Employment law

Mkabili v Vata Creations Limited & 3 others [2026] KEELRC 14687 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Machakos
Judgment date
16 October 2026
Judge(s)
Jemimah Keli

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application succeeded. The DOSH award dated 15 May 2025 was adopted as a decree, with judgment for the applicant against the 1st respondent for Kshs. 802,636.00. Interest was denied for the period before adoption but awarded from the adoption date, together with costs of the application.

Supporting judgment passages

30. The award dated 15th May 2025 by the 1st interested party is adopted as a Decree of the court. The Decree is entered in favour of the applicant against the 1st respondent for the sum of Kshs. 802,636.00.

Paragraph 30 →

31. On interest as sought, I find to have no jurisdiction to award interest from the date of the award by DOSH. The decision maker ought to have considered that.

Paragraph 31 →

32. The applicant is awarded interest from the date of adoption, together with the costs of the application.

Paragraph 32 →
Issue 1Whether the application to adopt and enforce the DOSH award was meritorious.

Held. Yes. The 15 May 2025 compensation award was a valid award for adoption and was adopted as a decree. The respondents had either to settle it or appeal the Director's 15 September 2025 decision; having lodged no appeal within 30 days, the award crystallised. The respondents could not challenge the 196-day temporary-disablement computation in this adoption application because the court had not been moved in its appellate jurisdiction under section 52(2) of WIBA.

Ratio. A Director's award becomes enforceable for adoption where, following determination of an objection, no statutory appeal is lodged within 30 days. In an adoption proceeding, the court's role is confined to satisfying itself that a valid award exists; it does not determine objections to the award that would require invocation of its statutory appellate jurisdiction.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

5. The issue for determination was whether the application is meritorious.

Paragraph 5 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

26. The appeal ought to have been filed within 30 days from 15th September 2025 or on date of receipt of the last letter by the interested parties. As at the time of filing the instant application for adoption of the award, no appeal had been lodged. I find that, contrary to the respondent's submissions, the award crystallised 30 days after the decision of 15th September 2025, as no appeal was lodged. The instant application was filed on 14th April 2026.

Paragraph 26 →

27. The defence of the 196 days of temporary disablement having not been proved by the applicant before the interested parties is not a relevant issue in the application as the court has not been moved to exercise appellate jurisdiction under section 52(2) of WIBA.

Paragraph 27 →

29. I find that there is a valid award for adoption dated 15th May 2025 and proceed to adopt it as a Decree of the court.

Paragraph 29 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

27. The defence of the 196 days of temporary disablement having not been proved by the applicant before the interested parties is not a relevant issue in the application as the court has not been moved to exercise appellate jurisdiction under section 52(2) of WIBA.

Paragraph 27 →

28. The exercise of jurisdiction of the court in the instant case is limited to the court satisfying itself that there is a valid award for adoption. The Court of Appeal in Charles v Cheto (Civil Appeal E046 of 2022) [2025] KECA 784 (KLR), agreed the Court has jurisdiction to adopt awards by DOSH.-

Paragraph 28 →
Issue 2Whether interest could be awarded from the date of the DOSH award.

Held. No. The court held it lacked jurisdiction to award interest from the DOSH award date. It awarded interest only from the date the award was adopted as a court decree, as well as costs of the application.

Ratio. The court cannot award interest for the period from the DOSH award date because that was for the original decision-maker to consider; interest may run from the date of the court's adoption of the award.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

31. On interest as sought, I find to have no jurisdiction to award interest from the date of the award by DOSH. The decision maker ought to have considered that.

Paragraph 31 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

31. On interest as sought, I find to have no jurisdiction to award interest from the date of the award by DOSH. The decision maker ought to have considered that.

Paragraph 31 →

32. The applicant is awarded interest from the date of adoption, together with the costs of the application.

Paragraph 32 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

31. On interest as sought, I find to have no jurisdiction to award interest from the date of the award by DOSH. The decision maker ought to have considered that.

Paragraph 31 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The applicant was an employee of the 1st respondent. During employment, he was injured on the shop floor. The injury claim was assessed by the interested parties pursuant to their mandate under WIBA and a demand sent to the 1st respondent. The award has not been settled. The applicant seeking to enforce the award filed a Notice of Motion application dated 14th April 2026 seeking for-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The issue for determination was whether the application is meritorious.

Paragraph 5 →

Reasoning passage

I find that there is a valid award for adoption dated 15th May 2025 and proceed to adopt it as a Decree of the court.

Paragraph 29 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the applicant’s Notice of Motion dated 14 April 2026 was meritorious; specifically, whether the DOSH compensation award of 15 May 2025 had become a valid, enforceable award capable of adoption by the Employment and Labour Relations Court, despite the…

Material facts

Christine Wawuda Mkabili was employed by Vata Creations Limited from 1 May 2022 and was injured at the workplace. The first interested party assessed her on 15 May 2025, finding 40% permanent disablement and awarding Kshs. 670,924.80, plus Kshs. 131,712 for…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS

ELRC MISC NO. E013 OF 2026

CHRISTINE WAWUDA MKABILI ……………………………………………………………….…….APPLICANT

-VERSUS –

VATA CREATIONS LIMITED………………………………………………………………...… 1ST RESPONDENT

TAUSI ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED…………………………………………… 2ND RESPONDENT

AND

DIRECTOR OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH SERVICES…..1ST INTERESTED PARTY

COUNTY OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND

HEALTH OFFICER, MACHAKOS…………………………………………………. 2ND INTERESTED PARTY

Coram

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

RULING

1. The applicant was an employee of the 1st respondent. During employment, he was injured on the shop floor. The injury claim was assessed by the interested parties pursuant to their mandate under WIBA and a demand sent to the 1st respondent. The award has not been settled. The applicant seeking to enforce the award filed a Notice of Motion application dated 14th April 2026 seeking for-

a) Spent.

b) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to adopt the Interested Parties' decision dated 15th May 2025 awarding the Applicant Kes. 802,636.00 as a judgment of the court.

c) THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to enter judgment in favour of the Applicant against the Respondents for Kes. 802,636.00 being the amount assessed under the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007.

d) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to award interest on the amount from the date of assessment until payment in full.

e) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to award any other relief this court may deem fit and just to grant.

f) THAT costs of this application be awarded to the Applicant.

2. The Notice of Motion application was supported by the affidavit of Christine Wawuda, the injured worker, sworn on 14th April 2026. The Applicant states that the Respondents have failed to comply with the decision of the 1st interested party and have refused to remit the sum of KES. 802,636.00 to her.

3. The Notice of Motion application was opposed by the respondents vide a replying affidavit sworn by Antonette Achieng on 28th May 2026. The gist of the response was that the objection by the respondent to the award dated 15th May 2025 before the interested parties was dismissed. That the respondent was objecting to the adoption as the computation was based on unsupported 196 days of temporary disablement while the applicant was only away from work for 21 days. The respondent contended that the claim should be considered for 21 days only .

Decision

4. The application was canvassed by way of written submission. Both parties complied.

5. The issue for determination was whether the application is meritorious.

The law

6. Section 52 of the Work Injury Benefits Act provides for objections and appeals against decisions of the Director as follows-

‘(1)Any person aggrieved by a decision of the Director on any matter under this Act, may within sixty days of such decision, lodge an objection with the Director against such decision.

(2)The objection shall be in writing in the prescribed form accompanied by particulars containing a concise statement of the circumstances in which the objection is made and the relief or order which the objector claims, or the question which he desires to have determined.’

7. Section 53 provides for response by the Director and for remedy vide appeal to the court as follows-

‘(1)The Director shall within fourteen days after the receipt of an objection in the prescribed form, give a written answer to the objection, varying or upholding his decision and giving reasons for the decision objected to, and shall within the same period send a copy of the statement to any other person affected by the decision.

(2)An objector may, within thirty days of the Director’s reply being received by him, appeal to the Industrial Court against such decision.’

8. In terms of procedure for adoption of the award the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, Legal Notice 133 of 2024, provides in rule 69-

‘’69. Adoption and enforcement of alternative dispute resolution agreements by the Court

(1)Where parties have entered into a conciliation, negotiation or mediation agreement, or, are bound by an arbitral award or a lawful decision reached in Alternative Justice Systems, a party may file the award, decision or agreement for adoption and enforcement as an order of the Court.

(2)An application under subrule (1) shall be by way of a miscellaneous application instituted through a notice of motion supported by an affidavit exhibiting the award, decision or agreement together with all relevant documents.’

Whether the application is meritorious

The applicant’s submissions

There is extensive jurisprudence which agrees that the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007 is silent on the mode of enforcing an award made by the Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health (DOSH). To cure this lacuna, the Employment and Labour Relations Courts (ELRC) have guided parties seeking to enforce their awards to either file a substantive suit or a miscellaneous application. Evidently, this court is vested with the requisite authority to determine the present application. The applicant relied on decision of the Court of Appeal in Charles v Cheto (Civil Appeal E046 of 2022) [2025] KECA 784 (KLR), which held the court had jurisdiction -

“… there is a lacuna in the law with regard to the procedure for enforcement of the Director’s decision in that there is no express provision of the WIBA stipulating the procedure for enforcement. Be that as it may, Employment and Labour Relations Courts have aptly held that enforcement of the Director’s decisions properly lies with the ELRC as the court with the jurisdiction to deal with employment and labour relations claims and for connected purposes, and as provided for under sections 86 and 89 (formerly sections 87 and 90) of the Employment Act (Cap. 226).”

9. The applicant submitted that she was severely injured while working for the 1st Respondent on 15th May 2024. Subsequently, the Applicant received treatment and as soon as she was stable, the Applicant took herself to the Interested Parties for assessment on 15th May 2025, who determined that she had sustained forty percent (40%) permanent incapacity for the thirty percent (30%) vision loss in her left eye and ten percent (10%) facial disfiguration. The Interested Parties equally awarded the Applicant one-hundred and ninety-six (196) days temporary incapacity, bringing the total amount payable to Kes. 802,636.00.

10. The 2nd Respondent objected to the award on or about the month of June 2025, stating that the term ‘facial disablement’ was not expressly provided for under the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007. The 1st Interested Party thereafter allowed the 2 nd Respondent’s Objection, directing the latter to facilitate the Applicant to have a second assessment at the 1st Interested Party’s offices. On 9th September 2025, the Applicant in the company of her advocate, presented herself and registered for re-assessment. However, the Applicant was shortly thereafter informed that the reassessment would not take place, and the reasons thereof would be communicated in due course.

11. On 15th September 2025, the 1st Interested Party upheld the assessment done on 15th May 2025, stating that the 2nd Respondent had failed to obtain the Director’s prior approval for the designated medical practitioner to conduct the re-assessment, and further rescinded its earlier decision allowing the objection. Armed with the said decision, the Applicant through her advocates sent several letters to the Respondents, who to date, did not seek review nor make any form of objection to the said decisions within the prescribed timelines under the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007.

12. It should be noted that in their replying affidavit, the Respondents only disputed the issue of the computation at this juncture and not at any time before the Interested Parties made their decision. In fact, prior to the Applicant moving this court, the Respondents made no formal objection, either via an application for review or by any other manner, to challenge the decision of the Interested Parties. Further, the Respondents only question the number of days used to compute the Applicant’s award, but not the award of Kes. 670,924.80 for forty percent (40%) disablement. For being unopposed, the Applicant submits that the award with respect to the disablement be allowed at this preliminary stage.

13. Coming to the aspect of the days used to compute the award, section 51 and 52 of the Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007 expressly provides that “any person aggrieved by a decision of the Director on any matter under this Act, may within sixty days of such decision, lodge an objection with the Director an objection against such decision. The objection shall be in writing in the prescribed form accompanied by particulars containing a concise statement of the circumstances in which the objection is made and the relief or order which the objector claims, or the question which he desires to have determined.” After receiving the decision of the Director thereafter, “An objector may, within thirty days of the Director’s reply being received by him, appeal to the Industrial Court against such decision.”

14. Taking into account the statutory timelines alluded to above, once seized with the decision of the Interested Parties dated 15th September 2025 (see page 5 of the Applicant’s documents) and served by the Applicant on 19th September 2025, the Respondents ought to have filed an appeal of any nature within (30) days thereafter, which period lapsed on or about 19 th October 2025. For reasons best known to them, the Respondents failed to do so and are only opposed to the Application merely to unfavourably protract the eventual settlement of the award. The Applicant associates fully with the ratio in the Cheto case(supra), where the Court of Appeal upheld the court finding that the original jurisdiction of this Honourable Court only applied to adopting the award by the DOSHS, while the appellate jurisdiction of the court applied to an appeal to a decision of the DOSHS on the objection filed before him/her. Accordingly, there being no objection or appeal filed by the Respondents, the inevitable outcome is that the Application ought to be allowed. The Respondents cannot purport to clothe an objection to the award at this stage, without first objecting the same before the 1 st Interested Party. Having failed to lodge a formal objection at the assessment stage and an appeal to the decision thereafter, the Respondent ought not to unprocedurally sneak in an objection or appeal through their Replying Affidavit herein. For this reason, the Applicant urges this court to dismiss the Respondents’ arguments and adopt the award for execution.

The 1st Respondent’s submissions

15. The Applicant alleges that she sustained serious injuries in the course of her employment when a pressing machine fell on her face, resulting in a skull fracture and significant facial trauma. The alleged incident was reported to the Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health Services (DOSH) in Machakos by the 1st Respondent on 17th July 2024. The Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health Services awarded the Applicant compensation in the sum of Kshs. 802,636.80cts on 15th May 2025. On 24th June 2025, the 2nd Respondent lodged an objection to the assessment particularly on the percentage of disablement. We refer to Annexure 2 of the Respondents' Replying Affidavit. The 1st Interested Party responded to the objection made by the 2nd Respondent vide a letter dated 2nd September 2025 and rendered the following decision: A The degree of disablement awarded for "facial disablement" is not expressly provided for in the First Schedule of Work Injury Benefits Act, 2007 that requires prescription of criteria) C The Claimant shall be facilitated by the Objector to appear before the Work Injury Evaluation Clinic (W.I.E.C.) panel at D.O.S.H.S Headquarters for reassessment on or before 23/09/2025. The W.I.E.C. panel's medical report shall be used in determination compensation and the decision shall be communicated to the affected parties.

16. At Page 3 of the Applicant's Annexures attached to the supporting affidavit , in a change of tune from their previous orders and even before the date of 23/09/2025 that the Applicant was to undergo medical reassessment, the 1st Interested Party purported to make a decision vide a letter dated 15th September 2025 dismissing the objection by the 2nd Respondent.

17. Sections 51 and 52 of the Work Injury Benefits Act (WIBA), require that an employer be notified of an accident, participate in the assessment of the injury and further allow the employer to lodge an objection to the decision of the Director within the prescribed period. That the law is also clear where an objection is lodged, the award does not crystallize into a final and enforceable determination until the objection is heard and determined. In the instant case, it is not disputed that the 2nd Respondent filed a Notice of Objection with the Director within the stipulated timelines.

18. Under Section 51 of WIBA, the objection by the 2nd Respondent re-opened the matter for further evaluation. Upon the objection being lodged, the Director was bound by section 52(1) of WIBA pronounce himself afresh on the matter. That the Director has not rendered his decision on the objection. The tentative award having been re-opened through the respondent's objection of 24th June 2025, did not crystallize. It would only have crystallized upon the director's decision on the objection. There is no final award that this Honourable Court can adopt. The current application has been filed prematurely there being no final award by the Director. In the premises, the tentative award of 15th May 2025 should not be adopted by this Honourable Court. The adoption of the award can only happen after the director has pronounced himself on the 2nd Respondent's objection in terms of section 52(1) of WIBA. In Mwangi v Unilever Kenya [2023] KEELRC 1475 (KLR) where the court held that;-‘ Section 51 of the WIBA contemplates that objection to the director’s tentative award be presented within sixty days of his decision. In my view, the sixty days period within which to lodge the objection begins to run from the date of communication of the director’s initial decision to the parties. This is either the date of postage of the decision to the parties’ last known postal or email address or the date it is physically delivered to them.’

19. 1st The court did not find relevance in the respondent’s submissions related to 2019, as they are not supported by the replying affidavit or the facts of the application, with the applicant having been employed on 1st May 2022.

Analysis and the application of the law.

20. It is not in dispute that the applicant was an employee of the 1st respondent from 1st May 2022, and the 2nd respondent was the 1st respondent’s insurer for WIBA.

21. It is also not in dispute that the applicant suffered injury at the workplace.

22. It is not in dispute that the applicant was assessed by the 1st interested party and an award for compensation was issued on 15th May 2025. (CWM). The applicant was declared 40 % permanently disabled and, under the disablement, awarded Kshs. 670,924.80. Under temporary disablement for 196 days, he was awarded Kshs. 131,712.00 . The total award was Kshs. 802,636.80.

23. The 2nd respondent filed an objection, which was considered and the decision communicated by the 1st interested party vide letter dated 2nd September 2025. The 1st interested party ordered a 2nd reassessment at its work-injury evaluation clinic panel at DOSH headquarters.

24. The 1st interested party further, vide letter dated 15th September 2025, communicated to the 2nd respondent the review of the motion on objection on the decision rendered on 2nd September 2025. This was indicated to have been done by the 1st interested party out of its own motion. In essence, the 1st interested party reconsidered its decision on the objection and rescinded the decision of 2nd September 2025 and upheld the award dated 15th May 2025.

25. The respondents did not take any further action in the matter. The respondents had 2 options on receipt of the decision dated 15th September 2025. Either settle the award or appeal against the decision of 15th September 2025 consistent with Section 52(2) of WIBA which states-

‘2)An objector may, within thirty days of the Director’s reply being received by him, appeal to the Industrial Court against such decision.’

26. The appeal ought to have been filed within 30 days from 15th September 2025 or on date of receipt of the last letter by the interested parties. As at the time of filing the instant application for adoption of the award, no appeal had been lodged. I find that, contrary to the respondent's submissions, the award crystallised 30 days after the decision of 15th September 2025, as no appeal was lodged. The instant application was filed on 14th April 2026.

27. The defence of the 196 days of temporary disablement having not been proved by the applicant before the interested parties is not a relevant issue in the application as the court has not been moved to exercise appellate jurisdiction under section 52(2) of WIBA.

28. The exercise of jurisdiction of the court in the instant case is limited to the court satisfying itself that there is a valid award for adoption. The Court of Appeal in Charles v Cheto (Civil Appeal E046 of 2022) [2025] KECA 784 (KLR), agreed the Court has jurisdiction to adopt awards by DOSH.-

“… there is a lacuna in the law with regard to the procedure for enforcement of the Director’s decision in that there is no express provision of the WIBA stipulating the procedure for enforcement. Be that as it may, Employment and Labour Relations Courts have aptly held that enforcement of the Director’s decisions properly lies with the ELRC as the court with the jurisdiction to deal with employment and labour relations claims and for connected purposes, and as provided for under sections 86 and 89 (formerly sections 87 and 90) of the Employment Act (Cap. 226).”

29. I find that there is a valid award for adoption dated 15th May 2025 and proceed to adopt it as a Decree of the court.

Order

30. The award dated 15th May 2025 by the 1st interested party is adopted as a Decree of the court. The Decree is entered in favour of the applicant against the 1st respondent for the sum of Kshs. 802,636.00.

31. On interest as sought, I find to have no jurisdiction to award interest from the date of the award by DOSH. The decision maker ought to have considered that.

32. The applicant is awarded interest from the date of adoption, together with the costs of the application.

33. It is so Ordered

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE.

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Applicant- Okari

Respondents- Gakungi

interested parties

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder