Background
Whether the termination of the Claimant’s employment was substantively justified.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The claim was dismissed. The court held that the termination was substantively justified and procedurally fair, denied the Claimant all reliefs, and ordered each party to bear its own costs.
i) The termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was substantively justified and procedurally fair.
Passage 25 →
ii) The Claimant’s claim dated 28th March, 2022 be and is hereby dismissed.
Passage 26 →
iii) Each party shall bear its own costs of this cause.
Passage 27 →
Held. Yes. The Respondent established persistent poor performance through appraisal records, coaching records and the Performance Improvement Programme. The Claimant did not prove that his scores had been manipulated. Although the unexplained March 2020 cashier job description favoured the Claimant, earlier appraisal evidence substantially outweighed it. He also did not establish a causal connection between his illness and the recorded performance shortfalls.
Ratio. Under sections 47(5) and 43 of the Employment Act, the employee must establish unfair termination and the employer must prove the reason for termination. Documentary evidence of persistent underperformance satisfies the employer’s burden where the employee’s challenge to the appraisals is unsupported.
Issue
1. Whether the termination of the Claimant’s employment was substantively justified.
Paragraph 1 →
Held
There is a genuine gap in the Respondent’s case that this court does not overlook. The cashier job description of 5th March 2020 was issued without any satisfactory explanation in the Respondent’s evidence of whether the Claimant was thereafter assessed on his new cashier responsibilities or on his prior Customer Service Manager role. That unexplained inconsistency is a point in the Claimant’s favour. It is not, however, dispositive. The cashier job description was issued in March, 2020 five months before the termination letter of August, 2020 and the appraisal record spanning 2017 to 2019 predates and substantially outweighs it. The Respondent has discharged its burden under Section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007. As to the Claimant’s ill health, the record corroborates the hospitalisation and surgery, but the Claimant has not established a causal nexus between his health condition and the specific performance shortfalls recorded in each appraisal cycle. There is no rebuttal that this was not disclosed or raised as a reason for poor performance. The termination was substantively justified.
Passage 20 →
i) The termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was substantively justified and procedurally fair.
Passage 25 →
Ratio
The 1st issue for determination is whether the termination was substantively justified. Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007 places on an employee the burden of proving that an unfair termination has occurred, while Section 43 places on the employer the burden of proving the reason for termination. The Respondent has produced documentary evidence spanning several appraisal cycles from 2017 through to 2020, showing performance consistently rated below the required standard, multiple coaching records and the outcome of the Performance Improvement Programme. The Claimant’s central contention that his scores were manipulated is not established on the evidence. He has produced no source data, assessor records or corroborating material capable of displacing the appraisal documents on the record.
Passage 19 →
There is a genuine gap in the Respondent’s case that this court does not overlook. The cashier job description of 5th March 2020 was issued without any satisfactory explanation in the Respondent’s evidence of whether the Claimant was thereafter assessed on his new cashier responsibilities or on his prior Customer Service Manager role. That unexplained inconsistency is a point in the Claimant’s favour. It is not, however, dispositive. The cashier job description was issued in March, 2020 five months before the termination letter of August, 2020 and the appraisal record spanning 2017 to 2019 predates and substantially outweighs it. The Respondent has discharged its burden under Section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007. As to the Claimant’s ill health, the record corroborates the hospitalisation and surgery, but the Claimant has not established a causal nexus between his health condition and the specific performance shortfalls recorded in each appraisal cycle. There is no rebuttal that this was not disclosed or raised as a reason for poor performance. The termination was substantively justified.
Passage 20 →
Held. Yes. The Claimant received warning letters, was placed on a Performance Improvement Programme, and was invited to and attended a hearing. His challenge to the venue stated in the invitation failed because he attended the hearing and was not denied an opportunity to be heard. The process substantially complied with section 41 of the Employment Act.
Ratio. Section 41 requires notice of poor-performance concerns, an opportunity to respond with a representative, and a hearing before termination. A defect alleged in the hearing venue does not make the procedure unfair where the employee attends and suffers no denial of a hearing.
Issue
2. Whether the termination was procedurally fair.
Paragraph 2 →
Held
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was procedurally fair. Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 requires that an employee facing termination on grounds of poor performance be notified of the concerns, given an opportunity to respond with a representative present and heard before the decision of termination is made. The record shows that the Claimant was issued with warning letters, placed on a Performance Improvement Programme and ultimately invited to and attended a hearing. The Claimant’s submission that the venue named in the invitation letter, at the Respondent’s Regional Office in the Western Region, was inappropriate is not sustainable. The Claimant attended the hearing and the principal prejudice that a defective venue notice could cause, namely denial of a hearing, does not materialize or make sense. The termination process substantially complied with Section 41.
Passage 21 →
i) The termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was substantively justified and procedurally fair.
Passage 25 →
Ratio
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was procedurally fair. Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 requires that an employee facing termination on grounds of poor performance be notified of the concerns, given an opportunity to respond with a representative present and heard before the decision of termination is made. The record shows that the Claimant was issued with warning letters, placed on a Performance Improvement Programme and ultimately invited to and attended a hearing. The Claimant’s submission that the venue named in the invitation letter, at the Respondent’s Regional Office in the Western Region, was inappropriate is not sustainable. The Claimant attended the hearing and the principal prejudice that a defective venue notice could cause, namely denial of a hearing, does not materialize or make sense. The termination process substantially complied with Section 41.
Passage 21 →
Held. No. Since the termination was substantively justified and procedurally fair, the Claimant was not entitled to any relief sought. The claim was dismissed.
Ratio. Where termination is substantively justified and procedurally fair, relief premised on unfair or unlawful termination is unavailable.
Issue
3. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
Paragraph 3 →
Held
The 3rd and 4th issues for determination are reliefs and costs. Having found the termination both substantively justified and procedurally fair, the Claimant is not entitled to any of the reliefs sought.
Passage 22 →
ii) The Claimant’s claim dated 28th March, 2022 be and is hereby dismissed.
Passage 26 →
Ratio
The 3rd and 4th issues for determination are reliefs and costs. Having found the termination both substantively justified and procedurally fair, the Claimant is not entitled to any of the reliefs sought.
Passage 22 →
Held. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs. Although costs ordinarily follow the event, the court departed from that rule because the Claimant had served for approximately nineteen years and brought the claim on a somewhat genuine belief that his performance records had been manipulated.
Ratio. Costs ordinarily follow the event, but the court may depart from that rule in light of the circumstances, including long service and a genuinely held basis for bringing the claim.
Issue
4. Who shall bear the costs of the suit.
Paragraph 4 →
Held
On costs, the ordinary rule is that costs follow the event. I am, however, mindful that the Claimant served the Respondent for approximately nineteen years and brought this claim on a somewhat genuine belief that his performance records had been unfairly manipulated. The length and nature of that service justify a departure from the ordinary cost’s rule.
Passage 23 →
iii) Each party shall bear its own costs of this cause.
Passage 27 →
Ratio
On costs, the ordinary rule is that costs follow the event. I am, however, mindful that the Claimant served the Respondent for approximately nineteen years and brought this claim on a somewhat genuine belief that his performance records had been unfairly manipulated. The length and nature of that service justify a departure from the ordinary cost’s rule.
Passage 23 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Whether the termination of the Claimant’s employment was substantively justified.
Paragraph 1 →Whether the claimant’s termination for poor performance was substantively justified; whether the process was procedurally fair; whether he was entitled to the requested declarations, reinstatement or compensation and expungement of performance records; and…
In Lang’at v KCB Bank (Kenya) Ltd [2026] KEELRC 2810 (KLR), the claimant had been employed from 19 November 2001 and rose to Customer Service Manager. He was hospitalised and underwent back surgery in July 2017. He maintained that ill health caused later…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E197 OF 2022
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
SAMMY KIPKORIR LANG’AT …………………………………………… CLAIMANT
VERSUS
KCB BANK (KENYA) LIMITED ……………………………….……… RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
This matter came to court by way of a Memorandum of Claim dated 28th March, 2022 filed on 30th instant. The issue in dispute is therein cited as;
unfair and unlawful termination of employment of the Claimant.
The Claimant’s case is that he was employed by the Respondent on 19th November, 2001 and rose through various positions to the grade of Customer Service Manager. From July, 2017 he began experiencing serious health challenges. He was hospitalised at The Karen Hospital in July, 2017 and underwent back surgery. He avers that his performance challenges from 2017 onwards were directly attributable to his ill health and that the Respondent failed to make reasonable accommodation for his medical condition before resorting to a performance management process.
The claimant’s further case is that on 23rd September, 2019 he was issued with a first warning letter for the H1 2019 performance period, and on 24th September, 2019 a second warning for H2 2018 performance. He was subsequently placed on a Performance Improvement Programme. He contends that he was issued a new job description as cashier on 5th March, 2020 which he argues amounted to a demotion, while he continued to be assessed against his original Customer Service Manager responsibilities. His central contention is that his true performance scores for 2019 and 2020 were 3.24 and 3.15 respectively, both above the pass mark of 3.0, and that these scores were manipulated downward. He prays for a declaration of unlawful termination, reinstatement, or alternatively twelve months’ compensation, an order to expunge adverse performance records, and costs.
The Respondent’s case, as set out in its Memorandum of Reply and elaborated in the witness statement of Stephen Mosong is that the Claimant’s performance fell below the Bank’s required standards over a materially long period spanning several half-year appraisal cycles. The Respondent avers that it placed the Claimant on a Performance Improvement Programme and offered him training, guidance and extended time to demonstrate improvement before resorting to termination. It avers that the Claimant was paid his full terminal dues, including one month’s salary in lieu of notice.
The issues for determination therefore are;
1. Whether the termination of the Claimant’s employment was substantively justified.
2. Whether the termination was procedurally fair.
3. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the reliefs sought.
4. Who shall bear the costs of the suit.
The 1st issue for determination is whether the termination was substantively justified. Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007 places on an employee the burden of proving that an unfair termination has occurred, while Section 43 places on the employer the burden of proving the reason for termination. The Respondent has produced documentary evidence spanning several appraisal cycles from 2017 through to 2020, showing performance consistently rated below the required standard, multiple coaching records and the outcome of the Performance Improvement Programme. The Claimant’s central contention that his scores were manipulated is not established on the evidence. He has produced no source data, assessor records or corroborating material capable of displacing the appraisal documents on the record.
There is a genuine gap in the Respondent’s case that this court does not overlook. The cashier job description of 5th March 2020 was issued without any satisfactory explanation in the Respondent’s evidence of whether the Claimant was thereafter assessed on his new cashier responsibilities or on his prior Customer Service Manager role. That unexplained inconsistency is a point in the Claimant’s favour. It is not, however, dispositive. The cashier job description was issued in March, 2020 five months before the termination letter of August, 2020 and the appraisal record spanning 2017 to 2019 predates and substantially outweighs it. The Respondent has discharged its burden under Section 43 of the Employment Act, 2007. As to the Claimant’s ill health, the record corroborates the hospitalisation and surgery, but the Claimant has not established a causal nexus between his health condition and the specific performance shortfalls recorded in each appraisal cycle. There is no rebuttal that this was not disclosed or raised as a reason for poor performance. The termination was substantively justified.
The 2nd issue for determination is whether the termination was procedurally fair. Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 requires that an employee facing termination on grounds of poor performance be notified of the concerns, given an opportunity to respond with a representative present and heard before the decision of termination is made. The record shows that the Claimant was issued with warning letters, placed on a Performance Improvement Programme and ultimately invited to and attended a hearing. The Claimant’s submission that the venue named in the invitation letter, at the Respondent’s Regional Office in the Western Region, was inappropriate is not sustainable. The Claimant attended the hearing and the principal prejudice that a defective venue notice could cause, namely denial of a hearing, does not materialize or make sense. The termination process substantially complied with Section 41.
The 3rd and 4th issues for determination are reliefs and costs. Having found the termination both substantively justified and procedurally fair, the Claimant is not entitled to any of the reliefs sought.
On costs, the ordinary rule is that costs follow the event. I am, however, mindful that the Claimant served the Respondent for approximately nineteen years and brought this claim on a somewhat genuine belief that his performance records had been unfairly manipulated. The length and nature of that service justify a departure from the ordinary cost’s rule.
In the result, I am inclined to dismiss the claim and order as follows:
i) The termination of the Claimant’s employment by the Respondent was substantively justified and procedurally fair.
ii) The Claimant’s claim dated 28th March, 2022 be and is hereby dismissed.
iii) Each party shall bear its own costs of this cause.
Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. T. O. Odero holding brief for Banking, Insurance & Finance Union (K) for the Claimant.
2. M/s Kangethe instructed by Mola Advocates for the Respondent.