Employment law

Muasya v Mars Wrigley Confectionery Kenya Ltd & 5 others [2026] KEELRC 14684 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Machakos
Case number
Elrc Cause E006 of 2026
Judgment date
16 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The petitioner, a former employee of the respondent, engaged as a Field Sales Associate, alleged unfair termination and a violation of her constitutional rights by the respondents. She filed a statement of claim dated 4th February 2026 against the respondents and sought the following relief-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The issue for determination in the ruling was whether the notice of preliminary objection was meritorious.

Paragraph 5 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS

ELRC CAUSE NO. E006 OF 2026

IN THE MATTER OF: THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010, ARTICLES 28, 41, 27, AND THE EMPLOYMENT ACТ, 2007

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: THE OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH AСТ, 2007

BETWEEN

VIVIAN NGENYI MUASYA ……………………………………………………………….………….……PETITIONER

-VERSUS-

MARS WRIGLEY CONFECTIONERY KENYA LTD ……………………………………..1ST RESPONDENT

PETER WANJOHI ……………………………………………………………………..………….2ND RESPONDENT

FRED GOR ……………………………………………………………………………………………3RD RESPONDENT

CAROLINE AELA ……………………………………………………………………………………. 4TH RESPONDENT

MATHIAS TENYWA………………………………………………………………………………5TH RESPONDENT

DENNIS NZUKI ………………………………………………………………………..………….6TH RESPONDENT

Coram

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

RULING

1. The petitioner, a former employee of the respondent, engaged as a Field Sales Associate, alleged unfair termination and a violation of her constitutional rights by the respondents. She filed a statement of claim dated 4th February 2026 against the respondents and sought the following relief-

a) The 1st 2nd 3ed ,4th ,5th,6th, Respondents threatened and grossly violated her Constitutional rights.

b) The 1st,2nd 3rd 4th 5th ,6th, Respondents violated the statutory provisions of the Occupational safety, the Employment Act 2007.

c) A declaration that the termination of the Petitioner's employment was unfair, unlawful and discriminatory.

d) Compensation for unlawful and unfair termination –

i. Statutory Compensation for unfair Termination to the tune of Kenya Shillings, Two hundred and fifty-eight million (KSh 258,000,000.00)

ii. Loss of career trajectory, Professional Standing and long -Term Earning Capacity to the tunes of Two hundred Eighty three million, eight hundred thousand Kenya Shilling. (283, 800, 000 ksh)

iii. General damages -Psychological injury &trauma owing to the tunes of Three hundred twenty-four million, eight hundred seventy-five thousand Kenyan shillings. (324,875,000)

e) General, aggravated and to the tuner of one ninety three million four Hundred and twenty - five thousand, seven hundred and fourteen Kenya Shillings (Kshs. 193,425,714)

f) Exemplary/Punitive Damages- Corporate Deterrence in sum of Two Hundred and fifty-eight Million Kenya Shilling ( Kshs. 258,000,000 )

g) Compensation for breach of constitutional rights in the sum of one hundred and twenty-nine million Kenya Shilling. (Kshs. 129,000,000)

h) One month's salary in lieu of notice, Accrued Leave, Allowances and Statutory Contributions in the sum of twelve million, nine Hundred thousand Kenya shillings (Kshs. 129,000,000.00)

i) Certificate of service.

j) Costs and interest of the claim.

2. In addition to the statement of claim, the petitioner filed a verifying affidavit, her witness statement and a list of witnesses on 5th February 2026. On 16th February 2026, the petitioner filed a list of documents together with the bundle.

3. The respondents entered appearance through the law firm of Obura Mbeche & Company. The 2nd to the 6th Respondents raised a Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 6th July 2026 on the following grounds -

a. The Petitioner has not demonstrated a cause of action against the 2nd -6th Respondent.

b. The Petitioner has not shown that there exists or existed any employment relationship between her and the 2nd - 6th Respondents.

c. The 2nd - 6th Respondent ought to be struck out from this suit as they are not necessary parties.

d. The Petitioner has raised matters falling within the jurisdiction of the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services. Accordingly, this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain those particular claims in the first instance, the Petitioner having failed to exhaust the statutory dispute resolution mechanism and they ought to be struck out.

4. The court directed the Notice of Preliminary Objection be canvassed by way of written submissions. The parties complied.

Decision

5. The issue for determination in the ruling was whether the notice of preliminary objection was meritorious.

The law

6. The Civil Procedure Rules set out who may be joined as a defendant in Order 1, rule 3-

‘All persons may be joined as defendants against whom any right to relief in respect of or arising out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged to exist, whether jointly, severally or in the alternative, where, if separate suits were brought against such persons any common question of law or fact would arise.’

7. The Employment Act section 86 provides for complaint and jurisdiction of the court in cases of dispute between employers and employees as follows-

‘86. (1)Subject to the provisions of this Act, whenever—

(a) an employer or employee neglects or refuses to fulfill a contract of service; or

(b) any question, difference or dispute arises as to the rights or liabilities of either party; or

(c) touching any misconduct, neglect or ill treatment of either party or any injury to the person or property of either party, under any contract of service, the aggrieved party may complain to the labour officer or lodge a complaint or suit in the Employment and Labour Relations Court.

(2)No court other than the Employment and Labour Relations Court shall determine any complaint or suit referred to in subsection (1).

(3)This section shall not apply in a suit where the dispute over a contract of service or any other matter referred to in subsection (1) is similar or secondary to the main issue in dispute.’

8. The preamble of the Work Injury Benefits Act states -

‘An Act of Parliament to provide for compensation to employees for work related injuries and diseases contracted in the course of their employment and for connected purposes’

The 2nd to 6th respondent’s submissions

9. For the cause of action against the 2nd - 6th Respondents, the starting point is the Petitioner 's own pleadings. The Court is invited to consider whether, assuming the pleaded facts to be true, any enforceable claim is disclosed against the 2nd - 6th Respondents. The jurisdiction of this Court under section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act principally concerns disputes arising out of employment and labour relations. Where no employment relationship is pleaded between a petitioner and a respondent, there must be some other identifiable legal basis upon which liability is sought against that respondent. In the present case, the Petitioner has not demonstrated any employment relationship, contractual obligation, or other legal basis upon which the 2nd - 6th Respondents can properly be held liable for the reliefs sought.

10. The 2nd to 6th Respondents relied on decision in Benard Ochieng Oduor v Trade Winds Aviation Services Limited & another [2020] KEELRC 152 (KLR)where the Court stated as follows:

"The upshot it is that the Petitioner 's claim can only be against the 1st Respondent with whom there existed an employment relationship.’’

11. The 2nd to 6th respondents further relied on the decision of the Court of Appeal in Abyssinia Iron & Steel Limited v Kenya Engineering Workers Union & another [2016] KECA 510 (KLR)  where it was held:

"In the instant case, the outsourced employees entered into express contractual relationships with Jokali, which in turn contracted with Abyssinia to provide employees to perform various duties. The employees, though working in Abyssinia’s premises, remained under Jokali’s management and control. Faced with these facts, we find that, bar the fulfillment of the mandatory legal requirements, it was Jokali, and not Abyssinia, that was obliged to recognise the Union in respect of Jokali’s employees. We therefore disagree with the learned judge that the employees outsourced to Jokali remained employees of Abyssinia." [Emphasis Added]

12. The 2nd to 6th respondents submitted that the Petitioner cannot sustain a cause of action against parties who were not his/her employer merely by associating them with the dispute. The substantive obligations concerning an employment relationship must be directed against the party with whom that relationship existed. In the circumstances, where the 2nd -6th Respondents were not the Petitioner 's employer and no employment contract between the parties is pleaded, the Petitioner has not disclosed an employment cause of action against them. That the mere fact that a party may have some connection with the circumstances giving rise to a claim does not, without more, make that party a necessary respondent. The question is whether the presence of the 2nd 6th Respondents is necessary for the Court to effectively and completely determine the dispute and whether any relief sought can properly issue against them.

13. In the present case, the reliefs arising from the alleged employment relationship can be determined between the Petitioner and the party alleged to have employed the Petitioner that is the 1st Respondent. The 2nd -6th Respondents have no contractual employment obligations to the Petitioner and no liability has been identified against them arising from such relationship. This was the approach by the Court in the Benard Oduor case where it was pointed out that the statutory obligations concerning termination and the justification for termination rest upon the employer, and that it serves no purpose to require a third party to defend the employer's actions. The 2nd -6th Respondents should therefore not be compelled to participate in proceedings in which no substantive relief can properly be granted against them.

14. The respondents further submitted on the allegation of failure to exhaust the statutory mechanism under the Occupational Safety and Health Act by the petitioner. The Petitioner has also raised matters falling within the statutory mandate of the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services. Where Parliament has established a specific statutory mechanism for the investigation and determination of a particular complaint, a party ought, in the first instance, to invoke that mechanism before approaching the Court, unless a recognized exception to the exhaustion requirement is demonstrated. The matters pleaded by the Petitioner which fall within the statutory mandate of the Director of Occupational Safety and Health Services therefore ought first to be addressed through the mechanism provided under the Occupational Safety and Health Act. The Petitioner has not demonstrated that the statutory process has been invoked and exhausted, nor has any basis been shown for bypassing that mechanism and approaching this Honourable Court in the first instance. To that extent, the Court is invited to find that the particular claims falling within the statutory mandate of the Director are premature and cannot properly be entertained before the prescribed statutory process has been exhausted.

The Petitioner’s submission on the notice of preliminary objection

15. The petitioner submitted that it is trite law that a Preliminary Objection must raise a pure point of law, be argued on the assumption that the facts pleaded by the opposing party are correct, and must not require the ascertainment of disputed facts or the exercise of judicial discretion. This position was firmly established in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969) EA 696, and reaffirmed by the Court of Appeal in Jack Kaguu Githae v James Mugo Kinga &9 Others [2019) КЕСА 87 (KLR) where the court relied on the Locus Classicus case of and had this to say:

"So far as I am aware, a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded, or which arises by clear implication out of the pleading, and which is argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit. Examples are an objection to the jurisdiction of the Court, or plea of limitation, or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the dispute to arbitration. Sir Charles NewBold, P. On the other hand, at age 701 had this to say: "A preliminary objection is the nature of what used to be a demurrer. II raises a pure point of law which is argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct. Il cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion."

16. The petitioner submitted that the Respondents' Preliminary Objection does not satisfy that threshold (Mukisa Biscuits case). The issues raised cannot be determined merely as matters of law without interrogating the facts and circumstances surrounding the alleged violation of the Petitioner 's constitutional rights. Such matters necessarily require evidentiary interrogation and cannot properly be determined through a Preliminary Objection. The Respondents cannot therefore employ a Preliminary Objection as a procedural shortcut to summarily terminate the Petitioner’s Claim where the matters raised require the Court to examine contested facts and determine the substantive constitutional violations complained of. The Preliminary Objection is consequently misconceived and ought to be dismissed with costs

17. On whether the 2nd respondent to the 6th respondent should bе struck out of the suit for want of being proper parties, the petitioner submitted as follows:- The violations meted out to Vivian, the Petitioner herein, were committed by the named individuals in their personal capacity. Their involvement has been particularized and is not denied. There are strong factual allegations that have been pleaded, and the respondents have not denied any factual analysis. There is no denial that they were senior employees of the company.

18. The petitioner further submitted that the respondents have not denied that –

a) they occupy the positions as stated by the petitioner ;

b) they committed the auctions complained of; and

c) that they were doing all that on behalf of the company.

19. The petitioner further submitted that the facts herewith pleaded and the prayers that are hereby sought in the Claim by the petitioner can only be answered by way of hearing and adducing evidence. That this Honourable Court was faced with the same issue to strike out the respondents in the preliminary stage while sitting in Kisumu in the case of Nesser v Globology Limited 7 others (Cause E033 of 2024) (2024) KEELRC 13551 (KLR) (19 December 2024) (Ruling), the court declined such invitation and held that-

"The Court is hesitant to ascertain issues such as the liability of the 2nd to 8th Respondents at an interlocutory stage. The averments in relation to the alleged involvement of the 6th to 8th Respondents in an alleged conspiracy to deny the claimant employee benefits is a matter that cannot be determined in limine. I as such decline to strike out the 6th to 8th Respondents as there has to be an interrogation of facts to ascertain whether they are culpable or not. Should the Court find, after trial, that there was no necessity in joining them, the Court would be able to mulct(sic) the Petitioner in costs for the misadventure. The same to the 2nd to 5th Respondents.’

20. The petitioner submitted that the Respondents cannot hide behind the corporate veil as a shield against justice where the corporate structure is being invoked to defeat or conceal violations of the Petitioner's constitutional rights. The separate legal personality of a company is not a licence to perpetrate injustice or evade accountability.

21. The petitioner further submitted on whether the claim raises occupational safety and health matters- The claim is for unlawful termination. The prayers sought are in the nature of Constitutional violations, and compensation for breach of constitutional rights. That there is nothing in totality that raises a claim under the Occupational Safety and Health Act.

22. The petitioner sought for the preliminary objection to be dismissed with cost; this Honourable Court be pleased to enter a Default Judgment for lack of defence; this Honourable Court be pleased to grant any other remedy as it deems fit.

Decision

23. At the heart of any determination is the question of jurisdiction. In employment cases, liability for performance of the contract lies with both the employee and the employer. The claim for breach of contract and termination can only lie against the parties to the employment contract, applying the doctrine of privity. The 2nd to 6th respondents were co-employees, and albeit bosses to the petitioner. They gave instructions pursuant to mandates of their employment contracts of which the petitioner was not privy. I am persuaded that the 2nd to 6th respondents are not the respondents envisaged under section 86 of the Employment Act-

‘86. Complaint and jurisdiction in cases of dispute between employers and employees-

(1)Subject to the provisions of this Act whenever—

(a)an employer or employee neglects or refuses to fulfill a contract of service; or

(b)any question, difference or dispute arises as to the rights or liabilities of either party; or

(c)touching any misconduct, neglect or ill treatment of either party or any injury to the person or property of either party, under any contract of service, the aggrieved party may complain to the labour officer or lodge a complaint or suit in the Employment and Labour Relations Court.

(2)No court other than the Employment and Labour Relations Court shall determine any complaint or suit referred to in subsection (1).

(3)This section shall not apply in a suit where the dispute over a contract of service or any other matter referred to in subsection (1) is similar or secondary to the main issue in dispute.’

24. The court has no jurisdiction to order any relief against the 2nd to 6th respondents as they are not employers of the petitioner applying the above section 86 of the Employment Act. I was persuaded by the decision relied on by the 2nd to 6th respondents, in Benard Ochieng Oduor v Trade Winds Aviation Services Limited & another [2020] KEELRC 152 (KLR)where the Court found that the Employment Act imposes specific obligations upon an employer and that there is no basis for joining a third party against whom no employment relationship exists. Respondents 2 to 6 can only be witnesses in the dispute.

25. On the issue of lack of exhaustion on WIBA cases- I find the preliminary objection on this issue did not meet the threshold of a preliminary objection.(Mukisa Biscuits case) There is no direct orders sought by the petitioner related to work injury. I rely on Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969) EA 696, reaffirmed by the Court of Appeal in Jack Kaguu Githae v James Mugo Kinga &9 Others [2019 КЕСА 87 (KLR) Where the court had this to say on preliminary objection:

"So far as I am aware, a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded, or which arises by clear implication out of the pleading, and which is argued as a preliminary point may dispose of the suit. Examples are an objection to the jurisdiction of the Court, or plea of limitation, or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the dispute to arbitration."

Sir Charles NewBold, P. On the other hand, at age 701 had this to say: "A preliminary objection is the nature of what used to be a demurrer. II raises a pure point of law which is argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct. Il cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained or if what is sought is the exercise of judicial discretion."

26. The preliminary objection is only upheld as it relates to joinder of the 2nd to 6th respondents. The court is pleased to strike out the 2nd to the 6th respondents from the petition.

27. The preliminary objection was not fully successful. Each party to bear its own costs in the preliminary objection.

28. Mention on 30th October 2026 for directions on the petition.

29. It is so Ordered

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Petitioner - Ndirangu h/b Kathili

Respondents- absent

interested parties absent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder