Employment law

Karimbux v Oduor [2026] KEELRC 2815 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Appeal E130 of 2025
Judgment date
13 October 2026
Judge(s)
D. K. Njagi Marete

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Learned Trial Magistrate erred in holding that the Appellant had proved her case to the required standard without giving the basis for such a finding.

Paragraph 1 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC APPEAL NO. E130 OF 2025

(Before D. K. N. Marete)

SAADIA KARIMBUX …………………………………………………………… APPELLANT

VERSUS

CAROLINE AKINYI ODUOR ……………………………………..………… RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

This matter was originated by way of a Memorandum of Appeal dated 12th April, 2025. It arises from a judgment delivered on 12th March, 2025 in MCELRC No. E046 of 2023 which the trial court found that the Respondent's termination from employment by the Appellant was unfair and awarded her one month's salary in lieu of notice, compensation for unfair termination, service pay and overtime, together with costs and interest and directed that a certificate of service do issue.

Aggrieved, the Appellant filed the present appeal, which comes out on the following grounds;

1. The Learned Trial Magistrate erred in holding that the Appellant had proved her case to the required standard without giving the basis for such a finding.

2. The Learned Trial Magistrate erred in Law in failing to appreciate the Law and evaluate the pleadings and evidence before him and consequently arrived at wrong conclusions.

3. The Learned Trial Magistrate erred in Law and in fact in failing to acknowledge that the Appellant had lawfully and procedurally terminated the Respondent's services as required by law.

4. The Learned Trial Magistrate failed to consider that the evidence adduced by the Respondent was at variance with her pleadings as filed and not reliable.

5. The Learned Honourable Magistrate erred in law and in fact in failing to attach any weight whatsoever to the evidence of the Appellant leading to the dismissal of the suit.

6. The Trial Magistrate failed to provide a basis/rationale for the award of overtime and failed to provide a breakdown of the amount awarded.

7. The Trial Magistrate unfairly and in a biased manner adopted the Plaintiff's computation of the overtime figures without any basis whatsoever.

The Appellant prays for orders thus;

a) This Appeal be allowed.

b) The Judgment in MCELRC No. E046 of 2023 delivered on the 12th of March, 2025 be set aside and the same be substituted with an Order allowing the Appellant's claim against the Respondent with costs to the Appellant.

c) Costs of the Appeal be awarded to the Appellant.

It is the Appellant's case and submission that the Respondent was engaged by her as a cleaner on part-time and full-time basis from 11th July, 2019 and not from May, 2018 as the Respondent has pleaded and testified, at a consolidated salary of Kshs. 18,000.00 inclusive of house allowance.

The Appellant's further case is that the Respondent was neglectful of her duties and was late for work on various occasions, for which she received warning letters dated 25th February, 2022 and 31st May, 2022 both touching on her sleeping while on duty as a night nurse aid, and that she was found in possession of a patient's towel on or about 18th September, 2022 leading to her summary dismissal by letter dated 29th September, 2022 which she declined to sign. The Appellant maintains that she was paid all her lawful dues and that the termination was both substantively and procedurally fair.

The Appellant's witness, testifying as RW1 before the trial court, admitted in cross-examination that no disciplinary hearing was held before the Respondent's employment was brought to an end on 30th September, 2022, the Respondent having only been orally invited to a meeting.

On the specific award for overtime, the Appellant submits that the sum of Kshs. 410,197.28 awarded by the trial court was made without any reasoned basis and by simply adopting the Respondent's computation wholesale, without regard to the pay record books for 2019 and 2020 which the Appellant produced and which are said to show that the Respondent was engaged on a casual basis with a weekly rest day during that period, contrary to the premise of continuous, uninterrupted daily work underlying the Respondent's computation.

The Respondent did not file written submissions in response to the appeal. Her case, as it appears from the record of the trial proceedings, is that she was engaged by the Appellant as a cleaner in or about May, 2018 at a monthly salary of Kshs. 12,000.00, later increased to Kshs. 17,000.00 and upon her promotion to the position of night nurse aid on 1st August, 2021 to Kshs. 18,000.00, in each case exclusive of house allowance. She served the Appellant diligently until 30th September, 2022 when her employment was terminated without any disciplinary process, notice to show cause or hearing. She denied the allegation of theft levelled against her and testified that she did not understand the contents of the letter she was asked to sign. She further testified that she worked extended hours during the day and night shifts without overtime compensation, that she did not go on annual leave for the greater part of her employment, and that she was not enrolled in any pension scheme.

After a considered look and scrutiny of the Memorandum of Appeal, the Record of Appeal and the submissions of the parties the issues for determination become;

1. Whether the trial court erred in finding that the Respondent’s termination from employment was unfair.

2. Whether the trial court erred in the award of overtime to the Respondent.

The 1st issue for determination is whether the trial court erred in finding that the Respondent’s termination from employment was unfair. Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007 requires that, before terminating an employee's employment on the grounds of misconduct, an employer must explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reasons why termination is being considered and afford the employee an opportunity to be heard, if she wishes with a representative of her choice. In the authority of Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that four elements must be discernible for the procedure to pass muster: an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee; the reason for which the employer is considering termination; the employee's entitlement to the presence of another employee of her choice when that explanation is made and the hearing and consideration of any representations made by the employee. This was applied at the trial in Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Co. Ltd [2013] eKLR, where the court held that the ingredients of procedural fairness reduce, in essence, to an information component, a hearing component and a consideration component and that the burden of demonstrating compliance rests squarely on the employer.

The Appellant's witness, RW1, admitted in cross-examination that no disciplinary process was followed before the Respondent's employment was ended on 30th September 2022. Section 47(5) of the Employment Act, 2007 places on an employer the burden of proving both substantive reason and procedural fairness. The trial court's finding that the termination was unfair is, in these circumstances, appropriate and therefore affirmed. Grounds 1 to 5 of the appeal fail. In this regard, the finding that the Respondent's termination was unfair stands, together with the consequential awards of one month's notice pay of Kshs. 18,000.00, compensation for unfair termination equivalent to two months' salary of Kshs. 36,000.00, and service pay of Kshs. 41,538.60, none of which is the subject of any distinct ground of appeal.

Grounds 3, 4 and 5 do not assist the Appellant. Ground 3 falls away for the same reason: on the Appellant's own account, the Respondent was not afforded a disciplinary hearing before the decision to dismiss her was taken and whatever view is taken of the warning letters or the allegation touching on the patient's towel, those matters go, at their best, to whether there was a valid reason to terminate and not to whether the Respondent was fairly heard beforehand. Ground 4 points to a minor inconsistency between the Respondent's pleaded case that her employment began in May, 2018 and her testimony in cross-examination that she began in August, 2018. This discrepancy of a few months does not render her evidence unreliable, particularly measured against the Appellant's own documentary record, which is itself inconsistent as to the same fact: the pay record books place the commencement of employment at 11th July, 2019 while the certificate of service produced by the Appellant records it as 16th January, 2020. Section 74 of the Employment Act, 2007 places the duty to maintain accurate employment records on the employer and the trial court cannot be faulted for declining to hold the Respondent's minor inconsistency against her where the Appellant's own records are, if anything, less consistent. Ground 5 complains that no weight was attached to the Appellant's evidence, but the trial court plainly considered that evidence and found it insufficient to discharge the burden section 47(5) of the Act places on the employer; that is a proper application of the burden of proof, not a failure to attach weight to the evidence.

The 2nd issue for determination is whether the trial court erred in the award of overtime to the Respondent. A claim for overtime, unlike a claim for notice pay or service pay which follow more or less mechanically from admitted facts, is in the nature of special damages and must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved. In Apex Steel Limited v Dominic Mutuamuendo [2020] KEELRC 567 (KLR), the court held that a party making a claim for special damages is under a duty to specifically plead the particulars of the claim and to adduce evidence to specifically prove the same, a duty which is not waived merely because the opposing party fails to tender evidence in defence. A like position was taken in Kenya National Private Security Workers Union v Watchdog Limited [2018] eKLR, where the court declined to uphold a claim for overtime for want of any tangible evidence that the employees concerned had worked beyond normal hours. The trial court's finding on overtime in the present matter is not supported by any reasoned basis or independent assessment of the evidence beyond the adoption of the Respondent's own computation. A trial court is, of course, entitled to prefer and adopt a party's submission where it is satisfied, on the evidence, that the submission is well founded, but the mere fact of the Respondent's testimony, without any corroboration, timesheets or other record capable of being independently assessed, and without any resolution of the dispute over whether her engagement was continuous or casual in its early years, is an insufficient basis for adopting the full claimed figure of Kshs. 410,197.28. The overtime award is set aside. Having set the award aside for want of a reasoned basis, this court does not substitute its own assessment, since the evidential material needed to do so reliably has not been placed before it.

On costs, and in the exercise of the discretion under Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act, Chapter 21, Laws of Kenya this matter becomes ripe for an award that each party bears its own costs of this appeal.

I am therefore inclined to partially allow the appeal and order as follows;

(i) The Judgment and Decree of the trial court delivered on 12th March, 2025 in MCELRC No. E046 of 2023 is varied to the extent set out in (ii) and (iii) below.

(ii) The Respondent is awarded and takes home the following:

a) One (1) month's notice pay ………………………………..…..…Kshs. 18,000.00

b) Two (2) months salary as compensation for unfair termination of employment …………………………………………………………………..……Kshs. 36,000.00

c) Service pay ………………………………………………..……...…Kshs. 41,538.60

Total of award………………………………………….……..…..…. Kshs. 95,538.60

d) Interest at court rates from the date of this judgment of court till payment in full.

(iii) The award of overtime of Kshs. 410,197.28 is set aside and the claim for overtime is dismissed.

(iv) The order for the issuance of a certificate of service to the Respondent, not being the subject of any ground of appeal, remains undisturbed.

(v) The costs of the suit in the trial court shall be borne by the Appellant, as ordered by the trial court.

(vi) Each party shall bear its own costs of this appeal.

Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.

D. K. Njagi Marete

JUDGE

Appearances:

1. Miss Okondo instructed by M/S. J.A. Guserwa & Company Advocates for the Appellant.

2. Miss Small instructed by M/S. Wanyonyi & Muhia Advocates for the Respondent.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder