Small Claims

Oyuchi v Magut [2026] SCC 209 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Small Claims Court at Eldoret
Case number
SCCCOMM/E731/2026
Judgment date
14 August 2026

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment for the Claimant limited to Kshs.150,000, the admitted outstanding amount. The Kshs.400,000 claim was otherwise dismissed, including the contractual double-refund claim, and the Kshs.200,000 expected-profits claim was dismissed for want of proof. The Claimant received costs of Kshs.32,000 and interest of the suit; execution was stayed for 30 days.

Supporting judgment passages

a. Kshs.150,000/- being the admitted outstanding amount;

Passage 24 →

b. The claim for Kshs.400,000/- is otherwise dismissed;

Passage 25 →

d. The claimant shall have costs of ksh 32,000/- and interest of the suit

Passage 27 →
Issue 1whether the Claimant has proved her claim.

Held. Partly proved. The Claimant could recover Kshs.150,000 because the Respondent admitted that amount remained due, corroborated by the Kshs.50,000 refund shown in the M-Pesa evidence. But the Court could not determine which party breached the agreements, so the double-refund contractual consequence and the wider Kshs.400,000 claim were not established. The Kshs.200,000 expected-profits claim also failed because there was no cogent evidence of the profits, their calculation, or causation.

Ratio. A claimant bears the burden of proving the claim on a balance of probabilities. A contractual double-refund clause may only be invoked on proof that the opposing party committed the relevant breach. Expected profits require cogent evidence of the alleged profits, their computation, and their loss as a consequence of breach. An amount expressly admitted to be outstanding is recoverable.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

a. whether the Claimant has proved her claim.

Passage 12 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

11. I have also considered the fact that the Respondent did not file a counterclaim seeking any relief arising from his allegation that the Claimant was the party in breach. This is in respect to the agreement dated 4th September, 2025. More importantly, the Respondent expressly admits that Kshs.150,000/- remains outstanding. The M-Pesa statement corroborates the payment of Kshs.50,000/- to the Claimant. In the circumstances, the admitted outstanding amount is recoverable by the Claimant.

Paragraph 11 →

13. As regards the claim for loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/-, no documentary or other cogent evidence was tendered to demonstrate the alleged profits, the basis upon which the amount was computed, or that such profits were actually lost as a consequence of the Respondent’s breach. The claim is therefore not proved and must fail.Consequently, I find that the Claimant has proved his claim only to the extent of the admitted outstanding sum of Kshs.150,000/-.

Paragraph 13 →

c. The claim for loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/- is dismissed for want of proof.

Passage 26 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

6. The burden of proof rests upon the Claimant to establish his claim on a balance of probabilities. The Claimant relies on the lease agreements dated 4th September 2025 and 31st October 2025 and M-pesa statements. Both agreements were executed by the parties and acknowledge payment of Kshs.100,000/- in respect of each transaction. The fact of payment is not disputed. What is principally disputed is the party responsible for the alleged breach and the extent of the Claimant’s entitlement arising therefrom.

Paragraph 6 →

10. Equally, the Respondent did not produce sufficient evidence to substantiate his assertion that it was the Claimant who breached the agreements by requesting a refund. Although he alleges that the Claimant sought a refund, the fact remains that the Respondent admits having refunded Kshs.50,000/- and further admits that Kshs.150,000/- remains due and payable to the Claimant. The Court therefore cannot, on the evidence before it, make a definitive finding as to which party was responsible for the breach so as to invoke the contractual provision requiring payment of double the amount paid.

Paragraph 10 →

13. As regards the claim for loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/-, no documentary or other cogent evidence was tendered to demonstrate the alleged profits, the basis upon which the amount was computed, or that such profits were actually lost as a consequence of the Respondent’s breach. The claim is therefore not proved and must fail.Consequently, I find that the Claimant has proved his claim only to the extent of the admitted outstanding sum of Kshs.150,000/-.

Paragraph 13 →
Issue 2Who should bear the costs of the claim?

Held. The Respondent was ordered to pay the Claimant's costs, assessed at Kshs.32,000, because the Respondent admitted owing Kshs.150,000 and the Claimant was compelled to bring proceedings to recover it.

