Background
Whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Claim allowed. The court declared the termination procedurally and substantively unfair, and discriminatory because of pregnancy and maternity status. The respondents were held jointly and severally liable for Kshs. 3,507,068.65 (March salary, severance, compensation, and constitutional damages), payable within 30 days, plus interest at court rates from judgment until payment. Respondents were ordered to bear costs.
I am inclined to allow the claim and order as follows:
Conclusion and orders →
iv) The 1st and 2nd Respondents shall, jointly and severally, pay to the Claimant the following sums within thirty (30) days of this judgment;
Passage 36 →
Total of Award……………………………………...………….Kshs. 3,507,068.65
Passage 41 →
Held. No. The termination by redundancy was procedurally and substantively unfair. The respondents gave no prior notice of the intended redundancy to a trade union or the Cabinet Secretary, contrary to the cumulative requirements of section 40(1). They also failed to prove a genuine redundancy: their asserted decline in COVID-19 testing demand rested only on an unsupported letter, without financial statements, board resolutions, or other documentary evidence.
Ratio. For a redundancy termination to be lawful, the cumulative conditions in section 40(1) of the Employment Act must be met. Failure to give the required redundancy notice is fatal procedurally; an employer must also substantiate the alleged operational basis rather than rely on an unsupported assertion.
Issue
1. Whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair.
Paragraph 1 →
Held
The 1st issue for determination is whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair. Section 40(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 sets out cumulative conditions precedent to a lawful termination on account of redundancy. It is not disputed and the Respondents concede in their own submissions, that no notice of the intended redundancy was given to any trade union or to the Cabinet Secretary before the redundancy notice was issued to the Claimant. That concession is, on its own, fatal to the procedural limb. As to the substantive genuineness of the redundancy, the Respondents rely on a single letter dated 14th April, 2022 contending a decline in COVID-19 testing demand. A single self-serving letter, unsupported by financial statements, board resolutions or any documentary evidence of the alleged decline, does not discharge the burden of proving a genuine redundancy. The termination was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Passage 24 →
ii) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively unfair and in violation of Section 40 and Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, 2007.
Passage 34 →
Ratio
The 1st issue for determination is whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair. Section 40(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 sets out cumulative conditions precedent to a lawful termination on account of redundancy. It is not disputed and the Respondents concede in their own submissions, that no notice of the intended redundancy was given to any trade union or to the Cabinet Secretary before the redundancy notice was issued to the Claimant. That concession is, on its own, fatal to the procedural limb. As to the substantive genuineness of the redundancy, the Respondents rely on a single letter dated 14th April, 2022 contending a decline in COVID-19 testing demand. A single self-serving letter, unsupported by financial statements, board resolutions or any documentary evidence of the alleged decline, does not discharge the burden of proving a genuine redundancy. The termination was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Passage 24 →
Held. Yes. The termination was discriminatory under section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act and violated Articles 27(4) and (5) of the Constitution. A redundancy notice issued barely two weeks after the Claimant returned from maternity leave, coupled with the absence of a section 40 process, documented business case, evidence of other redundancies, or selection criteria, established a presumption of discrimination. The respondents did not rebut it with proof of legitimate operational grounds unrelated to pregnancy or maternity.
Ratio. Under sections 5(3)(a) and 5(5) of the Employment Act, pregnancy discrimination is prohibited, and once an employee establishes facts from which discrimination may be presumed, the employer bears the burden of proving that discrimination did not occur. Timing following maternity leave and an unsubstantiated, procedurally defective redundancy can establish that presumption.
Issue
2. Whether the termination was discriminatory on account of the Claimant’s pregnancy and/or maternity status.
Paragraph 2 →
Held
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was discriminatory on account of the Claimant’s pregnancy and/or maternity status. Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007 prohibits an employer from discriminating against an employee on grounds including pregnancy, and Section 5(5) provides that where an employee establishes facts from which discrimination may be presumed, the burden shifts to the employer to prove that no discrimination occurred. The Claimant has established a prima facie case: the redundancy notice was issued barely two weeks after her return from maternity leave. The timing, combined with the conceded absence of any Section 40 process, the absence of any documented business case and the absence of any evidence that other employees were made redundant at the same time or that selection criteria were applied, is sufficient to raise a presumption of discriminatory motivation.
Passage 25 →
The burden accordingly shifted to the Respondents to prove, on a balance of probabilities, that the decision was taken on legitimate operational grounds and was in no way connected to her pregnancy or maternity status. They have not discharged that burden. The termination was discriminatory within the meaning of Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act aforesaid.
Passage 25 →
i) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the Claimant’s termination from employment was discriminatory and on account of her pregnancy and maternity status fell in violation of Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007 and Article 27(4) and (5) of the Constitution and was therefore unlawful.
Passage 33 →
Ratio
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was discriminatory on account of the Claimant’s pregnancy and/or maternity status. Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007 prohibits an employer from discriminating against an employee on grounds including pregnancy, and Section 5(5) provides that where an employee establishes facts from which discrimination may be presumed, the burden shifts to the employer to prove that no discrimination occurred. The Claimant has established a prima facie case: the redundancy notice was issued barely two weeks after her return from maternity leave. The timing, combined with the conceded absence of any Section 40 process, the absence of any documented business case and the absence of any evidence that other employees were made redundant at the same time or that selection criteria were applied, is sufficient to raise a presumption of discriminatory motivation.
Passage 25 →
The burden accordingly shifted to the Respondents to prove, on a balance of probabilities, that the decision was taken on legitimate operational grounds and was in no way connected to her pregnancy or maternity status. They have not discharged that burden. The termination was discriminatory within the meaning of Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act aforesaid.
Passage 25 →
Held. Yes, substantially. The court awarded unpaid March 2022 salary of Kshs. 180,731.65 because the Kshs. 88,709.28 deduction was unexplained; pro-rated severance pay of Kshs. 76,337; Kshs. 2,500,000 (ten months’ gross salary) as compensation for unfair and discriminatory termination; and Kshs. 750,000 general damages for the distinct constitutional violations. Total: Kshs. 3,507,068.65, payable jointly and severally within 30 days, with interest at court rates from judgment. The requested 20% interest rate was declined.
Ratio. The employer bears the burden of explaining a salary deduction. Severance is calculated under section 40(1)(g) at not less than 15 days’ pay for each completed year of service, here pro-rated for the proved period. Applying section 49(4), serious pregnancy discrimination, complete procedural non-compliance, and failure to rebut discrimination justified high-end compensation. A constitutional violation distinct from statutory unfair termination warrants separate damages. Interest above court rates requires an evidentiary basis.
Issue
3. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought, and to what extent.
Paragraph 3 →
Held
The 3rd and 4th issues for determination are reliefs and costs. On unpaid salary for March, 2022 the deduction of Kshs. 88,709.28 from the Claimant’s March, 2022 salary was unexplained by the Respondents, the burden of explaining a deduction lying on the employer. The net salary for March, 2022 less amounts properly deductible, being Kshs. 180,731.65, becomes payable and is awarded.
Passage 26 →
On compensation for unfair and discriminatory termination, having regard to the factors under Section 49(4), including the gravity of the violation (pregnancy discrimination on return from maternity leave with zero procedural compliance), the Respondents’ failure to adduce any evidence in rebuttal of the discrimination claim, and the nature of the employer conduct, an award at the higher end of the available scale is warranted. The statutory maximum is reserved for the most egregious cases, and this is one of them. An award of Kshs. 2,500,000 being ten months’ gross salary, is fair and just in the prevailing circumstances.
Passage 28 →
Total of Award……………………………………...………….Kshs. 3,507,068.65
Passage 41 →
Ratio
The 3rd and 4th issues for determination are reliefs and costs. On unpaid salary for March, 2022 the deduction of Kshs. 88,709.28 from the Claimant’s March, 2022 salary was unexplained by the Respondents, the burden of explaining a deduction lying on the employer. The net salary for March, 2022 less amounts properly deductible, being Kshs. 180,731.65, becomes payable and is awarded.
Passage 26 →
On compensation for unfair and discriminatory termination, having regard to the factors under Section 49(4), including the gravity of the violation (pregnancy discrimination on return from maternity leave with zero procedural compliance), the Respondents’ failure to adduce any evidence in rebuttal of the discrimination claim, and the nature of the employer conduct, an award at the higher end of the available scale is warranted. The statutory maximum is reserved for the most egregious cases, and this is one of them. An award of Kshs. 2,500,000 being ten months’ gross salary, is fair and just in the prevailing circumstances.
Passage 28 →
On general damages for violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights, the termination has been found to violate Article 27(4) and (5) and Article 41(1) of the Constitution. A constitutional violation, distinct from the statutory unfair termination claim, warrants a separate award and the sum of Kshs. 750,000 is awarded.
Passage 29 →
Held. The 1st and 2nd respondents were ordered to bear the costs because the Claimant substantially succeeded on liability.
Ratio. Costs followed the Claimant’s substantial success on liability in this case.
Issue
4. Who bears the costs of the cause.
Paragraph 4 →
Held
On costs, the Claimant has substantially succeeded on liability and the Respondents shall bear the costs of the suit.
Passage 31 →
vi) The costs of the claim shall be borne by the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Passage 43 →
Ratio
On costs, the Claimant has substantially succeeded on liability and the Respondents shall bear the costs of the suit.
Passage 31 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair.
Paragraph 1 →Whether the claimant’s redundancy termination was procedurally and substantively fair; whether it discriminated against her because of pregnancy or maternity status; what reliefs, if any, were due; and who should bear costs.
Dr. Diana Ng’endo Mburu was employed as a medical doctor at a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 250,000. The judgment contains inconsistent employment dates: the dispute listing refers to employment from 29 March 2021, while the claimant’s case and the severance…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E542 OF 2022
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
DR. DIANA NG’ENDO MBURU …………………………………………..……… CLAIMANT
VERSUS
SAGITARIX LIMITED ……………………………………………………… 1ST RESPONDENT
CHECKUPS MEDICAL CENTRE LIMITED …………………………… 2ND RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
This matter came to court by way of a Memorandum of Claim dated 27th July, 2022 and filed on 29th instant. The issues in dispute are therein cited as follows;
A) Whether the Claimant was an employee of the Respondents from 29th March, 2021.
B) Whether the Claimant was unfairly and discriminately terminated from her employment.
C) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
D) Who bears the costs.
The Respondents in written submissions admit that the Claimant was their employee but deny that her termination was discriminatory or procedurally unfair. The parties filed rival written submissions.
This judgment is rendered on the basis of the pleadings, the documentary exhibits, and the rival written submissions.
The Claimant’s case is that she was employed as a Medical Doctor by the Respondents, who operate a medical centre from 1st February, 2022 at a gross monthly salary of Kshs. 250,000. She proceeded on maternity leave from 1st December, 2021 and with the approval of her line manager extended that leave. She returned to work on or about 1st April, 2022. On 5th April, 2022 she received a payslip for March, 2022 bearing an unexplained deduction of Kshs. 88,709.28, which she reported to the human resources department. On or about 14th to 15th April, 2022 barely two weeks after her return from maternity leave, she received a redundancy notice. She contends that the redundancy was in truth actuated by her pregnancy and return from maternity leave. Besides, no notice was given to the relevant trade union or to the Cabinet Secretary as required by Section 40 of the Employment Act, 2007. Other failures are that no selection criteria was communicated and that the process was procedurally deficient in every respect. She prays for declarations of unlawful and discriminatory termination, for unpaid salary for March, 2022 severance pay, compensation for unfair and discriminatory termination, general damages for violation of constitutional rights, interest and costs.
The Respondents’ case is that the redundancy was genuine and occasioned by a decline in demand for COVID-19 testing services which constituted a significant part of the Claimant’s work, and that the decision was driven by legitimate operational and financial considerations. They deny that the termination was discriminatory. They contend that the Claimant was awarded her terminal dues but failed to cooperate in the handover process.
The issues for determination therefore are;
1. Whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair.
2. Whether the termination was discriminatory on account of the Claimant’s pregnancy and/or maternity status.
3. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought, and to what extent.
4. Who bears the costs of the cause.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively fair. Section 40(1) of the Employment Act, 2007 sets out cumulative conditions precedent to a lawful termination on account of redundancy. It is not disputed and the Respondents concede in their own submissions, that no notice of the intended redundancy was given to any trade union or to the Cabinet Secretary before the redundancy notice was issued to the Claimant. That concession is, on its own, fatal to the procedural limb. As to the substantive genuineness of the redundancy, the Respondents rely on a single letter dated 14th April, 2022 contending a decline in COVID-19 testing demand. A single self-serving letter, unsupported by financial statements, board resolutions or any documentary evidence of the alleged decline, does not discharge the burden of proving a genuine redundancy. The termination was both procedurally and substantively unfair.
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was discriminatory on account of the Claimant’s pregnancy and/or maternity status. Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007 prohibits an employer from discriminating against an employee on grounds including pregnancy, and Section 5(5) provides that where an employee establishes facts from which discrimination may be presumed, the burden shifts to the employer to prove that no discrimination occurred. The Claimant has established a prima facie case: the redundancy notice was issued barely two weeks after her return from maternity leave. The timing, combined with the conceded absence of any Section 40 process, the absence of any documented business case and the absence of any evidence that other employees were made redundant at the same time or that selection criteria were applied, is sufficient to raise a presumption of discriminatory motivation. The burden accordingly shifted to the Respondents to prove, on a balance of probabilities, that the decision was taken on legitimate operational grounds and was in no way connected to her pregnancy or maternity status. They have not discharged that burden. The termination was discriminatory within the meaning of Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act aforesaid.
The 3rd and 4th issues for determination are reliefs and costs. On unpaid salary for March, 2022 the deduction of Kshs. 88,709.28 from the Claimant’s March, 2022 salary was unexplained by the Respondents, the burden of explaining a deduction lying on the employer. The net salary for March, 2022 less amounts properly deductible, being Kshs. 180,731.65, becomes payable and is awarded.
On severance pay, Section 40(1)(g) computes severance pay at not less than fifteen days’ pay for each completed year of service. At the daily rate of Kshs. 8,333.33 (being Kshs. 250,000 divided by 30), and pro-rated for the proved service period from 1st February, 2022 to 15th April, 2022 the severance pay amounts to Kshs. 76,337.00. This is also payable under the claim.
On compensation for unfair and discriminatory termination, having regard to the factors under Section 49(4), including the gravity of the violation (pregnancy discrimination on return from maternity leave with zero procedural compliance), the Respondents’ failure to adduce any evidence in rebuttal of the discrimination claim, and the nature of the employer conduct, an award at the higher end of the available scale is warranted. The statutory maximum is reserved for the most egregious cases, and this is one of them. An award of Kshs. 2,500,000 being ten months’ gross salary, is fair and just in the prevailing circumstances.
On general damages for violation of the Claimant’s constitutional rights, the termination has been found to violate Article 27(4) and (5) and Article 41(1) of the Constitution. A constitutional violation, distinct from the statutory unfair termination claim, warrants a separate award and the sum of Kshs. 750,000 is awarded.
On interest, the rate of 20% per annum sought by the Claimant is declined in the absence of any evidentiary basis. The award of interest shall be at court rates from the date of this judgment of court until payment in full.
On costs, the Claimant has substantially succeeded on liability and the Respondents shall bear the costs of the suit.
I am inclined to allow the claim and order as follows:
i) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the Claimant’s termination from employment was discriminatory and on account of her pregnancy and maternity status fell in violation of Section 5(3)(a) of the Employment Act, 2007 and Article 27(4) and (5) of the Constitution and was therefore unlawful.
ii) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the Claimant’s termination was procedurally and substantively unfair and in violation of Section 40 and Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, 2007.
iii) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the Claimant’s rights under Article 41(1) and Article 23(3) of the Constitution were violated by the Respondents’ conduct.
iv) The 1st and 2nd Respondents shall, jointly and severally, pay to the Claimant the following sums within thirty (30) days of this judgment;
Unpaid salary, March, 2022……………………………...…….….Kshs. 180,731.65
Severance pay (pro-rated)………………………………………..…Kshs. 76,337.00
Ten (10) months salary as compensation for unfair and discriminatory termination …………………………………………………………………...Kshs. 2,500,000.00
General damages for violation of constitutional rights……………Kshs. 750,000.00
Total of Award……………………………………...………….Kshs. 3,507,068.65
v) Interest on the Total Award above at court rates from the date of this judgment until payment in full.
vi) The costs of the claim shall be borne by the 1st and 2nd Respondents.
Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Ms. Kalaine instructed by Gakii Kalaine & Co. Advocates for the Claimant.
2. Mr. Odiwuor instructed by Odiwuor & Associates Advocates for the 1st and 2nd Respondents.