Background
Spent.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Spent.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E101 OF 2026
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
MORRIS & COMPANY (2004) LTD …………………………… APPELLANT/APPLICANT
VERSUS
LEONARD MUSYOKA MAMBO & 76 OTHERS ………………………… RESPONDENTS
RULING
This is an application by way of a Notice of Motion dated 27th March, 2026. Here, the Applicant seeks stay of execution of the Order of Committal to Civil Jail and the Warrants of Arrest issued against its two Directors, Diamondali Hasham Lalji and Shahid Diamond Hasham Lalji pending the hearing and determination of this appeal.
The Respondent’s and decree holders oppose the application in these proceedings.
The Notice of Motion seeks the following orders of court:
1. Spent.
2. That pending the hearing and determination of this application inter partes and or until further orders of this court, execution of the Order of Committal to Civil Jail and warrants of arrest issued against the Directors of the Judgement Debtor be stayed.
3. That pending the hearing and determination of this appeal, execution of the said Order of Committal to Civil Jail and warrants of arrest be stayed.
4. That this Court be at liberty to issue any further orders in the interests of justice and that the costs of the application be provided for.
By a judgment delivered on 10th June, 2022 in CM.ELRC Cause No. E647 of 2019, the Respondents obtained judgment against the Applicant in the sum of Kshs. 8,256,356.01 together with costs and interest.
The decree not having been satisfied, the Respondents caused a Notice to Show Cause dated 10th September, 2024 to be issued against the Applicant’s Directors, seeking their committal to civil jail under sections 38 and 40 of the Civil Procedure Act. By a decision of 22nd October, 2025 the trial court committed the Directors to civil jail for the maximum allowable period of six months. On the same day, the Applicant filed an application to recall that order, which was dismissed by a ruling delivered on 8th November, 2025. A warrant of arrest against the Directors was issued and sealed on 8th November, 2025.
No appeal was filed against either the decision of 22nd October, 2025 or the ruling of 8th November, 2025 within the time prescribed by section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act, nor was any application for leave to appeal out of time made at that stage.
By a further Notice of Motion dated 25th February, 2026 the Applicant sought, among other things, a stay of execution of the committal order and warrants of arrest, together with enlargement of time within which to seek leave to appeal, and to file an appeal out of time, against the decision of 22nd October, 2025. That application was dismissed by a ruling delivered on 19th March, 2026 the trial court holding it to be substantially similar to and therefore res judicata by reason of, the application already determined on 8th November, 2025 and further finding that no draft memorandum of appeal or request for typed proceedings had been placed on record.
Aggrieved, the Applicant lodged the present appeal, together with a Memorandum of Appeal dated 27th March, 2026 setting out twelve grounds against the ruling of 19th March, 2026 and contemporaneously filed the Notice of Motion now before this court, seeking stay of execution of the Order of Committal to Civil Jail and the warrants of arrest against the Directors, last signed on 23rd February, 2026 pending the hearing and determination of this appeal. The application is supported by the affidavit of Diamond Hasham Lalji and opposed by the Replying Affidavit of Leonard Musyoka Mambo sworn on 6th April, 2026. Both parties filed written submissions, which the court has considered together with the record.
The Applicant’s case is that its Directors are being made to answer personally, by way of committal to civil jail, for a debt properly that of the company alone. This is without any order lifting the corporate veil having been sought or made and that the trial court, in its ruling of 19th March, 2026 erred in treating the Notice of Motion dated 25th February, 2026 as res judicata, the prayers for enlargement of time to seek and file leave to appeal being distinct from, and not previously determined in, the application of 22nd October, 2025. Invoking Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Applicant submits that it stands to suffer substantial and irreversible loss, namely the arrest and imprisonment of its Directors, unless the stay sought is granted, and that the appeal will otherwise be rendered nugatory.
The Respondents oppose the application. They contend that it is premature since the Directors have not yet been arrested and the purpose of a warrant of arrest is only to procure their attendance to show cause, not to effect automatic imprisonment. This is in accordance with the authority of Fina Bank Ltd v Francis Gitau Komu t/a Bomas Motor Mart [2015] eKLR, Innocent G. Ondieki v Julius Nakaya Kabole [2019] eKLR, and Chege v Kamau Kinga & Co. Advocates [2025] KEHC 5930 (KLR). They further contend that the Applicant has never disputed the underlying judgment, has recycled the same grounds at every stage, an abuse of process properly met by the finding below and has neither disputed the sum outstanding nor offered any security or proposal for settlement notwithstanding that the judgment has remained unsatisfied since 2022.
Two issues arise for determination. First, whether the appeal raises an arguable question meriting protection of the status quo pending its determination. Second, whether the Applicant has otherwise satisfied the conditions for a stay of execution pending appeal.
On the first issue, and beginning with the corporate veil question, the trial court’s judgment was against the Applicant company. No order lifting the corporate veil appears on the record, yet the Directors face committal to civil jail for the company’s debt. The separate legal personality of a company and the principle that its directors are not personally liable for its obligations save where the veil of incorporation is properly lifted, is settled law. This is traceable to the celebrated authority of Salomon v Salomon & Co [1897] AC 22 and applied by the High Court of Kenya in Multichoice Kenya Ltd v Mainkam Ltd & Anor [2013] eKLR, where the court held that directors are generally not personally liable on the obligations of their company absent fraud, impropriety, or another recognised ground for piercing the veil. Whether that principle was properly applied when the Directors here were committed to civil jail is a live and unresolved question; it was touched upon, but not squarely determined, in the ruling of 8th November, 2025 and has never been tested on appeal. This ground cannot be dismissed as frivolous.
On the second limb of the first issue as to whether the trial court correctly treated the Notice of Motion of 25th February, 2026 as res judicata. The elements of that doctrine under section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act were restated by the Supreme Court in John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another v Cabinet Secretary, Transport and Infrastructure & 3 others [2021] KESC 39 (KLR), which requires, among other things, that the former and later proceedings share an identical subject matter and cause of action. The application of 25th February, 2026 sought, in addition to relief already considered on 8th November, 2025, enlargement of time to seek and to file leave to appeal. This relief was not a subject matter in the earlier application. Whether that distinction was sufficient to displace the finding of res judicata and functus officio is properly a matter for the appeal itself; it suffices, for present purposes, that the point is arguable and not spurious.
On the second issue, the jurisdiction to grant a stay of execution pending appeal is donated by Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, requiring the Applicant to demonstrate that substantial loss will result absent a stay, that the application has been made without unreasonable delay, and that it has furnished or is prepared to furnish security for the due performance of the decree. Substantial loss is the cornerstone of this jurisdiction and is what a stay is meant to prevent. This is the rationale in Kenya Shell Limited v Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & another [1986] eKLR.
On substantial loss, the court is satisfied that this limb is met. Committal to civil jail entails deprivation of personal liberty for up to six months. Unlike loss occasioned by attachment or sale of property, loss of liberty once suffered cannot afterward be restored by a favourable outcome on appeal. That the Directors have not yet been arrested does not diminish the substance of this concern; it is precisely the imminence of arrest, on a warrant signed as recently as 23rd February, 2026 that the application seeks to forestall.
On delay, the committal order was made on 22nd October, 2025 and the application to recall it dismissed on 8th November, 2025 yet no application touching on leave to appeal was filed until 25th February, 2026 over three months later. The explanation offered, that the Applicant was unrepresented on the day the order was made and its advocates mistakenly anticipated the October application would cure the position, does not adequately account for so lengthy a delay and reflects, at best, an error of judgment by counsel rather than any impediment attributable to the Respondents or the court. This weighs against the Applicant, though it does not, in the circumstances, outweigh the liberty interest already discussed.
On security, the Applicant has offered none, and has at no stage proposed any manner of settling or partially settling the decree, notwithstanding that it has remained unsatisfied since June, 2022. The sum shown as due and payable, inclusive of interest and costs, stood at Kshs. 10,419,182.37 as at May, 2025. The Respondents, 77 in number, are entitled to the fruits of a judgment now approaching four years, and a stay granted without regard to that entitlement would occasion them real prejudice.
Balancing these considerations, the court is not persuaded that the application should be dismissed outright, given the liberty interest at stake and the unresolved state of the questions raised on appeal, nor that an unconditional stay is warranted, given the delay and the complete absence of any security or proposal for settlement. The appropriate course, in the exercise of the court’s discretion under Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, is to grant a conditional stay.
For the foregoing reasons, this court is satisfied that a conditional stay of execution is warranted, and order as follows:
i) The Notice of Motion dated 27th March, 2026 be and is hereby partially allowed.
ii) Execution of the Order of Committal to Civil Jail and the Warrants of Arrest issued against Diamondali Hasham Lalji and Shahid Diamond Hasham Lalji, Directors of the Applicant, is stayed pending the hearing and final determination of this appeal.
iii) The stay granted at order (ii) is conditional upon the Applicant depositing, within thirty (30) days of the date of this Ruling, security in the sum of Kshs. 5,209,591.19 being fifty per centum (50%) of the sum shown as due and payable as at May, 2025 either in cash into a joint interest-earning account held in the names of the advocates for the parties, or by way of an irrevocable bank guarantee from a reputable bank licensed in Kenya.
iv) The Applicant shall file and serve the Record of Appeal within forty-five (45) days of the date of this Ruling, in default of which the stay granted herein shall similarly lapse.
v) Costs of this application shall abide the outcome of the appeal.
Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Wepo instructed by Echessa & Bwire Advocates, LLP for the Appellant/Applicant.
2. Mr. Amutallah instructed by Amutallah Robert & Company Advocates for the Respondents.