Ratio. Where a respondent admits an amount due but does not pay it, necessitating proceedings for recovery, the claimant is entitled to the costs of the claim.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

b. Who should bear the costs of the claim?

Passage 13 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

14. On the issue of costs, the Respondent admits owing the Claimant Kshs.150,000/-. The Claimant was therefore compelled to institute these proceedings to recover the amount due. I accordingly find that the Claimant is entitled to the costs of the claim.

Paragraph 14 →

d. The claimant shall have costs of ksh 32,000/- and interest of the suit

Passage 27 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

14. On the issue of costs, the Respondent admits owing the Claimant Kshs.150,000/-. The Claimant was therefore compelled to institute these proceedings to recover the amount due. I accordingly find that the Claimant is entitled to the costs of the claim.

Paragraph 14 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Claimant instituted this claim seeking judgment against the Respondent for Kshs.400,000/-, compensation, costs of the claim and loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/-. The Claimant’s case is that on or about 4th September 2025, he entered into a land lease agreement with the Respondent for one acre of land at a consideration of Kshs.100,000/-. The Claimant was to plant sugarcane on the land and harvest the crop three…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

On the issue of costs, the Respondent admits owing the Claimant Kshs.150,000/-. The Claimant was therefore compelled to institute these proceedings to recover the amount due. I accordingly find that the Claimant is entitled to the costs of the claim.

Paragraph 14 →

Reasoning passage

As regards the claim for loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/-, no documentary or other cogent evidence was tendered to demonstrate the alleged profits, the basis upon which the amount was computed, or that such profits were actually lost as a consequence of the Respondent’s breach. The claim is therefore not proved and must fail.Consequently, I find that the Claimant has proved his claim only to the extent of the…

Paragraph 13 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Claimant proved entitlement to Kshs.400,000 under the parties’ lease agreements, including the contractual double-refund provisions; whether loss of expected profits of Kshs.200,000 was proved; and who should bear costs.

Material facts

Shadrack Mamba Oyuchi alleged that he leased one acre from Rajab Kipkosgei Magut for sugarcane cultivation under agreements dated 4 September 2025 and 31 October 2025, each for Kshs.100,000. The Claimant paid Kshs.200,000 in total. He alleged that, when…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE SMALL CLAIMS COURT OF KENYA AT UASIN GISHU COUNTY COURT NAME: ELDORET SMALL CLAIMS COURT

CASE NUMBER: SCCCOMM/E731/2026

SHADRACK MAMBA OYUCHI VS RAJAB KIPKOSGEI MAGUT

JUDGMENT

1. The Claimant instituted this claim seeking judgment against the Respondent for Kshs.400,000/-, compensation, costs of the claim and loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/-. The Claimant’s case is that on or about 4th September 2025, he entered into a land lease agreement with the Respondent for one acre of land at a consideration of Kshs.100,000/-. The Claimant was to plant sugarcane on the land and harvest the crop three times. She paid Kshs.70,000/- and subsequently cleared the balance of Kshs.30,000/- on 23rd October 2025.

2. The parties subsequently entered into another agreement dated 31st October 2025 at a consideration of Kshs.100,000/- for the lease of land for purposes of planting sugarcane. It was agreed that land preparation and planting would take place in April 2026 and that in the event of a breach, the defaulting party would refund double the amount paid.

3. The Claimant states that when he went to prepare the land for planting, she found another person on the parcel claiming to have leased the same land from the Respondent. He thereafter approached the Respondent, who promised to refund the monies paid, but failed to do so.

4. In his Response dated 16th July 2026, the Respondent denied breaching the agreement and averred that it was the Claimant who breached the agreement by requesting a refund of all the monies paid under the two agreements. The Respondent, however, admitted that he refunded Kshs.50,000/- to the Claimant and that a balance of Kshs.150,000/- remained outstanding. He did not dispute the Claimant’s entitlement to recovery of the said balance and reaffirmed his commitment to settling the same.

5. The parties took directions on 20th July 2026 to dispose of the matter under Section 30 of the Small Claims Court Act. Consequently, the Court is bound to determine the matter on the basis of the pleadings and documents filed by the parties.

The issues for determination are:

a. whether the Claimant has proved her claim.

b. Who should bear the costs of the claim?

6. The burden of proof rests upon the Claimant to establish his claim on a balance of probabilities. The Claimant relies on the lease agreements dated 4th September 2025 and 31st October 2025 and M-pesa statements. Both agreements were executed by the parties and acknowledge payment of Kshs.100,000/- in respect of each transaction. The fact of payment is not disputed. What is principally disputed is the party responsible for the alleged breach and the extent of the Claimant’s entitlement arising therefrom.

7. The Claimant’s position is that when he went to prepare the land for planting, she found another person on the land who claimed to have leased the same parcel from the Respondent. According to the Claimant, he thereafter approached the Respondent, who undertook to refund the monies paid.

8. The Respondent, on the other hand, maintains that it was the Claimant who breached their agreement and sought for a refund of the monies paid. The Respondent relies on the M-Pesa statement demonstrating that Kshs.50,000/- was refunded to the Claimant. He further admits that Kshs.150,000/- remains outstanding.

9. I have considered the agreements produced by the Claimant. The agreement dated 4th September 2025 contains a clause providing that in the event of breach, the defaulting party would pay double the amount paid. In the agreement dated 31st October 2025, it is the leaser who is to refund double the amount incurred in the event of a default. Parties therefore expressly provided for the consequences of breach. However, the evidence before the Court is insufficient to conclusively establish, on a balance of probabilities, which party breached the agreements. The Claimant did not place before the Court independent evidence, such as testimony from a person who witnessed the alleged occupation of the land by the third party, correspondence between the parties concerning the alleged breach, or any other communication demonstrating that the Respondent had leased the same parcel to another person.

10. Equally, the Respondent did not produce sufficient evidence to substantiate his assertion that it was the Claimant who breached the agreements by requesting a refund. Although he alleges that the Claimant sought a refund, the fact remains that the Respondent admits having refunded Kshs.50,000/- and further admits that Kshs.150,000/- remains due and payable to the Claimant. The Court therefore cannot, on the evidence before it, make a definitive finding as to which party was responsible for the breach so as to invoke the contractual provision requiring payment of double the amount paid.

11. I have also considered the fact that the Respondent did not file a counterclaim seeking any relief arising from his allegation that the Claimant was the party in breach. This is in respect to the agreement dated 4th September, 2025. More importantly, the Respondent expressly admits that Kshs.150,000/- remains outstanding. The M-Pesa statement corroborates the payment of Kshs.50,000/- to the Claimant. In the circumstances, the admitted outstanding amount is recoverable by the Claimant.

12. The Claimant, however, has not proved his entitlement to the sum of Kshs.400,000/-. In particular, the contractual double-refund clause can only be invoked upon proof of breach by the party against whom the contractual consequence is sought. That burden has not been discharged in the present case.

13. As regards the claim for loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/-, no documentary or other cogent evidence was tendered to demonstrate the alleged profits, the basis upon which the amount was computed, or that such profits were actually lost as a consequence of the Respondent’s breach. The claim is therefore not proved and must fail.Consequently, I find that the Claimant has proved his claim only to the extent of the admitted outstanding sum of Kshs.150,000/-.

14. On the issue of costs, the Respondent admits owing the Claimant Kshs.150,000/-. The Claimant was therefore compelled to institute these proceedings to recover the amount due. I accordingly find that the Claimant is entitled to the costs of the claim.

15. In the result, judgment is hereby entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent as follows:

a. Kshs.150,000/- being the admitted outstanding amount;

b. The claim for Kshs.400,000/- is otherwise dismissed;

c. The claim for loss of expected profits in the sum of Kshs.200,000/- is dismissed for want of proof.

d. The claimant shall have costs of ksh 32,000/- and interest of the suit

Stay of 30 days is granted.

Judgement signed and delivered at Eldoret this 14st day August of 2026

ME Aligula RM

In the presence of: C/A Mr. Lepatoiye

Claimant:

Respondent:

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder