Small Claims

Progressive Credit Ltd v Wanjala & another [2026] SCC 212 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Eldoret
Case number
SCCCOMM/E2841/2025
Judgment date
14 August 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Notice of Motion was allowed on instalment terms: the applicants must pay Kshs.70,000 within 14 days, then Kshs.30,000 monthly from September 2026 until the decretal sum is paid in full. Execution may issue on default. No order as to costs was made, and the parties were granted leave to appeal.

Supporting judgment passages

12. I therefore find the application meritorious to the extent stated below. Consequently, the Notice of Motion dated 1st July, 2026 is allowed on the following terms:

Paragraph 12 →

b. The balance thereof shall be paid by monthly instalments of Kshs.30,000/= until payment in full commencing in the month of September 2026.

Passage 19 →

d. no orders as to costs

Passage 21 →
Issue 1Whether the applicants had demonstrated sufficient cause for the court to exercise its discretion under Rule 27 of the Small Claims Court Rules to permit payment of the decretal sum by instalments, and on what terms.

Held. Decided in the applicants’ favour to a limited extent. Their evidence did not establish inability to pay a substantial amount to the fullest extent claimed because of discrepancies in their financial disclosure, but it sufficiently justified instalment payment. The court fixed the balance at Kshs.30,000 monthly from September 2026 and directed that execution issue upon default; the initial payment was separately fixed at Kshs.70,000 within 14 days.

Ratio. Where a decree-holder rejects a proposed instalment arrangement, the court may order payment in a lump sum or instalments on just terms. The debtor bears the burden of supplying sufficient evidence of inability to satisfy the decree in a lump sum, assessed by reference to income, assets and liabilities. In setting terms, the court must balance the debtor’s demonstrated financial circumstances with the decree-holder’s entitlement to expeditious enjoyment of the judgment.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

9. The Court is therefore not persuaded that the Applicants have demonstrated, to the fullest extent alleged, an inability to pay any substantial amount towards the decree. Nevertheless, the existence of the identified discrepancies does not, in my view, entirely displace the evidence placed before the Court regarding the Applicants' income, family obligations and general financial circumstances. I am accordingly satisfied that the Applicants have demonstrated sufficient cause for the Court to exercise its discretion under Rule 27 of the Small Claims Court Rules and permit the decretal sum to be paid by instalments.

Paragraph 9 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

a. The Applicants shall pay an initial sum of Kshs.70,000/= towards the decretal sum within fourteen (14) days from the date of this ruling.

Passage 18 →

c. In the event of default, execution to issue.

Passage 20 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

6. This is a concluded matter, judgment having been delivered on 5th June, 2026. To date the said judgment is yet to be satisfied by the applicants herein. The truth is, the claimant herein has been denied the opportunity of enjoying the fruits of the judgment delivered. From the applicant's averment he admits that they are yet to satisfy the judgment that is why he is before this court seeking to have the decree satisfied by way of instalment. Section 36(1) a of the small claims court act expressly provides that the Small Claims Court may make an order requiring payment of money “either in lump sum or by instalments. Rule 27(1) of the Small Claims Rules provides that where the decree-holder rejects the debtor's proposal to pay by instalments, the Court may, upon an oral or written application by the debtor, hear the competing proposals and, if satisfied by evidence that the debtor is unable to satisfy the decree in lump sum, order payment according to the debtor's proposed schedule; according to the creditor's proposed schedule;

Paragraph 6 →

or by instalments on such terms as the Court considers just. Importantly, Rule 27(2) directs the Court, in determining such an application, to consider, among other things the debtor's net monthly income; the aggregate value of the debtor's assets and liabilities; and assets disposed of by the debtor in circumstances suggesting an intention to defeat the creditor. In determining such an application, the Court is required to consider, among other matters, the debtor's net monthly income and the aggregate value of the debtor's assets and liabilities.

Paragraph 6 →

11. Equally, I have considered the Respondent's proposal for payment of an initial sum of Kshs.100,000/= followed by monthly instalments of Kshs.40,000/=. While the proposal is reasonable from the perspective of the decree-holder, the Court must also take into account the Applicants' demonstrated financial circumstances. Balancing the interests of both parties and exercising the discretion conferred upon the Court under Rule 27, I find that a monthly instalment of Kshs.30,000/= is just and reasonable in the circumstances. It is an amount which is higher than that proposed by the Applicants, thereby ensuring expeditious settlement of the decree, but lower than the amount proposed by the Respondent, thereby affording the Applicants reasonable accommodation in light of their financial circumstances.

Paragraph 11 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The ruling herein is in respect to the Notice of motion dated1st July, 2026. which was filed under certificate of urgency. The application is supported with grounds therein and supporting affidavit sworn by James Oduori Pamba. The major grounds being that this Honourable court delivered judgement ordering the respondents to pay ksh 293,162.84/- while allowing the counterclaim/ set off of ksh 48,000/- resulting a decretal balance to ksh…

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Equally, I have considered the Respondent's proposal for payment of an initial sum of Kshs.100,000/= followed by monthly instalments of Kshs.40,000/=. While the proposal is reasonable from the perspective of the decree-holder, the Court must also take into account the Applicants' demonstrated financial circumstances. Balancing the interests of both parties and exercising the discretion conferred upon the Court under Rule 27, I find…

Paragraph 11 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the applicants had shown sufficient cause, under the Small Claims Court Act and Rules, to satisfy the unsatisfied decretal balance by instalments; and, if so, the appropriate initial payment and monthly instalments.

Material facts

Following a judgment delivered on 5 June 2026, the applicants owed a decretal balance of Kshs.245,162.84 after a Kshs.293,162.84 award and a Kshs.48,000 set-off/counterclaim. James Oduori Pamba stated that his cyber business near the former Moi University…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT UASIN GISHU COUNTY COURT NAME: ELDORET SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E2841/2025

PROGRESSIVE CREDIT LIMITED VS SERAPHINE NAFULA WANJALA AND JAMES ODUORI PAMBA

RULING

1. The ruling herein is in respect to the Notice of motion dated1st July, 2026. which was filed under certificate of urgency. The application is supported with grounds therein and supporting affidavit sworn by James Oduori Pamba. The major grounds being that this Honourable court delivered judgement ordering the respondents to pay ksh 293,162.84/- while allowing the counterclaim/ set off of ksh 48,000/- resulting a decretal balance to ksh 245,162.84/-.

2. The 1st respondent averred that he operates a cyber business at the gate of former Moi University West campus making an average daily income of ksh 2,000/-. He further averred that when the university closed in 2024 indefinitely it greatly affected his business. That his wife the 2nd applicant works at a cyber where she is paid ksh 10,000/-. He poses that he is a family man with 5 children who fully depend on him and the eldest is a student at Kenyatta University. It is his evidence on oath that he is currently facilitating another loan of ksh 300,000/- with Equity Bank Kenya Limited and that the affidavit of means filed sets out his income, assets liabilities and family financial obligations which demonstrated his current financial position.

3. The application was opposed by a replying affidavit sworn on 27th July, 2026 by one Mr. Guto Ochoki who deponed that the applicants are indebted to the claimant's company in the sum of ksh 245,162.8/-4 which they have failed, neglected and or refused to settle within reasonable time. That the applicants’ application to pay in instalments is made in bad faith and is merely intended to delay and frustrate the execution of the lawful judgment. He deposes that the evidence placed before this court is insufficient and incredible incapable of demonstrating their alleged inability to settle the decretal sum as the same is marred with inconsistencies. Further, it is deponed that the copies of business daily sales and records of the applicant for the month of June contain a deliberate miscalculation for 29th June 2026 where the daily amount should be ksh 20,050/- but indicated as 2,050/-. That it is suspicious that the applicant pays their employee an average of ksh 500 per day which averages at ksh 13,000-15,000/- while the wife claims to be paid ksh 10,000/- per month.

4. The deponent avers that the affidavit of means has clear irregularities such that the business rent for the month of May is under receipt number 548 while the one for June is receipt number 546. That the applicant has failed to demonstrate that he is financially constrained. The respondent prays for the applicant to be compelled to pay an initial amount of ksh 100,000/- with the balance being paid in monthly instalment of ksh 40,000/- until payment in full and in default execution to issue. The respondent stated on oath that the loan amount, the subject of this suit was disbursed to the applicant in April, 2024 and the last payment made by the claimant was in August, 2025 and therefore the amount of time that hsa duly passed justifies the respondent asking for ksh 100,000/-. He deponed further that the respondent's proposal of payment of Monthly Installments of Kshs. 40,000/= is well below the initial installment amount agreed upon between the respondent and the Applicants which was Kshs. 53,340/= and thus reasonably considerate. That the Applicants have further failed to demonstrate that the proposed monthly instalment of Kshs. 20,000/= is reasonable and capable of settling the decretal sum within a reasonable period.

5. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions. From the application, replying affidavit and the trivial submissions, the issue for determination is: whether the applicant is meritorious?

6. This is a concluded matter, judgment having been delivered on 5th June, 2026. To date the said judgment is yet to be satisfied by the applicants herein. The truth is, the claimant herein has been denied the opportunity of enjoying the fruits of the judgment delivered. From the applicant's averment he admits that they are yet to satisfy the judgment that is why he is before this court seeking to have the decree satisfied by way of instalment. Section 36(1) a of the small claims court act expressly provides that the Small Claims Court may make an order requiring payment of money “either in lump sum or by instalments. Rule 27(1) of the Small Claims Rules provides that where the decree-holder rejects the debtor's proposal to pay by instalments, the Court may, upon an oral or written application by the debtor, hear the competing proposals and, if satisfied by evidence that the debtor is unable to satisfy the decree in lump sum, order payment according to the debtor's proposed schedule; according to the creditor's proposed schedule; or by instalments on such terms as the Court considers just. Importantly, Rule 27(2) directs the Court, in determining such an application, to consider, among other things the debtor's net monthly income; the aggregate value of the debtor's assets and liabilities; and assets disposed of by the debtor in circumstances suggesting an intention to defeat the creditor. In determining such an application, the Court is required to consider, among other matters, the debtor's net monthly income and the aggregate value of the debtor's assets and liabilities.

7. The burden therefore rests upon the Applicants to place before the Court sufficient evidence demonstrating their inability to satisfy the decretal sum in lump sum. In this case, the Applicants have placed before the Court an affidavit of means setting out their income, assets, liabilities and family obligations. The 1st Applicant has also explained that his cyber business has been adversely affected by the closure of the former Moi University West Campus and that he has five children who depend on him. He has further disclosed that the 2nd Applicant earns approximately Kshs.10,000/= per month.

8. I have, however, carefully considered the Respondent's challenge to the Applicants' evidence. The Respondent has pointed out discrepancies in the Applicants' business records, including the alleged erroneous entry for 29th June, 2026, inconsistencies concerning the amounts paid to an employee and discrepancies in the receipts relied upon in respect of business rent. These matters raise legitimate questions regarding the accuracy and completeness of the Applicants' disclosure of their financial position.

9. The Court is therefore not persuaded that the Applicants have demonstrated, to the fullest extent alleged, an inability to pay any substantial amount towards the decree. Nevertheless, the existence of the identified discrepancies does not, in my view, entirely displace the evidence placed before the Court regarding the Applicants' income, family obligations and general financial circumstances. I am accordingly satisfied that the Applicants have demonstrated sufficient cause for the Court to exercise its discretion under Rule 27 of the Small Claims Court Rules and permit the decretal sum to be paid by instalments.

10. However, the Applicants' proposed monthly instalment of Kshs.20,000/= would, in the circumstances of this case, result in the decree being settled over an unduly prolonged period and would not sufficiently take into account the Respondent's legitimate right to enjoy the fruits of the judgment.

11. Equally, I have considered the Respondent's proposal for payment of an initial sum of Kshs.100,000/= followed by monthly instalments of Kshs.40,000/=. While the proposal is reasonable from the perspective of the decree-holder, the Court must also take into account the Applicants' demonstrated financial circumstances. Balancing the interests of both parties and exercising the discretion conferred upon the Court under Rule 27, I find that a monthly instalment of Kshs.30,000/= is just and reasonable in the circumstances. It is an amount which is higher than that proposed by the Applicants, thereby ensuring expeditious settlement of the decree, but lower than the amount proposed by the Respondent, thereby affording the Applicants reasonable accommodation in light of their financial circumstances.

12. I therefore find the application meritorious to the extent stated below. Consequently, the Notice of Motion dated 1st July, 2026 is allowed on the following terms:

a. The Applicants shall pay an initial sum of Kshs.70,000/= towards the decretal sum within fourteen (14) days from the date of this ruling.

b. The balance thereof shall be paid by monthly instalments of Kshs.30,000/= until payment in full commencing in the month of September 2026.

c. In the event of default, execution to issue.

d. no orders as to costs

Parties are granted leave to appeal

Ruling dated and delivered at Eldoret this 14th August 2026.

M.E Aligula-RM

In the presence of C/A Mr. Lepatoiye

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder