Employment law

Mulegeta Stars Transporters v Muthemba [2026] KEELRC 14688 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Machakos
Judgment date
16 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Appellant herein, being dissatisfied with the Judgment and Decree of the Hon. M.A. Nanzushi (SPM) delivered on 12th September 2025 in Mavoko CMELRC NO. E046 of 2024 between the parties filed a Memorandum of Appeal dated the 26th of September 2025 seeking the following orders: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

In their submissions dated 6th August 2026, the Appellant identified the following issues for determination:

Paragraph 19 →

Decision / orders

The appeal is dismissed with costs to the respondent.

Paragraph 65 →

Reasoning passage

I find no basis to fault the finding of the trial court that there was unfair termination.

Paragraph 51 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS

APPEAL NUMBER E046 OF 2025

MULEGETA STARS TRANSPORTERS…………….…...........................................................................APPELLANT

-VERSUS

CHRISTOPHER MUTHEMBA ........................................................................................................ RESPONDENT

(Being an Appeal from the Judgment and Decree of the Hon. M.A. Nanzushi (SPM) delivered on 12th September 2025 in Mavoko CMELRC NO. E046 of 2024)

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

1. The Appellant herein, being dissatisfied with the Judgment and Decree of the Hon. M.A. Nanzushi (SPM) delivered on 12th September 2025 in Mavoko CMELRC NO. E046 of 2024 between the parties filed a Memorandum of Appeal dated the 26th of September 2025 seeking the following orders: -

a) This Appeal be allowed.

b) The Judgement of the Court dated 12th September 2025 be set aside.

c) The Appellant be granted costs of the Appeal.

GROUNDS OF THE APPEAL

2. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact in finding that the Respondent's employment was improperly, unfairly and unlawfully terminated.

3. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to find that the Respondent refused to resume work despite being summoned by the Appellant to return to work and clear his name against the theft accusations that had been levelled against him.

4. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to take into consideration the Appellant's testimony, documentary evidence and submissions while delivering her judgement.

5. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact in arriving at the conclusion that the Respondent was deserving of any terminal reliefs.

6. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to consider and deliver judgement on the Appellant's counterclaim.

7. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact in finding that the Respondent was merited for an award of compensation for unlawful termination and awarding him Kshs. 180,000/=.

8. The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact by NOT finding that the Respondent indeed stole from the Appellant and refused to defend himself.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

9. The Respondent filed a suit against the Appellant vide a memorandum of claim dated 31st January 2024 seeking the following orders: -

a. A declaration that the Claimant’s dismissal from his employment was wrongful, unprocedural and unlawful ab ignition and in violation of the Claimant’s right to fair labour practices.

b. An order or payment of the Claimant’s terminal benefits as set out in paragraph 6 herein totalling Kshs. 1,646,034/-.

c. Legal fee of Kshs. 50,000/-.

d. An order for payment of general damages.

e. An order for costs and interest of this claim.

(pages 94-96 of Appellant’s ROA dated 2nd June 2026).

10. The Respondent filed his list of witnesses dated 31st January 2024, his witness statement dated 18th January 2024, and his list of documents dated 31st January 2024, together with the attached bundle of documents (pages 98-105 of the ROA). The Claimant later filed a supplementary list of documents dated 23rd February 2024 with the attached bundle, and a further list of documents dated 16th May 2024, also with the attached bundle.

11. The claim was opposed by the Appellant who entered appearance on 8th February 2024 and filed an amended memorandum of reply to the memorandum of claim and counterclaim dated 17th October 2024. In the counterclaim, the Appellant sought the following orders:

a) Payment of Kshs. 250,000/-.

b) Costs of the suit.

c) Any other relief that this Court may deem fit to grant.

(pages 71-75 of ROA).

12. To support their case, the Appellant also filed a list of witnesses dated 17th October 2024; witness statement of MULUGETA TESFAI of even date; and list of documents of even date with the bundle of documents attached (pages 76-93 of ROA).

13. To counter the counterclaim, the Respondent filed a Reply to Counterclaim dated 16th January 2025.

14. The Plaintiff/Respondent’s case was heard on 10th March 2025, with the Claimant giving evidence. He adopted his filed witness statement as his evidence in chief and produced his documents as exhibits. He was cross-examined by counsel for the Appellant, Mr. Jaleny (pages 25-28 of ROA).

15. The Appellant/Respondent’s case was heard on 5th June 2025, with the Respondent’s sole witness, MULEGETA TESFAI, testifying as DW1. He adopted his filed witness statement as his evidence in chief and produced the Appellant/Respondent’s documents as exhibits. The witness was not cross-examined because counsel for the Claimant/Respondent was not present in Court (pages 29-30 of ROA).

16. From the record, the Court noted that it is not clear from the proceedings whether the Court allowed the application to amend the defence (see proceedings for 26/11/24 and 8/1/2025 on pages 24-25 of the ROA). However, during the hearing, the Appellant’s witness informed the Court that he had filed the amended defence and witness statement. In the Judgment, however, on page 35 of the ROA (marked 31), the Court refers to the original defence and completely disregards the counterclaim.

17. The Court entered Judgment on 12th September 2025, allowing the Respondent’s case in the sum of Kshs. 240,000/-, comprising one month’s pay in lieu of notice, 6 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination, and service pay, plus costs of the suit (judgment at pages 34-37 of ROA).

DETERMINATION

18. The appeal was canvassed by way of written submissions. Both parties complied.

Issues for determination

19. In their submissions dated 6th August 2026, the Appellant identified the following issues for determination:

i. Whether the trial Magistrate erred in law by finding that the

Respondent was unlawfully terminated.

ii. Whether the trial Magistrate erred in law in failing to find that by the Respondents refusing to return to work and immediately institute claim proceedings cannot be construed to be an unlawful termination.

iii. Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in law by failing to determine and pronounce judgement on the counter claim filed by the Appellant.

20. On his part, the Respondent submitted generally on the grounds of appeal in his submissions dated 17th September 2026.

21. The court, having perused the submissions of both parties and taking into account the grounds of the appeal, discerned the issues for determination in the appeal to be-

i. Whether the trial Magistrate erred in law by finding that the

Respondent was unlawfully terminated.

ii. Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in law by failing to determine and pronounce judgement on the counterclaim filed by the Appellant.

iii. Whether the appeal is merited

The law

22. Sections 41,43,45(2) and 44(4) of the Employment Act on the threshold of fairness in termination of employment.

23. The manner of proving employment claims as per Section 47(5) of the Employment Act.

24. The court is guided on the role of the first appellate court as held by the Court of Appeal in Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. [1968] EA 123 that:-

“The appellate court is not bound necessarily to accept the findings of fact by the court below. An appeal to the Court of Appeal from a trial by the High Court is by way of a retrial and the principles upon which the Court of Appeal acts are that the court must reconsider the evidence, evaluate it itself and draw its own conclusions though it should always bear in mind that it has neither seen nor heard the witnesses and should make due allowance in this respect. In particular the court is not bound necessarily to follow the trial Judge’s findings of fact if it appears either that he has clearly failed on some point to take account of particular circumstances or probabilities materially to estimate the evidence or if the impression based on the demeanor of a witness is inconsistent with the evidence in the case generally.”

Whether the trial Magistrate erred in law by finding that the Respondent was unlawfully terminated.

The appellant’s submissions

25. In the case of Ngunda v Ready Consultancy Limited [2022] KECA 577 (KLR)  the court held that once the employee is given the opportunity to a hearing and he refuses to attend, the employer cannot be blamed for termination of employment.

26. In the case of Chief Justice & Another -vs Khaemba, Civil Appeal No. 522 of 2019, the court held that once an employee is given the opportunity for a hearing, he must attend to defend himself. Similarly in Owudu -vs- Digital Sanitation services Limited Appeal E109 OF 2023 (2024)KEELRC 917 (KLR)(18 April 2024, the court stated that an employee who fails to attend as directed by the employer commits gross misconduct which is contrary to Section 44(4)(e) of the Act.

27. In the instant matter, it is clear that when a letter was written to the Respondent on 7th October 2023 to return to work and offer an explanation as to the accusations against him he immediately engaged the Kenya Long Distance Truck drivers and Allied workers Union in Mombasa who on 9th October 2023 hardly two days after the letter written by the Appellant to the Respondent who wrote a demand notice to the Appellant claiming compensation for unlawful termination instead of trying to resolve the issue between the Appellant and the Respondent then. This action clearly shows a pattern of pre-meditated chain of events by the Respondent, and in such conduct in such a situation, the Honourable court in Owudu case held that under the provisions of Section 45(5) of the Act, the court should consider these records of the employee, they are relevant and to assign compensation would be to reward the employee (Respondent) over his acts of misconduct.

Respondent’s submissions

28. Whether the Court erred in both law and fact by finding that the Respondent’s employment was improperly, unfairly and unlawfully terminated- it is the Respondent’s evidence that the Appellant verbally and unlawfully terminated his employment on or about October 2023, without issuing him with a notice to show cause and or inviting him to a disciplinary hearing.

29. Section 45(2) of the Employment Act states as follows;

‘A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove;

a. That the reason for termination is valid.

b. That the reason for termination is a fair reason

i. Related to the employees conduct, capacity or compatibility, or ii. Based on the operation requirements of the employer and

c. That the employment was terminated in accordance to fair procedure.’

30. The Appellant avers that pursuant to the Respondent deserting duty, it wrote a letter dated 7th October 2023, asking him to report to work and defend himself against the allegations levelled against him. It is important to note that there is no such letter at page 50 of the Record of Appeal but rather at Page 77 of the Record as what is at page 50 of the Record, is a Memorandum of Appearance dated 8th day of February 2024. The Respondent did respond to the said letter and gave account of each allegation via his letter dated 20th October 2023, through his union and gave a detailed response through the Appellants advocate (Pages 101 to 103) of the Record of Appeal.

31. The respondent contended that it was incumbent upon the Appellant to issue a notice to show cause to the Respondent why he should not be dismissed from his employment and or invite him for a disciplinary hearing and thereafter terminate him form employment. The Appellant did not during the hearing, demonstrate that it issued a notice to show cause and or summoned the Respondent to a disciplinary hearing and he failed to do appear. The said letter of 7th day of October 2023, does not meet the threshold of a notice to show cause and or an invitation to a disciplinary hearing as alluded by Appellant. If there any legal or contractual obligations that appear to advocate employment at will of the employer such provisions should be read as being subservient to the minimum termination standards created under sections 41,43 and 45 of the Employment Act 2007.The duty to give reason or reasons for termination is absolute terms by the law. That the Appellant has not told this court when the notice to show cause letter was issued and/or served upon the Respondent, when the Respondent was summoned to attend a disciplinary plenary, if any was at all convened and whether the outcome of the disciplinary was communicated to the Respondent. To buttress this position, the Respondent relied on Mary Chemweno Kiptui Vs Kenya Pipeline Company Ltd (2014) which affirmed that;

‘Section 41 of the Employment Act is couched in mandatory terms. Where an employer fails to follow these mandatory provisions, whatever the outcome of the process is bound to be unfair as the affected employee has not been accorded a hearing in the presence of their union representative or in the presence of a fellow employee of their choice.’

32. The Respondent submitted that the Appellant did not subject him to any due process before terminating his employment and as such, the Respondent was unfairly and/or improperly terminated. The Appellant has placed reliance on Ngunda v Ready Consultancy Limited [2022] KECA 577 (KLR)  to justify the termination of the Respondent from employment. However, the distinction in the cited authority from this case is that, in the instant case, the Respondent was never invited to any disciplinary hearing and or given an opportunity to a hearing and he refused to attend, and as such, the cited authority has no relevance herein.

33. Whether the Learned Magistrate erred both in Law and Fact by finding that the Respondent refused to return to work despite being summoned to return and clear his name against the theft accusations that had been leveled against him- the Appellant in his submissions at Page 1 of the Record more specifically paragraph 4, accuses the Respondent of failing to report to work and deserting duty. It is trite law that when faced with an employee who fails to attend work, the employer must issue notice to the employee to render an account of his misconduct. Where the employee fails to respond or persists in failing to abide by such directions, the employer is required to issue notice terminating employment or summary dismissal through the last known address of the employee. Further, where the employer cannot trace the employee, notice must be issued to the labour officer and any terminal dues deposited in such office, Then, the employer has undertaken its legal duty to properly end employment. In Richard Maingi Vs Wells Fargo Limited (2017) eKlr and Chrispine Onguso Okinyi vs Devki Steel Mills Limited (2018) See Page 45 of the Record of Appeal) the court held that dismissal on account desertion requires the employer to produce evidence showing reasonable steps were undertaken to contact the employee accused of desertion. The law regarding desertion and or absconding duty is now settled. An employer alleging desertion, must demonstrate attempts made to contact the employee, issue a notice to show cause, invite the employee to a disciplinary hearing and comply with section 41 of the Employment Act before termination. In the instant case, it is evident that; a. No notice to show cause was produced. b. No invitation to disciplinary hearing was produced. c. No evidence of calls, letters, emails, text messages or report to a labour officer was tendered.

34. Ground 3 of the Record of Appeal, Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in Law and Fact by failing to take into consideration the Appellant’s testimony, documentary evidence and submissions while delivering her judgement - is not enough to just allege that the court did not take into consideration the evidence and or documentary evidence while delivering its judgement. The trial court, while delivering its judgement, took into account the evidence of both the claimant and respondent before arriving at a determination. (Pages 30 -34, of the Record of Appeal) wherein the court at Pages 30 and 31 took time to analyze both the Appellant’s and Respondent’s case before arriving at the determination it did. We submit that the Appellant has not furnished this court with any evidence that the trial court failed to take into account while delivering its judgments and accusations are unfair and malicious.

Decision

35. The respondent stated in his witness statement that his employment was unfairly terminated on 2nd October 2023(page 91 of ROA).The respondent produced before the trial court a letter dated 3rd October 2023 to the employer explaining the September-October trip where he raised issue of irregular consumption of fuel by the truck he was using and explained the delay at the Uganda-South Sudan border by cargo owners, of which he stated the drivers were compensated for the unwarranted further expenditure on the road by the cargo owners of USD 500. He stated he was committed to service. (PAGES 98-99 OF ROA) The respondent wrote a further letter dated 6th October 2023 to explain the USD 500 payment and noted that he had not been advised of the date to report to work.(page 100 of ROA).

36. The appellant, vide letter dated 7th October 2023, asked the respondent where he was, informed him no one had stopped him from working and that he had escaped after being asked about the USD 500 . In the letter, the respondent was asked to refund the USD 500, 550 litres of fuel and to report to work with an official reason why he left the truck in the garage and made it out of work(page 77 of RoA).

37. During cross-examination, the respondent admitted receipt of a letter dated 7th October 2023 via WhatsApp. He noted it was a response to his letter demanding his September salary and requesting reinstatement to work. He denied having run away from work. The respondent stated that on 7th October 2023 he was not at work and that the truck had been re-assigned. That the employer deducted USD 500, which was his. He admitted having written a letter on 6th October and another on 20th October 2023. In the letter of 20th October 2023, the respondent admitted to having received a letter dated 7th October 2023 and stated that he presumed the letter was written with ulterior motive, having demanded his salary. He further stated that on 2nd October 2023, Mulugeta(the boss) told him not to step back to the company compound on account of the USD 500. (page 102-103 of RoA.)

38. The appellant produced an OB report dated 3rd October 2023 accusing the respondent of stealing.(Page 76 of RoA).

39. The appellant contended that the letter of 7th October 2023 was a show cause of which on receipt, the respondent did not respond but instructed the union which wrote a letter to the appellant on 9th October 2023(page 81 of RoA). The appellant relied on the Court of Appeal decision in Ngunda v Ready Consultancy Limited [2022] KECA 577 (KLR) 

40. The trial court held the termination was unfair for lack of procedural fairness under section 41 of the Employment Act,

41. The respondent contended that the letter of 7th October did not meet the threshold of section 41 of the Employment Act. The said letter of 7th day of October 2023, does not meet the threshold of a notice to show cause and or an invitation to a disciplinary hearing as alluded by Appellant. He relied James Kabengi Mugo V Syngenta East Africa Limited [2013] KEHC 3865 (KLR) wherein Justice Rika held that;-

‘The Employment Act 2007 makes it obligatory for employers to substantively justify termination decisions, and carry out the termination processes in a procedurally fair manner. Employment is no longer at the will of the employer. If there are any legal or contractual provisions that appear to advocate employment at the will of the employer, such provisions should be read as being subservient to the minimum statutory termination standards created under Section 41, 43, and 45 of the Employment Act 2007. The duty to give reason or reasons for termination is in absolute terms. It is imposed in absolute terms by the law. ‘

42. The appellant submitted that the respondent did not respond to show cause of 7th October and cannot claim unfair termination and relied on the decision in Ngunda v Ready Consultancy Limited [2022] KECA 577 (KLR)  the Court of Appeal held that-

‘The appellant was given an opportunity to be heard. He chose not to appear before the disciplinary hearing, as a consequence of which, he has no one else but himself to blame for having squandered that opportunity.’ (Similar holding in Chief Justice & Another -vs Khaemba, Civil Appeal No. 522 Of 2019 and Owudu -vs- Digital Sanitation services Limited Appeal E109 OF 2023 (2024)KEELRC 917 (KLR)(18 April 2024)

43. In the instant matter, it is clear that when a letter was written to the Respondent on 7th October 2023 to return to work and offer explanation as to the accusations against him, he immediately engaged the Kenya Long Distance Truck drivers and Allied workers Union in Mombasa who on 9th October 2023 hardly two days after the letter written by the Appellant to the Respondent who wrote a demand notice to the Appellant claiming compensation for unlawful termination instead of trying to resolve the issue between the Appellant and the Respondent then.

44. The appellant contended the action by the respondent clearly shows a pattern of pre-meditated chain of events by the Respondent, and in such conduct in such a situation, the Honourable court in Owudu case held that under the provisions of Section 45(5) of the Act, the court should consider these records of the employee, they are relevant and to assign compensation would be to reward the employee (Respondent) over his acts of misconduct. The respondent distinguished the cited authorities, stating in the instant case, the Respondent was never invited to any disciplinary hearing and or given an opportunity to a hearing and he refused to attend, and as such, the cited authority has no relevance herein.

45. The termination of employment procedural fairness is as stated in section 41 of the Employment Act -

‘41. Notification and hearing before termination on grounds of misconduct

(1)Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.

(2)Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) or (4) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1) make.’’

46. The court carefully considered the letter of 7th October 2023. It appears to the court that there were issues of lack of accountability by the respondent of fuel and USD 500 given by the cargo owner to the respondent during his trip to Sudan in September 2023. The employer reported the respondent to the police for theft on or about 3 October 2023(page 76 of RoA) but no progress was availed to the court on the accusation. The parties were in communication, and indeed in a letter of 6th October 2023 the respondent inquired about his September salary and indicated he should be on duty. The court finds that the respondent had not deserted duty. He was an employee and had the intention to continue working. In the letter of 7th October 2023, taking into account that there is no defined format for a show cause, I would not say it was not. It can be fit a show cause letter.

47. However, it is obvious to the court that there was no compliance with the procedural fairness under section 41 of the Employment Act. The letter dated 9th October 2023 from a third party, such as the union, cannot justify the appellant's failure to comply with section 41 of the Employment Act. In the decision delivered in Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Limited [2024] KEELRC 917 (KLR) the court held-

‘Even though an employee who fails to attend as directed by the employer commits gross misconduct which is contrary to Section 44(4) (e) of the Act, notice to the subject employee must be issued in accordance with Section 41(2) of the Act. Where the subject employee fails to attend or address, as analyzed above, such being an act of gross misconduct, the employer must issue a termination notice or summary dismissal notice and copy the Labour Officer. That terminates employment lawfully. The duty to end the employment relationship is on the employer.’

48. The letter dated 7th October 2023 was titled-‘escape from truth and fail to report to work(fugitive from justice)’.

49. It is the opinion of the court that the said letter fell short of the process under section 41, which includes informing the employee of the intention to terminate the employment and inviting them for a hearing in the company of a fellow employee or a lawyer. In the decision relied on, Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Limited [2024] KEELRC 917 (KLR), emphasis was placed on compliance with section 41.

50. Further on reason or termination, the allegation of desertion was not proved and was not true, as the respondent in correspondence analysed above indicated he considered himself to be in employment. The respondent was never invited for hearing as per section 41 of the employment Act. The instant case is distinguished from Ngunda v Ready Consultancy Limited [2022] KECA 577 (KLR)  where the Court of Appeal held that-

‘The appellant was given an opportunity to be heard. He chose not to appear before the disciplinary hearing, as a consequence of which, he has no one else but himself to blame for having squandered that opportunity.’

51. I find no basis to fault the finding of the trial court that there was unfair termination.

Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in law by failing to determine and pronounce judgment on the counterclaim filed by the Appellant.

52. The grounds of appeal was –

a) The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact by failing to consider and deliver judgement on the Appellant's counterclaim.

b) The Honourable Magistrate erred both in law and fact by NOT finding that the Respondent indeed stole from the Appellant and refused to defend himself.

53. The court, upon perusal of the judgment, found it was true that the trial court did not decide on the counterclaim. The appellant filed an amended reply to the memorandum of claim and counterclaim dated 17th October 2024.

The appellant’s submissions

54. Failure to determine and pronounce judgement on the counterclaim-The trial court had a strict legal duty to consider and pronounce judgement on a counterclaim. That failing to do so leaves a primary, legally contested dispute unresolved. When a court fails to address a counterclaim supported by uncontroverted evidence, an Appeal or a review to correct that omission must be granted to prevent an ongoing injustice. In the instant matter, the Appellant's counterclaim is on record, and the Appellant tendered uncontroverted evidence on the same, and we pray that this Honourable Court do enter judgment for the Appellant in terms of the counterclaim herein. That this Honourable Court do find that the Respondent was not unlawfully terminated and proceed to set aside the lower court's judgment award in terms of compensation for unlawful termination and enter judgment in terms of the counterclaim in favour of the Appellant with costs.

Respondent’s submissions

55. The Appellant, at page 2 of its submissions, avers that it filed a defence and counterclaim and that no defence was filed against the counterclaim. The Appellant filed a notice of motion application dated 17th October 2024, seeking to amend its Reply to Memorandum of Claim (Page 20 of the Record of Appeal) which application was allowed and thereafter, the Respondent filed his Reply to amended memorandum of claim and counter-claim dated 16th day of January 2025, which the Appellant has conveniently opted to mislead the court that the same was not filed. The respondent urged the court to peruse the entire lower court to confirm that indeed the same was filed. The Appellant in its counterclaim was praying for ksh 250,000/= together with costs and any other reliefs. It is not enough to just throw figures around and expect court to award the same without leading any evidence in support of the same. The Appellant alleged that it wants to be compensated Ksh 99,000 on account of 550 Litres of diesel, Ksh 78,000/ on account of Motor vehicle accessories.

56. It must be noted that the claim under this head is a special claim, which is not only pleaded but must strictly be proved. The Appellant did not produce any receipt and or evidence to show that it paid KSH 234,000/ to fuel the Subject Truck, that the amount of fuel allegedly siphoned amounted to Ksh 99,000/= and that the cost of the listed missing accessories amounted to Ksh 78,000/=, and in the absence of such evidence, the claimants counterclaim could not have seen the light of the day.

Decision

57. I hold that the trial court failed in its judicial duty by failing to make a decision on the counterclaim. The court did not find, on the record of appeal, the alleged response to the counterclaim. I also noted several pleadings were missing from the record. The respondent had informed the court of missing pleadings and sought a supplementary record. That notwithstanding, the court did re-evaluate the evidence before the court found witness statements and testamentary evidence.

58. On the counterclaim for USD 500 paid to the respondent by the cargo owner in Sudan. Both parties agreed it was paid on account of delay of goods at the Kenya-Sudan border. The respondent, in all his correspondence with the employer and in court, including at cross-examination, was emphatic that the USD 500 was his personal money paid to the drivers on account of the delay suffered at the border, which caused them to incur extra expenses. The respondent submitted that the appellant ought to have called the cargo owner to prove the money was not for the driver. I have to agree with the respondent. The appellant had the burden of proving that the said USD 500 given by the cargo owner to the respondent was intended for it. The respondent had the defence all along and yet failed to contact the cargo owner to verify the position of the respondent. It is unreasonable that the cargo owner would give the cash to the driver if it was meant for the appellant. The appellant failed to discharge the burden to prove the money was not for the benefit of the respondent.

59. On the 550 litres, it was stated that when the respondent came back to Nairobi he could not account for the 550 litres out of the 1300 litres fueled in South Sudan. During cross-examination, he told the trial court that he had explained to the appellant that the diesel had been consumed by the truck, that the truck had an issue, and that the mechanic had informed the employer. The court noted that there was no hearing on this issue. No investigation report was filed to prove the claim. Indeed, no document was filed to prove the loss of fuel. I find the claim was not proved on a balance of probabilities.

60. On the claim for accessories, again there was no proof before the trial court of the loss of the accessories. There was no detailed costing of the items as claimed. I find the claim was not proved strictly being special damages.

61. In the upshot, on re-evaluation of the evidence before the trial court, I find no merit in the counterclaim.

Whether the appeal is merited

62. I upheld the finding on unfair termination.

63. I held the trial court erred in fact and law by failing to make a determination of the counterclaim. Further, on re-evaluation of the evidence before the trial court, I found no merit in the entire counterclaim.

Disposition

64. The Judgment and Decree of the Hon. M.A. Nanzushi (SPM) delivered on 12th September 2025 in Mavoko CMELRC NO. E046 of 2024 is upheld.

65. The appeal is dismissed with costs to the respondent.

66. It is so Ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026

JEMIMAH KELI

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Appellant – Jaleny

Respondent – Momanyi

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder