IN THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS
ELRC PETITION NO. E015 OF 2026
FRANCIS MUSILI KAUTA……………………..………………………………………..….………………PETITIONER
-VERSUS
GOVERNOR,
KITUI COUNTY………………….…………………………………………………………….….…..1ST RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY SECRETARY-KITUI COUNTY ……………………………………………2ND RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARD-KITUI……………………………….……….3RD RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY OF KITUI…………………………………………………………4TH RESPONDENT
THE HON.ATTORNEY GENERAL……………………………………………….……………5TH RESPONDENT
Coram
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
RULING
1. The petitioner, a Kenyan citizen and a resident of Kitui County, aggrieved with the recruitment process by the respondents under advertisement dated 15th January 2026, invoked his right under the provisions of Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 and filed the instant petition dated 20th July 2026 in public interest seeking for the following relief-
a) A declaration that the Respondents' failure to publish the shortlist and status of the recruitment exercise commenced by advertisement of 15th January 2026 violates Articles 10, 27, 47 and 232 of the Constitution and the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015.
b) A conservatory order restraining the Respondents, whether by themselves, their agents, servants, or otherwise howsoever, from making, confirming, gazetting, or effecting any further appointments to the positions advertised on 15th January 2026, pending the hearing and final determination of this Petition.
c) An order of mandamus compelling the 1st Respondent to publish, within a specified time, the shortlist and current status of every position advertisedon15th January 2026, and the reasons for any positions not yet filled.
d) In the alternative to prayer (c), an order compelling the Respondents to terminate the impugned process and recommence recruitment for the affected positions in a manner that is open, transparent, competitive, and compliant with Article232ofthe Constitution and the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015.
e) A permanent injunction restraining the Respondents from filling any of the advertised positions otherwise than through open, transparent, and competitive shortlisting and interviews.
f) Costs of this Petition.
g) Any other or further relief that this Honourable Court may deem just and expedient to grant.
2. Simultaneously, the petitioner filed a Notice of Motion application of even date seeking conservatory orders with respect to the recruitment process. He filed an affidavit in support of the application and petition sworn on even date, where he annexed as ‘FK1’ being a copy of the Kitui County Public Service Board recruitment advertisement dated 15th January 2026.
3. The 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents entered an appearance through the County Attorney, County Government of Kitui, and filed a notice of preliminary objection dated 29th July 2026, seeking the petition to be dismissed with costs on the following grounds-
a. THAT the ELRC lacks the requisite jurisdiction to deal with, hear and determine the instant matter, as no contract of employment had been entered into between the Petitioner and the 1 st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents, and the dispute is not an employment and labour dispute in nature.
b. THAT there is no employer-employee relationship between the applicant and any of the respondents, and therefore the Applicant lacks the locus standi to institute the proceedings of this nature in the instant forum.
c. THAT the instant suit violates the provisions of Sections 77 of the County Government Act and 85, 86 & 87 of the Public Service Act. the Petition is premature for failing to exhaust the mechanisms provided therein.
d. THAT the instant Petition is fatally defective for failing to include the County Government of Kitui as a Respondent/Defendant in this matter.
e. THAT without any prejudice to the foregoing, the Notice of Motion and Petition violate the principles espoused in the case of Anarita Karimi Njeru vs. Republic (No. 1) (1979) I KLR 154 and Mumo Matemu vs. Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance Civil Appeal No. 290 of 2012 (2013) eKLR as the Petitioner lacks precision and specificity and does not raise any constitutional issues with reasonable degree of precision for determination requiring the court’s intervention.
Decision
3. The court directed that the preliminary objection be canvassed first by way of written submissions. The parties complied.
4. The court held that the issues for determination in the preliminary objection on priority was whether the court had jurisdiction;
if above in the affirmative -
Whether the petition was premature for non-exhaustion of mechanism under section 77 of the County Government Act; If in the negative Issue of joinder and competence of the petition.
Whether or not the court had jurisdiction.
5. The point of law under the preliminary objection was as follows-
a) THAT the ELRC lacks the requisite jurisdiction to deal with, hear and determine the instant matter, as no contract of employment had been entered into between the Petitioner and the 1 st, 2nd and 3rd Respondents, and the dispute is not an employment and labour dispute in nature.
6. Jurisdiction is a proper issue to be raised as a point of law. The Court of Appeal of East Africa in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd versus West End Distributors Ltd [1969]EA 696 Law, JA wrote that:-
“so far as I am aware, a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded, or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings and which, if argued as a preliminary point, may dispose of the suit.”
7. I find the issue of the jurisdiction of the court arises by clear implication out of the pleadings in the petition.
8. The undisputed fact before the court is that the petitioner is not an employee of the respondents and was not an applicant for any of the advertised positions. He pleaded as follows in paragraph 2 of his affidavit sworn in support of the petition on 20th July 2026-
‘THAT I am a civic and social justice activist based in Kitui County, engaged in public finance oversight, county governance accountability, and civic education, and bring this Petition and the accompanying Notice of Motion in the public interest’
9. The petitioner submitted as follows on jurisdiction - The Respondents contend that this Honourable Court lacks jurisdiction because no contract of employment exists between the Petitioner and the Respondents. This submission misapprehends the scope of this Court's jurisdiction under Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, No. 20 of 2011, which extends to disputes relating to employment and labour relations generally, including the conduct of recruitment processes by state organs and county public entities, and is not confined to disputes arising from an existing contract of employment. This Honourable Court has, in materially similar circumstances, exercised jurisdiction to restrain a public board from proceeding with shortlisting, interviews, and recruitment pending determination of a substantive challenge, notwithstanding the absence of any employment relationship between the applicant and the board: Barasa Kundu Nyukuri v County Assembly Service Board & 7 others [2021] eKLR. The Petitioner respectfully urges this Honourable Court to follow the same approach.
10. The respondent on jurisdiction submitted as follows- It has well been an enunciated principle that jurisdiction is everything, following the decision in The Owners of Motor Vessel “Lillian S” vs. Caltex Oil Kenya Limited (1989) KLR 1, which stated that:
“……..jurisdiction is everything and without it, a court or any other decision making body has no power to make one more step the moment it holds that it has no jurisdiction.” It now trite law that jurisdiction flows from either the Constitution or statute or both and without jurisdiction, a court cannot be seized of the power to hear and determine a matter.
11. In the case Samuel Kamau Macharia & Another v Kenya Commercial Bank and Another [2012] eKLR the Supreme Court of Kenya stated thus:
“A Court’s jurisdiction flows from either the Constitution or legislation or both.’
12. Thus, a Court of law can only exercise jurisdiction as conferred by the Constitution or other written law. It cannot arrogate to itself jurisdiction exceeding that which is conferred upon it by law. The E&LRC came into place following the enactment of the Constitution of Kenya (2010). The same is a creature of Article of Article 162 (2) of the Constitution of Kenya which provides:
“162. System of courtsThe superior courts are the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal, the High Court and the courts referred to in clause (2).
2. Parliament shall establish courts with the status of the High Court to hear and determine disputes relating to:
a) Employment and labour relations; …
3. Parliament shall determine the jurisdiction and functions of the courts contemplated in clause (2) ”
13. That to give effect to the provisions of Article 162 (3) of the Constitution, Parliament enacted the E&LRC Act No. 20 of 2011 which at Section 4 establishes the E&LRC. Section 12 of the Act sets out the jurisdiction of the Court. That the provisions of both Article 162 (2) (a) and Section 12 of the E&LRC Act, the jurisdiction of the E&LRC is limited to matters relating to employment and labour relations. The respondent relied on the decision in the Clerk, Nakuru County Assembly & 3 others v Odongo & 7 others (Civil Appeal E136 & E137 of 2022 (Consolidated)) [2023] KECA 427 (eKLR) (14 April 2023). That the Petitioner prays that this court restrains the Respondents from confirming or appointing for employment potential recruits. None of the said recruits is a party to this suit or is said to have been already appointed or engaged as an employee with a written or oral and as the process towards creating the relationship of an employer/employee is still ongoing and yet to conclude. The Petitioner confirmed that he brings the petition due to public interest and in his capacity as a civil activist. There is therefore no existence of an employer/employee relationship between the Respondents and the Petitioner or indeed any other matter akin to the employment nor any labour issue as contemplated by the provisions of Section 12 (1) (a-j) of the E&LRC Act. Further the respondent relied on the decision in The Supreme Court of Kenya in Republic v Karisa Chengo & Another [2017] eKLR on the the jurisdiction of specialized courts (i.e. the E&LRC and the Environment and Land Court (E&LC) viz-viz the High Court established pursuant to the provisions of Article 165 of the Constitution of Kenya.
Decision on jurisdiction
14. The petitioner brought the petition in public interest exercising his right under Article 22 of the Constitution. Article 22(1) and 2 provide as follows -
‘22. Enforcement of Bill of Rights
(1)Every person has the right to institute court proceedings claiming that a right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of Rights has been denied, violated or infringed, or is threatened.
(2)In addition to a person acting in their own interest, court proceedings under clause (1) may be instituted by—
(a)a person acting on behalf of another person who cannot act in their own name;
(b)a person acting as a member of, or in the interest of, a group or class of persons;
(c)a person acting in the public interest; or(d)an association acting in the interest of one or more of its members.’
15. There is no doubt the Petitioner has a right to bring the cause of action in public interest as pleaded. The issue is whether he is in the right court.
16. The petitioner relies on the decision of the court (Justice Radido as he then was) in which a petition was brought in the public interest to this court on a pre-employment dispute- Barasa Kundu Nyukuri v County Assembly Service Board & 7 others [2021] KEELRC 311 (KLR). The background to that case was as follows-
‘Background
4. Sometime in July 2018, the Board allegedly appointed and/or promoted a section of its employees.
5. A member of the County Assembly felt the appointments and promotions were irregular, and on 25th July 2018, he requested a statement from the Board on the appointments and promotions (copy of response if any was given was not filed in Court).
6. The member was concerned that the appointments and promotions had been made without a scheme of service as demanded by section 25 of the County Assembly Service Act, 2017, as well as the national values and principles of governance and the Employment Act, 2007.
7. Despite the concerns, the Board advertised for several vacancies through various media, including the Daily Nation newspaper, on 25th February 2021.
8. On 5th April 2019, the Petitioner lodged a Petition with the Court in Bungoma alleging that the Board had failed to uphold the constitutional values and principles in the discharge of its mandate, and more so in regard to career development and management of its employees.’’
17. The Judge (Radido J as he then was) held the court had jurisdiction as follows-
‘35. On the competency objections, the Court finds that since the dispute advanced by the Petitioner related to regulatory and policy issues likely to affect employment within the county assembly service, the Petitioner had the locus standi to bring the Petition in the public interest.
36. In this connection, the distinction of employee and employer dispute as envisaged under section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act had to give way to the right given to any person under Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution.’
18. It is a given right under the Constitution for any person alleging violation of the Constitution to file a case as stated in Articles 22 and 258 of the Constitution. It is also a fact that this is a specialised court with jurisdiction in employment and labour relations disputes as stated in article 162(2)a) of the Constitution, to wit-
‘The superior courts are the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal, the High Court and the courts referred to in clause (2).
(2)Parliament shall establish courts with the status of the High Court to hear and determine disputes relating to—
(a)employment and labour relations; ‘
19. The jurisdiction of the court has been the subject of a plethora of conflicting decisions of the superior courts. The Supreme Court as the most authoritative court with binding decisions on all courts has pronounced itself on the jurisdiction of the court with the latest decision in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR) where it held that in pre-employment disputes the court lacks jurisdiction in a case brought in public interest. The court held -
‘’70. Based on our own interpretation and application of Articles 162 (2)(a) and 165(3)(b) of the Constitution, read together with the provisions of the relevant statutes dealing with employment and labour relations, we entertain no doubt that pre-employment labour disputes involving parties identified in section 12 of the ELRC Act and those in related laws are in the exclusive domain of the ELRC. The jurisdiction of the ELRC therefore goes beyond resolving employer-employee disputes. The list in section 12 of ELRC is not exhaustive. Apart from listing persons, entities, and offices that by definition do not qualify as employees or employers, the Act, in explicit terms, extends the jurisdiction of the ELRC as may be conferred by any other law in respect of employment and labour relations. The three written laws, the Employment Act, the Labour Relations Act, and the Labour Institutions Act, create additional categories of persons and offices who have access to the court but who are neither employees nor employers. They provide in plain language that this category of persons and offices can sue or be sued before the ELRC. The statutes further provide that pre-employment grievances involving those categories are justiciable in the ELRC. Any dispute beyond those explicitly stated class must be instituted in the High Court.
71.Having so stated, we reiterate the ratio decidendi in Republic vs Chengo & 2 others (supra), that courts of equal status exercise sui generis jurisdiction; that by being equated in status with the High Court does not imply that either the ELC or the ELRC is the High Court or vice versa. The three are different and autonomous courts and exercise different and distinct jurisdictions; the High Court is precluded from entertaining matters reserved for the Supreme Court, ELC, and the ELRC. By the same token, the ELC and the ELRC, too, cannot hear matters reserved for the High Court by the Constitution.
72.As we conclude on this aspect of the appeal, we restate our determination at the beginning of this judgment that the appeal has been brought as of right under article 163(4)(a) of the Constitution. The question being, whether the Court of Appeal properly interpreted and applied the relevant provisions of the Constitution in arriving at the determination in the impugned judgment; namely whether the 1st to 7th respondents qualified as parties in terms of section 12 of the ELRC Act, or the other written laws. Did they petition the High Court as employees/employers, trade union officials, employers’ federation officials, prospective employees, persons seeking employment, Cabinet Secretaries, applicants for employment, or persons aggrieved by a decision of the Director of Employment? No. Not in any of those capacities.
73. The 1st to 7th respondents described themselves in the High Court Petition as human rights activist, patriotic citizens of Kenya, law-abiding citizens, public- spirited individuals, and human rights defenders. They did not petition the High Court on behalf of any of the applicants to the positions of CEO or MD of the four parastatals. We reiterate, they were acting in the public interest.’’
20. The Supreme Court (above) in summary held that this court lacked jurisdiction in the a constitutional petition related to a pre-employment dispute brought in the public interest by persons not falling under categories of - employees/employers, trade union officials, employers’ federation officials, prospective employees, persons seeking employment, Cabinet Secretaries, applicants for employment, or persons aggrieved by a decision of the Director of Employment.
21. The petitioner in the instant case brought the case in the public interest, as stated in his affidavit, being a civic activist and in the public interest. He was not an employee/employer, trade union official, employers’ federation official, prospective employee, person seeking employment, Cabinet Secretary, applicant for employment, or a person aggrieved by a decision of the Director of Employment. The court, applying the decision in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR), finds that the jurisdiction for the instant dispute lies with the High Court and not this court. The Supreme Court decision is binding on this court. The decision in Barasa Kundu Nyukuri v County Assembly Service Board & 7 others [2021] KEELRC 311 (KLR) is no longer good law as the Supreme Court decision is superior. I need not say more.
Disposition
22. The court holds it lacks jurisdiction on account of the decision of the Supreme Court in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyi & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR). The notice of preliminary objection dated 29th July 2026 is allowed. The instant petition and application thereunder are struck out for lack of jurisdiction. Each party to bear their own costs, taking into account the circumstances under which the petition is struck out.
23. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Petitioner – In person
Respondents- Nduva
AG- Absent