the respondent are in breach of the Constitution and section 18(5)(a) of the Employment Act in refusing to pay their terminal dues. The law requires the employer to pay the employee's full terminal dues at the end of employment. Employment ended in August 2017, and over 7 years have passed without payment of terminal dues.

The orders sought compel the respondents to pay the decretal sum, with interest, as due and payable, with additional interest.

Mutisya averts that on 30 April 2024, the respondents were served with the decrees and a demand to pay the ex parte applicants. On 15 January 2026, the respondents were served with the Certificates of Order against the Machakos Service Board and a demand letter but have refused to pay. On 6 February 2026, the respondents were served with a reminder letter. They have shown no willingness to settle the decretal sum leading to these proceedings. The respondents are thus abusing the immunity granted under Order 29 of the Civil Procedure Rules and section 21(4) of the Government Proceedings Act. Hence, the court should step in and protect the ex parte applicants' institutional right to fair labour practices guaranteed under Article 41 of the Constitution.

Mutisya avers that the foundation file in these proceedings is Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018. The Court delivered judgment on 14 October 2022 in favour of the ex parte applicants against the respondents, who have refused and failed to make payments under the decree.

In reply, the respondents filed the Replying Affidavit of Anne M. Kiusya, the 3rd respondent, who avers that, as the chairperson of the 1st respondent and acting for the 1st and 2nd respondents, she is conversant with the matters addressed herein. The ex parte applicants seek orders of mandamus and payment of decrees arising from Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018, consolidated with 106 others, in the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 with interest. The ex parte applicants also seek the court to determine the time period within which the decretal sum should be paid.

Kiusya avers that the decree the ex parte applicants refer to arises from Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018. This is a complex matter involving 107 claimants who filed separate claims and later consolidated them. Nelly Itumbi's claim became the test suit. The hearing was delayed for several reasons, including government bureaucracy and procurement systems, changes of advocates, and changes in the government and the Public Service Board.

The delays in hearing the matter to a conclusion are apparent. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the matter was only heard on 21 September 2021, and judgment was reserved on notice. By September 2022, the court had not delivered judgment, although the County Assembly of Machakos had engaged in the matter and had the option to file an appeal. Hence, if the orders sought in the matter are issued, the intended appeal will be rendered nugatory and cause irreparable loss and damage to the respondents, considering that the respondents do not have their own income or revenue collection role.

Kiusya avers that the amounts involved are substantial and not budgeted for in this financial year. It was not clear in which year the same would be determined. Under the Public Finance Management Act, any spending of government funds without an approved budget is illegal and constitutes financial misconduct. The County Assembly relies solely on the budget provided from the equitable share appropriated to the County Government in the national government's budget. The respondent thus operates on a predetermined cash flow, with monies paid directly to employees and for the supply of goods, services, and works, directly to vendors.

The judgment was delivered on 14 October 2022, and a quantum was issued on 21 June 2023, and the respondents were found liable to pay. As the respondents were keen to appeal, they filed the first Notice of Appeal dated 4 July 2023. On 4 August 2025, the Court of Appeal assigned Civil Application No. E463 of 2025 to the 1st respondent on an application dated 30 July 2025 seeking a stay of execution pending determination of the intended appeal. The Court of Appeal is yet to issue further directions in the matter.

Kiusya hence avers that the detailed sum and issues arising over time between the parties are in contest. The respondents wish to exercise their right of appeal, and the matters herein have not been exhausted, as there is an arguable appeal.

Although judicial review is entrenched in the Constitution to safeguard constitutional principles and values, every person deserves the equal protection of the law. The respondents' right to proceed on appeal should be weighed against those of the ex parte applicants' right to proceed with execution. If allowed to proceed as sought herein, this will paralyse the respondents' operations.

Kiusya admits that the respondents were served with the Certificate of Order dated 15 January 2026 assigned from Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018. In view of the right of appeal and the complex nature of the matters herein, consolidating 107 claimants, it is only fair to allow the appeal process to conclude first.

Determination

The essence of the instant application is to compel the respondents to settle the decree and certificate of orders against the County Assembly Service Board of Machakos in Machakos ELRC Case No. 4 of 2018, which consolidated 106 others for the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75, with interest, and a timeline for making the payment. The respondents assert that the issues herein are complex and have taken time to determine, and that they intend to file an appeal, which should be allowed to be completed before these proceedings.

The respondents' refusal to obey court orders issued on 14 March 2024 compelling them to pay Ksh. 13,404,913.33 to the ex parte applicant. For the disobedience, the ex parte applicant is seeking that the respondents, as the accounting officers for the respondents, be found in contempt of court and committed to civil jail for a term not exceeding six months.

Proceedings in Machakos ELRC No. 4 of 2018 are not contested. Therefrom, a decree was served on 30 April 2024.

A Certificate of Order Against the Government was served on 15 January 2025.

Demands to settle the decree have been served, and the respondents have not contested it.

There is no compliance.

The respondents have failed and neglected to settle the court's decree despite being aware of it. The Supreme Court of Kenya, in Githiga & 5 Others v Kiru Tea Factory Company Ltd [2023] KESC 41 (KLR), confirmed that courts have the inherent power to enforce compliance with their lawful orders. In Republic v Ahmad Abolfathi Mohammed & another, SC Criminal Application No 2 of 2018 [2018] eKLR, it was held that the deliberate refusal by a party, including the government, to comply with lawful directions and orders of the court is contempt of court. Contemnors demean the integrity and authority of courts and deride the rule of law. This must not be allowed.

In this case, the respondents, having been served with the orders herein, know the terms but have failed to comply. The payment to the ex parte applicants of the decretal sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75, as directed on 14 October 2022, and the tabulations directed on 21 June 2023 remain unpaid.

Compliance with court orders is imperative on the party served with them, as held in Michael Sistu Mwaura Kamau v Director of Public Prosecutions & 4 Others.

The respondents, through the Replying Affidavit of Anne Kiusya, acknowledge their active engagement in the matter. However, they aver that an appeal is intended, and that the same will be rendered nugatory if the orders granted are allowed.

These averments by the 3rd respondent are out of context. To begin with, judgment was delivered on 14 October 2022. There is no appeal. No appeal has been filed. The Notice of Appeal dated 4 July 2023 is not the subject of the appeal but merely an intention that has not been actualised.

Additionally, as an entity, upon the judgment, the decree is now considered served; the respondents have not engaged the ex parte applicants on the modalities of payment. Furthermore, a money decree is not a complex issue as the 3rd respondent asserts. There should either be an offer to pay or an election not to pay.

Fundamentally, no application seeks a stay of execution to allow any appellant to apply for procedures. The respondents' response is thus a sheer abuse of court process. The respondents have failed to take accountability for a public duty vested in them. Valid decrees, orders, and certificates have been issued against the government, and it has deliberately refused to settle.

The subject employment dispute arose in August 2017. Although judgment was delivered in October 2022, the settlement and payment of terminal dues under section 19(5) of the Employment Act remain outstanding. Such legal duty exists to date.

To this extent, the court is satisfied that the respondents have wilfully and deliberately disobeyed orders herein issued on 14 October 2022 and failed to pay the tabulated amounts as directed on 21 June 2023. The decree in Machakos ELRC Cause No. 4 of 2018 remains unsettled, despite the respondents' awareness.

The admission of service of the Certificate and Order Against Government on 15 January 2026 should have triggered action. Since June 2023, the respondents have not made the planning and budgetary allocations for the decree at issue in these proceedings.

In light of the above matters, the inevitable conclusion is as follows:

a) The respondents are hereby directed to pay the sum of Ksh. 37,716,975.75 to the ex parte applicants within 90 days from the date hereof. The sum shall bear interest at court rates from 21 June 2023 until paid in full. Accordingly, the court shall monitor the payment process.

b) At the lapse of the 90 days, the parties shall report to the court full compliance. Where this is not adequately addressed, the court directs the personal attendance of the 3rd respondent and Anne M. Kiusya, together with the 2nd respondent.

c) Mention on 18 January 2027.

d) Costs of the instant application to the ex parte applicants.

In the interim, the parties may reach a consent on any aspect of compliance as directed above. Such interim measure should not defeat the essence of compliance by the respondents as directed above.

Orders accordingly.

Delivered in open court this 30th day of September 2026

M. MBARŨ

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Court Assistant: Kemboi

…………………………………………… and …………………………………..………

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder